The management of rectal cancer in a resource poor environment - a review

Radiological staging of rectal cancer in a resource limited setting

Objective

Current guidelines on rectal cancer (RC) management recommend pre-operative MRI for loco-regional staging and CT for staging of metastases. This allows appropriate selection of patients for chemo-radiotherapy (CRT). However, MRI is not freely available in many low-income countries. We assessed the status of pre-operative imaging for RC in Sri Lanka and evaluated the performance of CT in RC staging.

Results

A pre-tested interview-administered questionnaire was used to assess the pre-operative use of MRI and CT in RC. CT findings from 37 RC patients were then compared with histopathology findings. Of the 64 surgeons interviewed, 57 (89.1%) did not request an MRI for their RC patients. Reasons cited included limited availability and long waiting times due to competing health needs. A CT was requested by all. In RC, the overall accuracy of CT for T staging was 43.2% and 29.7% of T1–T2 tumours were over-staged as T3. The overall accuracy of CT for regional lymph node staging was 70.3%. In summary, CT alone is not suitable for RC staging in any setting. It leads to over-staging and patients may thus receive unnecessary CRT. Steps must be taken to improve access to pre-operative MRI among Sri Lankan RC patients.

How comparable is so-called standard fracture fixation with an identical implant? A prospective experience with the antegrade femoral nail in South Africa and Europe

BACKGROUND

The utilisation and consequences of standardised operative procedures may importantly differ between different healthcare systems. This is the first investigation comparing the treatment and outcome of femoral shaft fractures stabilised with an identical implant between trauma centres in 2 continents (Europe, EU and South Africa, SA).

METHODS

Following standardised introduction of the technique, the prospective, observational multicentre study enrolled 175 patients who underwent intramedullary fracture fixation using the antegrade femoral nail (AFN) for femoral shaft fractures. Eleven EU hospitals recruited 86 patients and 1 SA centre 89 patients in the study period. Comparison of epidemiologic data, operative characteristics as well as subjective (e.g., pain, SF-36) and objective (e.g., X-ray, range of motion [ROM]) 3-month and 1-year outcomes were performed (p<0.05).

RESULTS

Compared to EU centres, several significant differences were observed in SA: (1) on average, patients operated on were younger, had less concomitant diseases and had more severe open fractures; (2) operative stabilisation was more often undertaken by young, unsupervised residents, with shorter operating and intraoperative fluoroscopy times; (3) mean hospital stay was shorter, with less recorded complications, but a higher loss to follow-up rate. Non- or malunion rates and subjective outcomes were similar for both groups, with the physical component of the SF-36 at the 1-year follow-up not fully restoring to baseline values.

CONCLUSIONS

Our investigation demonstrates the importance of several major differences between 2 different regions of the world in the treatment of femoral shaft fractures, despite involving only high level trauma centres and using an identical implant. The intercontinental comparison of results from clinical studies should be interpreted very carefully considering the heterogeneity of populations and clinical settings.

Surgical outcome of abdominoperineal resection for low rectal cancer in a Nigerian tertiary institution

BACKGROUND

Rectal cancer is a lifestyle-related illness with an increasing incidence in all developing countries in the last decade. Abdominoperineal resection (APR) offers a good oncologic clearance for low rectal cancer. The remaining controversies surrounding APR, as it is performed in a tertiary center in Nigeria, involve defining the role the operation plays in the management of existing rectal problems and determining what outcomes can be expected. The present study was aimed at examining the surgical outcomes of APR for low rectal cancers in a Nigerian tertiary institution.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This single-institution, retrospective, descriptive study analyzed APR rate, patient sex and age, subsite involvement, the diagnostic process, follow-up, and survival patterns after treatment of low rectal cancers. The study was conducted at Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospital Complex Ile-Ife, Nigeria, between January 1989 and December 2007.

RESULTS

During the 18-year period, 36 patients underwent APR. This accounts for 24.0% of all patients that had low rectal cancer. The age of the patients ranged from 29 years to 74 years (median: 58.9 years). Most of the patients were 60 years of age or older, and the majority were women (55.9%). The median duration of symptoms was 12 months, and all patients sought medical care for bleeding per rectum. Close to 80% of patients had advanced disease at presentation. Postoperatively, 17 patients (50%) had at least one complication and one patient (2.9%) died. Four (11.8%) patients had recurrence of the tumor, and in every case, recurrence occurred within the first year after operation. Operative blood loss (p = 0.006), degree of differentiation of the tumor (p = 0.011), distance from the anal verge (p = 0.033), and operative stage (p = 0.005) were found to significantly affect the outcome of treatment for the patients who underwent APR. The operative stage similarly affected the survival of patients (Mantel Cox = 0.026).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the advanced disease of our patients, the outcome of management appears to be comparable with results reported from other centers.