Changes in the functional binocular status of older children and adults with previously untreated infantile esotropia following late surgical realignment

Strabismus Surgery for Psychosocial Reasons-A Literature Review

Introduction

Strabismus surgery may be undertaken for visual benefit, to improve or eliminate diplopia symptoms, or to restore or improve binocular single vision (BSV). In patients without visual symptoms or expected visual benefit, strabismus surgery may still be undertaken if the presence of strabismus causes the patient psychosocial symptoms. To evaluate strabismus surgery undertaken for psychosocial reasons, evidence of postoperative outcomes in this specific cohort is needed.

Methods

A systematic search of the literature was conducted (1946-2023) to identify evidence where postoperative outcomes were reported for adult patients (age 18 years and above) who had undergone strabismus surgery for psychosocial reasons.

Results

Sixty-nine papers were included in the literature review. Most sources of evidence included patients within heterogeneous cohorts of strabismus surgery outcomes, with a range of symptoms and differing surgical aims.

Discussion

In adults who underwent strabismus surgery for psychosocial reasons, improved postoperative ocular alignment and/or improved health related quality of life (HRQoL) were common. Strabismus surgery outcomes appeared to be measured satisfactorily at three months postoperatively. Additional surgical outcomes, including an expanded field of vision, unexpected BSV, improved binocular summation, improved task performance and improved eye movements have been reported, but not fully investigated. There was a lack of consensus on how postoperative success should be defined and measured. A core outcome set for strabismus has been suggested and there is potential to add to the available evidence by investigating which outcome measures are most relevant to those with strabismus and psychosocial symptoms. There is a growing need for robust evidence in this specific subgroup of patients due to a lack of evidence specifically reporting postoperative outcomes in adults with strabismus and psychosocial symptoms.

Cortical Reorganization After Optical Alignment in Strabismic Patients Outside of Critical Period

PURPOSE

To measure visual crowding, an essential bottleneck on object recognition and reliable psychophysical index of cortex organization, in older children and adults with horizontal concomitant strabismus before and after strabismus surgery.

METHODS

Using real-time eye tracking to ensure gaze-contingent display, we examined the peripheral visual crowding effects in older children and adults with horizontal concomitant strabismus but without amblyopia before and after strabismus surgery. Patients were asked to discriminate the orientation of the central tumbling E target letter with flankers arranged along the radial or tangential axis in the nasal or temporal hemifield at different eccentricities (5° or 10°). The critical spacing value, which is the minimum space between the target and the flankers required for correct discrimination, was obtained for comparisons before and after strabismus surgery.

RESULTS

Twelve individuals with exotropia (6 males, 21.75 ± 7.29 years, mean ± SD) and 15 individuals with esotropia (6 males, 24.13 ± 5.96 years) participated in this study. We found that strabismic individuals showed significantly larger critical spacing with nasotemporal asymmetry along the radial axis that related to the strabismus pattern, with exotropes exhibiting stronger temporal field crowding and esotropes exhibiting stronger nasal field crowding before surgical alignment. After surgery, the critical spacing was reduced and rebalanced between the nasal and temporal hemifields. Furthermore, the postoperative recovery of stereopsis was associated with the extent of nasotemporal balance of critical spacing.

CONCLUSIONS

We find that optical realignment (i.e., strabismus surgery) can normalize the enlarged visual crowding effects, a reliable psychophysical index of cortical organization, in the peripheral visual field of older children and adults with strabismus and rebalance the nasotemporal asymmetry of crowding, promoting the recovery of postoperative stereopsis. Our results indicated a potential of experience-dependent cortical organization after axial alignment even for individuals who are out of the critical period of visual development, illuminating the capacity and limitations of optics on sensory plasticity and emphasizing the importance of ocular correction for clinical practice.

Evaluation of fixation characteristics in amblyopia using microperimetry

PURPOSE

To evaluate fixation characteristics in amblyopia using macular analyzer integrity assessment (MAIA) microperimetry and to investigate the factors affecting fixation stability.

METHODS

This prospective, cross-sectional study enrolled a total of 58 amblyopic patients who were between 8 and 55 years old. Average threshold macular sensitivity (AT) and fixation characteristics were assessed using MAIA microperimetry. Two Bivariate contour ellipse area (BCEA) fixation indices (63% and 95% proportional values) and the percentage of fixation points within 1° and 2° from the fovea (P1 and P2) were used to assess fixation stability. Non-amblyopic fellow eyes were used as the control group for comparison.

RESULTS

AT and fixation stability indices (P1, P2, BCEA 63%, BCEA 95%) were worse in the amblyopic eyes than in the fellow eyes (p < 0.05, for all indices). There was a moderate positive correlation between best corrected visual acuity (BCVA), and AT, and P2, and a moderate negative correlation between BCVA, and BCEA indices. 48% of the eyes were eccentrically fixating (the percentage was 25% in the anisometropic group, 52% in the strabismic group, and 69% in the combined group) and 32% in the non-amblyopic eye (p = 0.052). The preferred fixation eccentricity in amblyopic eyes was significantly greater than the non-amblyopic eyes (p = 0.004), and there was a negative correlation between preferred fixation eccentricity and BCVA (p = 0.012, r = - 0.327).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data showed a decrease in fixation stability, a positive correlation between fixation stability and BCVA, and a negative correlation between preferred fixation eccentricity and BCVA in amblyopic eyes.

Causes of concomitant strabismus surgery delay in teenagers and adults

To reveal the reasons for strabismus surgery delay and motivations for seeking surgical treatment in adulthood. Prospective survey among 91 adult patients, suffering from concomitant strabismus acquired in the childhood that underwent delayed strabismus surgery. The mean age of participants was 24 years (from 16 to 58 years); 48 females (52.7%), and 43 males (47.3%). Strabismus surgery has been delayed for about 20 years in adult patients who could potentially benefit of it in childhood. The most common reasons for strabismus surgery delay, reported by patients, included the following: lack of awareness about surgery (37.4%); surgery was recommended but declined by patients' parents/guardians in their childhood (6.6%); fear of surgery (17.6%); eye specialists affirmation that surgery would not lead to strabismus improvement (27.5%); previous poor surgical experience (6.6%); and non-affordability (4.4%). The main motivations for seeking strabismus surgery in adulthood among our patients were the following: appearance improvement (38.5%), strengthening of self-confidence (30.8%), better social relationship (16.5%), better job opportunities (7.7%), and advice from family and friends (6.6%). About 80% of strabismus surgery delays in teenagers and adults were caused by lack of awareness regarding strabismus surgery and even the misconception among primary health-care practitioners and some eye doctors who considered that surgery would not lead to strabismus correction. The main reasons for seeking strabismus surgery in adulthood were: esthetical ones, self-confidence strengthening, and building better social relationship. All factors mentioned below confirmed the negative impact of oculomotor disorders on patient's psychological condition. The focus on patient's individual concerns and needs was especially important for recovery and well-being of adult patients with strabismus and formed a central feature of patient centered medical approach.

Fixation stability after surgical treatment of strabismus and biofeedback fixation training in amblyopic eyes

Background

Visual fixation may be affected in amblyopic patients and, moreover, its stability may be associated with the effects of amblyopic treatments on visual performance in patients with strabismus. Therefore, fixation stability is a relevant biomarker that might predict the recurrence of amblyopia after a therapeutic intervention. Microperimetric biofeedback fixation training (BFT) can stabilize visual fixation in adult patients with central vision loss. It was the purpose of the present study to evaluate the effects of BFT on fixation stability in adult amblyopic patients after surgical intervention to treat strabismus.

Methods

Participants were 12 patients with strabismus (mean age = 29.6 ± 8.5 years; 6 females) and 12 healthy volunteers (mean age = 23.8 ± 1.5 years; 9 females). The protocol included ophthalmological and microperimetric follow-ups to measure fixation stability and macular sensitivity. BFT was applied monocularly to four amblyopic eyes either on the spontaneous preferential retinal locus or to a fixation area closer to the anatomical fovea after surgical treatment of strabismus.

Results

Baseline measurements showed significantly altered microperimetric average threshold in amblyopic eyes compared to fellow eyes (p = 0.024) and compared to control eyes (p < 0.001). Fixation was unstable in amblyopic eyes compared to control eyes (p < 0.001). Fixation stability did not significantly change after surgical alignment of strabismus (p = 0.805). BFT applied to operated eyes resulted in a more stable fixation with improvements of about 50% after three months of training.

Conclusions

Fixation stability improvements following BFT highlight its potential use in adult amblyopic eyes after the surgical alignment of the strabismus. Future investigations may also consider applying this method in combination with standard treatments to improve vision in amblyopic patients.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12886-021-02020-3.

Late Surgical Correction of Longstanding Constant Strabismus in Adults: Is Fusion Possible in All Successfully Aligned Patients?

PURPOSE

To determine whether late surgical correction provides fusion in adults who have constant strabismus beginning in early childhood.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This was a prospective study that included 34 consecutive adults with a history of early onset strabismus who had not previously undergone surgery. They were tested with the Bagolini striated glasses (BSG), Worth four-dot (W4D) test, cover test, and four-prism diopter (4-PD) test, preoperatively, and 6 weeks after surgery.

RESULTS

The mean age was 23.8 years, 17 patients had esotropia and 17 patients had exotropia. Preoperatively, all patients demonstrated a manifest horizontal deviation ranging from 30^∆ to 60^∆ and had suppression. At 6 weeks postoperatively, 33 patients had a horizontal manifest deviation of <15^∆ (range, 2^∆-14^∆; median, 6^∆), and none were orthotropic as determined by the cover test together with the 4-PD test. All of these 33 patients achieved anomalous retinal correspondence (ARC) with the BSG at near, and 25 (75%) had ARC with the W4D test at near.

CONCLUSIONS

Although our study has limited number of patients its findings suggest it is possible to develop ARC after surgery in almost all adult patients with childhood-onset strabismus associated with suppression, and who have not previously been operated upon, if satisfactory alignment is achieved in adulthood.

Long-term outcomes of prismatic correction in partially accommodative esotropia

Purpose

In partially accommodative esotropia (PAET), prism glasses can correct small angles of residual esotropia but the long-term effect of prismatic correction alone without surgery has not been reported. We aimed to investigate the long-term outcome of prism glasses after full hypermetropic correction for PAET.

Methods

This retrospective, case-control study was performed for children aged 10 years or younger with a residual esotropia of ≤ 20 prism diopters (PD) after full hypermetropic correction who were fitted with prism glasses and followed-up for 3 years or more. Clinical characteristics and the angle of esodeviation were obtained at each follow-up examination. Successful motor outcome after 3 years of prismatic correction was determined if the residual angle of esotropia after full hypermetropic correction was ≤ 10PD. Patients who eventually weaned off prism glasses were noted.

Results

Among 124 patients, 30.6% achieved success and 7.3% weaned off prism glasses after 3 years of prism-wear. Smaller amount of latent esodeviation (P = 0.001) revealed by prism adaptation and good fusional response at near with the Worth 4-dot test were significant prognostic factors of success by multivariate analysis (P = 0.033). After 3 years of wearing prism glasses, the rate of improvement in stereoacuity was higher in the Success group (60.5% vs 27.9%) (P = 0.001), however, there was no significant difference between the prism-weaned group and prism-wearing group within the Success group (P>0.05).

Conclusion

Prism glasses for small angle PAET can be a treatment option in patients who have a small angle of latent esodeviation revealed by prism adaptation and good sensory fusion at near. Otherwise, early surgery may be advisable as the majority of patients showed suboptimal outcome even after long-term prism-wear.

Clinical study of the influence of preoperative wearing time on postoperative effects in children with partially accommodative esotropia

The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of the preoperative wearing time on the postoperative effect in children with partially accommodative esotropia.Sixty children with partially accommodative esotropia who visited our hospital were placed in full cycloplegic refraction by using 1% Atropine eye gel and then wore full hyperopic correction glasses. Children were divided into groups A and B according to the preoperative wearing time. The visual acuity, eye position, and results of the synoptophore and Titmus stereoacuity tests were recorded before and half a year after the surgery in each group, and appropriate statistical analyses were conducted.Half a year after the operation, 54 cases achieved orthotropia when wearing full hyperopic correction glasses. One case was overcorrected. Five cases were undercorrected. The results of the synoptophore and Titmus stereoacuity test showed that there was no significant difference between postoperative outcomes for patients who wore glasses for half a year and for 1 year before the operation.For children with partially accommodative esotropia, surgery should be used to correct the eye position after wearing full hyperopic correction glasses for half a year to improve the eye position and binocular vision as early as possible. If the operation cannot be completed after the patient wears full hyperopic correction glasses for half a year due to various subjective and objective factors, a good postoperative effect can be obtained if the patients receive surgery after wearing full hyperopic correction glasses for 1 year.

New digital methods: remodelling the harms tangent scale setting

PURPOSE

The aim of this study is to present a feasibility study to evaluate and compare a self-constructed, digital-based tangent scale using the Harms tangent screen test for the examination of patients' strabismus angles.

METHODS

The documented strabismus angles of 10 patients were measured at nine gaze-positions and compared using the Harms tangent screen test (Harms Screen) and a self-constructed digital screen test (Digital Screen). The primary outcome is the difference in the measured angles between both methods. Secondary outcomes include the duration of the examinations and the diagnostic conclusion based on the results of the measurements.

RESULTS

The datasets from 10 of 13 patients were used for comparisons (median age 52 years; females 5; males 5). All measurements showed a mean of 1.77° (SD 2.95°) in horizontal deviations and 1.11° (SD 2.23°) in vertical deviations. The two methods showed differences (> 5°) in 12 cases (13.3%) for horizontal angle measurements and in four cases (4.4%) for vertical angle measurements. The median examination time was 238 s (range 60-430 s) for the Harms Screen and 150 s (range 120-600 s) for the Digital Screen tests. The diagnostic conclusions were identical for both methods.

CONCLUSIONS

The feasibility of the experimental digital setup in principle is shown. Despite some deviations in the measured strabismus angles, the resulting diagnosis of the paresis was identical. The new method showed a reduction of examination time.

Straightening the Eyes Doesn't Rebalance the Brain

Surgery to align the two eyes is commonly used in treating strabismus. However, the role of strabismic surgery on patients' binocular visual processing is not yet fully understood. In this study, we asked two questions: (1) Does realigning the eyes by strabismic surgery produce an immediate benefit to patients' sensory eye balance? (2) If not, is there a subsequent period of "alignment adaptation" akin to refractive adaptation where sensory benefits to binocular function accrue? Seventeen patients with strabismus (mean age: 17.06 ± 5.16 years old) participated in our experiment. All participants had normal or corrected to normal visual acuity (LogMAR < 0.10) in the two eyes. We quantitatively measured their sensory eye balance before and after surgery using a binocular phase combination paradigm. For the seven patients whose sensory eye balance was measured before surgery, we found no significant change [t₍₆₎ = -0.92; p = 0.39] in the sensory eye balance measured 0.5-1 months after the surgery, indicating that the surgical re-alignment didn't by itself produce any immediate benefit for sensory eye balance. To answer the second question, we measured 16 patients' sensory eye balance at around 5-12 months after their eyes had been surgically re-aligned and compared this with our measurements 0.5-1 months after surgery. We found no significant change [t₍₁₅₎ = -0.89; p = 0.39] in sensory eye balance 5-12 months after the surgery. These results suggest that strabismic surgery while being necessary is not itself sufficient for re-establishing balanced sensory eye dominance.

Sensory eye balance in surgically corrected intermittent exotropes with normal stereopsis

Surgery to align a deviated or strabismic eye is often done for both functional as well as cosmetic reasons. Although amblyopia is often an impediment to regaining full binocularity in strabismics in general, intermittent exotropes, because their deviation is intermittent, have no amblyopia and some degree of stereopsis. Binocular function, including a balanced ocular dominance, could be expected to be normal after surgical correction if normal levels of stereopsis and visual acuity are postsurgically achieved. Here we used a binocular phase combination paradigm to quantitatively assess the ocular dominance in a group of surgically corrected intermittent exotropes who have normal stereo and visual acuity as defined clinically. Interestingly, we found significant interocular imbalance (balance point < 0.9) in most of the surgically treated patients (8 out 10) but in none of the controls. We conclude that the two eyes may still have a residual sensory imbalance in surgically corrected strabismus even if stereopsis is within normal limits. Our study opens the possibility that a further treatment aimed at re-balancing the ocular dominance might be necessary in surgically treated intermittent exotropia to provide more efficient binocular processing in the long term.

Impact of strabismus surgery on health-related quality of life in adults

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Adult strabismus can cause many symptoms, which have generally been divided into functional complaints and social complaints. The validity of surgical correction has historically been based on the restoration of functional improvement. In the absence of this expectation, surgery was labeled cosmetic. Yet, many studies have revealed the immense impact of ocular misalignment on psychosocial variables. The purpose of this article is to review the potential functional and psychosocial benefits of strabismus surgery and to summarize the development and status of questionnaires to help quantify these benefits.

RECENT FINDINGS

Functional benefits of strabismus surgery have been recently summarized with a meta-analysis. Several questionnaires have been evaluated to assess the functional and psychosocial factors in adult strabismus. Two strabismus-specific questionnaires, the Amblyopia and Strabismus Questionnaire and the Adult Strabismus-20, reveal improvements in adults following surgery. The appropriate patient population, impact of comorbidities on the scores, and the timing of the administration of the questionnaire postoperatively still need to be determined.

SUMMARY

Future studies of the impact of strabismus surgery in adults will need to report not only objective motor results, but also the impact on health-related quality of life to encompass all the benefits of strabismus surgery.

Improvement in specific function-related quality-of-life concerns after strabismus surgery in nondiplopic adults

BACKGROUND

We have previously reported improvement in psychosocial scores after strabismus surgery on the patient-derived health-related quality of life (HRQOL) Adult Strabismus 20 (AS-20) questionnaire in adults with nondiplopic strabismus. Unexpectedly, we also found improvement in the function domain. The aim of the present study was to identify which specific aspects of function-related quality of life improved postoperatively.

METHODS

We retrospectively identified non diplopic adult patients with a history of childhood onset strabismus who underwent surgery and who had preoperative and 1-year postoperative AS-20 questionnaires (scored from 0 [worst] to 100 [best]). Change in scores for each item was evaluated using signed-rank tests.

RESULTS

A total of 20 patients were included. Of the 10 function-related AS-20 items, 9 showed significant mean improvement postoperatively (improvement ranged from 12.5 to 32.5 points, all P < 0.05). Rasch-derived mean scores improved in both reading function and general function domains (71.0 to 86.5 and 66.4 to 87.5, respectively; both P < 0.0001). Specific areas of function-related benefit were concentration, depth perception, hobbies, strain, reading, stress, and worry.

CONCLUSIONS

We found specific function-related quality of life benefits after strabismus surgery in nondiplopic adult patients, particularly those with childhood onset strabismus.

The prevalence of reoperation and related risk factors among patients with congenital esotropia

PURPOSE

To determine the prevalence rate and related risk factors of reoperation among patients with congenital esotropia.

METHODS

One hundred fifty-seven children with congenital esotropia were divided into two groups after at least one operation: children with deviation within 10 PD (n = 89; success group) and those with deviation greater than 10 PD or history of reoperation (n = 68; failure group). The relationship of risk factors such as age at first operation and primary congenital esotropia of less than 30 or more than 50 PD and accompanying factors such as inferior oblique muscle overaction (> +1), dissociated vertical deviation, lateral rectus muscle underaction, and A-V pattern with reoperation were studied. Final sensory status of children 5 years and older was evaluated by Worth 4-dot and Titmus tests.

RESULTS

Reoperation was indicated in 32.4% of children who had residual esotropia greater than 15 PD after 3 months following their first operation. Congenital esotropia greater than 30 PD (P = .002) and lateral rectus muscle underaction of −1 to −2 (P < .005), were statistically different between the two groups. Initial operation at younger than 3 years was more likely to achieve gross stereopsis in children 5 years and older (P = .032).

CONCLUSION

Congenital esotropia greater than 30 PD and lateral rectus muscle underaction were found to be risk factors of reoperation.

Comparing outcome criteria performance in adult strabismus surgery

PURPOSE

To evaluate the performance of motor, diplopia, and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) criteria when analyzing outcomes of adult strabismus surgery.

DESIGN

Cohort study.

PARTICIPANTS

We studied 159 adults undergoing 171 strabismus surgeries.

METHODS

All patients underwent clinical assessment preoperatively and 6 weeks postoperatively, including completion of Adult Strabismus-20 HRQOL questionnaires. Preoperatively, strabismus was classified as either diplopic (n = 117), nondiplopic (n = 38), or atypical diplopic (n = 16). To assess performance of motor, diplopia, and HRQOL criteria, success was defined a priori and applied separately and in combinations. For success: (1) motor criteria, <10 prism diopters by simultaneous prism cover test; (2) diplopia criteria, none or only rare in primary distance and for reading; (3) HRQOL criteria, exceeding previously reported 95% limits of agreement (LOA).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Surgical success rate when applying motor, diplopia, and HRQOL criteria alone and in combinations.

RESULTS

Overall, success rates were 90% for motor criteria, 74% for diplopia criteria, and 60% for HRQOL criteria. Combining criteria, the highest success rate was for motor plus diplopia criteria (67%) and the lowest success rate was when combining motor, diplopia, and HRQOL criteria (50%).

CONCLUSIONS

Applying motor criteria alone yields the highest success rates when evaluating outcomes in adult strabismus surgery, but motor criteria do not fully represent the patient's postoperative status. Combining diplopia criteria with motor criteria provides a more clinically relevant standard for judging the success of adult strabismus surgery. For HRQOL criteria, exceeding 95% LOA at 6 weeks postoperatively seems to be a difficult hurdle to clear for some individual patients, and evaluating change in HRQOL score may be more useful in cohort studies.

Development of motor fusion in patients with a history of strabismic amblyopia who are treated part-time with Bangerter foils

PURPOSE

To document the development of motor fusion when patients with a history of strabismic amblyopia are treated part-time with Bangerter foils.

METHODS

This was a prospective interventional outcome study of consecutive patients with a history of strabismic amblyopia, horizontal strabismus (only) ≤20(∆), visual acuity of 20/60 or better in the nonfixating eye, and no motor fusion (as indicated by the absence of prism vergence) for 1 year before entry into the study. Subjects wore a 0.1 density Bangerter foil for 3-4 hours daily. Data on visual acuity, alignment, and motor fusion status were collected for a minimum of 2 years. Patients with motor fusion were then followed for a minimum of 18 months to assess the stability of their motor fusion status after the Bangerter foil was discontinued.

RESULTS

Of the 46 patients meeting entry criteria (mean age, 5.3 ± 1.7 years) who completed follow-up, 28 (61%) developed motor fusion. Motor fusion was retained in all 17 patients who were followed after their foils were discontinued for a mean of 13.3 months.

CONCLUSION

A child's motor fusion status is generally believed to be established during an early formative period of visual development. The development of motor fusion in many of our patients during the course of part-time Bangerter foil treatment suggests that improvements in motor fusion status can occur at a later age than previously believed.