Salience-thalamic circuit uncouples in major depressive disorder, but not in bipolar depression

Functional Connectivity of the Anterior Cingulate Cortex and the Right Anterior Insula Differentiates between Major Depressive Disorder, Bipolar Disorder and Healthy Controls

Background: This study aimed to explore possible differences of the whole-brain functional connectivity of the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and anterior insula (AI), in a sample of depressed patients with major depressive disorder (MDD), bipolar disorder (BD) and healthy controls (HC). Methods: A hundred and three subjects (n_MDD = 35, n_BD = 25, and n_HC = 43) between the ages of eighteen and sixty-five years old underwent functional magnetic resonance imaging. The CONN Toolbox was used to process and analyze the functional connectivity of the ACC and AI. Results: The comparison between the patients (MDD/BD) and HC yielded increased resting-state functional connectivity (rsFC) between the ACC and the motor and somatosensory cortices (SSC), superior parietal lobule (SPL), precuneus, and lateral occipital cortex, which was driven by the BD group. In addition, hyperconnectivity between the right AI and the motor and SSC was found in BD, as compared to HC. In MDD, as compared to HC, hyperconnectivity between ACC and SPL and the lateral occipital cortex was found, with no statistical rsFC differences for the AI seed. Compared to BD, the MDD group showed ACC-cerebellum hyperconnectivity and a trend for increased rsFC between the right AI and the bilateral superior frontal cortex. Conclusions: Considering the observed hyperconnectivity between the ACC/somatosensory cortex in the patient group, we suggest depression may be related to an impairment of the sensory-discriminative function of the SSC, which results in the phenomenological signature of mental pain in both MDD and BD. These findings suggest that future research should investigate this particular network with respect to motor functions and executive control, as a potential differential diagnostic biomarker for MDD and BD.

Trait and state-related characteristics of thalamo-cortical circuit disruption in bipolar disorder: a prospective cross-sectional study

Objective

The purpose of this study is to investigate the shared and distinct thalamic-cortical circuit between bipolar depression and remission, as well as to investigate the trait and state-related characteristics of the abnormal thalamic-cortical circuit in bipolar disorder.

Methods

Resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging was performed on 38 bipolar depression patients, 40 bipolar remission patients, and 39 gender-matched healthy controls (rsfMRI). The thalamic subregions were used as seed points to draw the functional connectivity of the entire brain, and then the shared and distinct thalamic-cortical circuits between bipolar depression and remission were compared.

Results

When compared to the healthy group, both groups of patients had significantly lower functional connectivity between the rostral temporal thalamus and the lingual gyrus, the posterior parietal thalamus, the precuneus/cerebellum, and the occipital thalamus and the precuneus; however, functional connectivity between the premotor thalamus and the superior medial frontal was significantly lower in depression.

Conclusion

This study discovered that both bipolar depression and remission had abnormal sensorimotor-thalamic functional connectivity, implying that it is a trait-related characteristic of bipolar disorder; however, the decline in prefrontal-thalamic connectivity exists specifically in bipolar depression, implying that it is a state-related characteristic of bipolar disorder.

Shared and distinct patterns of dynamic functional connectivity variability of thalamo-cortical circuit in bipolar depression and major depressive disorder

Evidence has indicated abnormalities of thalamo-cortical functional connectivity (FC) in bipolar disorder during a depressive episode (BDD) and major depressive disorder (MDD). However, the dynamic FC (dFC) within this system is poorly understood. We explored the thalamo-cortical dFC pattern by dividing thalamus into 16 subregions and combining with a sliding-window approach. Correlation analysis was performed between altered dFC variability and clinical data. Classification analysis with a linear support vector machine model was conducted. Compared with healthy controls (HCs), both patients revealed increased dFC variability between thalamus subregions with hippocampus (HIP), angular gyrus and caudate, and only BDD showed increased dFC variability of the thalamus with superior frontal gyrus (SFG), HIP, insula, middle cingulate gyrus, and postcentral gyrus. Compared with MDD and HCs, only BDD exhibited enhanced dFC variability of the thalamus with SFG and superior temporal gyrus. Furthermore, the number of depressive episodes in MDD was significantly positively associated with altered dFC variability. Finally, the disrupted dFC variability could distinguish BDD from MDD with 83.44% classification accuracy. BDD and MDD shared common disrupted dFC variability in the thalamo-limbic and striatal-thalamic circuitries, whereas BDD exhibited more extensive and broader aberrant dFC variability, which may facilitate distinguish between these 2 mood disorders.

Distinguishing between depression in bipolar disorder and unipolar depression using magnetic resonance imaging: a systematic review

OBJECTIVES

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies comparing bipolar and unipolar depression characterize pathophysiological differences between these conditions. However, it is difficult to interpret the current literature due to differences in MRI modalities, analysis methods, and study designs.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review of publications using MRI to compare individuals with bipolar and unipolar depression. We grouped studies according to MRI modality and task design. Within the discussion, we critically evaluated and summarized the functional MRI research and then further complemented these findings by reviewing the structural MRI literature.

RESULTS

We identified 88 MRI publications comparing participants with bipolar depression and unipolar depressive disorder. Compared to individuals with unipolar depression, participants with bipolar disorder exhibited heightened function, increased within network connectivity, and reduced grey matter volume in salience and central executive network brain regions. Group differences in default mode network function were less consistent but more closely associated with depressive symptoms in participants with unipolar depression but distractibility in bipolar depression.

CONCLUSIONS

When comparing mood disorder groups, the neuroimaging evidence suggests that individuals with bipolar disorder are more influenced by emotional and sensory processing when responding to their environment. In contrast, depressive symptoms and neurofunctional response to emotional stimuli were more closely associated with reduced central executive function and less adaptive cognitive control of emotionally oriented brain regions in unipolar depression. Researchers now need to replicate and refine network-level trends in these heterogeneous mood disorders and further characterize MRI markers associated with early disease onset, progression, and recovery.

Resting-state fMRI in depressive and (hypo)manic mood states in bipolar disorders: A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

Abnormalities in spontaneous brain activity, measured with resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI), may be key biomarkers for bipolar disorders. This systematic review compares rs-fMRI findings in people experiencing a bipolar depressive or (hypo)manic episode to bipolar euthymia and/or healthy participants.

METHODS

Medline, Web of Science and Embase were searched up until April 2021. Studies without control group, or including minors, neurological co-morbidities or mixed episodes, were excluded. Qualitative synthesis was used to report results and risk of bias was assessed using the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute tool for case-control studies.

RESULTS

Seventy-one studies were included (3167 bipolar depressed/706 (hypo)manic). In bipolar depression, studies demonstrated default-mode (DMN) and frontoparietal network (FPN) dysfunction, altered baseline activity in the precuneus, insula, striatum, cingulate, frontal and temporal cortex, and disturbed regional homogeneity in parietal, temporal and pericentral areas. Functional connectivity was altered in thalamocortical circuits and between the cingulate cortex and precuneus. In (hypo)mania, studies reported altered functional connectivity in the amygdala, frontal and cingulate cortex. Finally, rs-fMRI disturbances in the insula and putamen correlate with depressive symptoms, cerebellar resting-state alterations could evolve with disease progression and altered amygdala connectivity might mediate lithium effects.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest DMN and FPN dysfunction in bipolar depression, whereas local rs-fMRI alterations might differentiate mood states. Future studies should consider controlling rs-fMRI findings for potential clinical confounding factors such as medication. Considerable heterogeneity of methodology between studies limits conclusions. Standardised clinical reporting and consistent analysis approaches would increase coherence in this promising field.

Increased ALFF and functional connectivity of the right striatum in bipolar disorder patients

BACKGROUND

Bipolar disorder (BD) is a serious neuropsychiatric disorder characterized by alternating periods of mania, depression, and euthymia. Abnormal spontaneous brain activity within the cortical-striatal neural circuits has been observed in patients with BD. However, whether the abnormality appears in patients with BD while not in a manic mood state is unclear.

METHODS

This study collected resting-state fMRI data from 65 patients with BD who were not in a manic mood state and 85 matched healthy controls. First, we examined differences in amplitude of low-frequency fluctuations (ALFF) between the patients with BD and the healthy controls to identify regions that show abnormal local spontaneous activity in the patients. Based on the ALFF results, we conducted seed-based resting-state functional connectivity (rsFC) analysis to identify the changes in brain networks that are centered on the regions showing abnormal local spontaneous activity in the patients. Finally, we repeated these analyses in a sub-sample comprising euthymic BD patients (N = 37) and between the euthymic BD patients and all the other patients who had at least mild depressive symptoms.

RESULTS

BD patients exhibited increased ALFF in the right caudate/putamen and increased rsFC in the right caudate/putamen with the right inferior parietal lobe (cluster-level FWE p < 0.05). Further analyses showed that the euthymic BD patients showed similar abnormalities in ALFF and rsFC maps as found in all patients with BD. And the euthymic BD patients were comparable with all the other patients who had at least mild depressive symptoms in ALFF values.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicated the important role of the right striatum in the baseline brain function of BD patients and suggested that the abnormality of spontaneous brain activity in the cortical-striatal neural circuits may be a trait-like variant in patients with BD. The results deepen our understanding of the neurobiological mechanisms associated with BD etiology.

Mood disorders disrupt the functional dynamics, not spatial organization of brain resting state networks

Spontaneous fluctuations in the blood oxygenation level dependent signal measured through resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging have been corroborated to aggregate into multiple functional networks. Abnormal resting brain activity is observed in mood disorder patients, however with inconsistent results. How do such alterations relate to clinical symptoms; e.g., level of depression and rumination tendencies? Here we recovered spatially and temporally overlapping functional networks from 31 mood disorder patients and healthy controls during rest, by applying novel methods that identify transient changes in spontaneous brain activity. Our unique approach disentangles the dynamic engagement of resting-state networks unconstrained by the slow hemodynamic response. This time-varying characterization provides moment-to-moment information about functional networks in terms of their durations and dynamic coupling, and offers novel evidence for selective contributionsto particular clinical symptoms. Patients showed increased duration of default-mode network (DMN), increased duration and occurrence of posterior DMN as well as insula- and amygdala-centered networks, but decreased occurrence of visual and anterior salience networks. Coupling between limbic (insula and amygdala) networks was also reduced. Depression level modulated DMN duration, whereas intrusive thoughts correlated with occurrence of insula and posterior DMN. Anatomical network organization was similar to controls. In sum, altered brain dynamics in mood disorder patients appear to mediate distinct clinical dimensions including increased self-processing, and decreased attention to external world.