When Argonaute takes out the ribonuclease sword

A tribute to Sidney Altman, one of the architects of modern RNA biology

This special issue of JBC pays tribute to Sidney Altman, whose discovery of a catalytic role for RNA, a breakthrough made independently by Thomas Cech, overturned the long-held dogma that only proteins can serve as catalysts in biological systems. The discovery of RNA catalysis galvanized biologists to think expansively in new directions and has given rise to a remarkable RNAissance in science and medicine. The collection of articles begins with the story of the discovery of RNase P and builds up to the emerging picture of an unexpectedly vast repertoire of RNase P variants in the three domains of life, including insights derived from recent high-resolution structures on how RNAs, ribonucleoproteins, or protein scaffolds can be used variably to generate an active site for catalyzing the same RNA processing reaction. The series of articles ends with a discussion of more recently discovered endonucleases (Argonautes, Cas), whose parallels with RNase P underscore recurring themes in diverse biological contexts.

Defining the contribution of microRNA-specific Argonautes with slicer capability in animals

microRNAs regulate gene expression through interaction with an Argonaute protein. While some members of this protein family retain an enzymatic activity capable of cleaving RNA molecules complementary to Argonaute-bound small RNAs, the role of the slicer residues in the canonical microRNA pathway is still unclear in animals. To address this, we created Caenorhabditis elegans strains with mutated slicer residues in the endogenous ALG-1 and ALG-2, the only two slicing Argonautes essential for the miRNA pathway in this animal model. We observe that the mutation in ALG-1 and ALG-2 catalytic residues affects overall animal fitness and causes phenotypes reminiscent of miRNA defects only when grown and maintained at restrictive temperature. Furthermore, the analysis of global miRNA expression shows that the slicer residues of ALG-1 and ALG-2 contribute differentially to regulate the level of specific subsets of miRNAs in young adults. We also demonstrate that altering the catalytic tetrad of those miRNA-specific Argonautes does not result in any defect in the production of canonical miRNAs. Together, these data support that the slicer residues of miRNA-specific Argonautes contribute to maintaining levels of a set of miRNAs for optimal viability and fitness in animals particularly exposed to specific growing conditions.

Catalytic residues of microRNA Argonautes play a modest role in microRNA star strand destabilization in C. elegans

Many microRNA (miRNA)-guided Argonaute proteins can cleave RNA ('slicing'), even though miRNA-mediated target repression is generally cleavage-independent. Here we use Caenorhabditis elegans to examine the role of catalytic residues of miRNA Argonautes in organismal development. In contrast to previous work, mutations in presumed catalytic residues did not interfere with development when introduced by CRISPR. We find that unwinding and decay of miRNA star strands is weakly defective in the catalytic residue mutants, with the largest effect observed in embryos. Argonaute-Like Gene 2 (ALG-2) is more dependent on catalytic residues for unwinding than ALG-1. The miRNAs that displayed the greatest (albeit minor) dependence on catalytic residues for unwinding tend to form stable duplexes with their star strand, and in some cases, lowering duplex stability alleviates dependence on catalytic residues. While a few miRNA guide strands are reduced in the mutant background, the basis of this is unclear since changes were not dependent on EBAX-1, an effector of Target-Directed miRNA Degradation (TDMD). Overall, this work defines a role for the catalytic residues of miRNA Argonautes in star strand decay; future work should examine whether this role contributes to the selection pressure to conserve catalytic activity of miRNA Argonautes across the metazoan phylogeny.