Interfacial dilatational rheology as a bridge to connect amphiphilic heterografted bottlebrush copolymer architecture to emulsifying efficiency

Bottlebrush Networks: A Primer for Advanced Architectures

Bottlebrush networks (BBNs) are an exciting new class of materials with interesting physical properties derived from their unique architecture. While great strides have been made in our fundamental understanding of bottlebrush polymers and networks, an interdisciplinary approach is necessary for the field to accelerate advancements. This review aims to act as a primer to BBN chemistry and physics for both new and current members of the community. In addition to providing an overview of contemporary BBN synthetic methods, we developed a workflow and desktop application (LengthScale), enabling bottlebrush physics to be more approachable. We conclude by addressing several topical issues and asking a series of pointed questions to stimulate conversation within the community.

Bottlebrush Block Copolymers at the Interface of Immiscible Liquids: Adsorption and Lateral Packing

Amphiphilic bottlebrush block copolymers (BBCPs), having a hydrophilic bottlebrush polymer (BP) linked covalently to a hydrophobic BP, were found to segregate to liquid-liquid interfaces to minimize the free energy of the system. The key parameter influencing the outcome of the experiments is the ratio between the degree of polymerization of the backbone (NBB) and that of the side-chain brushes (NSC). Specifically, a spherical, star-like configuration results when NBB < NSC, while a cylindrical, bottlebrush-like shape is preferred when NBB > NSC. Dynamic interfacial tension (γ) and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) measurements show that the BBCP configuration influences the areal density and in-plane diffusion at the fluid interface. The characteristic relaxation times associated with BBCP adsorption (τA) and reorganization (τR) were determined by fitting time-dependent interfacial tension measurements to a sum of two exponential relaxation functions. Both τA and τR initially increased with NBB up to 92 repeat units, due to the larger hydrodynamic radius in solution and slower in-plane diffusivity, attributed to a shorter cross-sectional diameter of the side-chains near the block junction. This trend reversed at NBB = 190, with shorter τA and τR attributed to increased segregation strength and exposure of the bare water/toluene interface due to tilting and/or wiggling of the backbone chains, respectively. The adsorption energy barrier decreased with higher NBB, due to a reduced BBCP packing density at the fluid interface. This study provides fundamental insights into macromolecular assembly at fluid interfaces, as it pertains to unique bottlebrush block architectures.

Amphiphilic Heterografted Molecular Bottlebrushes with Tertiary Amine-Containing Side Chains as Efficient and Robust pH-Responsive Emulsifiers

By combining the unique characteristics of molecular bottlebrushes (MBBs) and the properties of stimuli-responsive polymers, we show that MBBs with randomly grafted poly(n-butyl acrylate) and pH-responsive poly(2-(N,N-diethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (PDEAEMA) side chains are efficient and robust pH-responsive emulsifiers. Water-in-toluene emulsions were formed at pH 4.0 and disrupted by increasing the pH to 10.0. The emulsion generation and disruption was reversible over the ten cycles investigated, and the bottlebrushes remained intact. The exceptional emulsion stability stemmed from the high interfacial binding energy of MBBs, imparted by their large molecular size and Janus architecture at the interface, as evidenced by the interfacial jamming and wrinkling of the assemblies upon reducing the interfacial area. At pH 10.0, PDEAEMA became water-insoluble, and the MBBs desorbed from the interface, causing de-emulsification. Consequently, we have shown that the judicious design of MBBs can generate properties of particle emulsifiers from their large size, while the responsiveness of the MBBs enables more potential applications.

Fast Interfacial Polymerization for Stabilizing Emulsion Droplets with Polymer Films beyond Emulsifiers

Stabilizing emulsion droplets with amphiphilic emulsifiers are the current prevailing method, but the extensive use of such amphiphilic substances has caused widespread concerns. In this Perspective, three traditional methods for the stabilization of emulsion droplets according to the type of emulsifiers used are outlined, and the emphasis is placed on the mechanism of steric hindrance for emulsion stabilization. Then, we provide a concise introduction and discussion of the fast interfacial polymerization method as a new strategy for preparing stable emulsifier-free emulsion droplets with a polymer film, including its research background, current progress, and possible development directions. It is anticipated that this paper will promote the development of emulsifier-free emulsion production via fast interfacial polymerization and other related methods.

Oil-in-Water Emulsions Stabilized by Hydrophilic Homopolymers

Most of the polymeric emulsifiers have diblock and triblock copolymer architecture containing hydrophilic and hydrophobic domains. In this work, we show that hydrophilic homopolymers can be effective stabilizers of oil-in-water emulsions. Using polyethelyne oxide and poly(vinylpyrrolidone) as model hydrophilic homopolymers and n-decane and n-hexane as model nonpolar phases, we show that high-molecular weight polymers can stabilize emulsions over 24 h beyond a threshold concentration. We highlight the role of the molecular weight and concentration of the polymer in the stability of emulsions through kinetic measurements of emulsion volume, microscopic analysis, interfacial tension, and dilational rheology. We explain the mechanism of stabilization to stem from buoyancy-driven creaming of emulsion drops and film drainage and dilational elasticity of the interface in relation to the molecular weights and concentrations of polymers. This study demonstrates that water-soluble homopolymers can stabilize oil-in-water emulsions and open avenues for the use of eco-friendly biopolymers, which are inherently hydrophilic, as an alternative to synthetic emulsifiers.

Oscillatory and Relaxation Study of the Interfacial Rheology of Star Polymers with Low-Grafting-Density PEO Arms and Hydrophobic Poly(divinylbenzene) Cores

Star polymers have been gaining interest due to their tunable properties. They have been used as effective stabilizers for Pickering emulsions. Herein, star polymers were synthesized via activators regenerated by electron transfer (ARGET) atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP). Poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) with terminal α-bromoisobutyrate ATRP functionality was used as a macroinitiator and divinylbenzene as a crosslinker for the arm-first star synthesis. Stars with PEO arms with a molar mass of either 2 or 5 kDa had a relatively low density of grafted chains, i.e., ca. 0.25 chain/nm². The properties of PEO stars adsorbed at oil-water interfaces were investigated using interfacial tension and interfacial rheology. The magnitude of interfacial tensions at oil-water interfaces depends on the nature of the oil phase, being lower at the m-xylene/water interface than at the n-dodecane/water interface. Small differences were observed for stars with different molecular weights of PEO arms. The overall behavior of PEO stars adsorbed at an interface can be considered as an intermediate between a particle and a linear/branched polymer. Obtained results offer an important insight into the interfacial rheology of PEO star polymers in the context of their application as stabilizers for Pickering emulsions.

Adsorption of sterically-stabilized diblock copolymer nanoparticles at the oil-water interface: effect of charged end-groups on interfacial rheology

The RAFT aqueous emulsion polymerization of either methyl methacrylate (MMA) or benzyl methacrylate (BzMA) is conducted at 70 °C using poly(glycerol monomethacrylate) (PGMA) as a water-soluble precursor to produce sterically-stabilized diblock copolymer nanoparticles of approximately 30 nm diameter. Carboxylic acid- or morpholine-functional RAFT agents are employed to confer anionic or cationic functionality at the ends of the PGMA stabilizer chains, with a neutral RAFT agent being used as a control. Thus the electrophoretic footprint of such minimally-charged model nanoparticles can be adjusted simply by varying the solution pH. Giant (mm-sized) aqueous droplets containing such nanoparticles are then grown within a continuous phase of n-dodecane and a series of interfacial rheology measurements are conducted. The interfacial tension between the aqueous phase and n-dodecane is strongly dependent on the charge of the terminal group on the stabilizer chains. More specifically, neutral nanoparticles produce a significantly lower interfacial tension than either cationic or anionic nanoparticles. Moreover, adsorption of neutral nanoparticles at the n-dodecane-water interface produces higher interfacial elastic moduli than that observed for charged nanoparticles. This is because neutral nanoparticles can adsorb at much higher surface packing densities owing to the absence of electrostatic repulsive forces in this case.

Controlling Rheology of Fluid Interfaces through Microblock Length of Sequence-Controlled Amphiphilic Copolymers

Previous studies have demonstrated that films of sequence-controlled amphiphilic copolymers display contact angles that depend on microblock size. This suggests that microblock length may provide a means of tuning surface and interfacial properties. In this work, the interfacial rheology of a series of sequence-controlled copolymers, prepared through the addition of bicyclo[4.2.0]oct-1(8)-ene-8-carboxamide (monomer A) and cyclohexene (monomer B) to generate sequences up to 24 monomeric units composed of (A m B n ) i microblocks, where m, n, and i range from 1 to 6. Interfacial rheometry is used to measure the mechanical properties of an air-water interface with these copolymers. As the microblock size increases, the interfacial storage modulus, G', increases, which may be due to an increase in the size of interfacial hydrophobic domains. Small-angle X-ray scattering shows that the copolymers have a similar conformation in solution, suggesting that any variations in the mechanics of the interface are due to assembly at the interface, and not on solution association or bulk rheological properties. This is the first study demonstrating that microblock size can be used to control interfacial rheology of amphiphilic copolymers. Thus, the results provide a new strategy for controlling the dynamics of fluid interfaces through precision sequence-controlled polymers.

Study on the Liquid-Liquid and Liquid-Solid Interfacial Behavior of Functionalized Graphene Oxide

With the rise of carbon neutrality, the applications of carbon-based materials are gaining considerable attention. Graphene oxide (GO) is a two-dimensional sheet with epoxy and hydroxyl groups on the basal plane and carboxyl groups at the edge. In order to change the oil/water (o/w) interfacial activity, GO was controlled and modified by dodecylamine to get two kinds of functionalized GOs (fGOs), named as basal plane-functionalized GO (bGO) and edge-functionalized GO (eGO), respectively. The interfacial tension measurement showed that fGOs could reduce more interfacial tension at the poly-α-olefin/water interface than those at synthetic esters or aromatic compounds/water interfaces. Besides, eGO can reduce more poly-α-olefin-4/water interfacial tension compared to bGO. The interfacial dilatational rheology of eGO and fatty alcohol polyoxyethylene ether-4 (MOA4) showed that MOA4 gradually replaced eGO at the interface with the increase of MOA4, until the interface was completely occupied. eGO and MOA4 complex emulsion exhibited the best friction-reducing performance at 250 rpm. The coefficient of friction (COF) curves of the emulsions with eGO showed two platforms, with the COF reduced by 37.42% at the most. The rheological results of emulsions showed that the addition of eGO increased the elasticity of the emulsion. Emulsions showed shear-thinning and friction-thickening properties, which make it easier for the emulsion to form a lubricating film on the metal surface. Our research results suggested that the functionalization on the edge of GO will change the interfacial properties significantly, which have widespread applications in the encapsulation of active materials, surface protection, adsorption, and separation of pollutants.

pH-Dependent Interfacial Tension and Dilatational Modulus Synergism of Oil-Soluble Fatty Acid and Water-Soluble Cationic Surfactants at the Oil/Water Interface

While the concept of interfacial tension synergism in surfactant mixtures is well established, little attention has been paid to the possibility of synergistic effects on the interfacial rheology of mixed surfactant systems. Furthermore, interfacial tension synergism is most often investigated for mixtures of surfactants residing in a single phase. Here, we define dilatational modulus synergism and report a study of interfacial tension isotherms and complex dilatational moduli for a binary surfactant system with the two surfactants accessing the oil/water interface from opposite sides. Using an oil-soluble fatty acid surfactant (palmitic acid, PA) that may be ionized at the oil/water interface and a quaternary ammonium water-soluble cationic surfactant (tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide, TTAB), the binary interfacial interaction was tuned by the aqueous phase pH. Interfacial tensions and dilatational moduli were measured by the pendant drop method for the binary surfactant system as well as the corresponding single-surfactant systems to identify synergistic effects. The possible occurrence of dilatational modulus synergism was probed from two perspectives: one for a fixed total surfactant concentration and the other for a fixed interfacial tension. The aqueous pH was found to have a controlling effect on both interfacial tension synergism and the dilatational modulus synergism. The conditions for interfacial tension synergism coincided with those for the storage modulus synergism: both tension and storage modulus synergisms were observed under all conditions tested at pH 7 where PA was mostly deprotonated, for both perspectives examined, but not for any conditions tested at pH 3 where PA is mostly protonated. The loss modulus synergism exhibited more complex behaviors, such as frequency and interfacial tension dependences, but again was only observed at pH 7. The tension and modulus synergism at pH 7 were attributed to the increased attraction between ionized PA and cationic TTAB and the formation of catanionic complexes at the oil/water interface.

Multichain adsorption at fluid interfaces: Amphiphilic homopolymers vs copolymers

HYPOTHESIS

At selective liquid-liquid interface, amphiphilic homopolymers, having groups with different affinity for the liquids in each monomer unit, would demonstrate higher occupation of the interfacial layer than copolymers with various distributions of groups and be advantageous as interface stabilizers.

EXPERIMENTS

By means of Langevin dynamics computer simulation, conformations of multiple chains of amphiphilic macromolecules adsorbed at the liquid-liquid interface were studied. Monomer units having different affinity for the liquids were distributed variously along the polymer chains. Homopolymers, amphiphilic at the level of an individual monomer unit, and copolymers with random, altermating and multiblock distribution of groups were considered. The surface coverage, structure of the layer, and spatial distribution of monomer units were investigated depending on the polymer concentration.

FINDINGS

Compared to copolymers with random, alternating and multiblock distributions of the groups, the interfacial layer concentration of amphiphilic homopolymer is about 1.5 times higher, the adsorbed layer is remarkably thinner, has membrane-like structure and is asymmetric with respect to interface boundary. Also, the adsorbed amphiphilic homopolymers form fewer loops and tails, most located on one side of the interface. This combination of properties is promising for practical application in modern self-assembling molecular devices.