Steam condensation heat transfer on lubricant-infused surfaces

Limits of dropwise condensation heat transfer on dry nonwetting surfaces

Surface condensation is ubiquitous in applications such as power generation and desalination. Nonwetting surfaces have been studied extensively for their dropwise condensation potential with reports of dramatic improvements relative to the classical Nusselt equation for film-wise condensation that has long served as a reference theoretical lower bound on the condensation heat transfer coefficient. However, a theoretical upper bound on the maximum possible condensation heat transfer over a given surface is not available. Considering actual surface topographies as fractal surfaces, we present theoretical upper bounds for gravity-driven and jumping droplet condensation modes in a unified manner. Experimental data on steam condensation from this study as well as the literature on dry nonwetting surfaces are compared to the bounds to identify the opportunity gap to the theoretical maximum. Solid-infused surfaces, introduced recently by the authors, are shown to fall in this opportunity space, closer to the upper bound.

Investigating the Effects of Lubricant Infusion Methods on Polymer SLIPS

Slippery lubricant infused porous surfaces (SLIPSs) are promising bioinspired surfaces with self-healing and droplet wetting properties, among many others, that are desirable due to their range of applications. Recently, there have been many developments in the SLIPS field regarding the creation of textured surfaces and lubricant selection. However, there is a lack of knowledge regarding the method of lubricant infusion. In this study, we aim to fill this void by investigating different infusion methods that impose external forces on the lubricant. We developed our SLIPS by hot embossing nanostructures onto polypropylene by using molds that were laser micromachined. These textured surfaces were then infused with silicone oil using three different infusion methods: ultrasonication, vacuum, and hydrostatic pressure. We analyzed the wettability and slipperiness of the SLIPS by evaluating the critical tilt angle and comparing the sliding velocities of water droplets on each sample at a tilt angle of 20°. Additionally, the durability of the SLIPS was tested by dropping 50 successive water drops onto the samples and evaluating the droplet-surface interactions throughout. The sonicated infusion method yielded SLIPS that performed the best with a contact angle hysteresis of 13°, a critical tilt angle of 18.3°, a sliding velocity of 1.66 mm/s, and the least accumulation of droplets over time with use. These values are greatly improved when compared to the control sample where lubricant was simply dripped on, which resulted in a contact angle hysteresis of 20°, a critical tilt angle of 26.3°, and a sliding velocity of 0.23 mm/s. The sonicated and drip infusion methods were also compared with different materials (stainless steel) and different textures (microstructures). It was found that the improvement in slipperiness using the sonicated infusion method is prominent for nanoscale textures on both stainless steel and polypropylene. In this study, we discuss the challenges with oil depletion in SLIPS (cloaking and wetting ridges) and with the selection of contact angle measurement methods. While further investigation as to why certain applied forces during infusion yield better SLIPS is warranted, these forces greatly affect the outcome. This work suggests that researchers should consider using sonication or other methods of lubricant infusion that apply external forces as infusion techniques to yield better SLIPS on the nanoscale.

Analysis of freezing of a sessile water droplet on surfaces over a range of wettability

HYPOTHESIS

Nonwetting surfaces, by virtue of their water-repelling trait, offer desirable anti-icing characteristics. Surface roughness, type and wettability are important interfacial characteristics that affect the icing dynamics that can be tailored to achieve desired anti-icing designs.

EXPERIMENTS AND SIMULATIONS

The present study systematically explores the effect of surface roughness on the freezing behaviour of water droplets on surfaces ranging in their wettability. Surfaces with tailored textures and wettability were fabricated using chemical etching and electrodeposition by varying the voltage. The surfaces studied include bare copper, five different dry nonwetting copper surfaces, and five different lubricant-infused copper surfaces that ranged in surface texture fractal dimension from nearly 1.0 to 1.92 and wettability measures of average water contact angle from 91° to 162° and sliding angle from less than 3° to greater than 50°. A computational model is developed to simulate the freezing dynamics on the surfaces studied.

FINDINGS

With increasing roughness features, the freezing time increased due to the dual effects of increased contact angle and poor interfacial conductance caused by trapped air or infused liquid within the asperity textures. In general, the nonwetting surfaces increased the freezing time by a factor of at least 1.33 and up to about 3.2 compared to freezing on bare copper surfaces. The computational model shows close agreement with experimental measurements on the freeze front progression as well as freeze time. Design guidelines on the suitability of the different nonwetting surfaces for anti-icing purposes are derived from the systematic study, with the overall design recommendation favoring lubricant infused surfaces.

Freezing Characteristics of a Water Droplet on a Multiscale Superhydrophobic Surface

Superhydrophobic surfaces have the potential to retard ice formation owing to their super water-repellant nature arising from high static contact angle and low contact angle hysteresis. Most of the previous studies have focused on patterned surfaces with mono-scaled prismatic structures. In contrast, the freezing behavior on multiscaled rough superhydrophobic surfaces that are of practical significance is relatively little studied. This article presents, for the first time, the freezing dynamics of a water droplet interacting with multiscale fractal superhydrophobic surfaces which validates well with experimental measurements. It is shown that the dual effects of increased contact angle and poor interfacial conduction due to trapped air cavities within the roughness features of the superhydrophobic surface lead to increasing freezing time with increasing surface hydrophobicity, determined as a function of the fractal surface parameters. A comparison of the freezing dynamics of sessile droplets of identical contact angle on a smooth versus a rough superhydrophobic surface shows that interfacial asperity thermal resistance contributes to over 14% increase in the freeze time. It is further shown that by tailoring the multiscale characteristics, the freeze time may be increased by up to 7-fold compared to freezing on a smooth surface. The application of the numerical model to studying ice formation on several practical superhydrophobic surfaces of a range of metallic materials and fabrication methods is also discussed, which offers guidelines for the design of anti-icing surfaces in practice.

Novel nonwetting solid-infused surfaces for superior fouling mitigation

Fouling is a ubiquitous issue in several environmental and energy applications. Here we introduce novel nonwetting solid-infused surfaces (SIS) with superior anti-fouling characteristics that are durable than conventional nonwetting surfaces in a dynamic flow environment. A systematic study is presented to elucidate the fouling mitigation performance of SIS in comparison to lubricant-infused surface (LIS) and conventional smooth surface. Copper tubes with SIS, LIS or smooth inner walls are fabricated and subjected to accelerated calcium sulfate fouling in a flow fouling experimental setup. Fouling on the various surface types is quantified in terms of asymptotic fouling resistance, and the fundamental morphological differences in the interactions of the foulant and the various surface types are analyzed. Based on a systematic sweep of the parameter combinations using design of experiments and Taguchi analysis, an analytical dependence of asymptotic fouling resistance on the governing parameters namely, Reynolds number, foulant concentration and temperature is derived. The analytical model is shown to predict the asymptotic fouling resistance to within 20% accuracy with a 95% confidence. In addition, for the first time, the effects of shear durability on the fouling mitigation performance of LIS vis-à-vis SIS are studied. It is shown that the novel nonwetting SIS offers a robust option for superior fouling mitigation over LIS in the long run.

Analysis of silica fouling on nonwetting surfaces

Ground water sources used as coolant fluids in a variety of thermal systems such as heat exchangers and power plant condensers contain silica particles that accrete on heat transfer surfaces over time leading to reduction in thermal performance, a problem that is particularly exacerbated with temperature. Nonwetting superhydrophobic, lubricant-infused, and a new class of solid-infused surfaces introduced in this work are candidates for fouling mitigation, by virtue of their water repellency, but little is known about fouling of silica on the surfaces, especially under dynamic flow conditions and as a function of temperature. This article presents, for the first time, a systematic study of dynamic flow fouling of silica on nonwetting surfaces vis-à-vis conventional copper surface over a temperature range 20-50 °C. The mechanism of silica aggregate formation and its adherence to the different surfaces is elucidated by scanning electron microscope (SEM) imaging. Sigmoidal growth model is used to describe the time evolution of fouling thermal resistance and an Arrhenius model is presented for the temperature-dependent increase in the asymptotic fouling resistance on nonwetting and conventional surfaces alike. Lubricant-infused and solid-infused surfaces are shown to reduce fouling thermal resistance by up to 25% and 13%, respectively, compared to a conventional surface, whereas superhydrophobic surfaces lose their non-wettability under flow conditions, leading to an adverse increase in the fouling resistance by up to 13%. Considering the possible lubricant depletion in lubricant-infused surfaces over prolonged exposure to a flowing fluid, solid-infused surfaces present a robust alternative.

Fabrication and durability characterization of superhydrophobic and lubricant-infused surfaces

HYPOTHESIS

Practical applications of non-wetting surfaces require good mechanical durability in the wet environments for which they are intended to be used. Durability of non-wetting surfaces is influenced by the surface features, interaction with the functionalization agent, and the lubricant properties that can be tuned independently to identify optimal combination.

EXPERIMENTS

In this study, superhydrophobic and lubricant-infused surfaces are fabricated on copper tubes using chemical etching and electrodeposition texturing techniques, six different functionalizing agents, and five different infused lubricants. Through 180 fabrication combinations and 102 durability tests, each parameter is systematically studied for contributions to initial non-wetting behavior and its durability in heated, wet environment, under high-energy water jet impingement, and under accelerated flow conditions.

FINDINGS

Among the adsorbing and curing functionalization agents investigated, n-Hexadecyl mercaptan that belongs to the sulfhydryl group and Sylgard-184, respectively, showed high durability in heated water immersion and under jet impingement tests. For lubricant-infused surfaces, lubricants with high surface tension demonstrated high durability in heated water immersion test, whereas durability in hydrodynamic conditions is closely correlated to lubricant viscosity. Results showed that a lubricant-infused surface will maintain its non-wetting properties in dropwise condensation conditions for approximately 1.5 years.