The 2023 Bethesda System for reporting thyroid cytopathology

Thyroid nodulectomy: A promising approach to the management of solitary thyroid nodules

The choice between nodulectomy and lobectomy for managing thyroid nodules is a subject of debate in the field of thyroid surgery. The present study aims to share the experience of a single center in managing solitary thyroid nodules through nodulectomy from January 2023 to October 2023. The inclusion criteria encompassed symptomatic or suspicious solitary nodules and medically necessitated cases. The extracted data included patient demographics, medical history, symptoms, diagnostic details, surgery indication, procedure outcome and histopathological findings. The follow-up included clinic visits and phone calls. The mean age of the patients was 36.64±11.63 years, with 85.0% females and 15.0% males. Predominantly, patients were housewives (58.5%). Neck swelling (62.3%) was the most common presentation. Ultrasound examination revealed mixed nodules in more than half of the cases (54.7%). Right nodulectomy was performed in 26 cases (49.1%) and left nodulectomy in 23 (43.4%), and four cases (7.5%) underwent isthmusectomy. The mean operation time was 36.04±9.37 min and no drainage tube was used in any of the cases. One case (1.9%) of seroma was the only observed complication during the observational period. Nodulectomy may be a suitable choice for managing benign, large, solitary thyroid nodules, small suspicious nodules or microcarcinomas.

Oncocytic/Hürthle cell lesions have the same implied risk of neoplasm/malignancy as their follicular counterparts

INTRODUCTION

There are conflicting results on whether the presence of oncocytes modifies the risk of neoplasm (RON) or malignancy (ROM) for thyroid fine-needle aspirates (FNAs): Atypia of undetermined significance AUS and Follicular Neoplasm, FN, or Oncocytic Neoplasm, ON. To our knowledge, the effect of non-invasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features (NIFTP) has not yet been studied. We compared RON and ROM between follicular type AUS (AUS-FT) and oncocytic type AUS (AUS-OT) and between FN and ON.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analysed all thyroid FNAs with the diagnostic category of AUS-other or Neoplasm (2005-2015). AUS-FT had predominance of microfollicles and AUS-OT had predominance of oncocytes. Histology follow-up was then reviewed and RON, ROM was then calculated and compared (significant at p < 0.05). We repeated the search for 2018 to evaluate for NIFTP effect.

RESULTS

Pre-NIFTP, 859/5063 cases (17%) were AUS-FT, AUS-OT, FN, and ON. Histology follow-up was available for 297 cases (35%). RON was 83/183 (45%) for AUS-FT, 35/76 (46%) for AUS-OT, 15/25 (60%) for FN and 11/13 (85%) for ON. Post-NIFTP, RON was 11/31 (35%) for AUS-FT, 5/8 (63%) for AUS-OT, 1/2 (50%) for FN and 4/5 (80%) for ON. For both periods, RON, ROM of AUS-FT was not significantly different than AUS-OT, and no significant differences were observed comparing FN and ON.

CONCLUSION

The predominance of oncocytes does not modify the implied RON, ROM for categories of AUS or FN\ON, even after the adoption of NIFTP.

ThyroSeq overview on indeterminate thyroid nodules: An institutional experience

BACKGROUND

Molecular triage of indeterminate thyroid aspirates offers the opportunity to stratify the risk of malignancy (ROM) more accurately. Here we examine our experience with ThyroSeq v3 testing.

METHODS

We analyzed 276 of 658 (42%) fine needle aspiration samples classified as indeterminate thyroid nodules using ThyroSeq v3 (Sept 2017-Dec 2019). The test provides a ROM and detects specific mutations. Surgical diagnoses were reviewed.

RESULTS

Of 276 ThyroSeq-tested cases, 42% (n = 116) harbored genetic alterations, whereas 64% (n = 74) had surgical follow-up. Notably, 79% cases within intermediate to higher risk mutations were highly associated with surgical intervention, resulting in a 77.5% ROM when including both cancer and noninvasive follicular thyroid neoplasia with papillary-like features (cancer+NIFTP) and 68% malignant diagnosis when excluding NIFTP. RAS-like alterations were most common (66%), exhibiting a 73.4% ROM and a 59% malignant diagnosis. Interestingly, this group included 24 encapsulated follicular variant papillary thyroid carcinomas (EFVPTCs), 1 infiltrative FVPTC, 9 follicular carcinomas, and 7 NIFTP. Additionally, three high-risk mutations and eight BRAF/V600E mutations had a 100% ROM, all diagnosed as classic-type papillary thyroid carcinoma (cPTC). Combined analysis of thyroid nodules from Bethesda III and IV categories revealed a 78.2% positive predictive value (PPV) and a 75.9% negative predictive value (NPV).

CONCLUSION

ThyroSeq v3 effectively stratifies the ROM in indeterminate thyroid nodules based on specific genetic alterations, guiding appropriate surgical management. Notably, the BRAFV600E/high-risk group and RAS-like groups exhibited ROM of 100% and 77.5%, respectively, with promising predictive accuracy (PPV of 78.2% and NPV of 75.9%).

Doing more with less: integrating small biopsies in cytology practice

Cytopathologists are at the forefront of specimen acquisition during many different procedures while providing rapid on site evaluation (ROSE). This has added pressure to cytopathologists as more and more ancillary testing is being requested on smaller amounts of tissue. By focusing on the most common organ sites: lung, head and neck, and pancreas, there is a discussion of what the cytopathologist needs to know to triage tissue successfully. Finally, there is a discussion of the logistical aspects of integrating small biopsies into everyday practice.

DICER1 Mutations Define the Landscape of Poorly Differentiated Thyroid Carcinoma in Children and Young Adults: Case Report and Literature Review

Poorly differentiated thyroid carcinoma (PDTC) is a rare malignancy, representing ~1% of all thyroid tumors. It is characterized by high-grade histologic features without the anaplastic characteristics observed in anaplastic thyroid carcinoma. Although rare in children and young adults, there is emerging evidence of clinical and genetic differences with PDTC in adults. We present a case of a 19-year-old female with a right thyroid lobe nodule classified as an EU-TIRADS 5 lesion. Subsequent FNAC showed a cellular aspirate of solitary cells and scant microfollicles with variable nuclear irregularities, which was designated a Bethesda class IV lesion. Thyroidectomy revealed histopathological features consistent with PDTC, including solid/trabecular growth, increased mitotic activity, central necrosis, and extensive vascular invasion. Molecular analysis identified germline and somatic DICER1 mutations in the absence of other established driver mutations of PDTC. This case report describes the fourth reported patient with a PDTC and germline DICER1 mutation. Our findings contribute to a limited body of literature on pediatric/young adult PDTC cases and highlight the pivotal role of DICER1 mutations. Emerging evidence suggests that pediatric PDTC may exhibit unique clinical and genetic characteristics, prompting further research into its molecular profile.

Comprehensive evaluation of cytomorphologic, histologic, and molecular features of DICER1-altered thyroid lesions on FNA: A multipractice experience

BACKGROUND

DICER1 mutations, though infrequent, are encountered on preoperative molecular testing of indeterminate adult and pediatric thyroid fine-needle aspiration (FNA) specimens. Yet, published cytomorphologic features of DICER1-altered thyroid lesions are limited. Cytomorphological features of DICER1-altered thyroid lesions were examined in a multipractice FNA cohort with clinical, radiological, and histologic data.

METHODS

The cohort comprised 18 DICER1-altered thyroid FNAs, with 14 having slides available and eight having corresponding surgical resections. Smears, ThinPrep, and formalin-fixed cell block slides were reviewed and correlated with histology, when available. Clinical and radiologic data were obtained from the medical record.

RESULTS

Most DICER1-altered FNAs were classified as atypia of undetermined significance (94.4%). DICER1 mutations occurred in codons 1709 (50%), 1810 (27.8%), and 1813 (22.2%). One patient had an additional DICER1 p.D1822N variant in both of their FNAs. Lesions were often hypoechoic (35.3%) and solid (47.1%) on ultrasound. Notable cytomorphologic features include mixed but prominent microfollicular or crowded component, variable colloid, and insignificant nuclear atypia. On resection (n = 10), histologic diagnoses ranged from benign follicular adenoma and low-risk follicular thyroid carcinoma to high-grade follicular-derived nonanaplastic thyroid carcinoma. Subcapsular infarct-type change was the most common histologic change. There was no evidence of recurrence or metastasis in eight patients on limited follow-up.

CONCLUSION

DICER1-altered thyroid lesions occurred frequently in young females and FNAs show RAS-like cytomorphology including crowded, mixed macro-/microfollicular pattern, and bland nuclear features. On resection, DICER1-altered thyroid lesions include benign (50%), low-risk lesions (30%), or high-risk malignancies (20%).

Challenging the concept of "risk of malignancy" in cytology

Several standardized systems for nongynecological cytopathology have been published following the successful implementation of The Bethesda System for Reporting Cervical Cytology. Each of these systems comprises a set of reporting categories accompanied by a risk of malignancy. However, in most cases, these risk of malignancy estimates have not been based on high-quality evidence and often may not be consider proper "risks" (because they have been estimated based on cross-sectional studies). This commentary discusses the problems related to the data used to generate these risks. To make nongynecological cytopathology reporting more evidence-based, large-scale prospective cohort studies and randomized trials, in addition to high-quality systematic reviews and meta-analyses, should be performed.

Evaluating Diagnostic Clarity: The Comparative Efficacy of BlueStain in Serous Effusion Cytology under the International System for Reporting Serous Fluid Cytopathology Reporting Framework

Serous effusion cytology is a pivotal diagnostic and staging tool in clinical pathology, valued for its simplicity and cost-effectiveness. Staining techniques such as Giemsa and Papanicolaou are foundational, yet the search for rapid and efficient alternatives continues. Our study assesses the efficacy of an in-house-developed BlueStain, a toluidine blue variant, within the International System for Reporting Serous Fluid Cytopathology (TIS), aiming to optimize diagnostic clarity and resource use.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This section provides details on the cohort of 237 patients with serous effusions, the ethical approval process, sample collection, and staining procedures with BlueStain, Papanicolaou, and Giemsa. It also describes the microscopic evaluation criteria, scoring system, and statistical methods used to compare the stains.

RESULTS

BlueStain demonstrated notable performance, particularly in identifying malignant cells, presenting a competitive alternative to the Papanicolaou stain, which, despite higher quality indices in other categories, requires more resources and time. The study revealed that BlueStain might offer a valuable balance between quality and efficiency, especially in cases where rapid diagnostic turnaround is essential.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that BlueStain is a viable staining method in the context of serous effusions, capable of providing detailed cytomorphological analysis. While traditional stains hold their place for their established diagnostic clarity, BlueStain offers a rapid and resource-optimized alternative. The absence of definitive diagnostic criteria in the atypical category and the inherent sample heterogeneity underscores the necessity for adaptable staining methods like BlueStain. The study highlights the potential trade-offs between detail and practicality in staining techniques, advocating for further research into innovative methods that do not compromise diagnostic precision for cost and time efficiency.

Malignant risk of pediatric Bethesda category III thyroid nodules subcategorized by nuclear atypia and other: A single institution experience

BACKGROUND

The 2023 Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC) divides AUS diagnoses into two major subcategories: atypia of undetermined significance (AUS) nuclear atypia (AUS-N) and other (AUS-O). This study aims to compare the histological outcome and malignant rate of pediatric AUS thyroid nodules classified into AUS-N and AUS-O subcategories.

DESIGN

A search of our institutional electronic pathology database for the period from January 2012 to July 2023 was conducted to identify pediatric (<21 years old) thyroid nodules that were interpreted as AUS and subsequently had surgery. Cases were further divided into AUS-N and AUS-O subcategories. Results of follow-up surgical resections were collected. The malignant rate was calculated and compared between AUS-N and AUS-O groups.

RESULTS

The study identified 62 thyroid nodules from 58 pediatric patients. Among these nodules, 29 and 33 were subcategorized as AUS-N and AUS-O, respectively. Both groups exhibited a female predominance and displayed a similar nodule size distribution. Histological analysis revealed 15 carcinomas in AUS-N nodules, including 11 cases of classic papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) and four cases of follicular type of PTC. In contrast, in the AUS-O group, a total of five carcinomas were documented, including two PTCs and three oncocytic thyroid carcinomas. Notably, the malignant rate of AUS-N nodules (52%) is significantly higher than that of AUS-O nodules (15%) (p = .002).

CONCLUSION

In pediatric AUS thyroid nodules, the malignant risk in AUS-N is significantly higher than that in AUS-O. These findings may guide more appropriate clinical triage and/or improve management of pediatric patients with AUS thyroid nodules.

The Incidence of Thyroid Cancer in Bethesda III Thyroid Nodules: A Retrospective Analysis at a Single Endocrine Surgery Center

BACKGROUND

Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is widely used to diagnose and monitor thyroid nodules. The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC) is the standard for interpreting FNAC specimens. The risk of malignancy in Bethesda III nodules, also known as Atypia of Undetermined Significance (AUS), varies significantly throughout several studies published worldwide. This retrospective study examines the risk of cancer in thyroid FNAC categorized as Bethesda III as identified in the final histopathology of thyroidectomy specimens at a single endocrine surgery center.

METHODS

This retrospective cohort analysis included 1038 consecutive patients who underwent elective thyroid surgery with complete follow-up data between January 2020 and March 2024. Preoperative data on clinical and pathological characteristics have been collected. The final histopathology report from the thyroidectomy specimen was compared to the results of the preoperative FNAC on nodules that were judged to be Bethesda category III. Statistical methods were performed using SPSS version 29.

RESULTS

A total of 670 ultrasound-guided FNACs (64.5%) performed during the study period were included in the final analysis. The study population was predominantly female, represented by 79.6% of patients with a mean age of 42.5 (SD 12.1), while 20.4% were male and significantly older with mean age of 45.13 years (p = 0.02). The FNAC inadequacy rate was 5.1%, which was associated with a high risk of malignancy (6 out of 34; 17.6%). Out of the total sample size of 170 patients classified as group III, 57 were found to have malignancies in final surgical histopathology, representing 33.5% of the cases within this category. The secondary gender-related outcome analysis showed that female patients classified under the Bethesda II category had a significantly higher risk of malignancy, with a rate of 21.2%, compared to males who had a malignancy rate of 3.4% in the same Bethesda category (p = 0.001, chi-square test). However, the female patients exhibited prognostically superior non-invasive tumors compared to male individuals (p = 0.02, chi-square test).

CONCLUSION

This study's results indicate that Bethesda categories II and III are associated with a higher risk of malignancy in comparison to the reports of the first and third editions of the TBSRTC, particularly for female patients classified under category II.

Performance of Thyroid Fine-Needle Aspiration Biopsy in a Low- and Middle-Income Country

INTRODUCTION

The 6 categories of the Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytology (TBSRTC) with associated risk of malignancy (ROM) provide evidence-based clinical management guidelines. This study aimed to determine the ROM and accuracy of FNAB in South Africa (SA).

METHODS

Thyroid specimens from 3 pathology laboratories registered between January 2015 and December 2019 were considered for inclusion. ROM was obtained per TBSRTC category by cytohistological correlation and dividing the total number of specimens with malignant histology by the total number of cases operated. Accuracy was calculated based on the Bethesda category and eventual malignant histology.

RESULTS

Seventeen thousand seven hundred and seventy-three histology and 4,791 cytology cases were identified. Of the 4,791 cytology cases, 931 (19%) underwent surgery. More than a third (333, 35.8%) of cases were confirmed as malignant following histological assessment, with the majority being benign (584, 62.7%). The ROM for the nondiagnostic and benign categories was 24.3% and 20.5%. The highest ROM was for category VI (91.5%), followed by categories V (69.5%), IV (51.9%), and III (38.8%). Thyroid FNAB had a sensitivity of 73%, specificity of 74%, and overall accuracy of 74%.

CONCLUSION

Bethesda categories II and IV have a relatively higher ROM in SA compared to findings from other developed countries. The diagnostic accuracy of thyroid FNAB in SA and the high rate of nondiagnostic diagnoses (38%) require further investigation. A national thyroid registry could provide location-specific data to aid the implementation of appropriate local policies and national guidelines for practicing thyroid surgeons.

Combined fine needle aspiration cytology and core needle biopsy in the same setting: A two-years' experience

INTRODUCTION

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) combined with rapid on-site evaluation (ROSE) and ancillary techniques is an accurate diagnostic tool for many pathologies. However, in some cases, it may not be sufficient for actionable diagnoses or molecular testing, especially for cases that require large immunohistochemical panels or cases in which histological features are mandatory for the diagnosis. Core needle biopsy (CNB), on the contrary, provides samples that are suitable for histological features and sufficient for all ancillary studies. However, CNB is often performed by radiologists or clinicians without the direct participation of cytopathologists, which can lead to missed or delayed diagnoses. This study reports on the experience of combining FNAC and CNB performed in one setting by cytopathologists. The aim was to evaluate the impact of CNB on FNAC and the diagnostic efficiency of the combined procedures.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred forty-two FNAC and CNB procedures performed in the same setting over a period of 2 years were analysed. The FNAC diagnoses were compared and integrated with the subsequent CNB diagnoses. The impact of CNB was categorized as follows: non-contributory, in cases of inadequate samples; confirmed, when the CNB and FNAC diagnoses were the same; improved, when the CNB diagnosis was consistent with the FNAC diagnosis and further specified the corresponding entity; allowed, when CNB produced a diagnosis that could not be reached by FNAC; changed, when the CNB changed the previous FNAC diagnosis.

RESULTS

CNB confirmed the FNAC diagnosis in 40.1% of cases (n = 57/142). CNB improved the FNAC diagnosis in 47.2% of cases (n = 67/142). CNB allowed a diagnosis that could not be performed on FNAC in 2.1% of cases (n = 3/142). CNB changed a previous FNAC diagnosis in 2.1% of cases (n = 3/142). CNB was non-contributory in 8.4% of cases (n = 12/142). CNB produced a positive impact on the whole diagnostic procedure in 51.4% of total cases (n = 73/142). The combined FNAC and CNB resulted in actionable diagnoses in 91.5% of all cases (n = 130/142). A complete molecular assessment was successfully performed in 14.7% of cases (n = 21/142) utilizing either FNAC or CNB material.

CONCLUSIONS

The combined use of FNAC and CNB in one setting improves the diagnostic accuracy of both procedures. This approach exploits the advantages of each procedure, enhancing the accuracy of the final diagnosis.

The risk of malignancy in the atypia of undetermined significance/follicular lesion of undetermined significance (AUS/FLUS) category subgroups: a Thai institute experience

INTRODUCTION

This study investigated the rate of reporting and the risk of malignancy (ROM) for atypia of undetermined significance (AUS) subgroups in a Thai population. AUS, which is category III of the Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology, is a problematic diagnosis for thyroid nodule management because the risks of malignancy are diverse.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients who underwent thyroid fine needle aspirations between January 2015 and December 2019 were included in this retrospective study. Gender, age, and nodule features were described, and all slides were re-evaluated and categorized into 2 subgroups: AUS-Nuclear (including cytology atypia and cytologic and architectural atypia) and AUS-Other (including architectural atypia, oncocytic atypia, and atypia not otherwise specified). The lower and upper limits of ROM were calculated for each subgroup.

RESULTS

Of total, 258 out of 2995 fine needle aspirations (8.6%) were diagnosed as AUS. The patients were predominantly female (88.9%), with a mean age of 54.1 years. The average nodule size was 2.5 cm. Of the 258 AUS patients, 81 (38.9%) had histological correlations. The ROM for the AUS category was 9.1% to 23.5%. The ROM of the AUS-Nuclear and AUS-Other were 11.1% to 27.3% and 2.2% to 6.7%, respectively. Features of pseudonuclear inclusions had the highest ROM (33.3%-42.9%), followed by pale chromatin (28.57%-47.06%).

CONCLUSIONS

Less than ten percent of our interpretations were AUS, which is acceptable in our practice. Cytological atypia harbored the highest ROM. Studies of associations between cytology and histology may aid in improving diagnostic criteria for this population.

Ultrasound-guided thermal ablation for papillary thyroid microcarcinoma: the devil is in the details

Thermal ablation (TA) has harvested favorable outcomes in treating low-risk papillary thyroid microcarcinoma (PTMC). Preoperative assessment, intraoperative procedures and postoperative follow-up are all closely linked with the success and safety of TA on PTMC. However, many details in these aspects have not been systematically reviewed. This review firstly described the influence of preoperative assessment, especially for the risk of lymph node metastasis (LNM), as well as the molecular testing on the selection of TA for PTMC. Besides, we also summarized the experiences in treating special PTMC cases by TA, like multifocal lesions, PTMC located in the isthmus or adjacent to the dorsal capsule. At last, we discussed the follow-up strategies, the influence of the thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) level on the prognosis of PTMCs, and the management for recurrent cases. In conclusion, the procedures during the entire perioperative period should be standardized to improve the outcomes of TA in treating PTMC patients.