Melanoma risk after in vitro fertilization: A review of the literature

Melanoma in pregnancy

Cutaneous melanoma is a malignant neoplasm of melanocytes that most frequently affects the skin. It is the most common malignancy in women of childbearing age, and accounts for almost one-third of all malignancies diagnosed during gestation. The pathophysiology of melanoma, particularly during pregnancy, is not well understood, but there are several ways in which the physiologic state pregnancy may impact melanoma. Based on the available literature, pregnancy does not seem to worsen maternal outcomes with melanoma, and outside of placental and fetal metastases, melanoma does not seem to cause serious obstetric or fetal complications. Treatment of localized melanoma during pregnancy follows guidelines for the general population, but advanced melanoma in pregnancy poses unique challenges given the lack of unifying research and management recommendations. Herein, we review the current literature, highlighting diagnostic clinical pearls and key multidisciplinary management considerations with regard to melanoma in the child-bearing population.

Female Oncofertility and Immune Checkpoint Blockade in Melanoma: Where Are We Today?

The incidence of melanoma among young adults has risen, yet mortality has declined annually since the introduction of immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICI). The utilization of peri-operative ICI has significantly altered the treatment landscape in melanoma, with PD-1 inhibitors showing promising efficacy in improving relapse-free survival rates in high-risk stage II-III disease. With the increasing use of ICI, secondary concerns have emerged regarding the impact of cancer drugs on fertility and reproductive health among women of childbearing potential, especially in early-stage cancer settings. The exclusion of pregnant women from trials contributes to limited human data and clinical uncertainties, such as maternal and fetal toxicities related to ICI exposure during pregnancy, as well as the value of fertility preservation before ICI therapy. Uncertainty persists regarding pregnancy post-adjuvant immunotherapy, given the potential detrimental effects of hormonal and immunological changes during pregnancy on melanoma relapse. There is additional uncertainty about whether pregnancy-associated melanoma (PAM) represents a distinct disease entity that warrants tailored management compared to non-pregnant cases. Our review aims to give an overview of oncofertility practices among female melanoma patients after immunotherapy. We also focus on the literature gap in the published evidence and synthesize summaries regarding ICI toxicities on reproductive health and fetal development, pregnancy planning, and recurrence risks after melanoma treatment.

Melanoma and melanocytic nevi in pregnancy

A changing melanocytic nevus during pregnancy should be biopsied promptly. For women with the dysplastic nevus syndrome, there may be more changes in nevi during pregnancy, requiring close monitoring. Melanoma is one of the most common malignancies that occurs during pregnancy. Those diagnosed with a localized melanoma before, during, or after pregnancy do not have an altered prognosis; however, a few studies have noted thicker melanomas and poorer prognosis when melanoma is diagnosed in the first year postpartum, possibly due to a delay in diagnosis. Although local excision of melanomas can be performed safely during pregnancy, sentinel lymph node biopsy during pregnancy is controversial for the timing and method. There are safe methods of imaging with some special precautions for staging in pregnant women. Systemic therapy requires an interdisciplinary team to assist in patient decision-making because some of these agents are teratogenic. There is no reason to withhold combined estrogen-progestin oral contraceptives or menopausal hormone therapy in those with a previous diagnosis of melanoma, nor should future pregnancies be delayed in those diagnosed with localized melanoma. Only limited data are available concerning prognosis for women with a melanoma diagnosis after in vitro fertilization.

Assisted Reproductive Technology, Pregnancy, and Recurrent Disease in Melanoma Patients: A 30-Year Single Institution Experience

OBJECTIVES

The primary aim of this study was to assess differences in melanoma recurrence between patients conceiving spontaneously versus those undergoing assisted reproductive technology (ART) and to determine use of ART in post-melanoma patients. A secondary aim was to describe the use of immunotherapy as a novel treatment regimen for metastatic melanoma in a cohort of fertile patients.

DESIGN

This study is a 30-year analysis including data from a single-center questionnaire and a retrospective cohort study. Participants/Materials: Women of childbearing age with a history of melanoma were requested to participate in our study. We selected patients who underwent either primary melanoma treatment or treatment of local/distant recurrence at our institute between 1994 and 2021. Each participant received a questionnaire and informed consent form. The questions concerned general health, primary tumor characteristics, utilization of ART, subsequent pregnancies, and development of recurrent melanoma. Additional information was collected from the medical files.

SETTING

The research was conducted in a dedicated oncology center and tertiary referral center for melanoma in The Netherlands.

METHODS

Participants received the questionnaires by mail. Six weeks later a reminder was sent to nonresponders. Analysis was performed using descriptive statistics. For comparisons between groups, chi-square tests were used. p value was considered significant when below 0.05. A clinically relevant difference in recurrence rate was defined as a 10% difference.

RESULTS

A total of 498 questionnaires were available for analyses, 449 from living patients and 49 from relatives of diseased patients. One hundred and seventy-nine patients (36%) with a history of melanoma became pregnant following their diagnosis. There was no difference in the recurrence rate between patients who became pregnant after the diagnosis of melanoma and those who never subsequently conceived (37% vs. 35%, p = 0.609). In the total cohort, 28 patients (6%) attempted to conceive using ART, and eight of them experienced disease recurrence. A total of 58 patients (22% of patients since 2006) were treated with immunotherapy.

LIMITATIONS

The main limitations of the study are its size, observational design, and questionnaire methodology.

CONCLUSIONS

Pregnancy did not increase the risk of recurrent melanoma. The group of patients conceiving after ART was small, and therefore, it is difficult to confidently conclude that the recurrence risk is comparable to the other groups. Prospective international registration of these patients, their oncologic follow-up and possible use of assisted reproduction, will provide valuable information to determine any potential association between ART and risk of recurrent melanoma. This would enable health professionals to develop surveillance strategies and preconception counseling of patients wishing to conceive.

Dysregulation of intraovarian redox status and steroidogenesis pathway in letrozole-induced PCOS rat model: a possible modulatory role of l-Carnitine

Background

Polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) is a reproductive disorder associated with several endocrine and metabolic alterations. The mechanism underlying this syndrome is controversial. On the other hand, drugs used for the treatment are associated with several side effects and poor in controlling PCOS phenotype. l-Carnitine (LC) has been reported to have a significant regulatory function on the redox and metabolic status of female reproductive system. Nevertheless, its regulatory pathways to regulate PCOS are still under investigation. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the effects of LC on the steroidogenic pathways, oxidative stress markers and metabolic profile in letrozole (LTZ)-induced PCOS rat model.

Methods

For this aim, animals were divided into four groups (n = 6). Control group, untreated letrozole-induced PCOS group (1 mg/kg bwt) for 21 days, PCOS group treated with l-Carnitine (100 mg/kg bwt) for 14 days and PCOS group treated with clomiphene citrate (2 mg/kg bwt) for 14 days. Finally, body and ovarian weight, metabolic state(glucose and lipid profile), hormonal assays (testosterone, 17 β estradiol, LH and FSH levels), intraovarian relative gene expression (CYP17A1, StAR, CYP11A1 and CYP19A1 genes), ovarian redox state (malondialdehyde (MDA), reduced glutathione content (GSH) and catalase enzyme activity (CAT)) as well as serum total antioxidant capacity (TAC) were detected. Also, histomorphometric ovarian evaluation (number and diameter of cystic follicles, granulosa cell thickness and theca cell thickness) as well as immune expression of caspase-3 of granulosa cells of cystic follicles were determined.

Results

LC significantly improved ovarian redox state (GSH, MDA and CAT), steroidogenic pathways gene expression (CYP17A1, StAR, CYP11A1 and CYP19A1 genes), hormonal profile (Follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing hormone (LH), testosterone and estradiol), metabolic state (Glucose and lipid profile) histomorphometric alterations and decreased caspase 3 immune reaction of granulosa cells.

Conclusion

l-Carnitine supplementation can ameliorate the PCOS phenotype through its energetic, antioxidant and antiapoptotic functions as well as steroidogenesis regulatory role. This protocol could be modified to produce the best therapeutic benefits, and it could be regarded as a prospective therapeutic intervention for PCOS.

Minding the Bathwater: Fertility and Reproductive Toxicity in the Age of Immuno-Oncology

Immune checkpoint inhibition has resulted in significant efficacy across many cancer types, including melanoma. Melanoma is the second most common cancer among those of reproductive age, yet the reproductive toxicities of adjuvant and first-line immunotherapy are largely unknown.The normal innate and adaptive immune systems play a vital role in reproductive organ homeostasis of men and women and are essential for implantation, fertility, and a successful pregnancy. The programmed cell death-1 receptor/programmed cell death receptor ligand-1 (PD-1/PD-L1) pathway is essential in several aspects of fertility and pregnancy. Recent studies have largely focused on the role of the PD-1/PD-L1 pathway in fetomaternal tolerance, highlighting the importance of intact immune regulation in promoting a successful pregnancy.In this review, we describe a case of a reproductive-aged female with stage IIIC melanoma who sought guidance on family planning after pembrolizumab therapy. We discuss the known fertility-related toxicities of immune checkpoint inhibitors, the potential targets for reproductive toxicity in males and nonpregnant females, and the implications of anti-PD-1 therapy in relation to fetomaternal tolerance. Informed decision making will benefit from data and consensus.

Female melanoma and estrogen receptors expression: an immunohistochemical pilot study

Epidemiologic data highlight sex differences in melanoma outcome. A putative role of sex hormones is still under investigation. Very few laboratory investigations have focused on the level of expression of estrogen receptors in melanoma. We evaluated the presence of estrogen receptors alpha (ERα) and beta (ERβ) in melanoma specimens from female patients with a previous history of breast carcinoma (BC). Moreover, another group of female patients undergoing ovarian stimulation (OS) were also compared to two control groups matched for age and melanoma staging. The study was performed at the IRCCS Policlinico di Sant'Orsola Hospital's Melanoma Unit from January 2017 to December 2019. The nuclear and cytoplasmatic immunohistochemical staining was evaluated and scored by the percentage of stained tumour cells: 0 (≤20%), 1 (21-50%) or 2 (≥50%). Twenty-eight specimens were analysed. ERβ nuclear presence was detected in all cases of women with a history of breast cancer. Cytoplasmatic ERβ was clearly expressed with a score of 2 in seven cases. In the respective control group, nuclear and cytoplasmatic ERβ expression was much lower. A cytoplasmatic ERα positivity was also detected in almost all cases. In the second group of women who experienced ovarian stimulation for Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART), a lower abundance of nuclear ERs was detected. Conversely, cytoplasmatic ERβ and α expression ranged widely. Melanoma of women treated with anti-estrogen therapy is generally more prone to express estrogen receptors compared with women of the same age and CM staging but also compared with women in fertile age with and without a history of OS.

Hormone therapy and melanoma in women

•

Melanocytes are known to respond to estrogen stimulation.

•

Knowledge of estrogen therapy in melanoma tumor behavior is essential to inform accurate patient prognostication.

•

There is limited evidence to suggest oral contraception and fertility treatments affect melanoma incidence.

•

The effect of menopausal hormone therapy on melanoma risk requires further investigation with multinational studies.

Although primary cutaneous melanoma accounts for approximately 3% of all malignant skin tumors, it has the greatest contribution to skin cancer–related death. Sex-specific differences in melanoma tumor behavior have been described, and melanoma pathogenesis may be hormonally mediated. This review aims to summarize the literature to date regarding the effects of hormone therapy on melanoma in women. Women's exogenous hormone use has changed dramatically over the past few decades. Thus, we focus on studies investigating the associations between oral contraception, fertility treatments, menopausal hormone therapy (MHT), and melanoma. Across hormone therapy types, there does not appear to be a well-established association between exogenous female hormones and melanoma incidence. However, MHT practices and formulations vary significantly across countries. Although MHT does not appear to increase melanoma risk in studies from the United States, conflicting results have been observed in Europe. Unopposed estrogen MHT formulations require further investigation to determine a clear pattern between hormone use and the development of melanoma.

Use of Fertility Drugs and Risk of Malignant Melanoma: Results from a Large Danish Population-Based Cohort Study

Fertility drugs have not definitively been linked to malignant melanoma. By the use of data from a large nationwide cohort of women aged 20.0-45.0 years and living in Denmark between January 1, 1995 and December 31, 2011, we assessed the association between the use of fertility drugs and the risk of malignant melanoma. Information on fertility status and the use of fertility drugs was obtained from the population-based Danish Infertility Cohort. Cox proportional hazard regression models were applied to estimate hazard ratios and 95% confidence intervals with adjustment for potential confounders. The study population comprised 1,330,954 women, of whom 86,231 (6.5%) were treated with fertility drugs. During a median follow-up of 21.0 years, 6,139 women were diagnosed with malignant melanoma. Compared with fertile women, women with fertility challenges who had used any fertility drugs had an increased risk of malignant melanoma (hazard ratio = 1.14; 95% confidence interval = 1.02-1.27). Furthermore, the use of specific types of fertility drugs (clomiphene, gonadotropins, human chorionic gonadotropin, gonadotropin-releasing hormone preparations, and progesterone) was also associated with an increased risk of malignant melanoma, with hazard ratios ranging between 1.09 and 1.13; however, the association did not reach statistical significance. Our findings indicate that the use of fertility drugs was associated with a modestly increased risk of malignant melanoma.

A narrative review of pregnancy after malignancies in young women that don't originate in the female genital organs or in the breast

While cancer during pregnancy and its treatment has grown to be a popular topic in recent years, little is known on how to advise patients looking to conceive or conceiving after cancer treatment. The aim of this paper is to review the available literature on the impact of pregnancy on survivors of the most common childhood cancers, brain cancer, haematological malignancies, thyroid cancer, melanomas and sarcomas. Its main objective is to be a source of information for clinicians looking to counsel patients in these delicate moments exploiting all the available literature, albeit scarce. Given the available literature, we conclude that the presence of a multidisciplinary team is of great importance in supporting the patient and her loved ones when facing pregnancy with a previous cancer diagnosis.

Management of Melanoma during Pregnancy: A Case Series of 11 Women Treated at NYU Langone Health

OBJECTIVES

Melanoma is one of the most common malignancies diagnosed during pregnancy. This study examined the impact of pregnancy on management decisions of melanoma patients treated at NYU Langone Health (NYULH).

METHODS

We analyzed data for patients who were pregnant at initial or recurrent melanoma diagnosis at NYULH from 2012 to 2019 with prospective protocol-driven follow-up.

RESULTS

Of the 900 female patients accrued during this period, 11 women in the childbearing range were pregnant at melanoma diagnosis. Six patients presented with early (stage 0 or I) disease and five with advanced (stage III or IV) melanoma. Women with early stage disease had normal deliveries and minimal changes to their treatment timeline and regimen. However, patients with more advanced stage disease opted for either termination of the pregnancy or early delivery and altered treatment timelines because of pregnancy.

CONCLUSION

Both melanoma stage and gestational age at diagnosis contribute to the differences in the therapeutic management of melanoma in pregnant women. Given the complexity and variety of each case of melanoma during pregnancy, informed discussion between patients and physicians allows for individualized treatment plans that address each patient's unique situation.

Melanoma Following In Vitro Fertilization: Co-incident or Coincidence?

Melanoma may occur during or after natural or in vitro fertilization-associated pregnancy. A 43-year-old woman, who had received in vitro fertilization and developed a melanoma five months postpartum is described. Some studies have not shown in vitro fertilization to increase melanoma risk; however, several investigations have observed melanoma risk to be greater in women who have had this treatment. Therefore, although a potential increased risk for melanoma has been observed in infertile women who were either pregnant before or following in vitro fertilization, whether in vitro fertilization is an etiologic risk factor in the pathogenesis of melanoma for these individuals-or is merely a coincidental event-remains to be established.