Carbon dioxide laser versus cold-steel supraglottoplasty: A comparison of post-operative outcomes

Characteristics and outcomes of interventions for pediatric laryngomalacia: A systematic review with meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To analyze characteristics of children treated for laryngomalacia to determine predictive factors and provide an updated meta-analysis on outcomes.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted according to PRISMA guidelines from inception to May 2, 2023, using CINAHL, PubMed, and Scopus databases. Study screening, data extraction, quality rating, and risk of bias assessment were performed by 2 independent reviewers. Data were meta-analyzed using fixed-/random-effects model to derive continuous measures (mean), proportions (%), and mean difference (Δ) with 95% confidence interval (CI).

RESULTS

100 articles were identified with information on outcomes of pediatric patients with laryngomalacia (N = 18,317). The mean age was 10.6 months (range: 0 to 252, 95%CI: 9.6 to 11.6, p = 0.00) with a 1.4:1 male to female ratio. Many patients presented with stridor (87.9%, 95% CI: 69.8 to 98.4), and the most common comorbidity at time of diagnosis was gastroesophageal reflux disease (48.8%, 95%CI: 40.9 to 56.8). Based on the patient population included in our analysis, 86.1% received supraglottoplasty (95% CI: 78.7 to 92.1). A total of 73.6% (95% CI: 65.5 to 81.0) had reported complete resolution of symptoms. For patients with a concurrent diagnosis of sleep disordered breathing receiving supraglottoplasty, the apnea-hypopnea index improved with a mean difference of -10.0 (95%CI: 15.6 to -4.5) events per hour post-treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Laryngomalacia continues to be a common problem in the pediatric population. Supraglottoplasty remains an effective treatment option leading to symptomatic improvement in many cases. For those with concurrent sleep disordered breathing, supraglottoplasty lowers the apnea-hypopnea index.

Evaluating the Need for Intensive Care Admission After Supraglottoplasty for Severe Laryngomalacia

OBJECTIVE

Postoperative airway concerns persist despite a low rate of post-supraglottoplasty complications for children with laryngomalacia. The objective of this study is to determine the factors associated with the need for intensive care unit (ICU) admission following supraglottoplasty.

METHODS

A 7-year retrospective cohort analysis was conducted between 2014 and 2021. A patient requiring ICU level of care was defined as the use of respiratory support such as intubation, positive pressure ventilation, high-flow nasal cannula, or multiple doses of nebulized epinephrine.

RESULTS

About 134 medical charts were reviewed; 12 patients were excluded because of concurrent surgery. Age at the time of surgery was 2.8 (4.3) months (median [interquartile range]). About 33 (27.0%) ultimately required ICU-level care. Prematurity (odds ratio [OR] 13.8), neurological condition (OR ∞), American Society of Anesthesiology class 3-4 (OR 6.5), and younger age (OR 1.8) were more likely to require ICU admission. No patient above 10 months of age needed ICU monitoring. The use of respiratory support justifying ICU was known within the first 4 h after surgery for almost all (32/33, 97%) of these patients. 4/33 (12.1%) were kept intubated and the remaining needed non-invasive ventilation. Only one patient (1/122, 0.8%) was reintubated 12 h after surgery for progressive respiratory distress.

CONCLUSION

Approximately a quarter of patients required ICU-level care after supraglottoplasty. For nearly all patients without comorbidities requiring ICU, this can be safely predicted within the first 4 h after surgery. Our data suggest that selected patients undergoing supraglottoplasty may be safely monitored outside of an ICU setting after an observation period in the post-anesthesia care unit.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 134:466-470, 2024.

Disposition to pediatric intensive care unit post supraglottoplasty repair: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Patients undergoing supraglottoplasty are often routinely admitted post-operatively to the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) due to rare but potentially fatal complications such as airway compromise. A systematic review was performed to determine the rate of post-operative PICU-level respiratory support required by pediatric patients following supraglottoplasty, to identify risk factors for patients who may benefit from post-operative PICU admission and limit unnecessary use of intensivist resources.

REVIEW METHODS

Key search terms 'supraglottoplasty' OR 'supraglottoplasties' were queried on three databases: CINHAL, Medline and Embase. Inclusion criteria were pediatric patients under 18 years of age who underwent a supraglottoplasty procedure with either an admission to PICU or requirement for PICU-level respiratory support. Risk of bias was assessed by two independent reviewers using QUADAS-2. Findings were critically appraised by three independent reviewers and pooled proportions of criteria meeting PICU admission were calculated for meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Nine studies met inclusion criteria, totaling 922 patients. Age at time of surgery ranged from 19 days to 15.7 years with mean age of 5.65 months. A weighted pooled estimate suggested that 19% (95% CI 14-24%) of patients who underwent supraglottoplasty required PICU-admission. The included studies revealed several patient and surgical factors have been linked to postoperative respiratory issues requiring PICU admission, including: neurological disease, perioperative oxygen saturation < 95%, prolonged surgical time and age < 2 months.

CONCLUSIONS

This study found that the majority of supraglottoplasty patients do not require significant postoperative respiratory support and suggests that routine PICU admission of these patients may be avoided by careful patient selection. Given the wide heterogeneity of outcome measures, further studies are needed to determine the ideal PICU admission criteria following supraglottoplasty.

Optimal laser usage improves surgical efficiency in pediatric supraglottoplasty

OBJECTIVES

To compare patient specific and surgical efficiency outcomes in children undergoing supraglottoplasty (SGP) with flexible fiber CO2 laser in Ultrapulse mode versus cold steel at a tertiary care center.

METHODS

A single surgeon retrospective cohort study of pediatric patients with laryngomalacia undergoing SGP without concomitant or prior airway surgery. We reviewed perioperative complications, total hospital stay including intensive care admission, symptom resolution and the need for revision surgery. Surgical efficiency was measured as the mean total operative time and laryngeal suspension time.

RESULTS

Among 63 patients, 32 cold steel SGPs were compared with 31 flexible fiber CO2 Ultrapulse laser SGPs. There was no statistical difference in the demographic profile. There was no statistical difference in need for intraoperative resuscitation (1 [3.0%] vs 0 [0%] cases) or perioperative intubation (4 [12.1%] vs 2 [6.3%] cases), mean total days in ICU (1.09 [0.51] vs 1.06 [0.44] [p = 0.38]) or days hospitalized (1.73 [1.67] vs 1.62 [2.27] [p = 0.42]), symptom resolution, need for revision surgery (2 [6.3%] vs 0 [0%] [p = 0.49] patients) or mean operative time (29.0 [14.19] vs. 32.2 [22.71] [p = 0.95] minutes). There was a statistically significant decreased time in laryngeal suspension in the laser group versus cold steel group (5.9 [1.80] vs 7.9 [2.19] [p = 0.006] minutes).

CONCLUSION

For pediatric SGPs, optimal flexible fiber CO2 laser usage can improve surgical efficiency in comparison to cold steel, with no differences in postoperative outcomes or complications. Both the flexible fiber CO2 laser and cold steel SGPs are safe and effective methods for treatment of laryngomalacia.

Risk factors for peri-operative respiratory adverse events after supraglottoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To determine demographic and peri-operative characteristics that predict peri-operative respiratory adverse events (PRAE) requiring intensive care unit (ICU) level intervention after supraglottoplasty.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series with chart review.

SETTING

Tertiary care children's hospital.

METHODS

Retrospective chart review was conducted of children with laryngomalacia who underwent supraglottoplasty between October 2014 and November 2019. PRAE were defined as any of the following events or requirements within 24 h of surgery: 1) failure to extubate, 2) reintubation, 3) positive pressure ventilation, 4) more than one dose of racemic epinephrine, or 5) greater than 4 L of oxygen via nasal cannula.

RESULTS

Fifty-one subjects were enrolled, with a median age of 4.8 months and majority (62 %) Hispanic. Twenty-one (41 %) subjects experienced PRAE. After adjusting for age and gender on multivariate analysis, children admitted preoperatively to the ICU were more likely to have PRAE than those not admitted or admitted to a floor unit (OR 40.1, 95%CI: 4.1-388.6, p = 0.001). Additionally, children with intraoperative oxygen desaturations below 90 % for greater than 1 min were more likely to have PRAE than those who did not (OR 21.3, 95%CI: 2.4-189.9, p = 0.006). Other factors significantly associated with PRAE on univariate analysis included chronic lung disease, congenital cardiac abnormality, history of intubation, supplemental oxygen requirement, gastrostomy tube dependence, intraoperative intubation and longer surgery length.

CONCLUSION

Preoperative ICU admission and intraoperative oxygen desaturations are independent risk factors for PRAE after supraglottoplasty. Results from this study can help inform decisions regarding the appropriate level of postoperative care required after supraglottoplasty.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.