Force and deformation stresses in customized and non-customized plates during simulation of advancement genioplasty

Digital technology revolutionizing mandibular fracture treatment: a comparative analysis of patient-specific plates and conventional titanium plates

OBJECTIVES

The treatment of fractures prioritizes the restoration of functionality through the realignment of fractured segments. Conventional methods, such as titanium plates, have been employed for this purpose; however, certain limitations have been observed, leading to the development of patient-specific plates. Furthermore, recent advancements in digital technology in dentistry enable the creation of virtual models and simulations of surgical procedures. The aim was to assess the clinical effectiveness of patient-specific plates utilizing digital technology in treating mandibular fractures compared to conventional titanium plates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty patients diagnosed with mandibular fractures were included and randomly assigned to either the study or control groups. The surgical procedure comprised reduction and internal fixation utilizing patient-specific plates generated through virtual surgery planning with digital models for the study group, while the control group underwent the same procedure with conventional titanium plates. Assessment criteria included the presence of malunion, infection, sensory disturbance, subjective occlusal disturbance and occlusal force in functional maximum intercuspation (MICP). Statistical analysis involved using the Chi-square test and one-way repeated measures analysis of variance.

RESULTS

All parameters showed no statistically significant differences between the study and control groups, except for the enhancement in occlusal force in functional MICP, where a statistically significant difference was observed (p = 0.000).

CONCLUSION

Using patient-specific plates using digital technology has demonstrated clinical effectiveness in treating mandibular fractures, offering advantages of time efficiency and benefits for less experienced surgeons.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Patient-specific plates combined with digital technology can be clinically effective in mandibular fracture treatment.

3D printed plates based on generative design biomechanically outperform manual digital fitting and conventional systems printed in photopolymers in bridging mandibular bone defects of critical size in dogs

Conventional plate osteosynthesis of critical-sized bone defects in canine mandibles can fail to restore former functionality and stability due to adaption limits. Three-dimensional (3D) printed patient-specific implants are becoming increasingly popular as these can be customized to avoid critical structures, achieve perfect alignment to individual bone contours, and may provide better stability. Using a 3D surface model for the mandible, four plate designs were created and evaluated for their properties to stabilize a defined 30 mm critical-size bone defect. Design-1 was manually designed, and further shape optimized using Autodesk ^® Fusion 360 (ADF360) and finite element analysis (FE) to generate Design-2. Design-4 was created with the generative design (GD) function from ADF360 using preplaced screw terminals and loading conditions as boundaries. A 12-hole reconstruction titanium locking plate (LP) (2.4/3.0 mm) was also tested, which was scanned, converted to a STL file and 3D printed (Design-3). Each design was 3D printed from a photopolymer resin (VPW) and a photopolymer resin in combination with a thermoplastic elastomer (VPWT) and loaded in cantilever bending using a customized servo-hydraulic mechanical testing system; n = 5 repetitions each. No material defects pre- or post-failure testing were found in the printed mandibles and screws. Plate fractures were most often observed in similar locations, depending on the design. Design-4 has 2.8-3.6 times ultimate strength compared to other plates, even though only 40% more volume was used. Maximum load capacities did not differ significantly from those of the other three designs. All plate types, except D3, were 35% stronger when made of VPW, compared to VPWT. VPWT D3 plates were only 6% stronger. Generative design is faster and easier to handle than optimizing manually designed plates using FE to create customized implants with maximum load-bearing capacity and minimum material requirements. Although guidelines for selecting appropriate outcomes and subsequent refinements to the optimized design are still needed, this may represent a straightforward approach to implementing additive manufacturing in individualized surgical care. The aim of this work is to analyze different design techniques, which can later be used for the development of implants made of biocompatible materials.

Reoperative genioplasty: a 10-year retrospective study

PURPOSE

The purpose of this retrospective cohort study was to identify the causes of requiring reoperative genioplasty and determine the factors associated with reoperation.

METHODS

Medical records and radiographs of patients who underwent genioplasty were reviewed. The demographic data, characteristics of operation, and treatment outcomes were gathered to analyze the causes that required reoperation. Descriptive statistics and logistic regression analysis were computed to evaluate the study.

RESULTS

Of the 157 patients included, there were 12 patients (7.6%) who needed reoperation after genioplasty. Age ≤ 25 years significantly decreased the likelihood for the need for reoperative genioplasty compared with age > 35 years. However, the need for reoperative genioplasty was not directly associated with gender, simultaneous orthognathic operation, direction and amount of movement, method of fixation, or bone graft interposition. Fixation failure, esthetic problems, residual obstructive sleep apnea, and palpable step at the inferior border of the mandible were the causes that required a second operation by reposition and re-fixation with rigid fixation, recontouring, or reoperation by genioplasty.

CONCLUSION

Genioplasty procedure provided a predictive result. A reoperative rate was only 7.6% and younger age decreased the risk of reoperative genioplasty.

Accuracy of orthognathic surgery with customized titanium plates-Systematic review

This systematic review aimed to evaluate the accuracy of customized titanium plates in orthognathic surgery compared to standard outcome in virtual surgical planning. PRISMA and JBI guidelines were followed. Research protocol was registered in PROSPERO. Six databases and two gray literature repositories were used as sources of research articles. Descriptive clinical studies, that performed orthognathic surgery using custom titanium plates, were included. Risk of bias was assessed by "The Joanna-Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal tools for use in Systematic Reviews Checklist for Case Series". Of the 11,916 studies initially identified, seven met the eligibility criteria and were included. The studies were published between 2015 and 2019. Most of the studies (57%) had a low risk of bias, while one had a high risk of bias. Total sample included 74 patients with 63 bimaxillary surgeries and 11 unimaxillary surgeries. All studies showed acceptable accuracy within previously established clinical parameters. Although the eligible articles assessed the accuracy of the orthognathic surgery with respect to virtual planning, the wide variability of evaluation methodologies made it impossible to calculate a combined accuracy measure. It was not possible to perform a meta-analysis, so a pragmatic recommendation on the use of these plates is not possible.

Stability of the chin after advancement genioplasty using absorbable plate and screws with template devices

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare the stability of the chin between absorbable plate and screws with a template device and titanium plate after advancement genioplasty in class II patients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The subjects consisted of 22 Japanese class II patients who underwent genioplasty advancement in combination with bi-maxillary surgery. After genioplasty horizontal osteotomy, the template plate and screws were fixed at the central region of the chin temporarily. Then, two absorbable bi-cortical screws (uncalcined and unsintered hydroxyapatite and poly-l-lactic acid: uHA/PLLA) were used and fixed bilaterally. After removal of the template plate and screws, one absorbable plate and screws were added to fix the segment in the advancement genioplasty (n = 14). The remaining 8 patients underwent genioplasty advancement surgery with the conventional titanium plate. For all patients, lateral cephalograms were obtained pre- and immediately after surgery and at 1 year after surgery. Change in the Pogonion (Pog) and Menton (Me) points and the corresponding soft tissue points (PogS and MeS) were evaluated.

RESULTS

Although there were no significant differences in the change from before to immediately after surgery between the absorbable and titanium groups, there were significant differences in the Pog (Y) (P = 0.0379) and PogS (Y) (P = 0.0379) from immediately after surgery to after 1 year between both groups.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that predicted advancement of the chin in the absorbable group could be achieved by using a template and screws, and likewise in the titanium group. However, this study suggested that vertical relapse to the inferior site or resorption at the antero-superior edge of the segment could occur in the absorbable group.