Balance and recovery on coronally-uneven and unpredictable terrain

Motion Analysis of a Frontal Plane Adaptable Prosthetic Foot

Introduction

An objective of designing a prosthetic foot is to achieve the natural adaptability of the foot and ankle on various surfaces and different forms of gait. Frontal plane position of the foot relative to the shank changes with many functional aspects of gait, such as turning, stairs, and walking on uneven ground. Prosthetic foot designs have variable frontal plane adaptability. An investigation foot with a linkage with ±10° of frontal plane motion was developed to improve frontal plane response under various conditions. The purpose of this study was to compare the kinematics of locked and unlocked conditions of a frontal plane adaptable prosthetic foot and the person’s usual foot while walking forward on a level surface, on an unstable rock surface, and sidestep, using a crossover design. These different conditions result in changes in frontal plane motion in the anatomical foot and ankle, and the current study evaluates whether there are similar trends in prosthetic feet.

Materials and Methods

People were included if they had a unilateral below-knee amputation, intact residual limb skin, were over 16 years old, and were able to walk more than 400 m on level ground without using a walking aid and without an increase in pain. The control group was people without amputations who completed the procedures once. Participants with amputations completed forward walking on level ground, on an unstable rock surface, and sidestep with their usual foot. Then after 2 weeks of accommodation, participants repeated these tests with the investigational foot unlocked and locked. Motion analysis data were collected with a 12-camera optically based system. Primary outcomes were sagittal and frontal plane motions of the foot relative to the shank. In addition, step length, step width, and stride velocity were obtained from the kinematic measures. Paired t-tests were used for statistical inference for individual participant comparisons. Unpaired t-tests were used for comparisons between the controls and people with amputations.

Results

Twenty-one people with amputations and 10 controls completed the tests. Participants with amputation had 16 different usual feet. There was a wide variation in usual foot motion during forward walking, whereas investigational foot conditions showed less variability. During level walking, control subjects had more frontal plane motion than any of the foot conditions, and the unlocked had more frontal plane motion than the usual foot and locked condition. Walking across an unstable rock surface showed similar trends, with control participants having more sagittal and frontal plane ankle motion compared with any prosthetic foot condition. Also, the unlocked had statistically greater frontal plane motion than the usual foot or locked condition. Sidestep results were also consistent with other gait tests. The control participants’ sagittal plane ankle range of motion was significantly more than the prosthetic sagittal plane motion for all foot conditions, whether the prosthetic side was leading or trailing. There was significantly more frontal plane motion with the unlocked than the usual foot and locked condition when the prosthetic foot was trailing or leading.

Discussion and Conclusions

Wide variation in usual foot range of motions in the frontal and sagittal planes confirmed the need for additional controls when considering the effect of the linkage alone. The unlocked had increased frontal plane ranges of motion compared with the locked and the majority of usual foot for all gait conditions, including level walking. This finding demonstrated that people with amputations were functionally using the additional range of motion provided by the linkage. However, control subjects used more range of motion in both the sagittal and frontal planes for the unstable rock surface and sidestepping. Increased frontal plane range of motion did not translate into improved stride length and velocity, step width, or center of mass deviations.

Clinical Relevance

The person-specific functional activities should be considered when choosing a prosthetic foot. A prosthesis with frontal plane motion may be applicable for a person who moves in a sidestep pattern or on uneven ground.

Reframing Whole-Body Angular Momentum: Exploring the Impact of Low-Pass Filtered Dynamic Local Reference Frames During Straight-Line and Turning Gaits

Accurately estimating whole-body angular momentum (WBAM) during daily activities may benefit from choosing a locally-defined reference frame aligned with anatomical axes, particularly during activities involving body turns. Local reference frames, potentially defined by pelvis heading angles, horizontal center of mass velocity (vCoM), or average angular velocity ( Aω ), can be utilized. To minimize the impact of inherent mediolateral oscillations of these frames, such as those caused by pelvis or vCoM rotation in the transverse plane, a low-pass filter is recommended. This study investigates how differences among global, local reference frames pre- and post-filtering affect WBAM component distribution across anatomical axes during straight-line walking and various turning tasks, which is lacking in the literature. Results highlighted significant effects of reference frame choice on WBAM distribution in the anteroposterior (AP) and mediolateral (ML) axes in all tasks. Specifically, expressing WBAM in the vCoM-oriented local reference frame yielded significantly lower (or higher) WBAM in the AP (or ML) axes compared to pelvis-oriented and Aω -oriented frames. However, these significant differences disappeared after employing a low-pass filter to local reference frames. Therefore, employing low-pass filtered local reference frames is crucial to enhance their applicability in both straight-line and turning tasks, ensuring more precise WBAM estimates. In applications that require expressing anatomical axes-dependent biomechanical parameters in a local reference frame, pelvis- and vCoM-oriented frames are more practical compared to the A ω -oriented frame, as they can be determined by a reduced optical marker set or inertial sensors in future applications when the whole-body kinematics is not available.

Influence of Walking Over Unexpected Uneven Terrain on Joint Loading for Individuals With Transtibial Amputation

Individuals with transtibial amputation (TTA) experience asymmetric lower-limb loading which can lead to joint pain and injuries. However, it is unclear how walking over unexpected uneven terrain affects their loading patterns. This study sought to use modeling and simulation to determine how peak joint contact forces and impulses change for individuals with unilateral TTA during an uneven step and subsequent recovery step and how those patterns compare to able-bodied individuals. We expected residual limb loading during the uneven step and intact limb loading during the recovery step would increase relative to flush walking. Further, individuals with TTA would experience larger loading increases compared to able-bodied individuals. Simulations of individuals with TTA showed during the uneven step, changes in joint loading occurred at all joints except the prosthetic ankle relative to flush walking. During the recovery step, intact limb joint loading increased in early stance relative to flush walking. Simulations of able-bodied individuals showed large increases in ankle joint loading for both surface conditions. Overall, increases in early stance knee joint loading were larger for those with TTA compared to able-bodied individuals during both steps. These results suggest that individuals with TTA experience altered joint loading patterns when stepping on uneven terrain. Future work should investigate whether an adapting ankle-foot prosthesis can mitigate these changes to reduce injury risk.

A Passive Polycentric Mechanism to Improve Active Mediolateral Balance in Prosthetic Walking

Prosthetic legs are typically passive systems without active ankle control, restricting mediolateral balancing to a hip strategy. Resulting balance control impairments for persons with a lower extremity amputation may be mitigated by increasing hip strategy effectiveness, in which relatively small hip moments of force are adequate for mediolateral balancing. To increase hip strategy effectiveness we have developed a prosthetic leg prototype based on the Peaucellier mechanism, the Sideways Balance Mechanism (SBM). This polycentric mechanism adds a frontal plane degree of freedom, reducing mediolateral body displacements. Adding a passive joint alone introduces instability, in which mediolateral body rotation leads to CoM height loss, ultimately resulting in a fall. The SBM however provides stability typically absent by lengthening under rotation, thereby compensating for CoM height loss. By allowing for both foot rotation (in-/eversion), and increased mediolateral ground reaction force the SBM increases hip strategy effectiveness. We aimed to provide proof of principle that the SBM can improve active mediolateral balance control in prosthetic walking by increasing hip strategy effectiveness compared to a typical set-up. Comparison between a typical set-up and the SBM showed an increased mediolateral ground reaction force at equal hip moments of force for a 2D forwards dynamics computer simulation, and a reduced hip moment of force at equal mediolateral ground reaction force for a case study. Results validate increased hip strategy effectiveness of the SBM compared to a typical set-up, providing proof of principle that adding an SBM to a prosthetic set-up improves mediolateral balance control in prosthetic walking.

Biomechanical responses of individuals with transtibial amputation stepping on a coronally uneven and unpredictable surface

Coronally uneven surfaces are prevalent in natural and man-made terrain, such as holes or bumps in the ground, curbs, sidewalks, and driveways. These surfaces can be challenging to navigate, especially for individuals with lower limb amputations. This study examined the biomechanical response of individuals with unilateral transtibial amputation (TTA) taking a step on a coronally uneven surface while wearing their clinically prescribed prosthesis, compared to individuals without mobility impairments (controls). An instrumented walkway was used with the middle force plate positioned either flush or rotated ± 15˚ in the coronal plane and concealed (blinded). TTAs used greater hip abduction compared to controls across all conditions, but especially during blinded inversion. The recovery step width of TTAs was wider after blinded eversion and narrower after blinded inversion, but unchanged for controls. These results suggest TTAs may have decreased balance control on unexpected, uneven surfaces. Additionally, TTAs generated less positive prosthetic ankle joint work during blinded inversion and eversion, and less negative coronal hip joint work during blinded inversion compared to controls. These biomechanical responses could lead to increased energy expenditure on uneven terrain. Surface condition had no effect on the vertical center of mass for either group of participants. Finally, the TTAs and the control group generated similar vertical GRF impulses, suggesting the TTAs had sufficient body support despite differences in surface conditions. These results are important to consider for future prosthetic foot designs and rehabilitation strategies.

The effect of single and multiple split-toe designs on cross-slope adaptability of prosthetic feet: a finite element simulation study

Introduction

During activities of daily living, the foot-to-ground contact orientation changes in the frontal plane. The adaptability of a prosthetic foot in the frontal plane may improve functional mobility, comfort, and safety. Current prosthetic feet may or may not have a longitudinal split in the toe portion of the foot. The single-split (two-toe) prosthetic foot has been recommended for adaptability on uneven ground compared with feet without longitudinal splits. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of single and multiple split-toe cantilever spring designs of prosthetic feet on cross-slopes using finite element simulation.

Materials and Methods

Model construction (material data, geometry, and mesh) and simulations were performed using Ansys LS Dyna. A virtual mass of 75 kg, representing body mass, was fixed to the proximal pylon. Foot variations with one to six toes were created by modifying the base geometry with zero to five splits. Walking surfaces that were either flat or a 15-degree cross-slope was virtually fixed in space. The simulation was started at midstance with the pylon in a vertical position and was continued for 0.2 seconds. An initial velocity of 1 m/s was applied to the proximal mass. Lateral deviation, and vertical displacement and mediolateral contact forces of the simulated body mass were calculated. Von Mises stresses, indicating the potential for material failure, were evaluated.

Results

On level ground, after 0.2-second simulation, feet were comparable in outcomes. On a 15-degree cross-slope, lateral deviation of the body mass decreased with increasing splits from 15.5 mm with no splits to 6.9 mm with the five-split variation. Consistent with this finding, maximal and average forces at the pylon-body mass connection also decreased with increasing splits. Von Mises stress values increased at the proximal toes with increasing splits consistent with narrowing of each toe.

Discussion and Conclusions

The current study showed that the benefit of increasing the number of toes was most significant with the first split and diminishing returns as the number of splits increased beyond three. Adaptability of split-toe variations may have benefits beyond cross-slopes because there are many instances during activities of daily living where the foot-to-ground angle may change. These findings should be tested using other research methods such as biomechanical studies of multiple split-toe prosthetic feet, and if these results are supported, clinical trials may be warranted.

Clinical Relevance

This study supports the use of split-toe prosthetic feet for people who want more frontal plane adaptability during gait or who have lateral pressures at the socket. The study predicts that prosthetic feet with more than one split could provide more adaptability and should be explored for clients.

Muscle Contributions to Balance Control During Amputee and Nonamputee Stair Ascent

Dynamic balance is controlled by lower-limb muscles and is more difficult to maintain during stair ascent compared to level walking. As a result, individuals with lower-limb amputations often have difficulty ascending stairs and are more susceptible to falls. The purpose of this study was to identify the biomechanical mechanisms used by individuals with and without amputation to control dynamic balance during stair ascent. Three-dimensional muscle-actuated forward dynamics simulations of amputee and nonamputee stair ascent were developed and contributions of individual muscles, the passive prosthesis, and gravity to the time rate of change of angular momentum were determined. The prosthesis replicated the role of nonamputee plantarflexors in the sagittal plane by contributing to forward angular momentum. The prosthesis largely replicated the role of nonamputee plantarflexors in the transverse plane but resulted in a greater change of angular momentum. In the frontal plane, the prosthesis and nonamputee plantarflexors contributed oppositely during the first half of stance while during the second half of stance, the prosthesis contributed to a much smaller extent. This resulted in altered contributions from the intact leg plantarflexors, vastii and hamstrings, and the intact and residual leg hip abductors. Therefore, prosthetic devices with altered contributions to frontal-plane angular momentum could improve balance control during amputee stair ascent and minimize necessary muscle compensations. In addition, targeted training could improve the force production magnitude and timing of muscles that regulate angular momentum to improve balance control.

A Comparison of the Conventional PiG Marker Method Versus a Cluster-Based Model when recording Gait Kinematics in Trans-Tibial Prosthesis Users and the Implications for Future IMU Gait Analysis

Validation testing is a necessary step for inertial measurement unit (IMU) motion analysis for research and clinical use. Optical tracking systems utilize marker models which must be precise in measurement and mitigate skin artifacts. Prosthesis wearers present challenges to optical tracking marker model choice. Seven participants were recruited and underwent simultaneous motion capture from two marker sets; Plug in Gait (PiG) and the Strathclyde Cluster Model (SCM). Variability of joint kinematics within and between subjects was evaluated. Variability was higher for PiG than SCM for all parameters. The within-subjects variability as reported by the average standard deviation (SD), was below 5.6° for all rotations of the hip on the prosthesis side for all participants for both methods, with an average of 2.1° for PiG and 2.5° for SCM. Statistically significant differences in joint parameters caused by a change in the protocol were evident in the sagittal plane (p < 0.05) on the amputated side. Trans-tibial gait analysis was best achieved by use of the SCM. The SCM protocol appeared to provide kinematic measurements with a smaller variability than that of the PiG. Validation studies for prosthesis wearer populations must reconsider the marker protocol for gold standard comparisons with IMUs.

Regulation of Linear and Angular Impulse during the Golf Swing with Modified Address Positions

Golf shots off uneven terrain often require modifications in address position to complete the swing successfully. This study aimed to determine how golf players coordinate the legs to regulate linear and angular impulse (about an axis passing vertically through the center of mass) while modifying the lower extremity address position during the swing. Nine highly skilled golf players performed swings with a 6-iron under the Normal, Rear Leg Up and Target Leg Up conditions. Components of linear and angular impulse generated by the rear and target legs (resultant horizontal reaction force, resultant horizontal reaction force angle, and moment arm) were quantified and compared across the group and within a player (α = .05). Net angular impulse did not change between conditions. Target leg angular impulse was greater in the Target Leg Up condition than Rear Leg Up condition. Regulation of linear and angular impulse generation occurred while increasing stance width and redirecting resultant horizontal reaction forces to be more parallel to the target line under modified address positions. Net linear impulse perpendicular to the target was near zero or slightly posterior. Net linear impulse parallel to the target was less toward the target in the Target Leg Up condition compared to Normal and Rear Leg Up conditions. These results indicate individuals utilized player specific mechanisms to coordinate the legs and regulate impulse generation during the golf swing under modified address positions.

Dynamic Balance during Human Movement: Measurement and Control Mechanisms

Walking can be exceedingly complex to analyze due to highly nonlinear multi-body dynamics, nonlinear relationships between muscle excitations and resulting muscle forces, dynamic coupling that allows muscles to accelerate joints and segments they do not span, and redundant muscle control. Walking requires the successful execution of a number of biomechanical functions such as providing body support, forward propulsion and balance control, with specific muscle groups contributing to their execution. Thus, muscle injury or neurological impairment that affects muscle output can alter the successful execution of these functions and impair walking performance. The loss of balance control in particular can result in falls and subsequent injuries that lead to the loss of mobility and functional independence. Thus, it is important to assess the mechanisms used to control balance in clinical populations using reliable methods with the ultimate goal of improving rehabilitation outcomes. In this review, we highlight common clinical and laboratory-based measures used to assess balance control and their potential limitations, show how these measures have been used to analyze balance in several clinical populations, and consider the translation of specific laboratory-based measures from the research laboratory to the clinic.

A Coronally Clutching Ankle to Improve Amputee Balance on Coronally Uneven and Unpredictable Terrain

To improve the balance of individuals with lower limb amputation on coronally uneven terrain, a coronally clutching ankle (CCA) was developed to actively adapt through ±15 deg of free coronal foot rotation during the first ∼60 ms of initial contact. Three individuals with lower limb amputations were fit with the CCA and walked across an instrumented walkway with a middle step that was either flush, 15 deg inverted, or 15 deg everted. An opaque latex membrane was placed over the middle step, making the coronally uneven terrain unpredictable. Compared to participants' clinically prescribed prosthesis, the CCA exhibited significantly more coronal angular adaption during early stance. The CCA also improved participants' center of mass (COM) path regulation during the recovery step (reduced variation in mediolateral position) and reduced the use of the hip and stepping recovery strategies, suggesting it improved participants' balance and enabled a quicker recovery from the disturbance. However, use of the CCA did not significantly affect participants' ability to regulate their coronal angular momentum during the disturbance, suggesting that the CCA did not improve all elements of dynamic balance. Reducing the distance between the CCA's pivot axis and the base of the prosthetic foot might resolve this issue. These findings suggest that actively adapting the coronal plane angle of a prosthetic ankle can improve certain elements of balance for individuals with lower limb amputation who walk on coronally uneven and unpredictable terrain.

Dynamic balance during walking adaptability tasks in individuals post-stroke

Maintaining dynamic balance during community ambulation is a major challenge post-stroke. Community ambulation requires performance of steady-state level walking as well as tasks that require walking adaptability. Prior studies on balance control post-stroke have mainly focused on steady-state walking, but walking adaptability tasks have received little attention. The purpose of this study was to quantify and compare dynamic balance requirements during common walking adaptability tasks post-stroke and in healthy adults and identify differences in underlying mechanisms used for maintaining dynamic balance. Kinematic data were collected from fifteen individuals with post-stroke hemiparesis during steady-state forward and backward walking, obstacle negotiation, and step-up tasks. In addition, data from ten healthy adults provided the basis for comparison. Dynamic balance was quantified using the peak-to-peak range of whole-body angular-momentum in each anatomical plane during the paretic, nonparetic and healthy control single-leg-stance phase of the gait cycle. To understand differences in some of the key underlying mechanisms for maintaining dynamic balance, foot placement and plantarflexor muscle activation were examined. Individuals post-stroke had significant dynamic balance deficits in the frontal plane across most tasks, particularly during the paretic single-leg-stance. Frontal plane balance deficits were associated with wider paretic foot placement, elevated body center-of-mass, and lower soleus activity. Further, the obstacle negotiation task imposed a higher balance requirement, particularly during the trailing leg single-stance. Thus, improving paretic foot placement and ankle plantarflexor activity, particularly during obstacle negotiation, may be important rehabilitation targets to enhance dynamic balance during post-stroke community ambulation.

Identifying classifier input signals to predict a cross-slope during transtibial amputee walking

Advanced prosthetic foot designs often incorporate mechanisms that adapt to terrain changes in real-time to improve mobility. Early identification of terrain (e.g., cross-slopes) is critical to appropriate adaptation. This study suggests that a simple classifier based on linear discriminant analysis can accurately predict a cross-slope encountered (0°, -15°, 15°) using measurements from the residual limb, primarily from the prosthesis itself. The classifier was trained and tested offline using motion capture and in-pylon sensor data collected during walking trials in mid-swing and early stance. Residual limb kinematics, especially measurements from the foot, shank and ankle, successfully predicted the cross-slope terrain with high accuracy (99%). Although accuracy decreased when predictions were made for test data instead of the training data, the accuracy was still relatively high for one input signal set (>89%) and moderate for three others (>71%). This suggests that classifiers can be designed and generalized to be effective for new conditions and/or subjects. While measurements of shank acceleration and angular velocity from only in-pylon sensors were insufficient to accurately predict the cross-slope terrain, the addition of foot and ankle kinematics from motion capture data allowed accurate terrain prediction. Inversion angular velocity and foot vertical velocity were particularly useful. As in-pylon sensor data and shank kinematics from motion capture appeared interchangeable, combining foot and ankle kinematics from prosthesis-mounted sensors with shank kinematics from in-pylon sensors may provide enough information to accurately predict the terrain.

Foot and Ankle Joint Biomechanical Adaptations to an Unpredictable Coronally Uneven Surface

Coronally uneven terrain, a common yet challenging feature encountered in daily ambulation, exposes individuals to an increased risk of falling. The foot-ankle complex may adapt to improve balance on uneven terrains, a recovery strategy which may be more challenging in patients with foot-ankle pathologies. A multisegment foot model (MSFM) was used to study the biomechanical adaptations of the foot and ankle joints during a step on a visually obscured, coronally uneven surface. Kinematic, kinetic and in-shoe pressure data were collected as ten participants walked on an instrumented walkway with a surface randomly positioned ±15 deg or 0 deg in the coronal plane. Coronally uneven surfaces altered hindfoot–tibia loading, with more conformation to the surface in early than late stance. Distinct loading changes occurred for the forefoot–hindfoot joint in early and late stance, despite smaller surface conformations. Hindfoot–tibia power at opposite heel contact (@OHC) was generated and increased on both uneven surfaces, whereas forefoot–hindfoot power was absorbed and remained consistent across surfaces. Push-off work increased for the hindfoot–tibia joint on the everted surface and for the forefoot–hindfoot joint on the inverted surface. Net work across joints was generated for both uneven surfaces, while absorbed on flat terrain. The partial decoupling and joint-specific biomechanical adaptations on uneven surfaces suggest that multi-articulating interventions such as prosthetic devices and arthroplasty may improve ambulation for mobility-impaired individuals on coronally uneven terrain.