Airway inflammation after epicutaneous sensitization of mice requires protease activity of low-dose allergen inhalation

Airway inflammation in a novel mouse model of asthma-COPD overlap induced by co-exposure to papain and tobacco smoke

Asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) are respiratory diseases associated with airway inflammation, which is the main pathogenesis. Although their causes and characteristics differ, in some cases, asthma and COPD may coexist in the same patient in a condition called asthma-COPD overlap (ACO). The prognosis of ACO is more unfavourable than those of asthma or COPD alone, without any treatment strategies demonstrating efficacy. Owing to its intricate spectrum of features, the detailed pathogenesis of how ACO exacerbates respiratory features remains unclear. In this study, we exposed papain-induced asthma model mice to tobacco smoke to establish an ACO mouse model, in which features of airway inflammation observed in both asthma and COPD were incorporated. This model exhibited distinctive mixed and corticosteroid-resistant airway inflammation and emphysematous changes that are characteristic of ACO. The novel mouse model established here is expected to significantly contribute to elucidating the mechanisms of the broad pathologies of ACO and identifying potential therapeutic targets.

Antigen Protease Activity on Intact or Tape-Stripped Skin Induces Acute Itch and T Helper Sensitization Leading to Airway Eosinophilia in Mice

Respiratory allergen sources such as house dust mites frequently contain proteases. In this study, we demonstrated that the epicutaneous application of a model protease antigen, papain, onto intact or tape-stripped ear skin of mice induced acute scratching behaviors and T helper (Th)2, Th9, Th17/Th22, and/or Th1 sensitization in a protease activity-dependent manner. The protease activity of papain applied onto the skin was also essential for subsequent airway eosinophilia induced by an intranasal challenge with low-dose papain. With tape stripping, papain-treated mice showed barrier dysfunction, the accelerated onset of acute scratching behaviors, and attenuated Th17/Th22 sensitization. In contrast, the protease activity of inhaled papain partially or critically contributed to airway atopic march responses in mice sensitized through intact or tape-stripped skin, respectively. These results indicated that papain protease activity on epicutaneous application through intact skin or skin with mechanical barrier damage is critical to the sensitization phase responses, including acute itch and Th sensitization and progression to the airway atopic march, whereas dependency on the protease activity of inhaled papain in the atopic march differs by the condition of the sensitized skin area. This study suggests that exogenous protease-dependent epicutaneous mechanisms are a target for controlling allergic sensitization and progression to the atopic march.

Frequency of exacerbation and degree of required asthma medication can characterize childhood longitudinal asthma trajectories

BACKGROUND

To the best of our knowledge, there have been no investigations of longitudinal asthma trajectories based on asthma exacerbation frequency and medications required for asthma control in children.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate longitudinal asthma trajectories based on the exacerbation frequency throughout childhood and asthma medication ranks.

METHODS

A total of 531 children aged 7 to 10 years were enrolled from the Korean childhood Asthma Study. Required asthma medications for control of asthma from 6 to 12 years of age and asthma exacerbation frequency from birth to 12 years of age were obtained from the Korean National Health Insurance System database. Longitudinal asthma trajectories were identified on the basis of asthma exacerbation frequency and asthma medication ranks.

RESULTS

Four asthma clusters were identified: lesser exacerbation with low-step treatment (8.1%), lesser exacerbations with middle-step treatment (30.7%), highly frequent exacerbations in early childhood with small-airway dysfunction (5.7%), and frequent exacerbations with high-step treatment (55.6%). The frequent exacerbations with high-step treatment cluster were characterized by a high prevalence of male sex, increased blood eosinophil (counts) with fractional exhaled nitric oxide, and high prevalence of comorbidities. The highly frequent exacerbation in early childhood with small-airway dysfunction cluster was characterized by recurrent wheeze in preschool age, with high prevalence of acute bronchiolitis in infancy and a greater number of family members with small-airway dysfunction at school age.

CONCLUSION

The present study identified 4 longitudinal asthma trajectories on the basis of the frequency of asthma exacerbation and asthma medication ranks. These results would help clarify the heterogeneities and pathophysiologies of childhood asthma.

Proteolytic activity accelerates the TH17/TH22 recall response to an epicutaneous protein allergen-induced TH2 response

Epicutaneous exposure to protein allergens, such as papain, house dust mite (HDM), and ovalbumin (OVA), represents an important mode of sensitization for skin diseases including protein contact dermatitis, immunologic contact urticaria, and atopic dermatitis. These diseases are inducible by re-exposure to an allergen at both original skin sensitization and distant skin sites. In this study, we examined the serum IgE/IgG₁ response, differentiation of T-helper (T_H) cells, and epicutaneous T_H recall response in mice pre-sensitized with protein allergens through the back skin and subsequently challenged on the ear skin. Repeated epicutaneous sensitization with allergenic proteins including papain, HDM, OVA, and protease inhibitor-treated papain, but not bovine serum albumin, induced serum allergen-specific antibody production, passive cutaneous anaphylaxis responses, and T_H2 differentiation in the skin draining lymph node (DLN) cells. Sensitization with papain or HDM, which have protease activity, resulted in the differentiation of T_H17 as well as T_H2. In papain- or HDM-sensitized mice, a subsequent single challenge on the ear skin induced the expression of T_H2 and T_H17/T_H22 cytokines. These results suggest that allergenic proteins induce the differentiation of T_H2 in skin DLN cells and an antibody response. These findings may be useful for identifying proteins of high and low allergenic potential. Moreover, allergenic proteins containing protease activity may also differentiate T_H17 and induce T_H2 and T_H17/T_H22 recall responses at epicutaneous challenge sites. This suggests that allergen protease activity accelerates the onset of skin diseases caused by protein allergens.

Epicutaneous challenge with protease allergen requires its protease activity to recall TH2 and TH17/TH22 responses in mice pre-sensitized via distant skin

Epicutaneous exposure to allergenic proteins is an important sensitization route for skin diseases like protein contact dermatitis, immunologic contact urticaria, and atopic dermatitis. Environmental allergen sources such as house dust mites contain proteases, which are frequent allergens themselves. Here, the dependency of T-helper (T_H) cell recall responses on allergen protease activity in the elicitation phase in mice pre-sensitized via distant skin was investigated. Repeated epicutaneous administration of a model protease allergen, i.e. papain, to the back skin of hairless mice induced skin inflammation, serum papain-specific IgE and T_H2 and T_H17 cytokine responses in the sensitization sites, and antigen-restimulated draining lymph node cells. In the papain-sensitized but not vehicle-treated mice, subsequent single challenge on the ear skin with papain, but not with protease inhibitor-treated papain, up-regulated the gene expression of T_H2 and T_H17/T_H22 cytokines along with cytokines promoting these T_H cytokine responses (TSLP, IL-33, IL-17C, and IL-23p19). Up-regulation of IL-17A gene expression and cells expressing RORγt occurred in the ear skin of the presensitized mice even before the challenge. In a reconstructed epidermal model with a three-dimensional culture of human keratinocytes, papain but not protease inhibitor-treated papain exhibited increasing transdermal permeability and stimulating the gene expression of TSLP, IL-17C, and IL-23p19. This study demonstrated that allergen protease activity contributed to the onset of cutaneous T_H2 and T_H17/T_H22 recall responses on allergen re-encounter at sites distant from the original epicutaneous sensitization exposures. This finding suggested the contribution of protease-dependent barrier disruption and induction of keratinocyte-derived cytokines to the recall responses.

Epicutaneous vaccination with protease inhibitor-treated papain prevents papain-induced Th2-mediated airway inflammation without inducing Th17 in mice

Environmental allergen sources such as house dust mites contain proteases, which are frequently allergens themselves. Inhalation with the exogenous proteases, such as a model of protease allergen, papain, to airways evokes release and activation of IL-33, which promotes innate and adaptive allergic airway inflammation and Th2 sensitization in mice. Here, we examine whether epicutaneous (e.c.) vaccination with antigens with and without protease activity shows prophylactic effect on the Th airway sensitization and Th2-medated airway inflammation, which are driven by exogenous or endogenous IL-33. E.c. vaccination with ovalbumin restrained ovalbumin-specific Th2 airway sensitization and/or airway inflammation on subsequent inhalation with ovalbumin plus papain or ovalbumin plus recombinant IL-33. E.c. vaccination with papain or protease inhibitor-treated papain restrained papain-specific Th2 and Th9 airway sensitization, eosinophilia, and infiltration of IL-33-responsive Th2 and group 2 innate lymphoid cells on subsequent inhalation with papain. However, e.c. vaccination with papain but not protease inhibitor-treated papain induced Th17 response in bronchial draining lymph node cells. In conclusions, we demonstrated that e.c. allergen vaccination via intact skin in mice restrained even protease allergen-activated IL-33-driven airway Th2 sensitization to attenuate allergic airway inflammation and that e.c. vaccination with protease allergen attenuated the airway inflammation similar to its derivative lacking the protease activity, although the former but not the latter promoted Th17 development. In addition, the present study suggests that modified allergens, of which Th17-inducing e.c. adjuvant activity such as the protease activity was eliminated, might be preferable for safer clinical applications of the e.c. allergen administration.