Possible association of congenital Brown syndrome with congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders

[Brown's syndrome]

Brown's syndrome is related to an abnormality of the superior oblique muscle: it is manifested by an oculomotor disorder with active and passive limitation of elevation in adduction, the field of action of the inferior oblique muscle. The origin is congenital or acquired secondary to multiple causes - inflammatory-infectious, traumatic or iatrogenic. The clinical and paraclinical signs are suggestive. Cerebral and orbital imaging including CT and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is essential for the diagnosis and management of congenital or acquired Brown's syndrome. The course may yield improvement (spontaneous or after etiological treatment) or a steady state. Treatment is rarely surgical. The indication for surgery requires specific functional and clinical signs: torticollis, hypotropia in primary position, associated strabismus and impaired binocular vision; the long-term results of the various surgical techniques are variable.

Horizontal Deviations in Congenital Brown Syndrome

PURPOSE

To report the incidence of horizontal deviations requiring surgical correction in patients with congenital Brown syndrome.

METHODS

In a retrospective study, the medical records of all children who underwent a surgical correction of congenital Brown syndrome at Schneider Children's Medical Center of Israel from 1998 to 2016 were reviewed, analyzing the presence of preoperative primary position horizontal misalignment.

RESULTS

Overall, 19 eyes (8 right and 11 left eyes) of 16 patients (7 males, 9 females; mean age: 4.2 ± 2.6 years) were included in this study. Fourteen patients (88%) had surgery for correction of a compensatory head position, including 8 patients (50%) with a head tilt and 6 patients (38%) with a chin-up position, and 2 patients had surgery for primary position hypotropia. All of them underwent a weakening procedure of the superior oblique tendon, by either Z-tenectomy (81%, n = 13) or suture elongation of the superior oblique tendon (19%, n = 3). Fifty-six percent of patients (n = 9) had primary position horizontal deviation before surgery, including 50% (n = 8) exodeviations, ranging from exophoria of 4 prism diopters (PD) to exotropia of 30 PD, and one esotropia of 14 PD. Fifty percent of patients (n = 8) had surgery to correct the horizontal deviation by a recession of either one (31%, n = 5) or two (19%, n = 3) muscles. Mean preoperative horizontal deviation (9.3 ± 3.4 PD) decreased significantly following surgery (1.7 ± 1 PD, P = .001) (paired t test).

CONCLUSIONS

Significant horizontal misalignment is often present in patients with congenital Brown syndrome and its correction should be considered at the time of surgery. [J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 2018;55(2):113-116.].

Combined Brown syndrome and superior oblique palsy without a trochlear nerve: case report

Background

Congenital Brown syndrome is characterized by limited elevation particularly during adduction. The pathogenesis of congenital Brown syndrome is still controversial.

Case presentation

A 6-year-old boy had been tilting his head to the left since infancy. He showed right hypertropia (RHT) of 2 prism diopters (Δ) in the primary position. He showed RHT 6Δ in right gaze, RHT 2Δ in left gaze, RHT 12Δ in right head tilt, and orthotropia in left head tilt. The right eye showed limitation of elevation and depression on adduction, and the left eye showed overdepression on adduction. MR images showed an absent right trochlear nerve with a hypoplastic ipsilateral superior oblique muscle.

Conclusions

Congenital Brown syndrome may be associated with an absent trochlear nerve and hypoplastic superior oblique muscle suggesting an etiologic mechanism of congenital cranial dysinnervation disorder.

Size of the Oblique Extraocular Muscles and Superior Oblique Muscle Contractility in Brown Syndrome

PURPOSE

This study employed magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to investigate possible size and contractility changes in the superior oblique (SO) muscle, and possible isometric hypertrophy in the inferior oblique (IO) muscle, resulting from abnormal mechanical loading in Brown syndrome (BrS).

METHODS

High resolution orbital MRI was obtained in 4 congenital and 11 acquired cases of BrS, and compared with 44 normal subjects. Maximal cross-section areas and posterior partial volumes (PPVs) of the SO were analyzed in central gaze, supraduction, and infraduction [corrected] for the SO, and in central gaze only for the IO.

RESULTS

In congenital BrS, mean maximum SO cross-sectional areas were 24% and 20% less than normal in affected and unaffected eyes, respectively (P = 0.0002). Mean PPV in congenital BrS was also significantly subnormal bilaterally (29% and 34% less in affected and unaffected eyes, respectively, P = 0.001). However, SO muscle size and volume were normal in acquired cases. The SO muscle did not relax in supraduction in BrS, although there was normal contractile thickening in infraduction. The IO muscle had normal size bilaterally in BrS.

CONCLUSIONS

Congenital BrS may be associated with SO hypoplasia that could reflect hypoinnervation. However, unique isometric loading of oblique extraocular muscles due to restrictive hypotropia in adduction in BrS is generally not associated with changes in muscle bulk or in SO contractility. Unlike skeletal muscles, the bulk and contractility of extraocular muscles can therefore be regarded as independent of isometric exercise history. Restriction to elevation in BrS typically arises in the trochlea-tendon complex.

Considerations on the etiology of congenital Brown syndrome

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Brown syndrome is an ocular motility disorder characterized by limited volitional and passive elevation of the eye in adduction. Although originally thought due to abnormalities in the trochlea or tendon sheath (limiting the free movement of the tendon through the trochlea), recent evidence suggests that some cases of congenital Brown syndrome may be related to neurodevelopmental abnormalities of the extraocular muscles (congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders, CCDD).

RECENT FINDINGS

CCDD is a term encompassing congenital abnormalities of eye movements caused by congenital innervational abnormalities. The abnormal development of cranial nerve nuclei or abnormalities in cranial nerve axonal transport affects the development of the extraocular muscle(s). Currently, congenital fibrosis of the extraocular muscles, Duane syndrome, Moebius syndrome, Horizontal gaze palsy and progressive scoliosis, and synergistic divergence are included as CCDDs. In addition, congenial ptosis, Jaw Wink ptosis, and congenital superior oblique palsy are also included. Recently, it has been suggested that some cases of congenital Brown syndrome and congenital superior oblique paresis are related, and these entities may be part of the CCDDs spectrum.

SUMMARY

Important findings regarding the cause of congenital Brown syndrome will be reviewed.

Magnetic resonance imaging in congenital Brown syndrome

AIMS

Our aim was to elucidate the etiology of Brown syndrome by evaluating the trochlea position, morphologic characteristics of the extraocular muscles including superior oblique muscle/tendon complex, and the presence of the cranial nerves (CN) III, IV, and VI using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in eight patients with unilateral congenital Brown syndrome and one patient with bilateral congenital Brown syndrome.

METHODS

Nine consecutive patients diagnosed with congenital Brown syndrome had a comprehensive ocular examination and MRI for the CN III, CN VI, and the extraocular muscles. Five of the nine patients underwent additional high resolution MRI for CN IV. The distance from the annulus of Zinn to the trochlea was measured.

RESULTS

Normal sized CN III, IV, and VI, as well as all extraocular muscles, could be identified bilaterally in all patients with available MRI. The distance from the annulus of Zinn to the trochlea was the same in both eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings for our patients, particularly in those who underwent additional high resolution MRI, did not provide evidence of a lack of CN IV as a cause of Brown syndrome.

Fourth cranial nerve palsy and Brown syndrome: two interrelated congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders?

Based on neuroimaging data showing absence of the trochlear nerve, congenital superior oblique palsy is now classified as a congenital cranial dysinnervation disorder. A similar absence of the abducens nerve is accompanied by misinnervation to the lateral rectus muscle from a branch of oculomotor nerve in the Duane retraction syndrome. This similarity raises the question of whether some cases of Brown syndrome could arise from a similar synkinesis between the inferior and superior oblique muscles in the setting of congenital superior oblique palsy. This hypothesis has gained support from the confluence of evidence from a number of independent studies. Using Duane syndrome as a model, we critically review the accumulating evidence that some cases of Brown syndrome are ultimately attributable to dysgenesis of the trochlear nerve.