Strategies for microbiological control of the alcoholic fermentation in wines by exploiting the microbial terroir complexity: A mini-review

Improving aromatic higher alcohol acetates in wines by co-fermentation of Pichia kluyveri and Saccharomyces cerevisiae: growth interaction and amino acid competition

BACKGROUND

Higher alcohol acetates (HAAs) are potent aroma-active esters that impart desirable fruity and floral aromas. However, the conversion of higher alcohol precursors into HAAs is extremely low in winemaking. To investigate the underlying yeast-yeast interaction on targeted improvement of aromatic HAAs, we evaluated fermentation activity, cell viability, amino acid consumption and HAA production when Pichia kluyveri and Saccharomyces cerevisiae were inoculated concurrently or sequentially.

RESULTS

Pichia kluyveri PK-21 possessed the ability to survive and increased HAA level up to 5.2-fold in mixed fermentation. Such an increment may benefit from the efficient conversion of higher alcohol precursors into HAAs (>27-fold higher than S. cerevisiae). During mixed fermentation, the two yeasts exhibited crucial interactions regarding cell growth and amino acid competition. Saccharomyces cerevisiae dominated over the co-inoculated P. kluyveri by efficient uptake of amino acids and biomass production. However, this dominance decreased in sequential fermentation, where P. kluyveri growth increased due to the consumption of preferred amino acids prior to S. cerevisiae. Pearson correlation analysis indicated that phenylalanine and aspartic acid may act as positive amino acids in boosting P. kluyveri growth and HAA production. Laboratory-scale winemaking validated the fermentation performance of P. kluyveri in sequential inoculum, resulting in a balanced aroma profile with enhanced floral and tropical fruity characteristics in the final wines.

CONCLUSION

This study proposes a microbial, non-genetically engineered approach for targeted increase of HAA production in winemaking and the findings provide new insights into yeast-yeast interactions. © 2024 Society of Chemical Industry.

Strain prevalence and killer factor only partially influence the fermentation activity of pairwise Saccharomyces cerevisiae wine strains inoculation

Commercial Saccharomyces cerevisiae starters are single-strain cultures widely used in winemaking to optimise the fermentation process and improve the organoleptic quality of wine. Unfortunately, the worldwide extensive use of a limited number of industrial strains led to the standardisation of the sensory properties, reducing the identity of wines. Therefore, the use of multi-strain S. cerevisiae starters can be an alternative tool to alter the sensory profile of wines, increasing the diversity of wine styles. However, this strategy may be interesting only if the overall fermentation kinetics is not affected. To date, there is a lack of information regarding the influence of multi-strain starters on the overall fermentation process in wine. In this context, killer toxins, affecting the viability of sensitive strains, can play a significant role. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of pairing eight wine strains of S. cerevisiae (two sensitive, three neutral and three killer) in co-fermentations compared to single-strain fermentations. Results evidenced that, among co-fermentations where the strain prevalence was significant, the killer strains constituted 79% to 100% of the total yeast population when co-inoculated with a sensitive one. However, in most of the cases, co-fermentations kinetics were similar to those of sensitive strains or worse than both strains. Thus, the presence of a killer strain alone is not sufficient to predict the overall fermentation progress, which is an essential information in winemaking. Interestingly, the neutral strain P304.4 was always prevalent, regardless of the second strain and, in most of the co-fermentations, the overall fermentation trend was similar to the P304.4 single-strain fermentation. Regardless of killer activity, our results suggest that the effect of strains on fermentative kinetics is still unpredictable, and further studies are needed to thoroughly explore strain to strain interactions in winemaking.

Influence of spontaneous, "pied de cuve" and commercial dry yeast fermentation strategies on wine molecular composition and sensory properties

While most producers in recent decades have relied on commercial yeasts (ADY) as their primary choice given their reliability and reproducibility, the fear of standardising the taste and properties of wine has led to the employment of alternative strategies that involve autochthonous yeasts such as pied de cuve (PdC) and spontaneous fermentation (SF). However, the impact of different fermentation strategies on wine has been a subject of debate and speculation. Consequently, this study describes, for the first time, the differences between the three kinds of fermentation at the metabolomic, chemical, and sensory levels in two wines: Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. The results showed how the yeast chosen significantly impacted the molecular composition of the wines, as revealed by metabolomic analysis that identified biomarkers with varying chemical compositions according to the fermentation modality. Notably, higher numbers of lipid markers were found for SF and PdC than ADY, which contained more peptides. Key molecules from the metabolic amino acid pathway, which are addressed in this article, showed evidence of such variations. In addition, the analysis of volatile aromatic compounds revealed an increase in groups of compounds specific to each fermentation. The sensorial analysis of Chardonnay wine showed a more qualitative sensory outcome (Higher fruit intensity) for ADY and SF compared to PdC. Our finding challenges the common speculation among wine producers that autochthonous yeast fermentations may offer greater complexity and uniqueness in comparison to commercial yeast fermentations.

Non-Saccharomyces Yeasts from Organic Vineyards as Spontaneous Fermentation Agents

Currently, non-Saccharomyces yeasts are the subject of interest, among other things, for their contribution to the aromatic complexity of wines. In this study, the characterisation of non-Saccharomyces yeasts was addressed by their isolation during spontaneous fermentations of organic Verdejo grapes, obtaining a total of 484 isolates, of which 11% were identified by molecular techniques as non-Saccharomyces yeasts. Fermentative isolates belonging to the species Hanseniaspora meyeri, Hanseniaspora osmophila, Pichia guilliermondii, Pichia kudriavzevii, Torulaspora delbrueckii, and Wickerhamomyces anomalus were analysed. Significant differences were found in the yeast populations established at the different fermentation stages. Interestingly, W. anomalus stood up as a widely distributed species in vineyards, vintages, and fermentation stages. Several of the strains studied stood out for their biotechnological potential in the production of Verdejo wine, showing the presence of relevant enzymatic activity for the release of varietal aromas and the technological improvement of the winemaking process. Three enzymatic activities were found in an important number of isolates, β-glucosidase, protease, and β-lyase, implicated in the positive aromatic impact on this style of white wine. In that sense, all the isolates of W. anomalus presented those activities. T. delbrueckii isolates were highlighted for their significant β-lyase activity. In addition, T. delbrueckii was outlined because of its potential to achieve an elevated fermenting power, as well as the lack of lag phase. The results obtained highlight the importance of maintaining the microbial diversity that contributes to the production of wines with unique and distinctive characteristics of the production region.

Inside Current Winemaking Challenges: Exploiting the Potential of Conventional and Unconventional Yeasts

Wine represents a complex matrix in which microbial interactions can strongly impact the quality of the final product. Numerous studies have focused on optimizing microbial approaches for addressing new challenges to enhance quality, typicity, and food safety. However, few studies have investigated yeasts of different genera as resources for obtaining wines with new, specific traits. Currently, based on the continuous changes in consumer demand, yeast selection within conventional Saccharomyces cerevisiae and unconventional non-Saccharomyces yeasts represents a suitable opportunity. Wine fermentation driven by indigenous yeasts, in the various stages, has achieved promising results in producing wines with desired characteristics, such as a reduced content of ethanol, SO₂, and toxins, as well as an increased aromatic complexity. Therefore, the increasing interest in organic, biodynamic, natural, or clean wine represents a new challenge for the wine sector. This review aims at exploring the main features of different oenological yeasts to obtain wines reflecting the needs of current consumers in a sustainability context, providing an overview, and pointing out the role of microorganisms as valuable sources and biological approaches to explore potential and future research opportunities.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae responds similarly to co-culture or to a fraction enriched in Metschnikowia pulcherrima extracellular vesicles

The recent introduction of non-conventional yeast species as companion wine starters has prompted a growing interest in microbial interactions during wine fermentation. There is evidence of interactions through interference and exploitation competition, as well as interactions depending on physical contact. Furthermore, the results of some transcriptomic analyses suggest interspecific communication, but the molecules or biological structures involved in recognition are not well understood. In this work, we explored extracellular vesicles (EVs) as possible mediators of interspecific communication between wine yeasts. The transcriptomic response of Saccharomyces cerevisiae after 3 h of contact with a fraction enriched in EVs of Metschnikowia pulcherrima was compared with that induced by active M. pulcherrima cells. Interestingly, there is a high level of overlap between the transcriptomic profiles of yeast cells challenged by either M. pulcherrima whole cells or the EV-enriched fraction. The results indicate an upregulation of yeast metabolism in response to competing species (in line with previous results). This finding points to the presence of a signal, in the EV-enriched fraction, that can be perceived by the yeast cells as a cue for the presence of competitors, even in the absence of metabolically active cells of the other species.

Chemical Methods for Microbiological Control of Winemaking: An Overview of Current and Future Applications

Preservation technologies for winemaking have relied mainly on the addition of sulfur dioxide (SO2), in consequence of the large spectrum of action of this compound, linked to the control of undesirable microorganisms and the prevention of oxidative phenomena. However, its potential negative effects on consumer health have addressed the interest of the international research on alternative treatments to substitute or minimize the SO2 content in grape must and wine. This review is aimed at analyzing chemical methods, both traditional and innovative, useful for the microbiological stabilization of wine. After a preliminary description of the antimicrobial and technological properties of SO2, the additive traditionally used during wine production, the effects of the addition (in must and wine) of other compounds officially permitted in winemaking, such as sorbic acid, dimethyl dicarbonate (DMDC), lysozyme and chitosan, are discussed and evaluated. Furthermore, other substances showing antimicrobial properties, for which the use for wine microbiological stabilization is not yet permitted in EU, are investigated. Even if these treatments exhibit a good efficacy, a single compound able to completely replace SO2 is not currently available, but a combination of different procedures might be useful to reduce the sulfite content in wine. Among the strategies proposed, particular interest is directed towards the use of insect-based chitosan as a reliable alternative to SO2, mainly due to its low environmental impact. The production of wines containing low sulfite levels by using pro-environmental practices can meet both the consumers’ expectations, who are even more interested in the healthy traits of foods, and wine-producers’ needs, who are interested in the use of sustainable practices to promote the profile of their brand.

Wine Microbial Consortium: Seasonal Sources and Vectors Linking Vineyard and Winery Environments

Winemaking involves a wide diversity of microorganisms with different roles in the process. The wine microbial consortium (WMC) includes yeasts, lactic acid bacteria and acetic acid bacteria with different implications regarding wine quality. Despite this technological importance, their origin, prevalence, and routes of dissemination from the environment into the winery have not yet been fully unraveled. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the WMC diversity and incidence associated with vineyard environments to understand how wine microorganisms overwinter and enter the winery during harvest. Soils, tree and vine barks, insects, vine leaves, grapes, grape musts, and winery equipment were sampled along four seasons. The isolation protocol included: (a) culture-dependent microbial recovery; (b) phenotypical screening to select fermenting yeasts, lactic acid, and acetic acid bacteria; and (c) molecular identification. The results showed that during all seasons, only 11.4% of the 1424 isolates presumably belonged to the WMC. The increase in WMC recovery along the year was mostly due to an increase in the number of sampled sources. Acetic acid bacteria (Acetobacter spp., Gluconobacter spp., Gluconoacetobacter spp.) were mostly recovered from soils during winter while spoilage lactic acid bacteria (Leuconostoc mesenteroides and Lactobacillus kunkeii) were only recovered from insects during véraison and harvest. The fermenting yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae was only isolated from fermented juice and winery equipment. The spoilage yeast Zygosaccharomyces bailii was only recovered from fermented juice. The single species bridging both vineyard and winery environments was the yeast Hanseniaspora uvarum, isolated from insects, rot grapes and grape juice during harvest. Therefore, this species appears to be the best surrogate to study the dissemination of the WMC from vineyard into the winery. Moreover, the obtained results do not evidence the hypothesis of a perennial terroir-dependent WMC given the scarcity of their constituents in the vineyard environment along the year and the importance of insect dissemination.