Healthcare service utilisation costs attributable to rheumatoid arthritis in France: Analysis of a representative national claims database

Discrepancies in ICD-9/ICD-10-based codes used to identify three common diseases in cancer patients in real-world settings and their implications for disease classification in breast cancer patients and patients without cancer: a literature review and descriptive study

Background

International Classification of Diseases, Ninth/Tenth revisions, clinical modification (ICD-9-CM, ICD-10-CM) are frequently used in the U.S. by health insurers and disease registries, and are often recorded in electronic medical records. Due to their widespread use, ICD-based codes are a valuable source of data for epidemiology studies, but there are challenges related to their accuracy and reliability. This study aims to 1) identify ICD-9/ICD-10-based codes reported in literature/web sources to identify three common diseases in elderly patients with cancer (anemia, hypertension, arthritis), 2) compare codes identified in the literature/web search to SEER-Medicare's 27 CCW Chronic Conditions Algorithm ("gold-standard") to determine their discordance, and 3) determine sensitivity of the literature/web search codes compared to the gold standard.

Methods

A literature search was performed (Embase, Medline) to find sources reporting ICD codes for at least one disease of interest. Articles were screened in two levels (title/abstract; full text). Analysis was performed in SAS Version 9.4.

Results

Of 106 references identified, 29 were included that reported 884 codes (155 anemia, 80 hypertension, 649 arthritis). Overall discordance between the gold standard and literature/web search code list was 32.9% (22.2% for ICD-9; 35.7% for ICD-10). The gold standard contained codes not found in literature/web sources, including codes for hypertensive retinopathy/encephalopathy, Page Kidney, spondylosis/spondylitis, juvenile arthritis, thalassemia, sickle cell disorder, autoimmune anemias, and erythroblastopenia. Among a cohort of non-cancer patients (N=684,376), the gold standard identified an additional 129 patients with anemia, 33,683 with arthritis, and 510 with hypertension compared to the literature/web search. Among a cohort of breast cancer patients (N=303,103), the gold standard identified an additional 59 patients with anemia, 10,993 with arthritis, and 163 with hypertension. Sensitivity of the literature/web search code list was 91.38-99.96% for non-cancer patients, and 93.01-99.96% for breast cancer patients.

Conclusion

Discrepancies in codes used to identify three common diseases resulted in variable differences in disease classification. In all cases, the gold standard captured patients missed using the literature/web search codes. Researchers should use standardized, validated coding algorithms when available to increase consistency in research and reduce risk of misclassification, which can significantly alter the findings of a study.

[Implementation, of multidisciplinary consultations for patients with inflammatory arthritis and treated with subcutaneous biologic DMARDs: Assessment at one year and outlook]

INTRODUCTION

Biologics (bDMARDs) have revolutionized the prognosis of patients with inflammatory arthritis, but are not without serious side effects. The patient must be able to identify them, acquire self-care abilities or skills and adhere to their treatment. Multidisciplinary consultations, including a pharmaceutical consultation could improve the care of these patients. The pharmaceutical presence make it easier to switch to a biosimilar with etended patient support thanks to the community-hospital network. The return on investment is possible thanks to the more frequent use of biosimilars and the pricing of this type of consultation by the "Forfait de Prestation Intermédiaire".

METHODOLOGY

Eligible patients are patients with rheumatoid arthritis or spondyloarthritis, treated with subcutaneous bDMARDs. The criteria assessed were patient's knowledge of their biotherapy using the Biosecure score, their medication adherence using the CQR-5, the total of switch to biosimilars perform and the financial statement of the consultations. An assessment of the actions deployed for the community-hospital network.

RESULTS

Two hundred and ninety-five patients (47.4%) benefited multidisciplinary consultation. The mean score of the Biosecure score was 69.6/100 (moderate knowledge) and 261 patients (88.5%) were highly adherent. 57 patients (73%) accepted the switch to biosimilar. 197 pharmacy were contacted, all of witch for patients who receive the switch. Overall patient's satisfaction was 26.9/28.

CONCLUSION

Multidisciplinary consultations with involvement of the pharmacist should optimized patient care and the management of outpatients treated with bDMARDs. Patients have already expressed their satisfaction with this course of care and the return on investment is positive.

[Algorithms to identify chronic inflammatory rheumatism and psoriasis in medico-administrative databases: A review of the literature]

BACKGROUND

We aimed to describe and discuss the algorithms used to identify chronic inflammatory rheumatisms and psoriasis in medico-administrative databases.

METHODS

We performed a literature review on the Medline database of articles published up to 31 January 2018. Our inclusion criteria were: original articles using medico-administrative databases in accordance with the International Classification of Diseases, version 10 (ICD-10) and concerning rheumatoid arthritis (RA) or ankylosing spondylitis (AS) or psoriatic arthritis (PsoA) or Psoriasis (Pso). Our exclusion criteria were: letters to the editor, commentaries on published articles, studies using codes other than those of the ICD or a previous version.

RESULTS

Out of the 590 articles identified, 37 studies were included. Concerning RA (n=10), all studies used the M05 code, associated with the M06 code in six studies. The remaining four studies specifically targeted codes M06.0, M06.2, M06.3, M06.8, M06.9, and two of them also used code M12.3. For AS (n=8), 7 studies used the M45 code, while only one study used M45.9, M46.1 or M46.8. For Pso (n=17), all studies used the L40 code and/or at least two dispensations of vitamin D. Concerning PsoA (n=13), all studies used the same codes: M07.0, M07.1, M07.2, M07.3.

CONCLUSION

We recommend using codes M05 and M06 rather than M06.1 and M06.4 for RA, M45 for AS, the algorithm L40 and/or two dispensations of topical vitamin D for psoriasis, and codes M070 to M073 to identify PsoA patients in medico-administrative databases.

Health care costs of rheumatoid arthritis: A longitudinal population study

Quantifying the contribution of rheumatoid arthritis to the acquisition of subsequent health care costs is an emerging focus of the rheumatologic community and payers of health care. Our objective was to determine the healthcare costs before and after diagnosis of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) from the public payer's perspective. The study design was a longitudinal observational administrative data-based cohort with RA cases from Ontario Canada (n = 104,933) and two control groups, matched 1:1 on year of cohort entry from 2001 to 2016. The first control group was matched on age, sex and calendar year of cohort entry (diagnosis year for those with RA); the second group added medical history to the match before RA diagnosis year. The main exposure was new onset RA. The secondary exposure was calendar year of RA diagnosis to compare attributable costs over the study observation window. Main outcomes were health care costs in 2015 Canadian dollars, overall and by cost category. We used attribution methods to classify costs into those associated with RA, those associated with comorbidities, and age/sex-related underlying costs. Health care costs associated with RA increased up to the year of diagnosis, where they reached $8,591: $4,142 in RA associated costs; $1,242 in RA comorbidity associated costs; and $3,207 in underlying costs. In the eighth-year post diagnosis, the RA costs declined to $2,567 while the RA comorbidity associated costs remained relatively constant at $1,142, and the underlying age/sex related cost increased to $4,426. RA patients had lower costs when diagnosed in later calendar years. Our results suggest a large proportion of disease related health care costs are a result of costs associated with RA comorbidities, which may appear many years before diagnosis.

Disease course and healthcare costs of a cohort of rheumatoid arthritis patients from Turkey

The objective of the study is to assess the disease course and associated healthcare costs in a cohort of established rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients in Turkey. The study cohort consisted of 75 RA patients from our outpatient clinic who took part in a previous multicenter study assessing RA-related healthcare costs 6 years ago. In March 2018, we attempted to re-evaluate these patients with the same questionnaire of the previous study enabling us to get information on medication use, comorbidities, and RA-related healthcare costs. We used RAPID-3 for assessing disease activity, HAQ-DI for functional status and EQ-5D for quality of life. Sixty-two (83%) patients were re-evaluated, seven (9.3%) had died and three (4%) were receiving palliative care following major cardiovascular events. Forty-seven (76%) patients had used at least one biologic agent during 79.1 ± 3.3 months after the previous study. At the last evaluation, 34 patients (55%) were on biologics, 22 (35%) were on csDMARDs and 6 (9.6%) were off RA treatment. The mean RAPID3 score (4.3 ± 1.6 SD) was similar to that of the previous study. HAQ-DI (0.69 ± 0.57 SD) and EQ-5D (0.68 ± 0.21 SD) scores showed significant improvement over time. Median direct costs (€2998) were higher than indirect costs (€304). Medication costs were high (€2958). Disease activity remained stable, while functional status and QoL had improved over time. Serious infections and cardiovascular disability are a concern. Medication costs are still the main determinant of RA-related healthcare costs.

Cost-utility analysis of de-escalating biological disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

Objective

Recent guideline updates have suggested de-escalating DMARDs when patients with rheumatoid arthritis achieve remission or low disease activity. We aim to evaluate whether it is cost-effective to de-escalate the biological form of DMARDs (bDMARDs).

Methods

Using a Markov model, we performed a cost-utility analysis for RA patients on bDMARD treatment. We compared continuing treatment (standard care) to a tapering approach (i.e., an immediate 50% dose reduction), withdrawal (i.e., an immediate 100% dose reduction) and tapering followed by withdrawal of bDMARDs. The parametrization is based on a comprehensive literature review. Results were computed for 30 years with a cycle length of three months. We applied the payer’s perspective for Germany and conducted deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses.

Results

Tapering or withdrawing bDMARD treatment resulted in ICERs of €526,254 (incr. costs -78,845, incr. QALYs -0.1498) or €216,879 (incr. costs -€121,691, incr. QALYs -0.5611) compared to standard care. Tapering followed by withdrawal resulted in a loss of 0.4354 QALYs and savings of €107,969 per patient, with an ICER of €247,987. Deterministic sensitivity analysis revealed that our results remained largely unaffected by parameter changes. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis suggests that tapering, withdrawal and tapering followed by withdrawal were dominant in 39.8%, 28.2% and 29.0% of 10,000 iterations.

Conclusion

Our findings suggest that de-escalating bDMARDs in patients with RA may result in high cost savings but also a decrease in quality of life compared to standard care. If decision makers choose to implement de-escalation in daily practice, our results suggest the tapering approach.

Burden of severe spondyloarthritis in France: A nationwide assessment of prevalence, associated comorbidities and cost

OBJECTIVES

To estimate the number of patients with severe spondyloarthritis (SpA) in France, describe their comorbidities and document and value their healthcare resource consumption.

METHODS

Data were retrieved from an insurance claims database covering a 1/97 random sample of the French population. All patients benefiting from full insurance coverage ("ALD") for severe SpA in 2012 (including cases with structural damage and/or frequent flares) were identified, together with a control group frequency-matched by age and gender. Severe comorbidities were documented through ALD categories. Healthcare resource consumption was documented and valued from the payer's perspective. Rates of comorbidities and costs were compared in SpA patients versus controls using non-parametric testing.

RESULTS

Overall, 827 patients with ALD status for severe SpA were identified (control group: n=2.481), corresponding to a prevalence rate of 0.18% [0.17-0.19] for SpA with ALD in the general population. Severe comorbidities more frequent in patients with SpA than in controls included inflammatory bowel disorders (odds ratio: 15.0 [6.2-36.2]), hypertension (2.5 [1.6-3.9]), atrial fibrillation (4.3 [1.9-9.6]) and major depressive disorder (2.1 [1.3-3.6]). Mean per capita annual direct healthcare expenditure was 3.6 [3.2-4.1]-fold higher in SpA patients (€6,122 [€5,838-€6,406]) than in controls (€1,682 [€1,566-€1,798]). Extrapolating to all patients in France, total healthcare cost attributable to severe SpA patients was €391 [€355-€426] million, with medication accounting for 53.8% of this cost.

CONCLUSIONS

The burden of severe SpA in France is substantial, due to the high prevalence, high direct costs and associated comorbidities.

Health Data for Public Health: Towards New Ways of Combining Data Sources to Support Research Efforts in Europe

Objectives: To present the European landscape regarding the re-use of health administrative data for research. Methods: We present some collaborative projects and solutions that have been developed by Nordic countries, Italy, Spain, France, Germany, and the UK, to facilitate access to their health data for research purposes. Results: Research in public health is transitioning from siloed systems to more accessible and re-usable data resources. Following the example of the Nordic countries, several European countries aim at facilitating the re-use of their health administrative databases for research purposes. However, the ecosystem is still a complex patchwork, with different rules, policies, and processes for data provision. Conclusion: The challenges are such that with the abundance of health administrative data, only a European, overarching public health research infrastructure, is able to efficiently facilitate access to this data and accelerate research based on these highly valuable resources.

Essential Medicines List Implementation Dynamics: A Case Study Using Brazilian Federal Medicines Expenditures

The aim was to analyse the implementation dynamics of the essential medicines list (EML). We used the government expenditures on medicines and Brazil as a case study. Drug purchases were considered as a proxy for utilization. The essential medicines (EMs) expenditures were followed over time by Brazilian National EMLs life-time and defined by broad therapeutic categories and by specific medicines. Brazil increased the number of the medicines during the last four editions of Brazilian National EMLs and the federal government expenditures on them. The EML implementation dynamics changed the distribution of expenditures on EMs. We identified a common set of 404 EMs present in all four editions of the Brazilian National EMLs. There was a proportional decrease in expenditures on anti-infectives for systemic use, blood and blood-forming organs and alimentary tract and metabolism, and increase in expenditures on antineoplastic and immunomodulating agents. The expenditures distribution per specific medicines revealed that a small set of EMs was responsible for 50% or more of expenditures considering Brazilian National EML life-time for all four periods. The increase in expenditures on EMs in Brazil was a consequence of the newer medicines incorporated over time in the Brazilian National EMLs. The use of the medicines expenditures as a source of data and the definition of an EML life-time permitted follow-up of the implementation dynamics of different versions of the Brazilian National EMLs. Our results have implications for policymakers and stakeholders to gain a better understanding of the role EMLs play in health system sustainability and in the provision of the most beneficial heath care.

Non-medical costs during the first year after diagnosis in two cohorts of patients with early rheumatoid arthritis, enrolled 10 years apart

The aim of the present study was to calculate non-medical costs during year 1 after diagnosis in two cohorts of patients with early rheumatoid arthritis enrolled 1996-1998 and 2006-2009. Clinical data were collected regularly in both cohorts. Besides information about healthcare utilization and days lost from work, patients reported non-medical costs for aids/devices, transportation, formal and informal care. Formal care was valued as full labour cost for official home help (€42.80/h) and informal care from relatives and friends as opportunity cost of leisure time, corresponding to 35% of labour cost (€15/h). In both cohorts, only 2% used formal care, while more than 50% used informal care. Prescription of aids/devices was more frequent in cohort 2 and more women than men needed aids/devices. Help with transportation was also more common in cohort 2. Women in both cohorts needed more informal care than men, especially with personal care and household issues. Adjusting for covariates in regression models, female sex remained associated with higher costs in both cohorts. Non-medical costs in cohort 2 were €1892, €1575 constituting informal care, corresponding to 83% of non-medical costs. Total non-medical costs constituted 25% of total direct costs and 11% of total direct and indirect costs. Informal care accounted for the largest part of non-medical costs and women had higher costs than men. Despite established social welfare system, it is obvious that family and friends, to a large extent, are involved in informal care of patients with early RA, and this may underestimate the total burden of the disease.

Modeling of the clinical and economic impact of a risk-sharing agreement supporting a treat-to-target strategy in the management of patients with rheumatoid arthritis in France

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a Treat-to-Target strategy with certolizumab pegol in patients with rheumatoid arthritis in the context of a pay-for-performance agreement in which medication costs are refunded in case of discontinuation during the first 3 months of treatment.

METHODS

The Treat-to-Target strategy consisted of a systematic switch to second-line tumor necrosis factor (TNF)α inhibitor in case of an unmet ACR50 response at 3 months compared to current routine clinical practice. A reference cohort treated first-line with certolizumab pegol according to current practice without systematic switching was considered as the comparator. A decision-tree model was constructed to estimate clinical outcome (health assessment questionnaire-disability index or HAQ-DI score), time spent in ACR50 response (ACR 50), and direct costs of treatment over a 2-year period. HAQ scores were derived from American College of Rheumatology 50 (ACR50) responses. All TNFα inhibitors were assumed to have equivalent efficacy and tolerability. Costs were estimated at 2013 French retail prices (date of the pay-for-performance agreement).

RESULTS

The mean duration of an ACR50 response was 1.23 years in the Treat-to-Target strategy certolizumab pegol cohort vs 0.98 years in the reference cohort, resulting in a mean gain in HAQ at 24 months of 0.117. The Treat-to-Target strategy with a mix of TNFα inhibitors as second-line therapy was more expensive than the reference strategy in absolute terms, but this difference was entirely offset by the pay-for-performance agreement. The Treat-to-Target strategy was, thus, cost-neutral over a 2-year period after the payback of CZP cost for patients not achieving the target at 3 months.

CONCLUSIONS

In the context of a pay-for-performance agreement, the management of patients with rheumatoid arthritis using a Treat-to-Target strategy with certolizumab pegol in first line is dominant compared to standard use of this drug in the French setting in 2013.