Surgical techniques and outcomes of cochlear implantation in patients with radiographic findings consistent with X-linked deafness

Progressive Loss of Sensitivity to Electrical Stimulation After Cochlear Implantation in X-Linked Incomplete Partition Type III Deafness

OBJECTIVES

Patients with X-linked incomplete partition type III (IP3) deafness treated with cochlear implants exhibit higher "Most Comfortable Loudness" (MCL) levels of stimulation and more electrode deactivation than patients with normal morphology. We endeavored to analyze the progression of the MCL levels and electrode deactivation over time and assess those factors that could have led to deactivation. Furthermore, we aimed to assess whether speech perception was affected by a progressive loss of neural contact.

DESIGN

All 13 patients with the IP3 malformation in our clinical database were analyzed retrospectively with regard to impedance, stimulation levels, deactivated electrodes, and speech perception. A control group of patients with normal anatomy was included.

RESULTS

MCL levels increased over time by 2.5 charge units (qu) per year, which was not seen in the control group. Electrode deactivation was more common in IP3 malformation, and it was estimated that 25% of electrodes would be deactivated by 15 years of age. Impedance was stable but higher in the study population. Speech perception was lower in IP3 malformation generally and was correlated to the number of deactivated electrodes.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients diagnosed with IP3 malformation deafness may suffer a greater risk of cochlear implant discontinuation compared with those with normal anatomy. A progressive loss of sensitivity to electrical stimulation may indicate a form of neural degradation in the abnormal cochlea. With time, patients in this group, even with cochlear implant technology, may experience gradual deterioration of speech perception. This has clinical implications for the counseling of parents.

Exploration of different electrode types inserted in a 3D model of a patient with incomplete partition type III inner ear malformation

BACKGROUND

Incomplete partition type III (IP III) represents a rare malformation of the inner ear, posing challenges during cochlear implantation due to inevitable cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks and the potential misplacement of electrodes within the internal auditory canal (IAC). Despite the absence of a consensus on electrode selection, literature suggests both straight and perimodiolar electrodes as viable options for proper insertion. Limited implantation series contribute to the ambiguity in electrode choice. In this study, we evaluated the insertion performance of three electrode types in a 3D model simulating an IP III patient's inner ear.

METHODS

A 3D model replicating the inner ear of a patient with IP III undergoing surgery was created, incorporating a canal wall up mastoidectomy and an enlarged round window approach. Insertions were carried out using a straight electrode, a perimodiolar electrode, and a slim perimodiolar electrode, inserted through a sheath in the basal turn of the cochlea. Electrode positions were assessed after each insertion, with each type being tested 20 times.

RESULTS

Successful insertion rates were 95 % for the slim perimodiolar electrode, 85 % for the perimodiolar electrode, and 75 % for the slim straight electrode. Notably, the slim perimodiolar electrode required an adapted insertion technique due to the altered cochlear position in IP III cases. Statistical analysis revealed the slim perimodiolar electrode's superiority over the slim straight electrode in achieving successful insertions.

CONCLUSIONS

The 3D model of the IP III inner ear proved to be an effective tool for electrode testing and insertion training prior to surgery. Following multiple insertions in the 3D model, the slim perimodiolar electrode demonstrated the highest success rate, emphasizing its potential as the preferred choice for cochlear implantation in IP III cases.

Management of Cochlear Implant Electrode Arrays Misplaced in the Internal Auditory Canal: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVE

Misplacement of electrode arrays in the internal auditory canal (IAC) presents a unique clinical challenge. Speech recognition is limited for cochlear implant (CI) users with misplaced arrays, and there are risks with revision surgery including facial and/or cochlear nerve injury.

DATABASES REVIEWED

PubMed, Embase, and Scopus.

METHODS

A literature search was performed from inception to September 2023. The search terms were designed to capture articles on misplaced arrays and the management options. Articles written in English that described cases of array misplacement into the IAC for children and adults were included. The level of evidence was assessed using Oxford Center for Evidence Based Medicine guidelines. Descriptive statistical analyses were performed.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight cases of arrays misplaced in the IAC were identified. Thirteen (46%) were patients with incomplete partition type 3 (IP3), and 7 (25%) were patients with common cavity (CC) malformations. Most misplaced arrays were identified postoperatively (19 cases; 68%). Of these cases, 11 (58%) were managed with array removal. No facial nerve injuries were reported with revision surgery. Eight cases (42%) were left in place. Several underwent mapping procedures in an attempt improve the sound quality with the CI.

CONCLUSION

Electrode array misplacement in the IAC is a rare complication that reportedly occurs predominately in cases with IP3 and CC malformations. Removal of misplaced arrays from the IAC reportedly has not been associated with facial nerve injuries. Cases identified with IAC misplacement postoperatively can potentially be managed with modified mapping techniques before proceeding with revision surgery.

A New Treatment Option in Incomplete Partition Type III: The Varese Bone-Air Stimulation (B.A.S.)

The incomplete partition type III is a severe cochlear malformation present in X-linked deafness. It is a rare, non-syndromic cause of severe to profound mixed hearing loss, often progressive. The complete absence of bony modiolus and the wide communication between the cochlea and the internal auditory canal make cochlear implantation challenging, with still no consensus on the management of these patients. To the best of our knowledge, no results have ever been published in the literature on the treatment of these patients with hybrid stimulation (bone and air). We present three cases in which this hybrid stimulation gave better audiological results then air stimulation alone. A literature review on audiological results of the current treatment options in children affected by IPIII malformation was conducted independently by two researchers. Ethical considerations on the treatment of these patients were conducted by the Bioethics department of the University of Insubria. In two of the patients, the bone-air stimulation, associated with prosthetic-cognitive rehabilitation, meant that surgery was avoided, obtaining similar communication performances of those present in the literature. We believe that, when the bone threshold appears partially preserved, a stimulation through the bone or hybrid modality, such as the Varese B.A.S. stimulation, should be attempted.

Considering gene therapy to protect from X-linked deafness DFNX2 and associated neurodevelopmental disorders

Mutations and deletions in the gene or upstream of the gene encoding the POU3F4 transcription factor cause X-linked progressive deafness DFNX2 and additional neurodevelopmental disorders in humans. Hearing loss can be purely sensorineural or mixed, that is, with both conductive and sensorineural components. Affected males show anatomical abnormalities of the inner ear, which are jointly defined as incomplete partition type III. Current approaches to improve hearing and speech skills of DFNX2 patients do not seem to be fully effective. Owing to inner ear malformations, cochlear implantation is surgically difficult and may predispose towards severe complications. Even in cases where implantation is safely performed, hearing and speech outcomes remain highly variable among patients. Mouse models for DFNX2 deafness revealed that sensorineural loss could arise from a dysfunction of spiral ligament fibrocytes in the lateral wall of the cochlea, which leads to reduced endocochlear potential. Highly positive endocochlear potential is critical for sensory hair cell mechanotransduction and hearing. In this context, here, we propose to develop a therapeutic approach in male Pou3f4 -/y mice based on an adeno-associated viral (AAV) vector-mediated gene transfer in cochlear spiral ligament fibrocytes. Among a broad range of AAV vectors, AAV7 was found to show a strong tropism for the spiral ligament. Thus, we suggest that an AAV7-mediated delivery of Pou3f4 complementary DNA in the spiral ligament of Pou3f4 -/y mice could represent an attractive strategy to prevent fibrocyte degeneration and to restore normal cochlear functions and properties, including a positive endocochlear potential, before hearing loss progresses to profound deafness.

Frequency Mapping of a Precurved Electrode Array in the Internal Auditory Canal for a Pediatric Cochlear Implant Recipient

OBJECTIVES

Review the effectiveness of an alternative mapping procedure of a precurved electrode array in the internal auditory canal (IAC).

DESIGN

A 7-year-old bilateral cochlear implant (CI) recipient of precurved arrays transferred to the study site and demonstrated no speech recognition with the left CI. Imaging revealed bilateral incomplete partition type III malformations. For the left CI, four contacts were observed in the basal cochlear turn and 18 contacts were coiled in the IAC. The family decided against revision surgery. Pitch ranking was completed to map the contacts in the IAC that were perceptually discrete and tonotopically organized.

RESULTS

For the left CI, PB-K word recognition improved from no recognition to 32% after 1 month and to 52% after 3 months. In the bilateral CI condition, performance improved from 56 to 72% after 1 month and 80% after 3 months.

CONCLUSION

A precurved array in the IAC creates difficult management decisions. Direct stimulation of the auditory nerve resulted in better monaural and bilateral speech recognition, likely due to better spectral representation of the speech signal. Individualizing the map using imaging and behavioral findings may improve performance for malpositioned arrays when revision surgery is not pursued.

Cochlear implantation in a Chinese patient with a novel frameshift variant in POU3F4 gene and incomplete partition type III: a case report

Variations in the POU Class 3 Homeobox 4 ( POU3F4) gene are associated with X-linked mixed deafness. Here, the identification of a novel variant of POU3F4 in a male paediatric patient (the proband) with incomplete partition type III (IP-III) hearing impairment, is described. Clinical data were collected from the proband and his biological parents. Whole exome sequencing of the proband revealed a novel frameshift insertion mutation in POU3F4 (c.717_718ins GTGCCTTGCAG : p.Leu240Valfs*5) in a hemizygous state. This variant likely truncates the protein within the POU-specific domain, and the proband’s biological mother was found to be a carrier of this variant. After excluding all contraindications, the proband underwent cochlear implantation in the right ear in June 2020. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) gushing was observed during surgery, but there were no postoperative complications, such as CSF leak, meningitis, or facial nerve stimulation. A novel pathogenic frameshift variant of POU3F4 was identified, enriching the known mutation spectrum of POU3F4. Effective perioperative prevention and response measures should be taken to reduce the incidence of CSF gushing and meningitis in patients receiving IP-III cochlear implantation.

X-linked Malformation Deafness: Neurodevelopmental Symptoms Are Common in Children With IP3 Malformation and Mutation in POU3F4

Supplemental Digital Content is available in the text.

Incomplete partition type 3 (IP3) malformation deafness is a rare hereditary cause of congenital or rapid progressive hearing loss. The children present with a severe to profound mixed hearing loss and temporal bone imaging show a typical inner ear malformation classified as IP3. Cochlear implantation is one option of hearing restoration in severe cases. Little is known about other specific difficulties these children might exhibit, for instance possible neurodevelopmental symptoms.

A New Pathogenic Variant in POU3F4 Causing Deafness Due to an Incomplete Partition of the Cochlea Paved the Way for Innovative Surgery

Incomplete partition type III (IP-III) is a relatively rare inner ear malformation that has been associated with a POU3F4 gene mutation. The IP-III anomaly is mainly characterized by incomplete separation of the modiolus of the cochlea from the internal auditory canal. We describe a 71-year-old woman with profound sensorineural hearing loss diagnosed with an IP-III of the cochlea that underwent cochlear implantation. Via targeted sequencing with a non-syndromic gene panel, we identified a heterozygous c.934G > C p. (Ala31Pro) pathogenic variant in the POU3F4 gene that has not been reported previously. IP-III of the cochlea is challenging for cochlear implant surgery for two main reasons: liquor cerebrospinalis gusher and electrode misplacement. Surgically, it may be better to opt for a shorter array because it is less likely for misplacement with the electrode in a false route. Secondly, the surgeon has to consider the insertion angles of cochlear access very strictly to avoid misplacement along the inner ear canal. Genetic results in well describes genotype-phenotype correlations are a strong clinical tool and as in this case guided surgical planning and robotic execution.

Systematic Review of Outcomes After Cochlear Implantation in Children With X-Linked Deafness-2

OBJECTIVE

Outcomes following cochlear implantation in children with X-linked deafness-2 are variable, resulting in challenges in appropriate preoperative counseling. To address this uncertainty, we performed a systematic review and synthesis of the literature on audiologic and speech outcomes after cochlear implantation in these patients to inform prognostic counseling.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library were queried for articles published between January 2000 and July 2019.

REVIEW METHODS

We performed a systematic review of all studies published between 2000 and 2019 that reported on (1) children with confirmed X-linked deafness-2 undergoing cochlear implantation and (2) formal assessment of hearing and/or speech capabilities postimplantation.

RESULTS

Our initial database search yielded 313 articles. Fourteen articles met inclusion criteria. These studies reported on 61 children with X-linked deafness-2 who underwent implantation at a wide age range (1-29 years) for severe-profound sensorineural hearing loss of prelingual onset. The mean follow-up duration after implant activation was 32 months (range, 12-61). Outcome domains assessed at follow-up were heterogeneous, though each study employed at least 1 assessment of hearing (eg, pure tone audiometry), speech perception (eg, Early Speech Perception Test), or auditory perception (eg, Categories of Auditory Perception scores). In 10 of 14 studies, cochlear implantation afforded significant improvement in hearing and speech capabilities relative to preoperative performance or as compared with age-matched, normal-hearing controls.

CONCLUSION

The majority of studies demonstrate that cochlear implantation provides improvements in hearing and speech performance in patients with X-linked deafness-2. This information is valuable for decision making regarding cochlear implantation in these patients.

Outcomes of cochlear implantation in patients with incomplete partition type III

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the outcomes of the surgery of cochlear implantation (CI) in patients with incomplete partition type III.

METHODS

Five patients (6 ears) with incomplete partition type III were performed CI from January 2010 and July 2018. Five ears were performed CI with extended round window approach. One ear was performed with round window approach.

RESULTS

The results of computed tomography (CT) showed proper placement of the electrode in 5 ears with extended round window approach. The electrode went into the internal auditory canal in one ear with round window approach. The scores of patients in the CAP and SIR assessment significantly improved after cochlear implantation in all patients during an follow-up period of 12 months.

CONCLUSIONS

CI with extended round window approach in patients with incomplete partition type III is a safe and effective method, but also a challenging task. This method maybe avoid the problem of electrode insertion into the IAC.

Incomplete partition type III revisited-long-term results following cochlear implant

BACKGROUND

Incomplete partition type III (IP III) is defined by a missing lamina cribrosa between the cochlea and the internal auditory canal (IAC). Cochlear implantation (CI) may result in an insertion of the electrode array into the IAC. The aim of this study is to evaluate CI surgery protocols, long-term audiological outcome, mapping and electrophysiological data after CI in IP III patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Nine IP III patients were implanted with perimodiolar electrode arrays between 1999 and 2014; eight of them were included in this study. We evaluated mapping data, stapedius reflexes, electrode impedances and ECAP thresholds. We matched them with 3 CI patients each with normal cochlear morphology regarding sex, age, side, implant type and surgical date. Speech discrimination was evaluated with the Oldenburger sentence test for adults, Göttingen audiometric speech test for children and the Freiburger monosyllabic word test.

RESULTS

3 years after CI IP III patients showed a significant increase in pulse width, calculated electric load and electrode impedances in basal electrodes. Intraoperative electrically-evoked stapedius reflexes could be measured in all patients. Speech recognition scores were lower than average scores for matched patients, but without statistical significance.

CONCLUSIONS

The significant increase of pulse width, electric load and electrode impedances of basal electrodes over time seem to be characteristic for IP III patients probably occurring due to fibrosis and neurodegeneration of the cochlear nerve. The long term audiological results are stable. Intraoperative imaging and stapedius reflexes are highly recommended to control the right position of the electrode array.

[Incomplete partition type III revisited-long-term results following cochlear implant. German version]

BACKGROUND

Incomplete partition type III (IP III) is defined by a missing lamina cribrosa between the cochlea and the internal auditory canal (IAC). Cochlear implantation (CI) may result in an insertion of the electrode array into the IAC. The aim of this study is to evaluate CI surgery protocols, long-term audiological outcome, mapping and electrophysiological data after CI in IP III patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Nine IP III patients were implanted with perimodiolar electrode arrays between 1999 and 2014; eight of them were included in this study. We evaluated mapping data, stapedius reflexes, electrode impedances and ECAP thresholds. We matched them with 3 CI patients each with normal cochlear morphology regarding sex, age, side, implant type and surgical date. Speech discrimination was evaluated with the Oldenburger sentence test for adults, Göttingen audiometric speech test for children and the Freiburger monosyllabic word test.

RESULTS

3 years after CI IP III patients showed a significant increase in pulse width, calculated electric load and electrode impedances in basal electrodes. Intraoperative electrically-evoked stapedius reflexes could be measured in all patients. Speech recognition scores were lower than average scores for matched patients, but without statistical significance.

CONCLUSIONS

The significant increase of pulse width, electric load and electrode impedances of basal electrodes over time seem to be characteristic for IP III patients probably occurring due to fibrosis and neurodegeneration of the cochlear nerve. The long term audiological results are stable. Intraoperative imaging and stapedius reflexes are highly recommended to control the right position of the electrode array.

X-linked Malformation and Cochlear Implantation

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate if cochlear implantation is safe and constitutes an option for hearing rehabilitation of children with x-linked inner ear malformation.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective patient review in combination with a multidisciplinary follow-up.

SETTING

Tertiary referral hospital and cochlear implant program.

PATIENTS

Ten children with severe-profound mixed hearing loss and radiological findings consistent with Incomplete Partition type 3 cochlear malformation received cochlear implants during the years 2007 to 2015. Nine of the children had a mutation affecting the gene POU3F4 on Xq21.

INTERVENTION

Cochlear implantation.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Surgical events, intraoperative measures and electrical stimulation levels, hearing and spoken language abilities.

RESULTS

In all, 15 cochlear implantations were performed. In three cases the electrode was found to be in the internal auditory canal on intraoperative x-ray and repositioned successfully. One child had a postoperative rhinorrhea confirmed to be cerebrospinal fluid but this resolved on conservative treatment. No severe complications occurred. Postoperative electrical stimulation levels were higher in 9 of 10 children, as compared with typically reported average levels in patients with a normal cochlea. Eight patients developed spoken language to various degrees while two were still at precommunication level. However, speech recognition scores were lower than average pediatric cases.

CONCLUSION

Cochlear implantation is a safe procedure for children with severe-profound mixed hearing loss related to POU3F4 mutation inner ear malformation. The children develop hearing and spoken language but outcome is below average for pediatric CI recipients.

Cochlear implantation in X-linked deafness - How to manage the surgical challenges

OBJECTIVE AND IMPORTANCE

In children with X-linked deafness, cochlear malformations challenge the implant surgeon to avoid electrode insertion into the internal auditory meatus and prevent a continuous cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak. We describe our experience of cochlear implantation (CI) in two children with profound hearing loss secondary to X-linked deafness, highlighting safer operative techniques to avoid potential complications.

CLINICAL PRESENTATION

Descriptive cases of two children with X-linked deafness (patient 1 and patient 2) undergoing CI. Peri-operative imaging and work-up to surgery are discussed. Specific operative considerations, post-operative complications and subsequent audiological performance are highlighted.

TECHNIQUE

In each case, intra-operative fluoroscopic imaging ensured intra-cochlear insertion of electrodes. Expected CSF gusher was seen in each case which was initially controlled by packing around the cochleostomy and array with temporalis muscle and fascia. Patient 1 developed post-operative meningitis secondary to continuous CSF leak. We avoided further significant CSF leak by planning staged procedures for patient 2, with obliteration of the middle ear cleft and external ear canal (EAC) at the time of implantation. In both patients, bilateral implantation successfully provided hearing thresholds of less than 35 dB in both ears at routine follow up.

CONCLUSIONS

When planning for CI in children with radiological features of X-linked deafness, intra-operative imaging should be utilized to ensure correct electrode positioning. Traditional methods of stopping a CSF gusher may not suffice. We therefore encourage additional surgical obliteration of the middle ear space and EAC to avoid persistent CSF leak and its associated complications.