Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation Beyond Severe Combined Immunodeficiency: Seeking a Cure for Primary Immunodeficiency

Curative allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation following reduced toxicity conditioning in adults with primary immunodeficiency

Primary immunodeficiencies (PID) are heterogeneous inborn errors of the immune system. Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (allo-HSCT) is curative and safe at the pediatric age but remains underperformed in adults. We report our experience on 32 consecutive adult patients with various PID including 17 (53%) with a combined immune deficiency, six (19%) with a disease of immune dysregulation and nine (28%) with a chronic granulomatous disease (CGD) who underwent an allo-HSCT between 2011 and 2020. The median age at transplant was 27 years (17-41). All assessable patients engrafted. The majority of patients received a fludarabine-Busulfan (FB) based regimen (FB2-3 in 16, FB4 in 12). Overall survival (OS) was 80.4% (100% for CGD and 74% for other PID patients) at 9 months and beyond (median follow-up 51.6 months). Six patients died, all in the first-year post-transplant. Cumulative incidences of grade II-IV acute GVHD/chronic GVHD were 18%/22%. Stem cell source, GVHD prophylaxis and conditioning intensity had no impact on OS. All surviving patients had over 90% donor chimerism, immune reconstitution, no sign of active PID related complications and were clinically improved. Allo-HSCT is effective in young adults PID patients with an acceptable toxicity and should be discussed in case of life-threatening PID.

Multicenter Outcome of Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation for Primary Immune Deficiency Disorders in India

Background

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is the curative option for many primary immune deficiency disorders (PID). In the last 5 years, increased awareness, availability of diagnostics based on flow cytometry, genetic testing, improved supportive care, use of reduced toxicity conditioning, and success of haploidentical donor HSCT have improved access to HSCT for children with PID in India. We present results on children with PID who underwent HSCT across India and the factors that influenced outcome.

Patients and Methods

We collected retrospective data on the outcome of HSCT for PID from seven centers. We analyzed the impact of the type of PID, conditioning regimen, time period of HSCT- before or after January 2016, graft versus host disease prophylaxis, cause of mortality and overall survival.

Results

A total of 228 children underwent HSCT for PID at a median age of 12 months (range, 1 to 220 months) with a median follow up of 14.4 months. Infants accounted for 51.3% of the cohort and the male female ratio was 3:1. SCID (25%) and HLH (25%) were the more frequent diagnoses. Matched family donor was available in 36.4% and 44.3% children had a haploidentical HSCT. Reduced and myeloablative conditioning regimens were used with 64% children receiving a treosulfan based conditioning regimen. Peripheral blood stem cells were the predominant graft source at 69.3%. The survival in infants (60.2%) was inferior to children aged over 1 year (75.7% p value = 0.01). Children with Wiskott Aldrich syndrome (74.3%) and chronic granulomatous disease (82.6%) had the best outcomes. The survival was superior in children receiving HSCT from a matched sibling (78%) versus an alternate donor HSCT (61% p value = 0.04). In the cohort transplanted after January 2016 survival improved from 26.8% to 77.5% (p value = 0.00). Infection remains the main cause of mortality at in over 50% children. The 5-year overall survival rate was 68%.

Conclusion

Survival of children with PID undergoing HSCT in India has improved dramatically in last 5 years. Alternate donor HSCT is now feasible and has made a therapeutic option accessible to all children with PID.

Considerations for hematopoietic stem cell transplantation in primary immunodeficiency disorders

Primary immunodeficiency disorders (PIDs) result from inborn errors in immunity. Susceptibility to infections and oftentimes severe autoimmunity pose life-threatening risks to patients with these disorders. Hematopoietic cell transplant (HCT) remains the only curative option for many. Severe combined immunodeficiency disorders (SCID) most commonly present at the time of birth and typically require emergent HCT in the first few weeks of life. HCT poses an unusual challenge for PIDs. Donor source and conditioning regimen often impact the outcome of immune reconstitution after HCT in PIDs. The use of matched or unmatched, as well as related versus unrelated donor has resulted in variable outcomes for different subsets of PIDs. Additionally, there is significant variability in the success of engraftment even for a single patient’s lymphocyte subpopulations. While certain cell lines do well without a conditioning regimen, others will not reconstitute unless conditioning is used. The decision to proceed with a conditioning regimen in an already immunocompromised host is further complicated by the fact that alkylating agents should be avoided in radiosensitive PIDs. This manuscript reviews some of the unique elements of HCT in PIDs and evidence-based approaches to transplant in patients with these rare and challenging disorders.