Oscillatory behavior of microbubbles impacts efficacy of cellular drug delivery

A, Nayak UY. Low-Frequency Sonophoresis: A Promising Strategy for Enhanced Transdermal Delivery

Sonophoresis is the most approachable mode of transdermal drug delivery system, wherein low-frequency sonophoresis penetrates the drug molecules into the skin. It is an alternative method for an oral system of drug delivery and hypodermal injections. The cavitation effect is thought to be the main mechanism used in sonophoresis. The cavitation process involves forming a gaseous bubble and its rupture, induced in the coupled medium. Other mechanisms used are thermal effects, convectional effects, and mechanical effects. It mainly applies to transporting hydrophilic drugs, macromolecules, gene delivery, and vaccine delivery. It is also used in carrier-mediated delivery in the form of micelles, liposomes, and dendrimers. Some synergistic effects of sonophoresis, along with some permeation enhancers, such as chemical enhancers, iontophoresis, electroporation, and microneedles, increased the effectiveness of drug penetration. Sonophoresis-mediated ocular drug delivery, nail drug delivery, gene delivery to the brain, sports medicine, and sonothrombolysis are also widely used. In conclusion, while sonophoresis offers promising applications in diverse fields, further research is essential to comprehensively elucidate the biophysical mechanisms governing ultrasound-tissue interactions. Addressing these gaps in understanding will enable the refinement and optimization of sonophoresis-based therapeutic strategies for enhanced clinical efficacy.

The relationship between surface drug distribution of Dox-loaded microbubbles and drug release/cavitation behaviors with ultrasound

Ultrasound (US)-triggered microbubbles (MBs) drug delivery is a promising tool for noninvasive and localized therapy. Several studies have shown the potential of drug-loaded MBs to boost the delivery of therapeutic substances to target tissue effectively. Nevertheless, little is known about the surface payload distribution affecting the cavitation activity and drug release behavior of the drug-loaded MBs. In this study, we designed a common chemodrug (Doxorubicin, Dox)-loaded MB (Dox-MBs) and regulated the payload distribution as uniform or cluster onto the outer surface of MBs. The Dox distribution on the MB shells was assessed by confocal fluorescence microscopic imaging. The acoustic properties of the Dox-MBs with different Dox distributions were evaluated by their acoustic stability and cavitation activities. The payload release and the fragments from Dox-MBs in response to different US parameters were measured and visualized by column chromatography and cryo-electron microscopy, respectively. By amalgamating these methodologies, we found that stable cavitation was sufficient for triggering uniform-loaded MBs to release their payload, but stable cavitation and inertial cavitation were required for cluster-loaded MBs. The released substances included free Dox and Dox-containing micelle/liposome; their portions depended on the payload distribution, acoustic pressure, cycle number, and sonication duration. Furthermore, we also revealed that the Dox-containing micelle/liposome in cluster-loaded MBs had the potential for multiple drug releases upon US sonication. This study compared uniform-loaded MBs and cluster-loaded MBs to enhance our comprehension of drug-loaded MBs mediated drug delivery.

Quantitative Pharmacokinetics Reveal Impact of Lipid Composition on Microbubble and Nanoprogeny Shell Fate

Microbubble-enabled focused ultrasound (MB-FUS) has revolutionized nano and molecular drug delivery capabilities. Yet, the absence of longitudinal, systematic, quantitative studies of microbubble shell pharmacokinetics hinders progress within the MB-FUS field. Microbubble radiolabeling challenges contribute to this void. This barrier is overcome by developing a one-pot, purification-free copper chelation protocol able to stably radiolabel diverse porphyrin-lipid-containing Definity® analogues (pDefs) with >95% efficiency while maintaining microbubble physicochemical properties. Five tri-modal (ultrasound-, positron emission tomography (PET)-, and fluorescent-active) [64 Cu]Cu-pDefs are created with varying lipid acyl chain length and charge, representing the most prevalently studied microbubble compositions. In vitro, C16 chain length microbubbles yield 2-3x smaller nanoprogeny than C18 microbubbles post FUS. In vivo, [64 Cu]Cu-pDefs are tracked in healthy and 4T1 tumor-bearing mice ± FUS over 48 h qualitatively through fluorescence imaging (to characterize particle disruption) and quantitatively through PET and γ-counting. These studies reveal the impact of microbubble composition and FUS on microbubble dissolution rates, shell circulation, off-target tissue retention (predominantly the liver and spleen), and FUS enhancement of tumor delivery. These findings yield pharmacokinetic microbubble structure-activity relationships that disrupt conventional knowledge, the implications of which on MB-FUS platform design, safety, and nanomedicine delivery are discussed.

Barrier-breaking effects of ultrasonic cavitation for drug delivery and biomarker release

Recently, emerging evidence has demonstrated that cavitation actually creates important bidirectional channels on biological barriers for both intratumoral drug delivery and extratumoral biomarker release. To promote the barrier-breaking effects of cavitation for both therapy and diagnosis, we first reviewed recent technical advances of ultrasound and its contrast agents (microbubbles, nanodroplets, and gas-stabilizing nanoparticles) and then reported the newly-revealed cavitation physical details. In particular, we summarized five types of cellular responses of cavitation in breaking the plasma membrane (membrane retraction, sonoporation, endocytosis/exocytosis, blebbing and apoptosis) and compared the vascular cavitation effects of three different types of ultrasound contrast agents in breaking the blood-tumor barrier and tumor microenvironment. Moreover, we highlighted the current achievements of the barrier-breaking effects of cavitation in mediating drug delivery and biomarker release. We emphasized that the precise induction of a specific cavitation effect for barrier-breaking was still challenged by the complex combination of multiple acoustic and non-acoustic cavitation parameters. Therefore, we provided the cutting-edge in-situ cavitation imaging and feedback control methods and suggested the development of an international cavitation quantification standard for the clinical guidance of cavitation-mediated barrier-breaking effects.

C. elegans: Sensing the low-frequency profile of amplitude-modulated ultrasound

Several research groups have demonstrated that C. elegans can respond to pulsed ultrasound stimuli, and elucidating the underlying mechanisms is necessary to develop ultrasound neuromodulation. Here, amplitude-modulated (AM) ultrasound is applied to C. elegans, and its behavioral responses are investigated in detail. By loading surface acoustic waves (SAWs) onto free-moving worms on an agar surface, a carrier wave with a frequency of 8.80 MHz is selected. The signal is modulated by a rectangular or sinusoidal profile. It is demonstrated that sinusoidal modulation can produce similar responses in worms to rectangular modulation, with the strongest responses occurring at modulation frequencies of around 1.00 kHz. Meanwhile, the behavioral response is relatively weak when the ultrasonic signal is unmodulated, that is, when only the carrier wave is applied. At modulation frequencies other than 100.00 Hz to 10.00 kHz, the worms respond weakly, but when a second modulation frequency of 1.00 kHz is introduced, an improvement in response can be observed. These results suggest that C. elegans may sense the low-frequency envelope and respond to amplitude-modulated ultrasonic stimuli like an amplitude demodulator. MEC-4, an ion channel for touch sensing, is involved in the behavioral response of C. elegans to ultrasound in the present setup.

Cavitation-assisted sonothrombolysis by asymmetrical nanostars for accelerated thrombolysis

Sonothrombolysis with recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rtPA) and microbubbles has been widely studied to enhance thrombolytic potential. Here, we report different sonothrombolysis strategy in nanoparticles using microbubbles cavitation. We found that different particles in shape exhibited different reactivity toward the cavitation, leading to a distinct sonothrombolytic potential. Two different gold nanoparticles in shape were functionalized with the rtPA: rtPA-functionalized gold nanospheres (NPt) and gold nanostars (NSt). NPt could not accelerate the thrombolytic potential with a sole acoustic stimulus. Importantly, NSt enhanced the potential with acoustic stimulus and microbubble-mediated cavitation, while NPt were not reactive to cavitation. Coadministration of NSt and microbubbles resulted in a dramatic reduction of the infarcts in a photothrombotic model and recovery in the cerebral blood flow. Given the synergistic effect and in vivo feasibility of this strategy, cavitation-assisted sonothrombolysis by asymmetrical NSt might be useful for treating acute ischemic stroke.

State-of-the-art of ultrasound-triggered drug delivery from ultrasound-responsive drug carriers

INTRODUCTION

The development of new tools to locally and non-invasively transferring therapeutic substances at the desired site in deep living tissue has been a long sought-after goal within the drug delivery field. Among the established methods, ultrasound (US) with US-responsive carriers holds great promise and demonstrates on-demand delivery of a variety of functional substances with spatial precision of several millimeters in deep-seated tissues in animal models and humans. These properties have motivated several explorations of US with US responsive carriers as a modality for neuromodulation and the treatment of various diseases, such as stroke and cancer.

AREAS COVERED

This article briefly discussed three specific mechanisms that enhance in vivo drug delivery via US with US-responsive carriers: 1) permeabilizing cellular membrane, 2) increasing the permeability of vessels, and 3) promoting cellular endocytotic uptake. Besides, a series of US-responsive drug carriers are discussed, with an emphasis on the relation between structural feature and therapeutic outcome.

EXPERT OPINION

This article summarized current development for each of US-responsive drug carrier, focusing on the routes of enhancing delivery and applications. The mechanisms of interaction between US-responsive carriers and US energy, such as cavitation, hyperthermia, and reactive oxygen species, as well as how these interactions can improve drug delivery into target cell/tissue. It can be expected that there are serval efforts to further identification of US-responsive particles, design of novel US waveform sequence, and survey of optimal combination between US parameters and US-responsive carriers for better controlling the spatiotemporal drug release profile, stability, and safety in vivo. The authors believe these will provide novel tools for precisely designing treatment strategies and significantly benefit the clinical management of several diseases.

Overcoming Hypoxia-Induced Drug Resistance via Promotion of Drug Uptake and Reoxygenation by Acousto–Mechanical Oxygen Delivery

Hypoxia-induced drug resistance (HDR) is a critical issue in cancer therapy. The presence of hypoxic tumor cells impedes drug uptake and reduces the cytotoxicity of chemotherapeutic drugs, leading to HDR and increasing the probability of tumor recurrence and metastasis. Microbubbles, which are used as an ultrasound contrast agent and drug/gas carrier, can locally deliver drugs/gas and produce an acousto–mechanical effect to enhance cell permeability under ultrasound sonication. The present study applied oxygen-loaded microbubbles (OMBs) to evaluate the mechanisms of overcoming HDR via promotion of drug uptake and reoxygenation. A hypoxic mouse prostate tumor cell model was established by hypoxic incubation for 4 h. After OMB treatment, the permeability of HDR cells was enhanced by 23 ± 5% and doxorubicin uptake was increased by 11 ± 7%. The 61 ± 14% reoxygenation of HDR cells increased the cytotoxicity of doxorubicin from 18 ± 4% to 58 ± 6%. In combination treatment with OMB and doxorubicin, the relative contributions of uptake promotion and reoxygenation towards overcoming HDR were 11 ± 7% and 28 ± 10%, respectively. Our study demonstrated that reoxygenation of hypoxic conditions is a critical mechanism in the inhibition of HDR and enhancing the outcome of OMB treatment.

Ultrasound Microbubbles Mediated Sonosensitizer and Antibody Co-delivery for Highly Efficient Synergistic Therapy on HER2-Positive Gastric Cancer

Trastuzumab combined with chemotherapy is the first-line treatment for advanced HER2-positive gastric cancer, but it still suffers from limited therapeutic efficiency and serious side effects, which are usually due to the poor delivery efficiency and the drug resistance of tumor cells to the chemotherapeutic drugs. Herein, a type of ultrasound microbubble for simultaneous delivery of sonosensitizers and therapeutic antibodies to achieve targeting combination of sonodynamic therapy and antibody therapy of HER2-positive gastric cancer was constructed from pyropheophorbide-lipid followed by trastuzumab conjugation (TP MBs). In vitro and in vivo studies showed that TP MBs had good biological safety, and their in vivo delivery can be monitored by ultrasound/fluorescence bimodal imaging. With ultrasound (US) located at the tumor area, TP MBs can be converted into nanoparticles (TP NPs) in situ by US-targeted microbubble destruction; plus the enhanced permeability and retention effects and the targeting effects of trastuzumab, the enrichment of sonosensitizers and antibodies in the tumor tissue can be greatly enhanced (∼2.1 times). When combined with ultrasound, TP MBs can not only increase the uptake of sonosensitizers in HER2-positive gastric cancer NCI-N87 cells but also efficiently generate singlet oxygen to greatly increase the killing effect on cells, obviously inhibiting the tumor growth in HER2-positive gastric cancer NCI-N87 cell models with a tumor inhibition rate up to 79.3%. Overall, TP MBs combined with US provided an efficient way for co-delivery of sonosensitizers and antibodies, greatly enhancing the synergistic therapeutic effect on HER2-positive gastric cancer while effectively reducing the side effects.

Preparation, characterization, and antibacterial activity of tigecycline-loaded, ultrasound-activated microbubbles

Central nervous system infectious disease caused by the multidrug-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii (AB) seriously threatens human life in clinic. Tigecycline has good sensitivity in killing AB, but due to its wide tissue distribution and blood-brain barrier, concentration in cerebrospinal fluid is low, therefore, the clinical effect is limited. Herein, we designed micro-bubbled tigecycline, aimed to enhance its anti-MDRAB effects under ultrasound. The lipid microbubbles with different ratios of lipids to drugs (a ratio of 10:1, 20:1, and 40:1) were prepared by the mechanical shaking method. The morphology, zeta potential and particle size of microbubbles were tested to screen out the much better formulation. Encapsulation efficiency and drug loading amount were determined by ultracentrifugation combined with high-performance liquid chromatography. Then the in vitro antibacterial activity against AB was conducted using the selected ultrasound-activated microbubble. Results showed the selected microbubbles with high encapsulation efficiency and good stability. The mechanical shaking method is feasible for preparation of drug-loaded and ultrasound-activated lipid microbubbles. Using 0.2 mg/mL microbubbles, combined with 1 MHz, 2.5 W/cm² and 1 min of ultrasound exhibited a potent anit-AB in vitro. This study indicates that tigecycline treatment in form of ultrasound-activated microbubble is a promising strategy against AB infections.

Ultrasonic technologies in imaging and drug delivery

Ultrasonic technologies show great promise for diagnostic imaging and drug delivery in theranostic applications. The development of functional and molecular ultrasound imaging is based on the technical breakthrough of high frame-rate ultrasound. The evolution of shear wave elastography, high-frequency ultrasound imaging, ultrasound contrast imaging, and super-resolution blood flow imaging are described in this review. Recently, the therapeutic potential of the interaction of ultrasound with microbubble cavitation or droplet vaporization has become recognized. Microbubbles and phase-change droplets not only provide effective contrast media, but also show great therapeutic potential. Interaction with ultrasound induces unique and distinguishable biophysical features in microbubbles and droplets that promote drug loading and delivery. In particular, this approach demonstrates potential for central nervous system applications. Here, we systemically review the technological developments of theranostic ultrasound including novel ultrasound imaging techniques, the synergetic use of ultrasound with microbubbles and droplets, and microbubble/droplet drug-loading strategies for anticancer applications and disease modulation. These advancements have transformed ultrasound from a purely diagnostic utility into a promising theranostic tool.