Long-term efficacy of cryo catheter ablation for the treatment of atrial flutter

A randomized trial of contact force in atrial flutter ablation

Aims

Contact force (CF) sensing has emerged as a tool to guide and improve outcomes for catheter ablation (CA) for cardiac arrhythmias. The clinical benefit on patient outcomes remains unknown. To study whether CF-guided CA for typical atrial flutter (AFL) is superior to CA not guided by CF.

Methods and results

In a double-blinded controlled superiority trial, we randomized patients 1:1 to receive CA for typical AFL guided by CF (intervention group) or blinded to CF (control group). In the intervention group, a specific value of the lesion size index (LSI), estimating ablation lesions size was targeted for each ablation lesion. Patients underwent electrophysiological study (EPS) after 3 months to assess occurrence of the primary endpoint of re-conduction across the cavo-tricuspid isthmus (CTI). We included 156 patients with typical AFL, median age was 68 [interquartile range (IQR) 61–74] years and 120 (77%) patients were male. At index procedure median LSI was higher in the intervention group [6.4 (IQR 5.1–7) vs. 5.6 (IQR 4.5–6.9), P < 0.0001]. After 3 months, 126 patients (58 in intervention group) underwent EPS for primary endpoint assessment. Thirty (24%) patients had CTI re-conduction, distributed with 15 patients in each treatment group (P = 0.62). We observed no difference between treatment groups with regard to fluoroscopy, ablation, or procedure times, nor peri-procedural complications.

Conclusion

Contact force-guided ablation does not reduce re-conduction across the CTI after 3 months, nor does CF-guided ablation shorten fluoroscopy, ablation, or total procedure times.

Creating bidirectional conduction block in the cavotricuspid isthmus by cryothermal ablation with a short freeze time: Insight from the results with a 2-minute freeze cycle

BACKGROUND

Optimal freeze doses are unknown during cryothermal cavo-tricuspid isthmus (CTI) ablation. This study aimed to evaluate the feasibility of 2-minute freeze doses for CTI ablation.

METHODS

Forty-eight consecutive patients undergoing cryothermal CTI ablation following pulmonary vein isolation were enrolled. CTI ablation was performed with 2-minute freeze cycles and 8-mm tip cryocatheters.

RESULTS

Bidirectional CTI block was successfully achieved in 45(93.8%) patients with a median of 5.0[4.0-6.0] cryocatheter applications. The total procedure and fluoroscopic times were a median of 16.5[13.0-20.0] and 4.0[2.0-5.0]min, respectively. A crossover to radiofrequency was performed in 3 patients including 1 due to coronary spasms during the cryoapplication. The tip temperature when block was achieved was a median of -81.0[-73.3 - -84.0]°C. Application times from the start of the last application to achieving block were significantly longer in patients with acute conduction resumption than in those without (46.8±4.0 vs. 20.2±8.8s, p<0.0001), and the optimal cutoff point for predicting no acute resumption was 38.5s (sensitivity 100%, specificity 99.5%). Vasospastic angina occurred in 2 patients, during the procedure in 1 and after in another. Durability could be evaluated a median of 6.0[3.0-8.0] months after the procedure in 14 patients, and conduction resumption was observed in 8(57.1%). The majority of gaps were located at the inferior vena cava edge.

CONCLUSIONS

Acute CTI block was obtained by 2-minute freeze cycles with short procedure and fluoroscopic times. Care should be taken to avoid coronary spasms during the peri-procedural period. Additional cryoapplications might be required to improve conduction block durability.

Current treatment options for atrial flutter and results with cryocatheter ablation

Rhythm disturbances arising in the upper chambers of the heart are not uncommon. They are associated with a heavy burden of illness for the affected individual, as well as society in general. Atrial flutter, a re-entrant atrial tachycardia, is one such rhythm disturbance. The objective of this review article is twofold: first, to provide a brief insight into atrial flutter and the typical treatments for this arrhythmia in clinical practice; and second, to give an in-depth account of cryocatheter ablation as a relatively new treatment option for this potentially debilitating condition. The many recent clinical studies documenting the use of cryocatheter ablation for treatment of atrial flutter are presented, and their results briefly discussed. Overall, as cryocatheter ablation embeds itself among the arsenal of treatments for atrial flutter, the promising results from clinical studies appear destined to elevate cryocatheter ablation to a premier position among the treatment options for atrial flutter.

Prospective randomized comparison of durability of bidirectional conduction block in the cavotricuspid isthmus in patients after ablation of common atrial flutter using cryothermy and radiofrequency energy: the CRYOTIP study

BACKGROUND

Recent studies have shown that cryoablation and radiofrequency (RF) ablation are comparable with regard to success rates and safety in the treatment of common atrial flutter (AFL). Long-term success requires persistence of bidirectional conduction block (BCB) in the inferior cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI).

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine the persistence of BCB in a prospective randomized multicenter trial of the two ablation techniques.

METHODS

A total of 191 patients were randomized to RF ablation or cryoablation of the CTI using an 8-mm-tip catheter. In all patients, BCB was defined as the ablation end-point. Primary end-point of the study was nonpersistence of achieved BCB and/or ECG-documented relapse of common AFL within 3-month follow-up.

RESULTS

Acute success rates were 91% (83/91) in the RF group and 89% (80/90) in the cryoablation group (P = NS). Invasive follow-up after 3 months with repeated electrophysiologic study was available for 60 patients in the RF group and 64 patients in the cryoablation group. Persistent BCB could be confirmed in 85% of the RF group versus 65.6% of the cryoablation group. The primary end-point was achieved in 15% of the RF group and 34.4% of the cryoablation group (P = .014). As a secondary end-point, pain perception during ablation was significant lower in the cryoablation group (P <.001).

CONCLUSION

Persistence of BCB in patients treated with cryoablation reinvestigated after 3 months is inferior to that patients treated with RF ablation, as evidenced by the higher recurrence rate of common AFL seen in this study.

Typical atrial flutter can effectively be treated using single one-minute cryoapplications: results from a repeat electrophysiological study

Purpose

Catheter-based cryoablation (cryo) has proven to be as effective as radiofrequency energy (RF) ablation for the treatment of arrhythmias. Nevertheless, the duration of cryoapplications has been reported as being significantly longer than RF applications.

Methods

Thirty-seven consecutive patients (28 men; mean age 59 ± 14 years) with typical atrial flutter (AFL) underwent cryo of the cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI). Applications of 1 min were delivered with a 10-French, 10-mm tipped catheter (CryoCor™). If bidirectional CTI block was not obtained after 12 1-min applications, applications of 3 min were selectively delivered to areas of conduction breakthrough. The endpoint of the procedure was creation of bidirectional CTI block and non-inducibility of AFL.

Results

A median of 7 (range 3 to 12) 1-min applications were given along the CTI with a mean temperature of −88.6 ± 2.3°C. Mean fluoroscopy and procedure time were 27 ± 14 min and 110 ± 28 min respectively. Five patients required additional 3-min applications; in one patient an overextended ablation catheter prevented the completion of the index-procedure. The acute success rate of the index-procedure was 97%. In 12/24 patients, two with AFL recurrence, resumption of CTI conduction was found 4 months post-ablation. In all patients bidirectional CTI block was re-obtained after a median of one 1-min application. No additional AFL recurrences occurred, after a mean follow-up of 37 ± 3 (range 30 to 44) months.

Conclusions

Cryo of AFL can successfully be performed using the same application duration as used for RF ablation. Both acute and long-term results are comparable to RF ablation. AFL recurrences occurred in only a minority of patients with resumption of CTI conduction.

Acute success and short-term follow-up of catheter ablation of isthmus-dependent atrial flutter; a comparison of 8 mm tip radiofrequency and cryothermy catheters

Objectives

To compare the acute success and short-term follow-up of ablation of atrial flutter using 8 mm tip radiofrequency (RF) and cryocatheters.

Methods

Sixty-two patients with atrial flutter were randomized to RF or cryocatheter (cryo) ablation. Right atrial angiography was performed to assess the isthmus. End point was bidirectional isthmus block on multiple criteria. A pain score was used and the analgesics were recorded. Patients were followed for at least 3 months.

Results

The acute success rate for RF was 83% vs 69% for cryo (NS). Procedure times were similar (mean 144 ± 48 min for RF, vs 158 ± 49 min for cryo). More applications were given with RF than with cryo (26 ± 17 vs. 18 ± 10, p < 0.05). Fluoroscopy time was longer with RF (29 ± 15 vs. 19 ± 12 min, p < 0.02). Peak CK, CK-MB and CK-MB mass were higher, also after 24 h in the cryo group. Troponin T did not differ. Repeated transient block during application (usually with cryoablation) seemed to predict failure. Cryothermy required significantly less analgesia (p < 0.01), and no use of long sheaths (p < 0.005).

The isthmus tended to be longer in the failed procedures (p = 0.117). This was similar for both groups, as was the distribution of anatomic variations. Recurrences and complaints in the successful patients were similar for both groups, with a very low recurrence of atrial flutter after initial success.

Conclusions

In this randomized study there was no statistical difference but a trend to less favorable outcome with 8 mm tip cryocatheters compared to RF catheters for atrial flutter ablation. Cryoablation was associated with less discomfort, fewer applications, shorter fluoroscopy times and similar procedure times. The recurrence rate was very low. Cryotherapy can be considered for atrial flutter ablation under certain circumstances especially when it has been used previously in the same patient, such as in an AF ablation.

Long term outcome of cavotricuspid isthmus cryoablation for the treatment of common atrial flutter in 180 patients: a single center experience

OBJECTIVE

Recent literature has shown that common type atrial flutter (AFL) can recur late after cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) catheter ablation using radiofrequency energy (RF). We report the long term outcome of a large group of patients undergoing CTI ablation using cryothermy for AFL in a single center.

METHODS

Patients with AFL referred for CTI ablation were recruited prospectively from July 2001 to July 2006. Cryoablation was performed using a deflectable, 10.5 F, 6.5 mm tip catheter. CTI block was reassessed 30 min after the last application during isoproterenol infusion. Recurrences were evaluated by 12-lead ECG and 24 h Holter recording every clinic visit (1/3/6/9 and 12 months after the procedure and yearly thereafter) or if symptoms developed.

RESULTS

The 180 enrolled patients had the following characteristics: 39 women (22%), mean age 58 years, no structural heart disease in 86 patients (48%), mean left atrium diameter 44+/-7 mm and mean left ventricular ejection fraction 57+/-7%. The average number of applications per patient was 7 (3 to 20) with a mean temperature and duration of -88 degrees C and 3 min, respectively. Acute success was achieved in 95% (171) of the patients. There were no complications. After a mean follow-up of 27+/-17 (from 12 to 60) months, the chronic success rate was 91%. The majority of the recurrences occurred within the first year post ablation. One hundred and twenty three patients had a history of atrial fibrillation (AF) prior to CTI ablation and 85 (69%) of those remained having AF after cryoablation. In 20 of 57 (35%) patients without a history of AF prior to CTI ablation, AF occurred during follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

This prospective study showed a 91% chronic success rate (range 12 to 60 months) for cryoablation of the CTI in patients with common type AFL and ratified the frequent association of AF with AFL.

Assessment of the maximum voltage-guided technique for cavotricuspid isthmus ablation during ongoing atrial flutter

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to test the maximum voltage-guided cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) ablation technique during ongoing atrial flutter.

BACKGROUND

Former pathological and electrophysiological studies clarified that the cavotricuspid isthmus is composed of distinct muscular bundles, which are responsible for the conduction of electrical activation. Based on this observation, a maximum voltage-guided ablation technique (MVGT) was developed. This technique was assessed during pacing from the coronary sinus and was reported to be a feasible method to reach bidirectional isthmus block without the need for a complete anatomic ablation line.

METHODS

This was a prospective, randomized single center study. Twenty patients underwent CTI ablation during atrial flutter. In group I (10 pts) CTI ablation was performed with complete anatomical ablation line. In group II (10 pts) ablation was guided by the highest amplitude potentials on the CTI sequentially until bidirectional isthmus block was reached. The following parameters were compared: acute success rate, procedure time, fluoroscopy time, number of radiofrequency (RF) applications and total RF duration.

RESULTS

In all patients, atrial flutter terminated during ablation. Bidirectional isthmus block could be achieved in all pts. Procedure time was shorter in group II (107 +/- 40 vs 68 +/- 19 min, p < 0.01). Significantly less fluoroscopy was used in group II (22.6 +/- 10.6 vs 12.1 +/- 3.8 min, p < 0.01). There were less RF applications in group II (27.1 +/- 21.5 vs 5.9 +/- 2.4, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

(1) The major finding of this study is that MVGT is a feasible method even during ongoing atrial flutter. (2) Our data confirm that MVGT is an effective technique for CTI ablation with considerable decrease in procedure and fluoroscopy times.

Atrial flutter: a focus on treatment options for a common supraventricular tachyarrhythmia

Atrial flutter (AFl), a re-entrant atrial tachycardia, is a cardiac rhythm disturbance that arises in the upper chambers of the heart. This usually non-life-threatening condition can be treated by a number of medical intervention strategies, which include electrical cardioversion, pharmacological therapy, and catheter ablation. These options have been available in clinical practice for a number of years. However, catheter ablation, in the form of radiofrequency catheter ablation and cryo catheter ablation, is increasingly utilised as a first-line treatment option for AFl in certain patients. The purpose of this review article is two-fold: first, to briefly present an overview of AFl and the more familiar treatment options for this arrhythmia, and second to provide more in-depth coverage of catheter ablation technologies as a treatment option for patients with AFl. As part of the latter objective, recent clinical studies documenting the use of radiofrequency catheter ablation and cryo catheter ablation for AFl are presented and their results briefly discussed.

Cryoablation versus Radiofrequency Ablation in the treatment of Atrial Flutter trial (CRAAFT)

INTRODUCTION

Atrial flutter is frequently treated with radiofrequency (RF) ablation with excellent results. While RF ablation remains the gold standard for catheter based treatment of atrial flutter, cryoablation has potential advantages including painless ablation and cryoadherence to the myocardium. We performed a prospective randomised trial comparing cryoablation and RF ablation in the treatment of atrial flutter.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We randomised 32 consecutive patients with typical atrial flutter to either radiofrequency ablation using an 8 mm tip Blazer II XP catheter (EP Technology, San Jose, USA) or cryoablation using a 9 French 8 mm tip Freezor Max catheter (CryoCath Technologies Inc, Kirkland, QU, Canada). Twenty eight patients were then followed up for a mean of 14.7 months. The procedure was successful in producing isthmus block in all but one patient in the cryoablation group. Cryoablation was associated with a significantly longer procedure (171 vs 99 min) and ablation duration (59 vs 12.7 min), however fluoroscopy exposure was similar (30 vs 29 min). Cryoablation was associated with reduced pain scores compared with RF (mean pain score 0.4 vs 3.5). There were two recurrences of atrial flutter during follow-up, both in the cryoablation group.

CONCLUSIONS

Cryoablation has improved patient tolerability compared to RF ablation, however is associated with longer procedure and ablation durations. Further trials are required to confirm whether cryoablation has similar acute and chronic efficacy to RF ablation.

Low clinical recurrence and procedure benefits following treatment of common atrial flutter by electrogram-guided hot spot focal cryoablation

BACKGROUND

The study sought to evaluate whether electrogram-aided identification of hot spot targets produces additional clinical and/or procedure benefits when using a non-traditional focal cryo ablation method to treat common atrial flutter.

METHODS

A preliminary study identified a specific electrogram criterion (e.g., a stimulus to onset of electrogram time of 74 [+/- 5] ms) that produced successful cryo testing plus subsequent cryoablation with demonstrable bi-directional isthmus block created at intervention site. In the present study, 26 consecutive patients with symptomatic common atrial flutter were ablated with a 9FR 8 mm tip cryo catheter using electrogram-aided identification of hot spot targets with a stimulus to onset of electrogram time of > or =70 ms. Outcomes measured were bi-directional isthmus block at intervention, symptom and conduction recurrence at 3 month follow-up, symptom recurrence at 6 month follow-up, and procedure characteristics.

RESULTS

Acute success rate at intervention was 100%. The percentage of patients with symptom recurrence by 3 month follow-up was 4.5% and no additional patients had arrhythmia symptoms documented by 12 month follow-up. Repeat electrophysiological study (EPS) at 3 month follow-up identified 44% of patients with conduction recurrence. The mean +/- SD number of cryo tests and ablations were 11 +/- 9 and 2 +/- 1, respectively. Procedure, fluoroscopy and cryoapplication times were 77 +/- 29 min, 11 +/- 7 min, and 28 +/- 11 min, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A high acute success rate, plus low long-term clinical recurrence rate and procedure benefits may be achieved with electrogram-aided identification of hot spots for focal cryo ablation treatment of common atrial flutter using a 9FR 8 mm tip cryo catheter. The population of patients who were asymptomatic and had demonstrated conduction recurrence on repeat EPS at 3 month follow-up require close scrutiny over the long-term to ascertain whether they eventually experience arrhythmic symptoms. However, should these patients remain symptom-free over the long-term it would suggest that the entire isthmus may not be needed to support symptomatic common atrial flutter.

Acute Success and Persistence of Bidirectional Conduction Block in the Cavotricuspid Isthmus One Month Post Cryocatheter Ablation of Common Atrial Flutter

INTRODUCTION

Cryoablation is successful in the treatment of common atrial flutter. Long-term clinical success is mainly dependent on persistence of bidirectional conduction block (BCB) in the inferior cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI). Only few data on persistence of BCB post cryoablation with the reported technique are available. This prospective study aimed to test efficacy of cryo energy and persistence of BCB in the CTI 1 month post cryoablation.

METHODS

Cryoablation of the CTI was performed in 50 consecutive patients (64 +/- 12 years, 40 males) with symptomatic common atrial flutter using a novel 9 Fr 8-mm-tip catheter. BCB in the CTI 30 minutes following the final cryoapplication was the ablation endpoint. Thirty days post ablation, persistence of BCB was controlled by repeat electrophysiological study (EPS).

RESULTS

In all patients BCB was achieved with a mean of 9 (IQR 7-17.5) cryo applications and a mean cryo time of 2,378 seconds (IQR 1,680-3,474 seconds). In 5 of 50 patients, common atrial flutter recurred within 1 month post cryoablation. In 30 of 32 recurrence-free patients, persistence of BCB was verified. In 2 patients, resumption of isthmus conduction was detectable. Including relapses, 81.1% of patients (30/37) showed persistence of BCB. No patients reported pain during cryoapplication. No procedural complications were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Cryoablation of the CTI using a large-tip catheter is feasible and safe in the treatment of common atrial flutter. Acute and short-term success rates are comparable to those reported for radiofrequency (RF) ablation. Besides short-term clinical success, the persistence of BCB demonstrates efficacy of the cryoablation technique.