Manipulating the fragmentation patterns of phosphopeptides via gas-phase boron derivatization: determining phosphorylation sites in peptides with multiple serines

Integration of a Multichannel Pulsed-Valve Inlet System to a Linear Quadrupole Ion Trap Mass Spectrometer for the Rapid Consecutive Introduction of Nine Reagents for Diagnostic Ion/Molecule Reactions

Gas-phase ion/molecule reactions have been used extensively for the structural elucidation of organic compounds in tandem mass spectrometry. Reagents for ion/molecule reactions can be introduced into a mass spectrometer via a continuous flow apparatus or through a pulsed inlet system. However, most of these approaches enable the use of only a single reagent at a time. In this work, a multichannel pulsed-valve inlet system was developed for the rapid consecutive introduction of up to nine different reagents or reagent systems into a linear quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer for diagnostic gas-phase ion/molecule reactions. Automated triggering of the pulsed valves enabled these experiments to be performed on the high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) time scale. This enables high-throughput screening of several functionalities in analytes as they elute from an HPLC column.

A Modified Traveling Wave Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometer as a Versatile Platform for Gas-Phase Ion-Molecule Reactions

Taken individually, chemical labeling and mass spectrometry are two well-established tools for the structural characterization of biomolecular complexes. A way to combine their respective advantages is to perform gas-phase ion-molecule reactions (IMRs) inside the mass spectrometer. This is, however, not so well developed because of the limited range of usable chemicals and the lack of commercially available IMR devices. Here, we modified a traveling wave ion mobility mass spectrometer to enable IMRs in the trapping region of the instrument. Only one minor hardware modification is needed to allow vapors of a variety of liquid reagents to be leaked into the trap traveling wave ion guide of the instrument. A diverse set of IMRs can then readily be performed without any loss in instrument performance. We demonstrate the advantages of implementing IMR capabilities in general, and to this quadrupole-ion mobility-time-of-flight (Q-IM-TOF) mass spectrometer in particular, by exploiting the full functionality of the instrument, including mass selection, ion mobility separation, and post-mobility fragmentation. The potential to carry out gas-phase IMR kinetics experiments is also illustrated. We demonstrate the versatility of the setup using gas-phase IMRs of established utility for biological mass spectrometry, including hydrogen-deuterium exchange, ion-molecule proton transfer reactions, and covalent modification of DNA anions using trimethylsilyl chloride.

Design of a TW-SLIM Module for Dual Polarity Confinement, Transport, and Reactions

Here we describe instrumental approaches for performing dual polarity ion confinement, transport, ion mobility separations, and reactions in structures for lossless ion manipulations (SLIM). Previous means of ion confinement in SLIM, based upon rf-generated pseudopotentials and DC fields for lateral confinement, cannot trap ions of opposite polarity simultaneously. Here we explore alternative approaches to provide simultaneous lateral confinement of both ion polarities. Traveling wave ion mobility (IM) separations experienced in such SLIM cause ions of both polarities to migrate in the same directions and exhibit similar separations. The ion motion (and relative motion of the two polarities) under both surfing and IM separation conditions are discussed. In surfing conditions the two polarities are transported losslessly and non-reactively in their respective potential minima (higher absolute voltage regions confine negative polarities, and lower absolute potential regions are populated by positive polarities). In separation mode, where ions roll over an overtaking traveling wave, the two polarities can interact during the rollovers. Strategies to minimize overlap of the two ion populations to prevent reactive losses during separations are presented. A theoretical treatment of the time scales over which two populations (injected into a DC field-free region of the dual polarity SLIM device) interact is considered, and SLIM designs for allowing ion/ion interactions and other manipulations with dual polarities at 4 Torr are presented. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Modulation of Phosphopeptide Fragmentation via Dual Spray Ion/Ion Reactions Using a Sulfonate-Incorporating Reagent

The labile nature of phosphoryl groups has presented a long-standing challenge for the characterization of protein phosphorylation via conventional mass spectrometry-based bottom-up proteomics methods. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) causes preferential cleavage of the phospho-ester bond of peptides, particularly under conditions of low proton mobility, and results in the suppression of sequence-informative fragmentation that often prohibits phosphosite determination. In the present study, the fragmentation patterns of phosphopeptides are improved through ion/ion-mediated peptide derivatization with 4-formyl-1,3-benezenedisulfonic acid (FBDSA) anions using a dual spray reactor. This approach exploits the strong electrostatic interactions between the sulfonate moieties of FBDSA and basic sites to facilitate gas-phase bioconjugation and to reduce charge sequestration and increase the yield of phosphate-retaining sequence ions upon CID. Moreover, comparative CID fragmentation analysis between unmodified phosphopeptides and those modified online with FBDSA or in solution via carbamylation and 4-sulfophenyl isothiocyanate (SPITC) provided evidence for sulfonate interference with charge-directed mechanisms that result in preferential phosphate elimination. Our results indicate the prominence of charge-directed neighboring group participation reactions involved in phosphate neutral loss, and the implementation of ion/ion reactions in a dual spray reactor setup provides a means to disrupt the interactions by competing hydrogen-bonding interactions between sulfonate groups and the side chains of basic residues.

Large-Scale Examination of Factors Influencing Phosphopeptide Neutral Loss during Collision Induced Dissociation

Collision-induced dissociation (CID) remains the predominant mass spectrometry-based method for identifying phosphorylation sites in complex mixtures. Unfortunately, the gas-phase reactivity of phosphoester bonds results in MS/MS spectra dominated by phosphoric acid (H3PO4) neutral loss events, suppressing informative peptide backbone cleavages. To understand the major drivers of H3PO4 neutral loss, we performed robust nonparametric statistical analysis of local and distal sequence effects on the magnitude and variability of neutral loss, using a collection of over 35,000 unique phosphopeptide MS/MS spectra. In contrast to peptide amide dissociation pathways, which are strongly influenced by adjacent amino acid side chains, we find that neutral loss of H3PO4 is affected by both proximal and distal sites, most notably basic residues and the peptide N-terminal primary amine. Previous studies have suggested that protonated basic residues catalyze neutral loss through direct interactions with the phosphate. In contrast, we find that nearby basic groups decrease neutral loss regardless of mobility class, an effect only seen by stratifying spectra by charge-mobility. The most inhibitory bases are those immediately N-terminal to the phosphate, presumably because of steric hindrances in catalyzing neutral loss. Further evidence of steric effects is shown by the presence of proline, which can dramatically reduce the presence of neutral loss when between the phosphate and a possible charge donor. In mobile proton spectra, the N-terminus is the strongest predictor of high neutral loss, with proximity to the N-terminus essential for peptides to exhibit the highest levels of neutral loss.

Probing the exposure of the phosphate group in modified amino acids and peptides by ion-molecule reactions with triethoxyborane in Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry

RATIONALE

Intramolecular hydrogen bonds between a phosphate group and charged residues play a crucial role in the chemistry of phosphorylated peptides, driving the species to specific conformations and affecting the exposure of the phosphate moiety. The nature and extent of these interactions can be investigated by measuring the reactivity of phosphate groups toward selected substrates in the gas phase.

METHODS

We used Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry (MS) to perform a systematic study on the gas-phase ionic reactivity of phosphorylated amino acids and peptides with triethoxyborane (TEB). Ions of interest were generated by electrospray ionization (ESI), isolated in the cell of the FT-ICR mass spectrometer, and allowed to react with a stationary pressure of TEB. The temporal evolution of the reaction was monitored and thermal rate constants were derived. The structure of the ionic products was confirmed by Collision-Induced Dissociation (CID) tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS).

RESULTS

TEB was found to react with the phosphate of protonated phosphorylated amino acids and peptides by an addition-elimination pathway. The kinetic efficiency of the reaction showed a positive correlation with the charge state of the reagent ion, suggesting the existence of charge-state-dependent exposure of the phosphate groups towards the incoming neutral during the reaction. Isomeric phosphorylated peptides, only differing for the position of the modified serine residue, showed markedly different kinetic efficiencies.

CONCLUSIONS

The ability of a phosphorylated species to react with TEB depends on the ease of access to the phosphate moiety in the corresponding gaseous ion. Measuring the kinetic efficiency of such reactions can represent a valuable tool to explore the accessibility of phosphate groups in biomolecules.

Unblocking the sink: improved CID-based analysis of phosphorylated peptides by enzymatic removal of the basic C-terminal residue

A one-step enzymatic reaction for improving the collision-induced dissociation (CID)-based tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analysis of phosphorylated peptides in an ion trap is presented. Carboxypeptidase-B (CBP-B) was used to selectively remove C-terminal arginine or lysine residues from phosphorylated tryptic/Lys-C peptides prior to their MS/MS analysis by CID with a Paul-type ion trap. Removal of this basic C-terminal residue served to limit the extent of gas-phase neutral loss of phosphoric acid (H3PO4), favoring the formation of diagnostic b and y ions as determined by an increase in both the number and relative intensities of the sequence-specific product ions. Such differential fragmentation is particularly valuable when the H3PO4 elimination is so predominant that localizing the phosphorylation site on the peptide sequence is hindered. Improvement in the quality of tandem mass spectral data generated by CID upon CBP-B treatment resulted in greater confidence both in assignment of the phosphopeptide primary sequence and for pinpointing the site of phosphorylation. Higher Mascot ion scores were also generated, combined with lower expectation values and higher delta scores for improved confidence in site assignment; Ascore values also improved. These results are rationalized in accordance with the accepted mechanisms for the elimination of H3PO4 upon low energy CID and insights into the factors dictating the observed dissociation pathways are presented. We anticipate this approach will be of utility in the MS analysis of phosphorylated peptides, especially when alternative electron-driven fragmentation techniques are not available.

Utilisation of gas-phase ion-molecule reactions for differentiation between phospho- and sulfocarbohydrates

Gas-phase ion-molecule reactions of four boron-containing neutrals were explored as a means for differentiation between isobaric phospho- and sulfocarbohydrates. Phosphorylation and sulfation impose an addition of 80 Da to the molecular mass, so for low-resolution mass spectrometers compounds that have such modifications will appear at the same nominal mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio. However, the ions of these isobaric species behave differently in ion-molecule reactions. All four evaluated neutral molecules [trimethyl borate (TMB), triethyl borate (TEB), diethylmethoxyborane (DEMB) and diisopropoxymethylborane (DIPMB)] proved to be reactive towards phosphorylated sugars and unreactive towards sulfated carbohydrates. In addition, TMB and TEB were found suitable for distinguishing positional isomers of phosphorylated carbohydrates, while reactions with DEMB and DIPMB were successful in differentiating phosphorylated, sulfated and unmodified deprotonated sugars. Similar reactions in the positive ion mode (alkali cationised) were found to be less conclusive.

Evaluation of various silicon-and boron-containing compounds for the detection of phosphorylation in peptides via gas-phase ion-molecule reactions

Gas-phase ion-molecule reactions [IMR] of various boron- and silicon-containing neutrals were investigated as a potential route for detecting phosphorylation within peptides in the negative ion mode. Trimethyl borate (TMB), triethyl borate (TEB) and N,O- Bis(trimethylsilyl)acetamide (TMSA), unlike diethylmethoxyborane (DEMB), diisopropoxymethylborane [DiPMB] and chlorotrimethylsi- Lane (TMSCIL], reacted differently if a phosphate moiety was present and thus are suitable to detect phosphorylation. During multistage collision-induced dissociation experiments of the reaction products of IMR with TMB and TEB, the [LSsF - 4H + B]- ion formed a modified y2 fragment allowing the phosphorylation site to be assigned, unlike reaction products of DEMB and DiPMB which lost both the phos- phoric acid and the boron-containing moiety.

Borononucleotides as substrates/binders for human NMP kinases: enzymatic and spectroscopic evaluation

Borononucleotides are a family of natural nucleotide monophosphate analogues with a 5'-boronic acid function. As B-O-P linkages are known to be unstable in solution, we evaluated the ability of borononucleotides to be recognized by nucleoside monophosphate kinases and eventually foil the phosphorylation process. In this context, and with the idea of probing the influence of their size, shape, and flexibility, a library of borononucleotides were synthetized starting from the borononucleotide analogue of thymidine, which was shown to behave as a slow substrate of human TMP kinase. This study thus constitutes a good starting point for the development of new monophosphate mimics as potential substrates or ligands for NMP kinases.

Modelling of the gas-phase phosphate group loss and rearrangement in phosphorylated peptides

The gas-phase dissociation of phosphorylated peptides was modelled using a combination of quantum mechanics and the Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus theory. Potential energy surfaces and unimolecular reaction rates for several low-energy fragmentation and rearrangement pathways were estimated, and a general mechanism was proposed. The neutral loss of the phosphoric acid was mainly an outcome of the intramolecular nucleophilic substitution mechanism. The mechanism involves a nucleophilic attack of the phosphorylated amino acid N-terminal carbonyl oxygen on β-carbon, yielding a cyclic five-membered oxazoline product ion. Regardless of the proton mobility, the pathway was charge directed either by a mobile proton or by a positively charged side chain of some basic residue. Although the mechanistic aspects of the phosphate loss are not influenced by the proton mobility environment, it does affect ion abundances. Results suggest that under the mobile proton environment, the interplay between phosphoric acid neutral loss product ion and backbone cleavage fragments should occur. On the other hand, when proton mobility is limited, neutral loss product ion may predominate. The fragmentation dynamics of phosphoserine versus phosphothreonine containing peptides suggests that H(3)PO(4) neutral loss from phosphothreonine containing peptides is less abundant than that from their phosphoserine containing analogs. During the low-energy CID of phosphorylated peptides in the millisecond time range, typical for ion trap instruments, a phosphate group rearrangement may happen, resulting in an interchange between the phosphorylated and the hydroxylated residues. Unimolecular dissociation rate constants imply the low abundance of such scrambled product ions.

Tandem mass spectrometry strategies for phosphoproteome analysis

Protein phosphorylation is involved in nearly all essential biochemical pathways and the deregulation of phosphorylation events has been associated with the onset of numerous diseases. A multitude of tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) and multistage MS/MS (i.e., MS(n) ) strategies have been developed in recent years and have been applied toward comprehensive phosphoproteomic analysis, based on the interrogation of proteolytically derived phosphopeptides. However, the utility of each of these MS/MS and MS(n) approaches for phosphopeptide identification and characterization, including phosphorylation site localization, is critically dependant on the properties of the precursor ion (e.g., polarity and charge state), the specific ion activation method that is employed, and the underlying gas-phase ion chemistries, mechanisms and other factors that influence the gas-phase fragmentation behavior of phosphopeptide ions. This review therefore provides an overview of recent studies aimed at developing an improved understanding of these issues, and highlights the advantages and limitations of both established (e.g., CID) and newly maturing (e.g., ECD, ETD, photodissociation, etc.) yet complementary, ion activation techniques. This understanding is expected to facilitate the continued refinement of existing MS/MS strategies, and the development of novel MS/MS techniques for phosphopeptide analysis, with great promise in providing new insights into the role of protein phosphorylation on normal biological function, and in the onset and progression of disease. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc., Mass Spec Rev 30:600-625, 2011.

Mapping N-terminus phosphorylation sites and quantitation by stable isotope dimethyl labeling

We have previously coupled stable isotope dimethyl labeling with IMAC enrichment for quantifying the extent of protein phosphorylation in vivo. The enhanced a(1) signal of dimethylated peptides served as a unique mass tag for unequivocal identification of the N-terminal amino acids. In this study, we demonstrate that the a(1) ion could further assist in mapping the precise phosphorylation site near the N-terminal region and allow the determination of the exact site and level of phosphorylation in one step by stable isotope dimethyl labeling. We show that the a(1) ion signal was suppressed for dimethylated peptides with a phosphorylation site at the N-terminus Ser/Thr residue (N-p*Ser/Thr) but was still enhanced for N-terminus Tyr residue (N-p*Tyr) or internal Ser/Thr residues (-p*Ser/Thr). Based on the dominant de-phosphorylated molecular ions and b-H(3)PO(4) ions for N-p*Ser/Thr, we propose that dimethyl labeling increases the basicity of the N-terminus and accelerates the de-phosphorylation for N-p*Ser/Thr precursors, which, however, suppresses the a(1) ion enhancement due to the resulting unsaturated covalent bond on C(alpha) of the N-terminus amino acid. Using this method, we excluded three Ser/Thr phosphorylation sites in A431 cells, two of which, however, were previously reported to be phosphorylation sites; we confirmed three known phosphorylation sites in A431 cells and quantified their ratios upon EGF treatment. Notably, we identified a novel phosphorylation site on Ser43 residue at N-terminus of the tryptic peptide derived from SVH protein in pregnant rat uteri. SVH protein has not been reported or implied with any phosphorylation event, and our data show that the Ser43 of SVH is an intrinsic phosphorylation site in pregnant rat uteri and that its phosphorylation level was slightly decreased upon c-AMP treatment.

Speeding up tandem mass spectrometry based database searching by peptide and spectrum indexing

Database searching is the technique of choice for shotgun proteomics, and to date much research effort has been spent on improving its effectiveness. However, database searching faces a serious challenge of efficiency, considering the large numbers of mass spectra and the ever fast increase in peptide databases resulting from genome translations, enzymatic digestions, and post-translational modifications. In this study, we conducted systematic research on speeding up database search engines for protein identification and illustrate the key points with the specific design of the pFind 2.1 search engine as a running example. Firstly, by constructing peptide indexes, pFind achieves a speedup of two to three compared with that without peptide indexes. Secondly, by constructing indexes for observed precursor and fragment ions, pFind achieves another speedup of two. As a result, pFind compares very favorably with predominant search engines such as Mascot, SEQUEST and X!Tandem.

Atmospheric pressure thermal dissociation of phospho- and sulfopeptides

Several phospho- and sulfopeptides were subjected to atmospheric pressure thermal dissociation (APTD), which was effected by passing peptide ions generated by electrosonic spray ionization (ESSI) through a heated coiled metal tube. Sequence informative fragment ions including a-, b-, c-, and y-types of ions were observed with increased relative intensities under APTD compared with collision-induced dissociation (CID), performed inside the ion trap. A certain degree of preservation of phosphate and sulfate ester moieties was observed for some fragments ions under APTD. The neutral fragments generated outside the mass spectrometer were further analyzed via on-line corona discharge to provide rich and complementary sequence information to that provided by the fragment ions directly obtained from APTD, although complete losses of the modification groups were noted. Improved primary sequence information for phospho- and sulfopeptides was typically obtained by analyzing both ionic and neutral fragments from APTD compared with fragment ions from CID alone. Localization of the modification sites of phospho- and sulfopeptides was achieved by combining the structural information acquired from APTD and CID.

Coupling of ion-molecule reactions with liquid chromatography on a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer

We report for the first time a coupling of gas-phase ion-molecule reactions with chromatographic separations on a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. The interface was accomplished by using a pulsed valve for the introduction of a volatile neutral into the ion trap. The pulsed valve controller is synchronized with the mass spectrometer software. The setup requires some minor modifications to the vacuum system of the commercial quadrupole ion trap but most of the modifications are external to the mass spectrometer. Two applications of this interface are described: differentiation between two phosphoglucose positional isomers and detection of a phosphopeptide in a peptide mixture. Both applications are using the reactivity of trimethoxyborate towards a phosphate moiety in the negative ion mode. The detection of phosphopeptides hinges on our findings that non-phosphorylated peptide anions do not react with trimethoxyborate. This LC/MS detection can be easily visualized in terms of selected reaction monitoring.

Analytical methodologies for the detection and structural characterization of phosphorylated proteins

Phosphorylation of proteins is a frequent post-translational modification affecting a great number of fundamental cellular functions in living organisms. Because of its key role in many biological processes, much effort has been spent over the time on the development of analytical methodologies for characterizing phosphoproteins. In the past decade, mass spectrometry-based techniques have emerged as a viable alternative to more traditional methods of phosphorylation analysis, providing accurate information for a purified protein on the number of the occurring phosphate groups and their exact localization on the polypeptide sequence. This review summarizes the analytical methodologies currently available for the analysis of protein phosphorylation, emphasizing novel mass spectrometry (MS) technologies and dedicated biochemical procedures that have been recently introduced in this field. A formidable armamentarium is now available for selective enrichment, exaustive structural characterization and quantitative determination of the modification degree for phosphopeptides/phosphoproteins. These methodologies are now successfully applied to the global analysis of cellular proteome repertoire according a holistic approach, allowing the quantitative study of phosphoproteomes on a dynamic time-course basis. The enormous complexity of the protein phosphorylation pattern inside the cell and its dynamic modification will grant important challenges to future scientists, contributing significantly to deeper insights into cellular processes and cell regulation.