Cerclage retention versus removal following preterm premature rupture of membranes and association with amniotic fluid markers

Removal versus retention of cervical cerclage with preterm prelabor rupture of membranes: Systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate maternal and perinatal outcomes of removal versus retention of cervical cerclage after premature preterm rupture of membranes (pPROM).

STUDY DESIGN

Medline, Embase and Cochrane databases were searched electronically on February 2023 utilizing combinations of the relevant medical subject heading (MeSH) terms, keywords, and word variants that were considered suitable for the topic. Either prospective or retrospective trials were considered suitable for the inclusion. The coprimary outcome of this study were pregnancy latency >7 days from pPROM and pregnancy latency >48 h from pPROM. Random effect head to-head meta-analyses were performed to directly compare each outcome, expressing the results as summary odds ratio (OR) for dichotomous outcomes and as mean difference (MD) for continuous outcomes, plus relative 95% confidence interval (CI). Quality assessment of the included studies was performed using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

RESULTS

Six studies involving a total of 377 women (169 in the "removal" and 208 in the "retention" group) were included. The rate of pregnancy prolongation >48 h was significantly lower in the removal compared to retention group (OR 0.15, 95% CI 0.07-0.31; p < 0.0001), as well as the rate of pregnancy prolongation >7 days (OR 0.30 95% CI 0.11-0.83; p = 0.02) and pregnancy latency expressed in days (MD -2.84 days, 95% CI -5.40 to -0.29; p = 0.03). The rate of chorioamnionitis was significantly lower in the removal compared to the retention group (OR 0.57 95% CI 0.34-0.96p = 0.03) as was the rate of Apgar score < 7 at 5 min (OR 0.22 95% CI 0.08-0.56; p = 0.002). There was no difference between removal and retention groups for all the other maternal and perinatal outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

The decision whether to remove or retain cerclage in case of pPROM should balance the prematurity-related risks with that of infectious complications, thus highlighting the need for tailored management based on gestational age at occurrence of pPROM.

The Association of Inflammatory Markers with Maternal-Neonatal Outcome After Cervical Cerclage

Objective

Cervical cerclage is effective in prolonging the number of weeks gestation in patients with cervical insufficiency(CI). However, valuable predictors with successful cervical cerclage remain limited. It aimed to evaluate the value of the systemic immune-inflammation index (SII), and systemic inflammation response index (SIRI) to predict the outcomes of cervical cerclage.

Methods

This study analyzed 374 participants. Inflammatory markers were calculated using maternal peripheral blood. The association of inflammatory markers and the outcome of cervical cerclage were analyzed. And the optimal cut-off values of inflammatory markers were calculated. Also, the Chi-square test and logistic and linear regression analyses were performed to evaluate inflammatory markers with the maternal outcome and neonatal outcomes.

Results

374 pregnancies were included in this study. Finally, 268 (71.7%) participants suffered successful cervical cerclage. This study demonstrated that the baseline BMI (cm²/kg), the bulging membrane, cervical dilation (≥2cm), the amniotic sac herniation, the neutrophils counts, the systemic immune-inflammation index (SII), and systemic inflammation response index (SIRI) were significant difference between the successful and unsuccessful groups (all P<0.05). Additionally, maternal blood inflammatory markers, such as WBC, lymphocyte, neutrophils, monocyte, platelet counts, SII, and SIRI, were significantly associated with maternal-neonatal outcomes. Furthermore, the results demonstrated that the SII level had the highest OR (OR=4.626; 95% CI (2.500-8.560)), as well as the following: SIRI level (OR = 3.795; 95% CI (1.989-7.242)), cervical dilation (≥2cm) (OR =3.477; 95% CI (1.458-10.844)), and amniotic sac herniation (OR = 1.796; 95% (0.473-4.975)).

Conclusion

This study demonstrated that the baseline SII level and SIRI level are important biochemical markers for predicting the outcome of cervical cerclage and maternal-neonatal outcomes with non-invasive procedures. They can help to provide personalized treatment before surgery and enhance postoperative surveillance.

Management of Cerclage in Patients With Preterm Prelabor Rupture of Membranes

Importance

Women undergoing cerclage placement remain at high risk for preterm labor and preterm prelabor rupture of membranes (PPROMs). The management of cervical cerclage after PPROM is controversial given the potential for prolonged latency when the cerclage is kept in place balanced with a potential increased risk of maternal infectious morbidity.

Objective

In this review, we compared studies that examined maternal, fetal, and neonatal outcomes in women with cerclage at the time of PPROM. We evaluated latency after PPROM and maternal and neonatal complications in the setting of PPROM with cervical cerclage.

Evidence Acquisition

Original research articles, review articles, and guidelines on cerclage removal were reviewed.

Results

Nine studies comparing cerclage retention versus removal were examined with mixed results, in particular between studies before the routine use of latency antibiotics and corticosteroid administration. There was an associated increase in latency to delivery with retention of cerclage, with a potential increase in maternal infectious morbidity. No significant differences were noted for neonatal mortality, neonatal sepsis, or other neonatal morbidity outcomes. The majority of studies were limited by their retrospective nature and small sample sizes.

Conclusions and Relevance

Cerclage removal at the time of diagnosis of PPROM can be considered due to the concern for increased risk of maternal morbidity without definitive benefit in latency to delivery or neonatal outcomes. However, data are limited, and clinicians should engage in shared decision-making with patients in this setting.

The Short Cervix: A Critical Analysis of Diagnosis and Treatment

A short cervix in the second trimester is a significant risk factor for spontaneous preterm birth, preterm prelabor rupture of membranes, and subsequent adverse perinatal outcome. The pathophysiology is complex and multifactorial with inflammatory and/or infectious processes often involved. Biomarkers have been developed in an effort to predict preterm birth with varying degrees of success. The treatment options of cerclage, progesterone, pessary, and combination therapy are reviewed. Evidence-based protocols are summarized for singleton and multiple gestation.

Optimal timing of cervical cerclage removal following preterm premature rupture of membranes; a retrospective analysis

OBJECTIVE

Preterm prelabour rupture of membranes occurs in over one third of pregnant women with a cervical cerclage in situ. In the setting of preterm prelabour rupture of membranes, clinicians are faced with the difficult decision of the optimal timing for removing the cerclage. We compared the maternal and neonatal outcomes following immediate removal or retention of the cervical cerclage.

STUDY DESIGN

Women were retrospectively identified from St Thomas's Hospital Preterm Surveillance clinic database. Asymptomatic women with preterm prelabour rupture of membranes were identified and separated into those that had the cerclage removed and those that had the cerclage retained within 24 h of presentation. Women who were symptomatic at presentation and who delivered within 24 h of presentation were excluded from the analysis. Maternal outcomes measured were latency between preterm prelabour rupture of membranes and delivery, gestation at delivery and maternal chorioamnionitis and infection markers. Neonatal outcomes including birthweight and Apgar scores were also measured.

RESULTS

43 women with cerclage retained for over 24 h following preterm prelabour rupture of membranes were compared to 25 women in whom the cerclage was removed. The latency between preterm prelabour rupture of membranes and delivery was on average 70.4 h longer in women who had their cerclage retained compared to the removed group (p = 0.009). Rates of chorioamnionitis, maternal blood results, neonatal birthweight and Apgar scores did not differ significantly between the two groups, however a trend towards higher rates of chorioamnionitis (60 % vs 45 %) were seen in the retained group.

CONCLUSION

Cervical cerclage retention in women following preterm prelabour rupture of membranes was associated with a longer latency period to delivery and was not significantly associated with any adverse obstetric, maternal or neonatal outcomes. Therefore, in women at risk of spontaneous preterm birth, cerclage retention may be beneficial, however these women and their babies should be monitored closely for any signs of infection. Further prospective randomised controlled studies assessing these outcomes as well as longer-term outcomes in these women and their children are needed.

Association of the vaginal microbiota with pregnancy outcomes in Chinese women after cervical cerclage

RESEARCH QUESTION

The study aimed to investigate the relationship between risk factors associated with vaginal microbiota and outcomes of cervical cerclage.

DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study of singleton pregnancies with cervical cerclage was conducted. Before cerclage, participants underwent a vaginal microbiota assay, including morphological examination and functional vaginal microecological analysis using a vaginitis multi-test kit. The chi-squared test and logistic and linear regression analyses were performed to evaluate the associations of various risk factors with maternal and neonatal outcomes.

RESULTS

Eighty-five participants were included. The mean interval between cerclage and delivery was 69.4 ± 36.7 days, and 12 (14.1%) of newborns died. A higher grade of vaginal cleanliness, a higher pH, a lower abundance of Lactobacillus spp., a higher sialidase-positive percentage, a higher positive percentage of clue cells, a higher lactobacillary grade, a higher Nugent score and a higher rate of microecological dysbiosis were significantly associated with a poor neonatal outcome and shorter cerclage to delivery intervals (P < 0.001-0.041). Furthermore, sialidase positivity was associated with the highest risk of cervical cerclage failure (odds ratio [OR] 10.469; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.096-36.087), followed by the presence of bulging membranes (OR 6.400; 95% CI 0.428-15.641) and vaginal microbiota dysbiosis (OR 6.038; 95% CI 0.173-17.072).

CONCLUSIONS

An absence of Lactobacillus spp. and some functional factors of vaginal microbiota are potential risk factors that predict subsequent cerclage failure. These findings indicate the potential clinical utility of these factors to predict cervical cerclage failure for managing patient expectations and providing improved postoperative surveillance.

Removal vs. retention of cervical cerclage in pregnancies complicated by preterm premature rupture of membranes: a retrospective study

PURPOSE

To compare pregnancy outcomes in women with pPROM and a cervical cerclage in whom the cerclage was removed within 24 h and those in whom the cerclage was retained in situ.

METHODS

A two-center retrospective cohort study of women with a singleton gestation with pPROM at < 34^0/7 weeks of gestation in the presence of cervical cerclage (January 1, 2012-July 30, 2016). Maternal and perinatal outcomes were compared between women in whom cerclage was removed within 24 h from pPROM and those in whom cerclage was retained until the onset of delivery. The primary outcome was time from pPROM to delivery.

RESULTS

Seventy women met inclusion criteria. Cerclage was left in situ in 47 (67.1%) and removed in 23 (32.9%) women. Women in the cerclage retention group had a higher pPROM-to-delivery interval (7.0 ± 7.2 vs. 6.0 ± 10.9 days, p = 0.03), and were more likely to have a latency period > 48 h (87.2% vs. 65.2%, p = 0.03; aOR 3.9, 95% CI 3.1-4.9) or > 7 days (29.8% vs. 8.7%, p = 0.04; aOR 7.0, 95% CI 2.5-19.6) compared with women in whom cerclage was removed. Furthermore, chorioamnionitis rate was lower in the cerclage retention group compared to cerclage removal group (aOR 0.7, 95% CI 0.5-1.0). There were no differences between the groups in early neonatal sepsis, severe brain injury, or composite neonatal outcome.

CONCLUSION

In women with pPROM and cervical cerclage, retention of cerclage may be associated with a longer latency period, and a lower chorioamnionitis rate, without an associated increase in the risk of neonatal infectious morbidity. Presentation information: The abstract of this study was presented as a poster at the 38th SMFM (Society of Maternal and Fetal Medicine) annual meeting, February 2018, Dallas, Texas, USA.

Factors associated with neonatal outcomes in preterm prelabor rupture of membranes after cervical cerclage

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate risk factors associated with neonatal morbidity and mortality in pregnant women with preterm prelabor rupture of membranes (PPROM) after cervical cerclage.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of singleton pregnancies with cervical insufficiency was conducted at a tertiary referral center in Taiwan from May 1, 2000 to July 31, 2017. Patients with PPROM after cerclage and delivered between 20 0/7 days and 36 6/7 days were recruited. Logistic and linear regression analyses were performed to evaluate various risk factors.

RESULTS

Overall, 109 women were included. Mothers with a higher white blood cell count, a higher C-reactive protein (CRP) level, a lower amniotic fluid index, and chorioamnionitis were significantly associated with neonatal morbidity. Neonatal mortality was related to oligohydramnios (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 2.98, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.11-8.01) and chorioamnionitis (aOR 3.17, 95% CI 1.03-9.69). An elevated CRP level was associated with a shorter PPROM to delivery latency (adjusted B -16.64, 95% CI -29.88 to -3.41), but cerclage retention more than 12 hours after PPROM was associated with a prolonged latency (adjusted B 17.21, 95% CI 3.25-31.18).

CONCLUSION

Oligohydramnios and chorioamnionitis are associated with neonatal mortality.

Good prognosis of cerclage in cases of cervical insufficiency when intra-amniotic inflammation/infection is ruled out

OBJECTIVE

To determine if absence of sub-clinical intra-amniotic inflammation improves the prognosis of rescue cerclage in cases of bulging membranes.

METHODS

Cohort study with all women with bulging membranes admitted into our hospital between 2009 and 2013. Patients underwent amniocentesis to quantify amniotic glucose, leukocytes, IL-6 and leukocyte esterase levels and for microbiological culture. All patients without intra-amniotic inflammation or sub-clinical chorioamnionitis were proposed a physical examination-indicated cervical cerclage. Those who did not accept were treated with bed rest.

RESULTS

We enrolled 31 women. Median gestational age at diagnosis was 23 + 1 (21–25 + 4) weeks. Median interval until delivery was 12 (3–52.5) d. IL-6 had the highest diagnostic accuracy for good prognosis. Patients with IL6 <2.90 ng/ml were diagnosed later in pregnancy and presented a longer interval until delivery (89 versus 4 d), higher gestational age at delivery (35 + 1 versus 23 + 3 weeks) and a lower rate of prematurity (54.5% versus 100%) and perinatal mortality (0% versus 80%) than those with IL-6 ≥2.90 ng/ml. Rescue cerclage and low Il-6 were the best predictors of good outcome.

CONCLUSION

IL-6 levels in amniotic fluid may be of clinical value for individualizing the management of patients with bulging membranes for placement of rescue cerclage.

Premature rupture of the fetal membrane combined with subclinical chorioamnionitis negatively affects pregnancy outcomes by a mechanism associated with reduced levels of matrix metalloproteinase-2

The present study aimed to investigate whether premature rupture of the fetal membrane, combined with subclinical chorioamnionitis, affects pregnancy outcomes. In addition, the association between premature rupture of the fetal membrane (PROM) and the levels of matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2), an inactive proenzyme that can be activated by other factors or signals in humans, was examined. In total, 80 pregnant patients with PROM were classified into the experimental and control groups, according to their final placental pathological diagnosis results. The 40 patients in the experimental group suffered from subclinical chorioamnionitis, while the 40 patients in the control group exhibited no lesions of the placenta or fetal membrane. Tissue samples were collected and the total protein and mRNA were extracted for western blot and quantitative polymerase chain reaction analyses. ELISA was performed in order to detect the levels of MMP-2 in the serum of the two groups of patients. The rates of cesarean section, puerperal infection, postpartum hemorrhage, preterm incidence, placenta accreta, residual placental blood and stillbirth were all significantly higher in the experimental group compared with the control group. In addition, the mRNA and protein expression levels of MMP-2 were reduced in the experimental group compared with the control group. ELISA results indicated that the serum MMP-2 concentrations were also reduced in the patients with PROM. Therefore, the present study demonstrated that the PROM, combined with subclinical chorioamnionitis, significantly affected pregnancy outcomes and was associated with reduced levels of MMP-2.