In vitro analysis of varus-valgus laxity of the knee joint: Comparison of clinical evaluation with measurements using a reference motion analysis system

The contralateral knee is a good predictor for determining normal knee stability: a cadaveric study

PURPOSE

The goal is to evaluate contralateral knee joint laxity and ascertain whether or not contralateral symmetry is observable. Secondary, a validation of a knee laxity testing rig is provided.

METHODS

Seven pairs of cadaveric knee specimens have been tested under passive conditions with and without external loads, involving a varus/valgus and an external/internal rotational torque and an anteroposterior shear force.

RESULTS

Through the range of motion, the width of the varus/valgus laxity, internal/external laxity and anterior/posterior laxity for the medial and lateral compartment show no significant differences between left and right leg. These findings allow us to validate the setup, especially for relative values of laxity based on anatomical measures and knee joint biomechanics.

CONCLUSION

A multidirectional laxity symmetry has been demonstrated for the intact knee and its contralateral knee in passive conditions as in an anesthetized patient. The passive laxity evaluation setup has been validated. Our work furthermore demonstrated a pronounced difference in anteroposterior mobility between the medial and lateral compartment of the knee, with a more stable medial side and more mobile lateral side.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The contralateral knee can be used as reference for determining optimal knee laxity peri-operatively in total knee replacement and ligament reconstruction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, Case series.

Reproducibility of an optical measurement system for the clinical evaluation of active knee rotation in weight-bearing, healthy subjects

INTRODUCTION

A knee is typically evaluated passively by a clinician during an office visit, without using dedicated measurement tools. When the knee is evaluated with the patient standing and actively participating in the movement, the results will differ than when the knee is passively moved through its range-of-motion by the surgeon. If a precise measurement system was available, it could provide additional information to the clinician during this evaluation.

HYPOTHESIS

The goal of this study was to verify the reproducibility of a fast, flexible optical measurement system to measure rotational knee laxity during weight-bearing.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Two passive reflective targets were placed on the legs of 11 subjects to monitor femur and tibia displacements in three dimensions. Subjects performed internal and external rotation movements with the knee extended or flexed 30°. During each movement, seven variables were measured: internal rotation, external rotation and overall laxity in extension and 30° flexion, along with neutral rotation value in 30° flexion. Measurement accuracy was also assessed and the right and left knees were compared. Reproducibility was assessed over two measurements sessions.

RESULTS

The calculated intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) for reproducibility was above 0.9 for five of the seven variables measured. The calculated ICC for the right/left comparison was above 0.75 for five of the seven variables measured.

DISCUSSION

These results confirmed that the proposed system provides reproducible measurements. Our right/left comparison results were consistent with the published literature. This system is fast, reproducible and flexible, which makes it suitable for assessing various weight-bearing movements during clinical evaluations.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, experimental study.