Symptomatic Dermographism: A Systematic Review of Treatment Options

Eating increases disease activity in pediatric patients with symptomatic dermographism

Background: Symptomatic dermographism (SD) is the most common form of chronic inducible urticaria. SD disease activity increases with food intake in adult patients. Whether this is also so in children with SD is currently unknown. Objective: To assess children with SD for their disease activity by standardized provocation testing before and after eating. Methods: We subjected 44 children with SD (29 girls; median [interquartile range] age 12.5 years [8.3-15 years]), before and after eating, to standardized skin provocation testing with a dermographometer. Dermographometer scores were calculated based on responses evaluated at 1-minute intervals for 10 minutes and recorded as negative (-) or positive (+ to ++++). Clinical characteristics and urticaria control test scores were documented. Results: Dermographometer scores before eating were 2.3 of 4 on average and inversely correlated with urticaria control test scores. Dermographometer scores were higher after eating than before eating. Of 44 children with SD, 35 had increased dermographometer scores after eating and 9 patients had a postprandial increase of ≥1 point. Eating-induced increases in dermographometer scores were linked to earlier whealing in 17 of 35 patients, and differences in preprandial versus postprandial dermographometer responses were more pronounced at earlier than later time points after testing. Conclusion: Disease activity, as assessed by provocation testing, is increased in most pediatric patients with SD after eating. Future studies should explore the prevalence of food-exacerbated SD in larger pediatric SD populations. Most pediatric patients with symptomatic dermographism have higher disease activity, assessed by provocation testing, after eating as compared to before eating. Standardized provocation testing and trigger threshold assessments in children with symptomatic dermographism should be performed before and after eating. Knowledge of food-exacerbated disease may help patients with the management of their symptomatic dermographism.

Shedding light on dermographism: a narrative review

Dermographism is a common subtype of chronic urticaria. It generally manifests as a linear wheal after scratching or friction, with or without angioedema. The pathophysiology is not clear, but currently, we believe that the stimulation of the skin by mechanical stress leads to the activation of mast cells, which provoke the release of histamine and pro-inflammatory mediators, ultimately forming wheal along the stressed area. The gold standard for diagnosis is a medical history and provocation test or dermatographic test. As one of the subtypes of chronic urticaria, the Urticaria Control Test (UCT), Chronic Urticaria Quality of Life questionnaire (CU-Q2oL), and Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) are also effective tools for evaluating disease control in dermographism patients. In addition to avoiding triggers, nonsedating H1 antihistamines are the first-line medications recommended by EAACI and other guidelines; for those who do not respond to standard doses, the recommended dosage can be increased up to 4 times. When necessary, the off-label use of omalizumab can be considered, and some drugs with potential therapeutic effects are still being explored. However, there is still a lack of biomarkers for predicting disease severity, efficacy, and prognosis. Here, we review what we know about dermographism and some points that need exploration in the future.

New insights into chronic inducible urticaria

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Chronic inducible urticaria (CIndU) is a group of long-persisting and challenging to manage diseases, characterized by recurrent wheals and angioedema induced by definite triggers. In this review, we address recent findings on CIndU pathogenesis, diagnosis as well as its treatment, and we discuss novel potential targets that may lead to the development of more effective therapies for CIndU patients.

RECENT ADVANCES

Meaningful advances in the understanding of its pathogenesis have been reported in the last decades. Novel CIndU-specific patient-reported outcome measures enable a closer and better evaluation of patients. CIndU is a hard-to-treat disease that highly impairs quality of life (QoL) of affected patients. Provocation tests allow to diagnose CIndU subtypes. The only licensed and recommended treatment for CIndU are second generation non-sedating H1-antihistamines, which lack efficacy in many cases. Omalizumab off-label use has been assessed in all types of CIndU with overall good outcomes. Promising emerging therapies currently assessed in chronic spontaneous urticaria are paving the path for novel treatments for CIndU.

Identification of pyruvic and maleic acid as potential markers for disease activity and prognosis in chronic urticaria

BACKGROUND

Population-based studies have highlighted the link between chronic urticaria (CU) and metabolic syndrome, and metabolic alterations have been revealed in CU. However, to our knowledge, a comprehensive metabolomics study on a large cohort of patients with CU has not been reported.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to explore the underlying metabolic subtypes and novel metabolite biomarkers for CU diagnosis and therapy.

METHODS

Plasma samples from 80 patients with CU and 82 healthy controls were collected for metabolomics quantification and bioinformatics analysis. Another independent cohort consisting of 144 patients with CU was studied to validate the findings. Bone marrow-derived mast cells and mice with IgE-induced passive cutaneous anaphylaxis were used for in vitro and in vivo experiments, respectively.

RESULTS

We observed clear metabolome differences between CU patients and healthy controls. Meanwhile, differential metabolites N6-acetyl-l-lysine, l-aspartate, maleic acid, and pyruvic acid were used to construct random forest classifiers and achieved area under receiver operating characteristic curve values greater than 0.85, suggesting their potential as diagnostic biomarkers of CU. More importantly, by exploring the underlying metabolic subtypes of CU, we found that the low abundance of pyruvic acid and maleic acid was significantly related to the activity of CU, poor efficacy of second-generation H1 antihistamines, and short relapse-free time. The results were validated in the independent cohort. Moreover, supplementation with pyruvate or maleate could significantly attenuate IgE-mediated mast cell activation in vitro and in vivo.

CONCLUSIONS

Plasma pyruvic acid and maleic acid may be effective biomarkers for predicting disease activity, therapeutic efficacy, and prognosis for patients with CU.

Symptomatic dermographism induced by oral minocycline: A report of four cases

Symptomatic dermographism (SD) is the most common form of chronic inducible urticarias. The etiology of this disease has rarely been reported in the literature. Minocycline is widely used in the treatment of acne, rosacea, and other inflammatory skin diseases. Herein we report four cases of SD onset during minocycline administration. These were young women in their 20s to 30s who were taking minocycline orally for acne vulgaris or rosacea. They all experienced the onset of SD 2-3 weeks after taking the drug, and then the complete disappearance of SD 1 month after stopping the drug. Minocycline was thought to be the culprit drug in these cases as other drugs were ruled out on clinical grounds. Our small series suggests that oral minocycline may induce SD, thus raising the awareness of this association in clinical practice. More research is needed to further confirm this association and reveal the underlying mechanism(s).

Evidence for histamine release in chronic inducible urticaria – A systematic review

Background

Chronic inducible urticaria (CIndU) constitutes a group of nine different CIndUs in which pruritic wheals and/or angioedema occur after exposure to specific and definite triggers. Histamine released from activated and degranulating skin mast cells is held to play a key role in the pathogenesis of CIndU, but evidence to support this has, as of yet, not been reviewed systematically or in detail. We aim to characterize the role and relevance of histamine in CIndU.

Methods

We systematically searched 3 electronic databases (PubMed, Scopus, and Embase) for studies that reported increased serum or skin histamine concentration (direct evidence) or in vitro or ex vivo histamine release (indirect evidence) following trigger exposure.

Results

An initial total of 3,882 articles was narrowed down to 107 relevant studies of which 52 were in cold urticaria, 19 in cholinergic urticaria, 14 in heat urticaria, 10 in contact urticaria, 7 each in solar urticaria and vibratory angioedema, 4 each in symptomatic dermographism and aquagenic urticaria, and 3 in delayed pressure urticaria. The results of our review support that histamine has a key pathogenic role in the pathogenesis of all CIndUs, but it is not the sole mediator as evidenced by the often poor relationship between the level of histamine and severity of symptoms and the variable clinical efficacy of H1-antihistamines.

Conclusions

Histamine released from skin mast cells is a key driver of the development of signs and symptoms and a promising therapeutic target in CIndU.

Dermatographism with vulvar symptoms

Dermatographism (DG) is characterized by a localized, inducible, wheal-and-flare response along the distribution of mechanical pressure. We report an illustrative case of DG with vulvar symptoms (DG-VS) and review the literature on this rarely recognized but easily treated etiology of vulvar complaints. A 35-year-old woman presented with a 1-year history of vulvar pruritus unresponsive to antifungal, antibacterial, and steroid treatments. A prior punch biopsy was nondiagnostic. Vulvar examination revealed normal architecture and no cutaneous abnormalities. She was markedly dermatographic with a scratch test. DG-VS was diagnosed. The patient achieved complete symptomatic control on low-dose hydroxyzine. She maintains excellent control at 3.5 years. In the literature, a typical patient with DG-VS is of reproductive age, with several years’ history of vulvar symptoms (itching, burning, pain, or swelling) and repeated empiric treatment for infectious/inflammatory etiologies. Exacerbation with sexual activity, menstruation, or wearing tight clothing is characteristic and supports the role of mechanical pressure in inducing focal symptoms. Dermatologic changes to the vulvar skin are rarely noted. DG-VS is diagnosed based on clinical findings, symptom patterns, and a positive scratch test and is treated with antihistamines. DG-VS remains absent from current vulvar disease guidelines. In the complex world of vulvar pain and itch, an etiology so easily screened for and readily treated warrants consideration.

Chronic Urticaria: Advances in Understanding of the Disease and Clinical Management

Chronic urticaria (CU) is a common skin condition characterized by the recurrence of wheals, with or without angioedema, which lasts for at least 6 weeks. Owing to its pruritus and incurability, this disease adversely affects the patients' physical and mental health and diminishes the quality of life. CU is generally classified into two subtypes based on the relevance of eliciting factors: chronic spontaneous urticaria (CSU) and chronic inducible urticaria (CIndU), the latter of which is further divided into several subtypes. To improve the understanding and clinical management of this highly heterogeneous disorder, the EAACI/GA²LEN/EDF/WAO guideline was developed and published in 2018 based on evidence and expert consensus. The diagnostic and treatment algorithms proposed by the guideline have largely facilitated dermatologists in clinical practice. However, several questions remained unsolved and have been widely investigated in the recent years. First, a better understanding of the association between chronic urticaria and its potential underlying causes or eliciting factors such as autoimmunity, infections, coagulation aberrance, and vitamin D deficiency is warranted. This would lead to updates in the diagnostic and treatment procedures of different subtypes of chronic urticaria. Secondly, treatment for recalcitrant cases, especially those resistant to or intolerant of second-generation antihistamines and (or) omalizumab, calls for novel therapeutic measures or strategies. In the present review, we summarized recent advances in the understanding and management of both CSU and CIndU, with special emphasis on their underlying causes or eliciting factors, pathogenic mechanisms, potential targets for intervention, and advances in treatment strategies.

Food-dependent and food-exacerbated symptomatic dermographism: New variants of symptomatic dermographism

BACKGROUND

Symptomatic dermographism (SD) is the most common form of chronic inducible urticaria. The criterion standard for diagnosing SD and disease activity assessment in SD is provocation testing. As of now, if and what cofactors have an impact on provocation test results is unknown.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to determine whether the induction of signs and symptoms of SD is affected by the intake of food.

METHODS

We performed standardized skin provocation testing with a dermographometer (FricTest) before and after the intake of food. Patients were off antihistamine treatment for at least 3 days before testing. In total, 17 patients were tested after not having eaten for at least 4 hours (preprandial) on one volar forearm and 60 minutes after a carbohydrate-rich meal (postprandial) on the other. FricTest responses (wheals, itch) at trigger thresholds were assessed at 5 and 30 seconds as well as at 1, 2, 5, and 10 minutes.

RESULTS

We identified 7 patients with SD who showed faster onset of FricTest-induced whealing and/or lower trigger thresholds after the intake of food, that is, food-exacerbated SD. In 5 other patients, FricTest provocation testing resulted in a positive response only after the intake of food, but not before. Three of these 5 patients with food-dependent SD had comorbid chronic spontaneous urticaria and 1 had cholinergic urticaria.

CONCLUSIONS

We describe 2 previously unknown subtypes of SD, food-exacerbated SD and food-dependent SD. The prevalence and underlying pathomechanisms of food-exacerbated SD and food-dependent SD need to be investigated, and the impact of food intake on other forms of chronic inducible urticaria should be explored.