Pediatric turbinate radiofrequency ablation improves quality of life and rhinomanometric values. A prospective study

Efficacy and safety of turbinate reduction surgery in children: a systematic review

PURPOSE

Inferior turbinate hypertrophy is not a rare problem in children, it causes chronic nasal obstruction which can severely impact the quality of life. This study aimed to investigate the efficacy and safety of turbinate reduction surgery in children with impaired nasal breathing due to hypertrophied inferior turbinate that's refractory to medical treatment.

METHODS

We included 23 articles with various study designs: randomized controlled trials, single-arm clinical trials, and prospective and retrospective cohort studies. We searched PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science with the relevant keywords till April 9th, 2023. The inclusion criteria were studied with the three prespecified study design that addressed children under 18 years who underwent turbinate reduction with any technique and evaluating the improvement whether by objective or subjective methods.

RESULTS

Studies used objective measures favor turbinate surgery except two that showed no significant difference between pre and postoperative results. All studies used subjective measures showed an improvement postoperatively except one study. Complication rates are rare, with crust formation is being the commonest (6.03%), however, the procedure is generally safe in children. In addition, follow-up periods varied widely between 2 weeks and more than 5 years.

CONCLUSION

Turbinate reduction in children is an effective as a treatment method for nasal blockage due to inferior turbinate hypertrophy which is resistant to medical treatment. It is a safe procedure with low rates of complications, however, due to the heterogenicity of the study designs, with a possible risk of bias we could not conduct a meta-analysis besides our systematic review.

Pediatric Inferior Turbinate Hypertrophy: Diagnosis and Management. A YO-IFOS Consensus Statement

OBJECTIVE

Pediatric inferior turbinate hypertrophy (PedTH) is a frequent and often overlooked cause or associated cause of nasal breathing difficulties. This clinical consensus statement (CCS) aims to provide a diagnosis and management framework covering the lack of specific guidelines for this condition and addressing the existing controversies.

METHODS

A clinical consensus statement (CCS) was developed by a panel of 20 contributors from 7 different European and North American countries using the modified Delphi method. The aim of the CCS was to offer a multidisciplinary reference framework for the management of PedTH on the basis of shared clinical experience and analysis of the strongest evidence currently available.

RESULTS

A systematic literature review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) criteria was performed. From the initial 96 items identified, 7 articles were selected based on higher-evidence items such as randomized-controlled trials, guidelines, and systematic reviews. A 34-statement survey was developed, and after three rounds of voting, 2 items reached strong consensus, 17 reached consensus or near consensus, and 15 had no consensus.

CONCLUSIONS

Until further prospective data are available, our CCS should provide a useful reference for PedTH management. PedTH should be considered a nasal obstructive disease not necessarily related to an adult condition but frequently associated with other nasal or craniofacial disorders. Diagnosis requires clinical examination and endoscopy, whereas rhinomanometry, nasal cytology, and questionnaires have little clinical role. Treatment choice should consider the specific indications and features of the available options, with a preference for less invasive procedures.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

5 Laryngoscope, 134:1437-1444, 2024.

Pediatric inferior turbinate surgery: A review and meta-analysis of midterm nasal patency

OBJECTIVES

The surgical treatment of children with enlarged inferior turbinates is still controversial. Foundational evidence for indicating turbinoplasty is still scarce, and there is a myriad of proposed techniques. This work aimed to address the midterm nasal obstruction outcomes of pediatric inferior turbinate surgery.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A Literature search across PUBMED and Cochrane collaboration databases was undertaken, using the MeSH terms: turbinates, nasal obstruction, surgery, and children. Articles focusing on turbinate surgery with an exclusively pediatric cohort were included. The minimum follow-up time for inclusion was set at four months, and only the latest available follow-up in each study was considered. All the integrated studies used objective instruments to quantify nasal obstruction before and after surgery. A comprehensive review and meta-analysis were performed to assess nasal outcomes after the intervention. The 95% confidence interval of the effect magnitude for each study was calculated to elucidate effect sizes.

RESULTS

Seven studies met the inclusion criteria for review, and five were included in the meta-analysis, accounting for a total of 510 patients. The follow-up period ranged from 4 months to 1 year. Pooled results showed that nasal patency was significantly improved after surgery (p < 0.001) in the midterm follow-up. No significant differences were found between bone-sparing and bone-removal procedures (p = 0.38).

CONCLUSION

This is the first meta-analysis to address midterm results of pediatric turbinate surgery. Our results suggest a positive impact of inferior turbinate surgery on nasal patency, irrespective of technique.

A review of health-related quality of life issues in children suffering from certain key otolaryngological illnesses

BACKGROUND

The health-related quality of life (HRQoL) concept is nowadays increasingly and more broadly used for helping evaluate the effectiveness of medical treatment, superseding the earlier "quality of life" approach. The HRQoL concept likewise applies to otolaryngology and this narrative review study is focused on HRQoL outcomes in four key childhood otolaryngological diseases as reported in the literature.

STUDY AIM

To retrospectively evaluate the literature on measuring HRQoL in children suffering from selected otolaryngological illnesses, during treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Published studies/case reports were searched for in Medline, PubMed, Web of Science, Scopus and ORCID on the quality of life based on paediatric patient questionnaires, whether completed by subjects themselves or by their parents (by proxy). The following key words were used: health quality of life, otolaryngology/ENT, pediatrics/paediatrics. Studies before 1999 were omitted because hitherto, the "quality of life" had been imprecisely defined thus rendering any subsequent comparisions problematic.

RESULTS

HRQoL scores and well-being were found to significantly deteriorate in child patients suffering from four important otolaryngological disorders: chronic sinusitis, nasal septum deviation, adenoid hypertrophy and hearing disease. The main problems found were infection, inflammation, disruption to family life and child-parental interaction, fitness-related issues, reduced ENT patencies and apnea.

CONCLUSIONS

The HRQoL appears to significantly deteriorate in children suffering from otolaryngological diseases. Further such studies are needed for other ENT diseases.