Nutcracker syndrome: A rare cause of left flank pain that can also manifest as unexplained pelvic pain

Treatment of Nutcracker Syndrome with Left Renal Vein Transposition and Endovascular Stenting

BACKGROUND

Nutcracker syndrome is a rare condition that occurs as a result of the entrapment of the left renal vein (LRV) between the aorta and the superior mesenteric artery. It is typically associated with symptoms such as left flank pain, hematuria, proteinuria, and pelvic congestion. The current treatment approach may be conservative in the presence of tolerable symptoms, and surgical or hybrid and stenting procedures in the order of priority in the presence of intolerable symptoms. The aim of this study is to review our experiences to evaluate the results of both methods in this series in which we have a greater tendency toward surgery instead of stenting.

METHODS

The clinical data of consecutive patients with nutcracker syndrome who underwent LRV transposition and LRV stenting between July 2019 and October 2023 were retrospectively reviewed. The patients were divided into 2 groups based on the methods of treatment: surgical and stenting. For procedure selection, LRV transposition was primarily recommended, with stenting offered to those who declined. Primary end points were morbidity and mortality. Secondary end points included late complications, patency, freedom from reintervention, and resolution of symptoms. Standard basic statistics and survival analysis methods were employed.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients with nutcracker syndrome (female: 100%) were treated with LRV stentings (n = 5) and LRV transposition (n = 14). The mean age was 24 (20-27, interquartile range [IQR]) years. The mean follow-up was 23 (9-32, IQR) months. There were no major complications and mortality after both procedures. The most frequent sign and symptom associated with LRV entrapment were left flank pain 100% (n = 19), proteinuria 88% (n = 15), and hematuria 47% (n = 9). The mean peak velocity ratio on Doppler ultrasound was 6.13 (6-6.44, IQR). Aortomesenteric angle, beak angle (beak sign), and mean diameter ratio on computed tomography were 26° (22.6-28.5, IQR), 25° (23.9-28, IQR), and 5.3 (5-6, IQR), respectively. Venous pressure measurements were only used to confirm the diagnosis in 5 patients in the stenting group. The measured renocaval gradient was 4 (3.9-4.4, IQR) mm Hg. After both procedures, the classical symptoms, including left flank pain, proteinuria, and hematuria, resolved in 89.5% (n = 17), 57.8% (n = 11), and 82.3% (n = 15) of the cases, respectively. A total of 4 patients required reintervention, 3 patients after LRV transposition (occlusion, n = 2; stenosis, n = 1), and 1 patient after stenting (occlusion, n = 1). The 1-year and 3-year primary patency for the 19 patients was 87% and 80%, respectively. Three-year primary-assisted patency was 100%. Similarly, the 1-year and 3-year freedom from reintervention rate was 83% and 72%, respectively. Additionally, the 1-year and 3-year primary patency for the surgical group was 91% and 81%, respectively, and the 1-year and 3-year primary patency for the stenting group was 75%.

CONCLUSIONS

Nutcracker syndrome should be kept in mind in cases where flank pain and hematuria cannot be associated with kidney diseases. Radiographic evidence must be accompanied by serious symptoms to initiate the treatment of nutcracker syndrome with LRV transposition and endovascular stenting procedures. Both procedures, along with their respective advantages and disadvantages, can be preferred as primary treatments for nutcracker syndrome. Our study demonstrates that both procedures can be safely and effectively performed, yielding good outcomes.

Anterior Nutcracker syndrome in a young male patient: a case report and review of literature

Introduction and importance

The left renal vein (LRV) is affected by a venous compression syndrome called Nutcracker syndrome (NCS). This syndrome is characterized by extrinsic compression of the LRV, which usually occurs between aorta and superior mesenteric artery. It is a rare and under-diagnosed condition, more prevalent in females and that, if left untreated, can lead to severe problems. There are no clear guidelines regarding management. Therefore, the authors report this rare case and its symptoms in male patient and they display current management options.

Case presentation

NCS was observed during computer tomography in a male patient presented with persistent left flank pain and associated haematuria. Ultrasound for left scrotum demonstrated left moderate-sized varicocele. The left varicocele testis unit was 1.6 mm and during the Valsalva manoeuvre in the supine position the testis unit was 2 mm. LRV compression between abdominal aorta and superior mesenteric artery was identified by computer tomography imaging and therefore, diagnosis of NCS was confirmed.

Clinical discussion

The actual prevalence is unclear, and incidence rates have been observed to fluctuate among age group and more prevalent in women. Main symptoms include haematuria, left flank discomfort, varicocele in men, proteinuria and anaemia. Depending on severity of symptoms, management might range from conservative care to surgery.

Conclusion

This treatment strategy was effective in reducing the symptoms of the patients. In young patients, conservative treatment is advised for a fair amount of time. However, more studies on how much the authors should wait before considering surgery is important.

Nutcracker Phenomenon: A Rare Incidental Finding

The nutcracker phenomenon, or left renal vein (LRV) entrapment syndrome, occurs when there is compression of the LRV, mostly between the abdominal aorta and the superior mesenteric artery. Patients with nutcracker syndrome (NCS) may present with various symptoms, with the most common being hematuria, left flank pain, varicocele in males, proteinuria, and anemia. Our 22-year-old male patient presented with abdominal pain without hematuria. Insidiously, we made the diagnosis of NCS with this unusual presentation. Some studies have proposed a relationship between rapid weight loss in a short period of time and the appearance of NCS. We recommend that healthcare providers suspect NCS in patients who present with abrupt severe abdominal discomfort, particularly in situations that coincide with rapid weight loss for an unknown reason.

Left renal vein entrapment in postural proteinuria: the diagnostic utility of the aortomesenteric angle

Nutcracker syndrome related to the left kidney vein compression is a cause of orthostatic proteinuria during childhood. Some studies have shown that the ratios between maximum velocities and anterior-posterior diameters of hilar and aortomesenteric segments of the left kidney vein between upright and supine positions must be more than 4 in order to make a Nutcracker syndrome diagnosis. Our aim was to investigate whether the use of a decrease in aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions in the presence of isolated orthostatic proteinuria can be a criterion for the diagnosis of Nutcracker syndrome. Relevant patient information, which included demographic data, clinical examination findings, laboratory data, urinary system ultrasound, and kidney color flow Doppler ultrasound results, were prospectively collected. Thirty-nine pediatric patients with orthostatic proteinuria were included in the study. Left kidney vein compression findings were demonstrated in 31 patients. The ratio of maximum velocities of hilar and aortomesenteric segments of the left kidney vein between upright and supine positions was above 4 in only 7 of our patients. Ratio of aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions was significantly decreased for patients with left kidney vein compression findings.  Conclusion: The use of a decrease in the ratio of aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions in the presence of orthostatic proteinuria, instead of the ratios for maximum velocities and anterior-posterior diameters of hilar and aortomesenteric segments, can be more helpful for the diagnosis of Nutcracker syndrome in the differential diagnosis of orthostatic proteinuria. What is Known: • Proteinuria may be a sign of an impending kidney disease • Nutcracker syndrome is a cause of orthostatic proteinuria. What is New: • Ratio of aortomesenteric angle between upright and supine positions > 0.6 can be used for Nutcracker syndrome diagnosis.

Venous congestion as a central mechanism of radiculopathies

Compression of roots/nerves can disrupt some of their functions, but does not necessarily cause pain. This is illustrated by the frequency of nearly asymptomatic spinal stenosis or disc herniations. In fact, pain of radiculopathies (and nerve entrapments) may mostly be the consequence of intraneural oedema induced by microscopical venous stasis around roots/spinal ganglia (or nerves) not or poorly shown by imaging. This narrative review first lists arguments for a role of congestion of vasa-nervorum in the pathophysiology of radiculopathies, including those induced by disc herniation and spinal stenosis, but also other sources of overpressures in spinal venous plexuses (pregnancy, vena cava atresia and thrombosis, portal hypertension, epidural varices, arterio-venous fistula, vertebral hemangioma or hemangioblastoma). It also details sources of venous congestion around nerves outside the spine, from pelvis (May-Thurner syndrome, Nut-cracker syndrome) to buttocks (superior and inferior gluteal veins), and even thighs and legs. A better recognition of a preeminent role of venous congestion in radiculopathies, plexopathies, and nerve entrapments, should have major consequences: (i) discard the dogma that compression is mandatory to induce root/nerve suffering, since root/nerve adherences in two locations can impair blood flow in vasa-nervorum through root/nerve stretching; (ii) implementation of sensitive techniques to visualise impingement of blood flow around or within roots and nerves; (iii) better prevention of roots/nerves adherence, or arachnoiditis induced by extravascular fibrin deposition secondary to venous stasis.; (iv) optimizing treatments dampening clot formation and/or extravascular fibrin leakage in the intradural/peridural spaces, or around roots/nerves, like guided injection of tissue plasminogen activator.

Nutcracker Syndrome: A Single-Center Experience

Nutcracker syndrome, whose prevalence and natural history are still poorly known, is a clinical syndrome caused by left renal vein compression between the superior mesenteric artery and the aorta. Long-term results and treatment outcomes are not well known. Our group aimed to characterize 7 patients diagnosed with nutcracker syndrome in childhood and to describe their clinical manifestations, diagnostic approaches, and mostly their clinical evolution, rate of complications, and treatment outcomes.

RENAL VEIN THROMBOSIS DUE TO POSTERIOR NUTCRACKER SYNDROME

Thrombosis of the left renal vein (LRV) is a rare occurrence usually associated with hypercoagulable disorders. It may also be caused by extrinsic compression due to anatomical variations. Such variations, known as nutcracker phenomenon (NP), are usually completely asymptomatic, and they have been described in three variants: a narrowed aortomesenteric angle (AMA) with entrapment of the LRV; a second, rarer variant with an anomalous retro aortic LRV compressed between the abdominal aorta (AA) and the spine (posterior nutcracker syndrome, PNCS); and a third variant with a duplicated LRV with a pre- and retroaortic course, compressed both anteriorly and posteriorly. The development of symptoms secondary to NP is mainly due to renal congestion, often difficult to identify, and includes flank pain, ipsilateral varicocele, hematuria, and orthostatic proteinuria, among others. The most severe complication of NCS is LRV thrombosis with or without associated predisposing prothrombotic factors. The present case associates a PNCS to LRV thrombosis with a floating thrombus in the inferior vena cava and pulmonary embolism.

A Case of Posterior Nutcracker Syndrome Revealed in the Aerospace Environment

BACKGROUND: Nutcracker syndrome is caused by a rare anatomic variant where the left renal vein is trapped between the aorta and the superior mesenteric artery. Posterior nutcracker syndrome is an even rarer entity, characterized by the retro-aortic positioning of the renal vein, causing compression between the aorta and spinal vertebrae. Symptoms include microscopic or frank hematuria, flank pain, varicocele, pelvic congestion syndrome, and abdominal pain. A search of the literature did not reveal prior cases of nutcracker syndrome that became symptomatic and diagnosed secondary to the unique stressors of high gravitational force (G force) in the aviation environment.CASE REPORT: A 25-yr-old man training as an F-16 flight test engineer presented with left scrotal/testicular pain, varicocele, and intermittent gross hematuria. After an extensive workup, he was diagnosed with posterior nutcracker syndrome and underwent a left varicocele ligation with spermatic cord denervation. He was eventually able to be returned to flying duties with limitation to non-high performance aircraft.DISCUSSION: This case is particularly unique as its diagnosis was dependent on exposure to high G force conditions that may have otherwise remained asymptomatic without this environmental stressor. Education on the diagnosis of nutcracker syndrome as a differential in the setting of hematuria and pain is an important lesson learned. This case also illustrates the necessity of considering the effects of the stressful environment of high G force on even overall healthy individuals. Fortunately, due to the collaboration of medical-surgical expertise and familiarity with the requirements for operational readiness, this patient was able to resume his aviation career, albeit in a different capacity compatible with his condition.Chung CY, Lytle ME, Clemente Fuentes RW. A case of posterior nutcracker syndrome revealed in the aerospace environment. Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2021; 92(1):5456.

Left Renal Vein Stenting in Nutcracker Syndrome: Outcomes and Implications

Nutcracker syndrome refers to the symptomatic extrinsic compression of the left renal vein presenting most commonly as flank pain and haematuria. While surgery remains the first-line treatment, stenting is gaining more acceptance and there are now several published case series. This article highlights the outcomes of left renal vein stenting in the setting of nutcracker syndrome.

3D-Printed PEEK Extravascular Stent in the Treatment of Nutcracker Syndrome: Imaging Evaluation and Short-Term Clinical Outcome

Minimally invasive options are safe and reliable alternatives for the treatment of nutcracker syndrome (NCS). After continued efforts, our team successfully devised a new and effective therapeutic method: 3D-printed extravascular stenting of the left renal vein. From December 2017 to May 2019, 28 patients (25 men and 3 women) from different parts of China between 18 and 37 years old (mean, 23.6 years) diagnosed with NCS were admitted for laparoscopic 3D-printed extravascular stenting treatment. The post-operative follow-up duration was 6-24 months (median, 16.3 months). Technical success of the operation was achieved in all patients. After treatment, the NCS symptoms all patients resolved or improved during the follow-up period, without relapse. Most symptoms, including macro-/microhematuria, proteinuria, and flank/abdominal pain, tended to resolve within 3-6 months after the surgery; other symptoms, such as left-sided varicocele, also showed varying degrees of improvement at different times post-operatively. Perioperative complications were noted in two patients, including transient and mild lymphatic leakage, without any adverse effects. All extravascular stents were visualized on computed tomography and Doppler ultrasound scans, and no migration or any side effects occurred during the entire follow-up period. Compared to endovascular stenting or polytetrafluoroethylene artificial vessel procedures, 3D-printed polyetheretherketone extravascular stenting has more advantages in terms of stent design and rigidity and approach rationality while successfully preventing stent migration and thrombosis. Therefore, this method may serve as an accurate and effective treatment for NCS patients.

Nutcracker Syndrome-An Unusual Case of Chronic Left Upper Abdominal Pain: A Case Report

A 38-year-old woman presented with a chief complaint of sharp, achy left upper abdominal pain with radiation to the left flank. This pain started approximately one-and-a-half years before she consulted with a pain specialist. Although an extensive workup was completed, no organic cause was established as the cause of her pain. After undergoing successful fluoroscopically guided celiac plexus blocks, an abdominal magnetic resonance imaging scan was obtained that revealed nutcracker phenomenon. The patient was evaluated by an urologist and underwent renal autotransplantation. The patient subsequently had complete relief of her pain.

Diagnosis and treatment of the Nutcracker syndrome: a review of the last 10 years

The nutcracker syndrome is characterized by a group of clinical manifestations caused by compression of the Left Renal Vein. The main symptoms are: macro and micro hematuria, proteinuria, and flank pain. Diagnosis is usually made after excluding other causes, because there are no clinical criteria for diagnosis. Confirmation is by Doppler ultrasonography or computed tomography. Treatment can vary, depending on patient characteristics and the severity of the symptoms, while conservative treatment, open surgery, and endovascular surgery may be employed. Currently, open surgery is still the first-line treatment, but some less invasive approaches are gaining acceptance.

Co-occurring superior mesenteric artery syndrome and nutcracker syndrome requiring Roux-en-Y duodenojejunostomy and left renal vein transposition: a case report and review of the literature

BACKGROUND

The duodenum and the left renal vein occupy the vascular angle made by the superior mesenteric artery and the aorta. When the angle becomes too acute, compression of either structure can occur. Each type of compression is associated with specific clinical symptoms that constitute a rare disorder. If clinical symptoms are mild, conservative treatment is implemented. However, surgery is often the only solution that can improve quality of life and/or avoid life-threatening complications. This report describes a case of a patient with both types of aortomesenteric compression that required two separate surgeries to alleviate all symptoms.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 20-year-old white woman presented to the Emergency Room complaining of sudden onset severe left flank and lower left quadrant abdominal pain, nausea, and vomiting. A clinical work-up revealed elevated white blood cells and hematuria. She was discharged with a diagnosis of urinary tract infection. Symptoms continued to worsen over the subsequent 2 months. Repeated and extensive clinical work-ups failed to suggest evidence of serious pathology. Ultimately, an endoscopy revealed obstruction of her duodenum, and barium swallow identified compression by the superior mesenteric artery, leading to the diagnosis of superior mesenteric artery syndrome. She underwent a Roux-en-Y duodenojejunostomy. Six weeks later she continued to have severe left-sided pain and intermittent hematuria. Venography revealed compression of the left renal vein, extensive pelvic varices, and significant engorgement of her left ovarian vein. A diagnosis of nutcracker syndrome was made and a left renal vein transposition was performed. Significant improvement was seen after 8 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

The disorders associated with aortomesenteric compression can lead to serious symptoms and sometimes death. Diagnosis is challenging not only because of the lack of awareness of these rare disorders, but also because they are associated with symptoms that are similar to those seen in less serious diseases. Guidance for health care professionals with respect to relevant radiological and clinical markers needs to be reconsidered in order to clarify the etiology of the diseases and create better diagnostic protocols.