A new biomechanical model for evaluation of fixation systems of maxillofacial fractures

Biomechanical influence of plate configurations on mandible subcondylar fracture fixation: a finite element study

Mandible subcondylar fractures have very high complication rate, yet there is no consensus on suitable plate design for optimal patient outcomes. Our study is aimed at comparing single mini, trapezoid, lambda, strut and double mini plates. A finite-element (FE) model of intact mandible was developed based on healthy CT-scan data, which was further virtually osteotomized and fixated with plates. The cortical and cancellous bones were assigned region-specific orthotropic and heterogenous isotropic material properties respectively. The models were subjected to six load cases representing the mastication cycle. Under opposite lateralities, the tensile and compressive mandibular strain distributions were found as the opposite, with tensile strains at the posterior border under ipsilateral molar clenching (RMOL) resulting in lesser mandibular strain in reconstructed mandible with single mini plate under RMOL but highest mandibular strain under the contralateral molar clenching (LMOL). Owing to the reduced mandibular strains under LMOL than RMOL, the contralateral chewing is preferred during the immediate post-surgery period for patients. Under LMOL, the peak von Mises stresses in the plate decreased with increase in the number of screws. Furthermore, the presence of two arms in double mini and trapezoid plates seems beneficial to neutralise the tensile and compressive strains across load cases.

Caudal mandibular fracture repair using three-dimensional printing, presurgical plate contouring and a preformed template to aid anatomical fracture reduction

Case summary

Two cats were presented with mandibular fractures following head trauma. Following a CT scan, both were diagnosed with fractures of the ramus. The CT scans were used to print three-dimensional (3D) models of the mandibular fractures, which were used to pre-contour stainless steel mini-plates. These were fixed to the models and the screw positions used to produce a stainless steel template. The template was used as a pattern during surgery to drill holes in the ramus so that the pre-contoured mini-plates could be fixed in the exact same position as they had been on the 3D model. The fractures healed in both cats achieving normal jaw function and occlusion.

Relevance and novel information

Conventional techniques used to treat caudal mandibular fractures in cats, such as maxillomandibular fixation and bignathic encircling and retaining device (BEARD), are associated with significant patient morbidity and postoperative complications. Internal rigid fixation is difficult because of small bone size, requirement for considerable plate contouring and difficulty in achieving accurate anatomical reduction of caudal mandibular fractures. These are the first reported cases of mini-plate fixation of caudal mandibular fractures in cats using 3D models, pre-contouring of bone plates and the use of a template to facilitate accurate plate positioning, which may provide an alternative technique suitable for fixing caudal mandibular fractures in cats.

Comparison of Different Fixation Types Used in Unilateral Mandibular Condylar Fractures: An In Vivo Study With New Biomechanical Model

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this in vivo study is to compare the single-titanium, double-titanium mini plate, and single resorbable plate systems used in internal rigid fixation of the unilateral mandibular condylar fractures on new design biomechanical model.

METHODS

Thirty synthetic polyurethane models were used for biomechanical testing. Fracture lines were created for each model. Fragments were fixed with single-titanium plates in Group A (n = 10), double-titanium plates in Group B (n = 10), and single biodegradable plate (PPLA) in Group C (n = 10). Masticatory forces were applied to the models and the biomechanical properties of the titanium plate and screws, resorbable plate, and screws were evaluated.

RESULTS

The average failure force for Group A, Group B, and Group C is 199, 324, 177N and the average bone displacement for Group A, Group B, Group C is 1.9, 0.3, 2.1 mm, respectively.

DISCUSSION

Double titanium plates showed the most acceptable results in the fixation of unilateral subcondylar fractures where the single titanium and biodegradable plate systems failed to provide enough stability in unilateral subcondylar fracture fixation. Biodegradable plate systems are still not an alternative in fixation of unilateral condylar fractures.

Biomechanical study in polyurethane mandibles of different metal plates and internal fixation techniques, employed in mandibular angle fractures

The aim of this study was to perform a physicochemical and morphological characterization and compare the mechanical behavior of an experimental Ti-Mo alloy to the analogous metallic Ti-based fixation system, for mandibular angle fractures. Twenty-eight polyurethane mandibles were uniformly sectioned on the left angle. These were divided into 4 groups: group Eng 1P, one 2.0-mm plate and 4 screws 6 mm long; group Eng 2P, two 2.0-mm plates, the first fixed with 4 screws 6 mm long and the second with 4 screws 12 mm long. The same groups were created for the Ti-15Mo alloy. Each group was subjected to linear vertical loading at the first molar on the plated side in a mechanical testing unit. Means and standard deviations were compared with respect to statistical significance using ANOVA. The chemical composition of the Ti-15Mo alloy was close to the nominal value. The mapping of Mo and Ti showed a homogeneous distribution. SEM of the screw revealed machining debris. For the plates, only the cpTi plate undergoes a surface treatment. The metallographic analysis reveals granular microstructure, from the thermomechanical trials. A statistically significant difference was found (P < 0.05) when the comparison between both internal fixation techniques was performed. The 2P technique showed better mechanical behavior than 1P.

Assessment of compression and strength of divergent screws mounted on miniplates for fixation of mandibular fractures: an in vitro experimental study

An efficient band of tension is critical for the adequate fixation of mandibular fractures, so fixation devices that compress are helpful. We aimed to evaluate the possibility of creating compression using screws inserted divergently into miniplates placed in the tension zone of mandibular fractures and record the effects on the strength of fixation. For this in vitro experimental study we prepared 20 sheep hemimandibles. After angle fractures had been created, the specimens were divided into standard and study groups (n=10 in each). In the standard group the tension zones were fixed in the standard manner with 4-hole miniplates and 4 parallel screws. Those in the study group were fixed as for the standard group but with 4×45° divergent screws. The differences in the gap in the fracture line before and after fixation were measured as indicators of compression. The strength of fixation was also assessed with a universal testing machine in vitro. The amount of compression was significant only in the study group (p<0.001), and there was no difference in the strength of fixation between the two groups (p=0.7). We conclude that divergent drilling and insertion of screws creates more horizontal force when miniplates are used, and results in reduction in the size of the probable gap in the fracture line. Insertion of divergent screws in miniplates may create compression between fractured segments without jeopardising the strength of fixation.

The Le Fort system revisited: Trauma velocity predicts the path of Le Fort I fractures through the lateral buttress

OBJECTIVE

To examine the effect of trauma velocity on the pattern of Le Fort I facial fractures.

METHOD

A retrospective medical record review was conducted on a consecutive cohort of craniofacial traumas surgically treated by a single surgeon between 2007 and 2011 (n=150). Of these cases, 39 Le Fort fractures were identified. Patient demographic information, method of trauma and velocity of impact were reviewed for these cases. Velocity of impact was expressed categorically as either 'high' or 'low': high-velocity fractures were those caused by a fall from >1 story or a motor vehicle collision; low-velocity fractures were the result of assaults with a blunt weapon, closed fist or falls from standing height. The vertical position of each fracture was measured at its point of entry on the lateral buttress and its point of exit on the piriform aperture. To allow for comparison across individuals, values were expressed as ratios based on their location on the face relative to these landmarks. A Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used to compare the fracture heights caused by high- and low-velocity trauma.

RESULTS

The results revealed that high-velocity traumas to the face create Le Fort I fractures at a higher point in the lateral buttress compared with low-velocity traumas. There was no difference between heights at the piriform aperture.

CONCLUSION

High-velocity trauma resulted in higher Le Fort I fracture patterns compared with low-velocity trauma.

The Le Fort system revisited: Trauma velocity predicts the path of Le Fort I fractures through the lateral buttress

Objective

To examine the effect of trauma velocity on the pattern of Le Fort I facial fractures.

Method

A retrospective medical record review was conducted on a consecutive cohort of craniofacial traumas surgically treated by a single surgeon between 2007 and 2011 (n=150). Of these cases, 39 Le Fort fractures were identified. Patient demographic information, method of trauma and velocity of impact were reviewed for these cases. Velocity of impact was expressed categorically as either ‘high’ or ‘low’: high-velocity fractures were those caused by a fall from >1 story or a motor vehicle collision; low-velocity fractures were the result of assaults with a blunt weapon, closed fist or falls from standing height. The vertical position of each fracture was measured at its point of entry on the lateral buttress and its point of exit on the piriform aperture. To allow for comparison across individuals, values were expressed as ratios based on their location on the face relative to these landmarks. A Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used to compare the fracture heights caused by high- and low-velocity trauma.

Results

The results revealed that high-velocity traumas to the face create Le Fort I fractures at a higher point in the lateral buttress compared with low-velocity traumas. There was no difference between heights at the piriform aperture.

Conclusion

High-velocity trauma resulted in higher Le Fort I fracture patterns compared with low-velocity trauma.