Monitoring of in-situ chemical oxidation for remediation of diesel-contaminated soil with electrical resistivity tomography

Groundwater electro-bioremediation via diffuse electro-conductive zones: A critical review

Microbial electrochemical technologies (MET) can remove a variety of organic and inorganic pollutants from contaminated groundwater. However, despite significant laboratory-scale successes over the past decade, field-scale applications remain limited. We hypothesize that enhancing the electrochemical conductivity of the soil surrounding electrodes could be a groundbreaking and cost-effective alternative to deploying numerous high-surface-area electrodes in short distances. This could be achieved by injecting environmentally safe iron- or carbon-based conductive (nano)particles into the aquifer. Upon transport and deposition onto soil grains, these particles create an electrically conductive zone that can be exploited to control and fine-tune the delivery of electron donors or acceptors over large distances, thereby driving the process more efficiently. Beyond extending the radius of influence of electrodes, these diffuse electro-conductive zones (DECZ) could also promote the development of syntrophic anaerobic communities that degrade contaminants via direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). In this review, we present the state-of-the-art in applying conductive materials for MET and DIET-based applications. We also provide a comprehensive overview of the physicochemical properties of candidate electrochemically conductive materials and related injection strategies suitable for field-scale implementation. Finally, we illustrate and critically discuss current and prospective electrochemical and geophysical methods for measuring soil electronic conductivity-both in the laboratory and in the field-before and after injection practices, which are crucial for determining the extent of DECZ. This review article provides critical information for a robust design and in situ implementation of groundwater electro-bioremediation processes.

Induced polarization monitoring of in-situ chemical oxidation for quantification of contaminant consumption

Dynamic monitoring of in-situ chemical oxidation (ISCO) of LNAPLs in groundwater is the foundation for evaluating remediation effectiveness. In this study, spectral (SIP) and time-domain induced polarization (TDIP) measurements are conducted in laboratory columns and sandboxes to monitor the ISCO of LNAPL for characterizing oxidant transport and quantifying contaminant consumption under different injection strategies. To support the interpretation, this was combined with total petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH), hydrochemistry and computed tomography (CT) measurements. Experiments were performed using two media, and the monitoring results showed similar variations in key parameters. The electrical resistivity, chargeability and TPH decreased significantly during ISCO remediation, while the hydrochemical parameters showed an increasing trend. Specifically, IP variations before and after injection revealed that more oxidant remained in the source area using a multiple-injection strategy compared to a single-injection strategy. The effect of contaminant consumption under well-controlled conditions on electrical resistivity was <3 % and the effect on chargeability was <8 %. In conditions with oxidant migration, the effect of oxidant on the resistivity and chargeability was similar at ∼89 % in the source area, whereas the oxidant had a greater effect on the resistivity (>58 %) than the chargeability (<40 %) outside the source area. Based on the experimental results, a conceptual model for the IP response during ISCO remediation is proposed and we delineate the pore structural characteristics of porous media based on the conceptual model. Oxidant injection develops a high conductivity environment and causes a decrease in LNAPLs content and number of interfaces, leading to the suppression of the IP response. In conclusion, IP measurement in combination with supporting information clearly enables the characterization of the ISCO remediation of LNAPLs in groundwater and facilitates the pore structure characterization of porous media based on the IP conceptual model.

Spectral induced polarization of corrosion of sulfur modified Iron in sediments

Spectral induced polarization (SIP) responses are not well understood within the context of remediation applications at contaminated sites. Systematic SIP studies are needed to gain further insights into the complex electrical response of dynamic, biogeochemical states to enable the use of SIP for subsurface site characterization and remediation monitoring. Although SIP measurements on zero valent iron have been previously published, the SIP response for sulfur modified iron (SMI), a similar potential subsurface reductive amendment, has not yet been reported. Hence, the purpose of this laboratory-scale study was to evaluate SIP for nonintrusive monitoring of SMI under relevant subsurface conditions. SMI was separately mixed with silica sand or sediments from the Hanford Site (Washington, USA) and then packed into columns for geochemical and SIP analysis for up to 77 days under fully saturated conditions. SMI exhibited distinguishable phase peaks between 0.1 and 1.0 Hz, which changed in magnitude based on content and were detected as low as 0.3 wt%. In the initial days, the complex conductivity, phase maxima, and chargeability increased while the peak locations shifted to higher frequency (decreasing relaxation times), suggesting an initial increase in polarization and concurrent decrease in the length scales (potentially due to changes in particle size and mineralogy). Then, after 77 days, the phase maxima and chargeability decreased with a concurrent increase in relaxation times, suggesting that over longer periods, less polarizable phases are forming and particle size or connectivity of polarizable phases is increasing. These results demonstrated a unique SIP response to SMI transformations that might be applied to monitoring of SMI emplaced as a subsurface barrier or injected in the field.

Study on the influence of different water and black shale content on the resistivity of loess

Soil degradation, characterized by the deterioration of soil physical and chemical properties, nutrient loss, and an increase in toxic substances, is a key ecological concern in mining activities. This study explores the use of waste black shale from mining development as an additive to loess to enhance soil properties for reclamation in mining areas. The research includes resistivity and organic carbon content tests on modified reclaimed loess with varying black shale and water contents. Additionally, the electrical properties of these modified soils are investigated across different AC frequencies. The results highlight the significance of soil plasticity and a 1.5% black shale content in influencing reclaimed loess's electrical properties. Moisture content and black shale influence changes in soil conductive paths and resistivity. The abundance of clay minerals in black shale plays a crucial role in altering soil electrical resistivity due to the adsorption of cations in water and the directional transport under an electric field. Considering soil's three-phase composition and diffuse bilayer structure, the study elucidates the mechanism behind changes in the electrical properties of improved reclaimed loess, accounting for water and black shale content. This research demonstrates the feasibility of using black shale as a soil additive and emphasizes the non-destructive assessment potential of electrical resistivity test (ERT) measurements for modified reclaimed soils.

Understanding the dynamics of enhanced light non-aqueous phase liquids (LNAPL) remediation at a polluted site: Insights from hydrogeophysical findings and chemical evidence

This study intricately unfolds a pioneering methodology for remediating contaminants in a persistent light non-aqueous phase liquids (LNAPL)-contaminated site. The remediation strategy seamlessly integrates enhanced desorption and in-situ chemical oxidation (ISCO), orchestrating the injection of PetroCleanze® (a desorbent) and RegenOx® (an oxidizer) through meticulously designed wells. These injections, based on detailed geological and hydrogeological assessments, aim at mobilizing residual contaminants for subsequent extraction. Real-time subsurface dynamics are investigated through geophysical monitoring, employing electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) to trace reagent migration pathways via their effect on bulk electrical conductivity. The integration of groundwater sampling data aims at providing additional insights into the transformations of contaminants in the spatiotemporal context. Vivid two-dimensional time-lapse ERT sections showcase the evolution of resistivity anomalies, providing high-resolution evidence of the heterogeneity, dispersion pathways of desorbent and oxidant, and residual LNAPL mobilization. Hydrochemical analyses complement this, revealing effective mobilization processes with increasing aqueous concentrations of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) over time. Speciation analysis unveils the intricate interplay of desorption and oxidation, portraying the dynamic fractionation of hydrocarbon components. The hydrogeophysical and data-driven framework not only delivers qualitative and quantitative insights into reagent and contaminant distribution but also enhances understanding of spatial and temporal physio-chemical changes during the remediation process. Time-lapse ERT visually narrates the reagent's journey through time, while chemical analyses depict the unfolding processes of desorption and oxidation across space and time. The coupling of hydrogeophysical and chemical findings pictures the transformations of pollutants following the sequence of product injection and the push and pull activities, capturing the removal of mobilized contaminants through hydraulic barrier wells. This enhanced understanding proves instrumental towards optimizing and tailoring remediation efforts, especially in heterogeneous environmental settings. This study establishes a new standard for a sophisticated and innovative contaminant remediation approach, advancing environmental practices through the harmonized analysis of geophysical and chemical data.

Real-time monitoring of in situ chemical oxidation (ISCO) of dissolved TCE by integrating electrical resistivity tomography and reactive transport modeling

Successful in situ chemical oxidation (ISCO) applications require real-time monitoring to assess the oxidant delivery and treatment effectiveness, and to support rapid and cost-effective decision making. Existing monitoring methods often suffer from poor spatial coverage given a limited number of boreholes in most field conditions. The ionic nature of oxidants (e.g., permanganate) makes time-lapse electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) a potential monitoring tool for ISCO. However, time-lapse ERT is usually limited to qualitative analysis because it cannot distinguish between the electrical responses of the ionic oxidant and the ionic products from contaminant oxidation. This study proposed a real-time quantitative monitoring approach for ISCO by integrating time-lapse ERT and physics-based reactive transport models (RTM). Moving past common practice, where an electrical-conductivity anomaly in an ERT survey would be roughly linked to concentrations of anything ionic, we used PHT3D as our RTM to distinguish the contributions from the ionic oxidant and the ionic products and to quantify the spatio-temporal evolution of all chemical components. The proposed approach was evaluated through laboratory column experiments for trichloroethene (TCE) remediation. This ISCO experiment was monitored by both time-lapse ERT and downstream sampling. We found that changes in inverted bulk electrical conductivity, unsurprisingly, did not correlate well with the observed permanganate concentrations due to the ionic products. By integrating time-lapse ERT and RTM, the distribution of all chemical components was satisfactorily characterized and quantified. Measured concentration data from limited locations and the non-intrusive ERT data were found to be complementary for ISCO monitoring. The inverted bulk conductivity data were effective in capturing the spatial distribution of ionic species, while the concentration data provided information regarding dissolved TCE. Through incorporating multi-source data, the error of quantifying ISCO efficiency was kept at most 5 %, compared to errors that can reach up to 68 % when relying solely on concentration data.