Meta-analyses comparing spine simulators with cadavers and finite element models by analysing range-of-motion data before and after lumbar total disc replacement

Effect of patient-specific factors on regeneration in lumbar spine at healthy disc and total disc replacement. Computer simulation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Degenerative diseases of the spine have a negative impact on the quality of life of patients. This study presents the results of numerical modelling of the mechanical behaviour of the lumbar spine with patient-specific conditions at physiological loads. This paper aims to numerically study the influence of degenerative changes in the spine and the presence of an endoprosthesis on the creation of conditions for tissue regeneration.

METHODS

A numerical model of the mechanical behaviour of lumbar spine at healthy and after total disc replacement under low-energy impacts equivalent to physiological loads is presented. The model is based on the movable cellular automaton method (discrete elements), where the mechanical behaviour of bone tissue is described using the Biot poroelasticity accounting for the presence and transfer of interstitial biological fluid. The nutritional pathways of the intervertebral disc in cases of healthy and osteoporotic bone tissues were predicted based on the analysis of the simulation results according to the mechanobiological principles.

RESULTS

Simulation of total disc replacement showed that osseointegration of the artificial disc plates occurs only in healthy bone tissue. With total disc replacement in a patient with osteoporosis, there is an area of increased risk of bone resorption in the near-contact area, approximately 1 mm wide, around the fixators. Dynamic loads may improve the osseointegration of the implant in pathological conditions of the bone tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

The results obtained in the case of healthy spine and osteoporotic bone tissues correspond to the experimental data on biomechanics and possible methods of IVD regeneration from the position of mechanobiological principles. The results obtained with an artificial disc (with keel-type fixation) showed that the use of this type of endoprosthesis in healthy bone tissues allows to reproduce the function of the natural intervertebral disc and does not contribute to the development of neoplastic processes. In the case of an artificial disc with osteoporosis of bone tissues, there is a zone with increased risk of tissue resorption and development of neoplastic processes in the area near the contact of the implant attachment. This circumstance can be compensated by increasing the loading level.

Biomechanical Comparison of Multilevel Stand-Alone Lumbar Lateral Interbody Fusion With Posterior Pedicle Screws: An In Vitro Study

OBJECTIVE

Lumbar lateral interbody fusion (LLIF) allows placement of large interbody cages while preserving ligamentous structures important for stability. Multiple clinical and biomechanical studies have demonstrated the feasibility of stand-alone LLIF in single-level fusion. We sought to compare the stability of 4-level stand-alone LLIF utilizing wide (26 mm) cages with bilateral pedicle screw and rod fixation.

METHODS

Eight human cadaveric specimens of L1-5 were included. Specimens were attached to a universal testing machine (MTS 30/G). Flexion, extension, and lateral bending were attained by applying a 200 N load at a rate of 2 mm/sec. Axial rotation of ± 8° of the specimen was performed at 2°/sec. Three-dimensional specimen motion was recorded using an optical motion-tracking device. Specimens were tested in 4 conditions: (1) intact, (2) bilateral pedicle screws and rods, (3) 26-mm stand-alone LLIF, (4) 26-mm LLIF with bilateral pedicle screws and rods.

RESULTS

Compared to the stand-alone LLIF, bilateral pedicle screws and rods had 47% less range of motion in flexion-extension (p < 0.001), 21% less in lateral bending (p < 0.05), and 20% less in axial rotation (p = 0.1). The addition of bilateral posterior instrumentation to the stand-alone LLIF resulted in decreases of all 3 planes of motion: 61% in flexion-extension ( p < 0.001), 57% in lateral bending (p < 0.001), 22% in axial rotation (p = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

Despite the biomechanical advantages associated with the lateral approach and 26 mm wide cages, stand-alone LLIF for 4-level fusion is not equivalent to pedicle screws and rods.

Impact of adjacent pre-existing disc degeneration status on its biomechanics after single-level anterior cervical interbody fusion

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Mechanics and biology may be interconnected and amplify each other during disc degeneration. It remains unknown the influence of pre-existing disc degeneration and its impact on adjacent segment degeneration (ASD) after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF). This study aimed to discuss the necessity of including degenerated adjacent segments in single-level ACDF surgery from a biomechanical view.

METHODS

A poroelastic C2-T1 finite element model was created and validated. A C5-C6 ACDF model was developed based on this normal model. Moderate C4-C5 disc degeneration was created by appropriately modifying the morphology and tissue material properties in this fusion model. Degenerative morphology was modeled based on Thompson's grading system and Walraevens's scoring system for cervical spine, including disc height, whole disc area, nucleus pulposus (NP) area, endplate sclerosis and curvature. Stresses in disc and endplate and loads in facet joint were computed under moment loads in the fusion models with normal and pre-existing degenerative disc condition.

RESULTS

As for the adjacent disc, the stress values in degenerative condition were 7.41%, 5% and 5.26% larger than that in normal situation during extension, axial rotation and lateral bending motion, respectively. The disc stress changes mainly stemmed from annulus fibrosus (AF) tissue, but not NP. In the endplate, stress values of degeneration status were 4.17, 4.35 and 6.06% larger than that of normal condition under axial rotation, lateral bending and extension. The facet load magnitudes of pre-existing degeneration were 11.28, 11.57, 11.78 and 11.42% greater than that of normal condition in flexion, extension, axial rotation and lateral bending motion.

CONCLUSION

Pre-existing degenerated disc experience increased biomechanical changes in adjacent segment after single-level ACDF. It may pose a long-term cumulative problem related to biomechanics in cervical spine after fusion. Before surgery, surgeons should be careful about selecting the fusion level.

Finite Element Method for the Evaluation of the Human Spine: A Literature Overview

The finite element method (FEM) represents a computer simulation method, originally used in civil engineering, which dates back to the early 1940s. Applications of FEM have also been used in numerous medical areas and in orthopedic surgery. Computing technology has improved over the years and as a result, more complex problems, such as those involving the spine, can be analyzed. The spine is a complex anatomical structure that maintains the erect posture and supports considerable loads. Applications of FEM in the spine have contributed to the understanding of bone biomechanics, both in healthy and abnormal conditions, such as scoliosis, fractures (trauma), degenerative disc disease and osteoporosis. However, since FEM is only a digital simulation of the real condition, it will never exactly simulate in vivo results. In particular, when it concerns biomechanics, there are many features that are difficult to represent in a FEM. More FEM studies and spine research are required in order to examine interpersonal spine stiffness, young spine biomechanics and model accuracy. In the future, patient-specific models will be used for better patient evaluations as well as for better pre- and inter-operative planning.