Performance evaluation of the Vela Dx Sentosa next-generation sequencing system for HIV-1 DNA genotypic resistance

HIV-1 genotypic resistance testing using single molecule real-time sequencing

BACKGROUND

HIV-1 resistance testing is recommended in clinical management and next-generation sequencing (NGS) methods are now available in many virology laboratories.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the diagnostic performance of Long-Read Single Molecule Real-time (SMRT) sequencing (Sequel, PacBio) for HIV-1 polymerase genotyping.

STUDY DESIGN

111 prospective clinical samples (83 plasma and 28 leukocyte-enriched blood fraction) were analyzed for routine HIV-1 resistance genotyping using Sanger sequencing, Vela NGS, and SMRT sequencing. We developed a SMRT sequencing protocol and a bio-informatics pipeline to infer antiretroviral resistance on both haplotype and variant calling approaches.

RESULTS

The polymerase was successfully sequenced by the three platforms in 98 % of plasma RNA samples for viral loads above 4 log copies/mL. The success rate decreased to 83 % using Sanger or Vela sequencing and to 67 % using SMRT sequencing for viral loads of 3 to 4 log copies/mL. Sensitivities of 50 %, 54 % and 61 % were obtained using SMRT, Vela, and Sanger sequencing, respectively, in cellular DNA from patients with prolonged undetectable plasma HIV-1 RNA. Ninety-eight percent of resistance-associated mutations (RAMs) identified with Sanger sequencing were detected using SMRT sequencing. Furthermore, 91 % of RAMs (> 5 % threshold) identified with Vela NGS were detected using SMRT sequencing. RAM quantification using Vela and SMRT sequencing was well correlated (Spearman correlation ρ = 0.82; P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

SMRT sequencing of the full-length HIV-1 polymerase appeared performant for characterizing HIV-1 genotypic resistance on both RNA and DNA clinical samples. Long-read sequencing is a new tool for mutation haplotyping and resistance analysis.

Optimization of HIV Sequencing Method Using Vela Sentosa Library on Miseq Ilumina Platform

Genotypic testing is often recommended to improve the management of patients infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). To help combat this major pandemic, next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques are widely used to analyse resistance to antiretroviral drugs. In this study, we used a Vela Sentosa kit (Vela Diagnostics, Kendall, Singapore), which is usually used for the Ion Torrent personal genome machine (PGM) platform, to sequence HIV using the Illumina Miseq platform. After RNA extraction and reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), minor modifications were applied to the Vela Sentosa kit to adapt it to the Illumina Miseq platform. Analysis of the results showed the same mutations present in the samples using both sequencing platforms. The total number of reads varied from 185,069 to 752,343 and from 642,162 to 2,074,028 in the Ion Torrent PGM platform and the Illumina Miseq platform, respectively. The average depth was 21,955 and 46,856 for Ion Torrent PGM and Illumina Miseq platforms, respectively. The cost of sequencing a run of eight samples was quite similar between the two platforms (about USD 1790 for Illumina Miseq and about USD 1833 for Ion Torrent PGM platform). We have shown for the first time that it is possible to adapt and use the Vela Sentosa kit for the Illumina Miseq platform to obtain high-quality results with a similar cost.

Need assessment for HIV drug resistance testing and landscape of current and future technologies in low- and middle-income countries

Resistance to antiretroviral drugs used to treat HIV is an important and evolving concern, particularly in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) which have been impacted to the greatest extent by the HIV pandemic. Efforts to monitor the emergence and transmission of resistance over the past decade have shown that drug resistance-especially to the nucleoside analogue and non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors-can (and have) increased to levels that can jeopardize the efficacy of available treatment options at the population level. The global shift to integrase-based regimens as the preferred first-line therapy as well as technological advancements in the methods for detecting resistance have had an impact in broadening and diversifying the landscape of and use case for HIV drug resistance testing. This review estimates the potential demand for HIV drug resistance tests, and surveys current testing methodologies, with a focus on their application in LMICs.

Sensitive HIV-1 DNA Pol Next-Generation Sequencing for the Characterisation of Archived Antiretroviral Drug Resistance

Modern HIV-1 treatment effectively suppresses viral amplification in people living with HIV. However, the persistence of HIV-1 DNA as proviruses integrated into the human genome remains the main barrier to achieving a cure. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) offers increased sensitivity for characterising archived drug resistance mutations (DRMs) in HIV-1 DNA for improved treatment options. In this study, we present an ultra-sensitive targeted PCR assay coupled with NGS and a robust pipeline to characterise HIV-1 DNA DRMs from buffy coat samples. Our evaluation supports the use of this assay for Pan-HIV-1 analyses with reliable detection of DRMs across the HIV-1 Pol region. We propose this assay as a new valuable tool for monitoring archived HIV-1 drug resistance in virologically suppressed individuals, especially in clinical trials investigating novel therapeutic approaches.

HIV-1 RNA and DNA genotyping drug resistance detection in patients with low-level viremia in Liangshan, China

In this study, we characterized HIV-1 RNA and HIV-1 DNA genotyping drug resistance detection in patients with low-level viremia in Liangshan, China. Whole blood samples were collected from HIV/AIDS patients who had received anti-retroviral therapy for more than six months and whose HIV-1 RNA loads were 50-1000 copies/mL for two consecutive times at least one month apart. The patients were enrolled from a county in Liangshan Yi Autonomous Prefecture, Sichuan Province between May 2021 and May 2022. Plasma and blood cells were separated. Plasma samples were tested for HIV-1 RNA genotyping drug resistance, while blood cell samples were tested for HIV-1 DNA genotyping drug resistance. Then, HIV-1 RNA and HIV-1 DNA genotyping drug resistance outcomes were compared. Among the 32 participants, 16 were males while 16 were females; with the median age of 34.5 years. The main HIV-1 infection route was heterosexual transmission. The median anti-retroviral therapy duration was 3.9 years. Two types of nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTIs) + one non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTIs) were the main antiviral therapeutic options. Pol region genes for 28 HIV-1 DNA samples and 10 HIV-1 RNA samples were successfully amplified. The success rate of pol region genes amplification for HIV-1 DNA was significantly higher than that of HIV-1 RNA (χ2 = 20.988, P < 0.05). In HIV-1 RNA and HIV-1 DNA samples, M184 (4/8) and K103 (3/8) were the most frequent drug resistance mutation sites. Among the NNRTIs, the rates of drug resistance were highest to EFV (6/8) and NVP (6/8) while among the NRTIs, the rates of drug resistance were highest to ABC (4/8), FTC (4/8) and 3TC (4/8). In conclusion, detection of HIV-1 RNA genotyping drug resistance combined with HIV-1 DNA genotyping drug resistance can improve the success rate of drug resistance detection in patients with low-level viremia.

Prevalence of Drug Resistance and Genetic Transmission Networks Among Human Immunodeficiency Virus/Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome Patients with Antiretroviral Therapy Failure in Guangxi, China

Prevalence of drug resistance (DR) challenges the epidemic control of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1. However, little is known about DR among patients with antiretroviral therapy (ART) failure in Guangxi province, China. This cross-sectional study was aimed to investigate the prevalence of DR and the characteristics of DR sequences in the genetic transmission network among HIV-1 patients with ART failure in Guangxi. We enrolled 358 eligible patients between 2012 and 2018. Blood samples were subjected to reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction, followed by sequencing of the HIV-1 polymerase (pol) gene. An online subtyping tool and neighbor-joining phylogenetic tree were used to determine the genotype. HIV-TRACE tool was used to constructed transmission network with a pairwise genetic distance of 0.013. DR was analyzed using the Stanford University HIV Drug Resistance Database. We obtained 293 pol-sequences from participants; CRF01_AE (75.4%), CRF 08_BC (15.7%), and CRF07_BC (8.5%) were the main subtypes, and an A1 subtype was detected in Guangxi for the first time. The overall prevalence of DR was 32.4% (95/293). Among those with identified DR, 25.6% were against non-nucleoside analog reverse-transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTIs), 17.7% were against nucleoside analog reverse-transcriptase inhibitors (NRTIs), and 14.3% were against both NRTIs and NNRTIs. The common drug-resistant mutations were M184V (10.2%), K103N (10.6%) and V179D (6.1%). The patients located in the southern Guangxi [adjust odds ratio (AOR) = 10.87], or whose blood plasma were taken in 2017-2018 (AOR = 3.98) had an increased risk of DR. Of the CRF01_AE, CRF07_BC, and CRF08_BC sequences, 18.6%, 8.0%, and 13.0% fell into clusters, respectively. Nine (9.7%) sequences from patients with DR fell into three clusters. The largest cluster containing 11 individuals was the CRF01_AE subtype, 27.3% of whom were DR patients. Although the prevalence of DR among ART failure patients in Guangxi was at a low level, the continuous surveillance of DR in ART patients is necessary.

HIV-1 Drug Resistance Assay Using Ion Torrent Next Generation Sequencing and On-Instrument End-to-End Analysis Software

HIV-1 antiretroviral therapy management requires sequencing the protease, reverse transcriptase, and integrase portions of the HIV-1 pol gene. Most resistance testing is performed with Sanger sequencing, which has limited ability to detect minor variants. Next generation sequencing (NGS) platforms enable variant detection at frequencies as low as 1% allowing for earlier detection of resistance and modification of therapy. Implementation of NGS assays in the clinical laboratory is hindered by complicated assay design, cumbersome wet bench procedures, and the complexity of data analysis and bioinformatics. We developed a complete NGS protocol and companion analysis and reporting pipeline using AmpliSeq multiplex PCR, Ion Torrent S5 XL sequencing, and Stanford's HIVdb resistance algorithm. Implemented as a Torrent Suite software plugin, the pipeline runs automatically after sequencing. An optimum variant frequency threshold of 10% was determined by comparing Sanger sequences of archived samples from ViroSeq testing, resulting in a sensitivity of 98.2% and specificity of 99.0%. The majority (91%) of drug resistance mutations were detected by both Sanger and NGS, with 1.7% only by Sanger and 7.3% only by NGS. Variant calls were highly reproducible and there was no cross-reactivity to VZV, HBV, CMV, EBV, and HCV. The limit of detection was 500 copies/mL. The NGS assay performance was comparable to ViroSeq Sanger sequencing and has several advantages, including a publicly available end-to-end analysis and reporting plugin. The assay provides a straightforward path for implementation of NGS for HIV drug resistance testing in the laboratory setting without additional investment in bioinformatics infrastructure and resources.

Analytical Assessment of the Vela Diagnostics NGS Assay for HIV Genotyping and Resistance Testing: The Apulian Experience

Drug-resistance monitoring is one of the hardest challenges in HIV management. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies speed up the detection of drug resistance, allowing the adjustment of antiretroviral therapy and enhancing the quality of life of people living with HIV. Recently, the NGS Sentosa^® SQ HIV Genotyping Assay (Vela Diagnostics) received approval for in vitro diagnostics use. This work is the first Italian evaluation of the performance of the Vela Diagnostics NGS platform, assessed with 420 HIV-1 clinical samples. A comparison with Sanger sequencing performance is also reported, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of the Sentosa^® NGS assay. The precision of the technology was studied with reference specimens, while intra- and inter-assay reproducibility were evaluated for selected clinical samples. Vela Diagnostics’ NGS assay reached an 87% success rate through 30 runs of analysis in a real-world clinical context. The concordance with Sanger sequencing outcomes was equal to 97.2%. Several detected mismatches were due to NGS’s superior sensitivity to low-frequency variants. A high accuracy was observed in testing reference samples. Repeatability and reproducibility assays highlighted the good performance of the NGS platform. Beyond a few technical issues that call for further optimization, the key improvement will be a better balance between costs and processing speed. Once these issues have been solved, the Sentosa^® SQ HIV Genotyping Assay will be the way forward for HIV resistance testing.

Implementation of an interactive mobile application to pilot a rapid assay to detect HIV drug resistance mutations in Kenya

Usability is an overlooked aspect of implementing lab-based assays, particularly novel assays in low-resource-settings. Esoteric instructions can lead to irreproducible test results and patient harm. To address these issues, we developed a software application based on "Aquarium", a laboratory-operating system run on a computer tablet that provides step-by-step digital interactive instructions, protocol management, and sample tracking. Aquarium was paired with a near point-of-care HIV drug resistance test, "OLA-Simple", that detects mutations associated with virologic failure. In this observational study we evaluated the performance of Aquarium in guiding untrained users through the multi-step laboratory protocol with little supervision. To evaluate the training by Aquarium software we conducted a feasibility study in a laboratory at Coptic Hope Center in Nairobi, Kenya. Twelve volunteers who were unfamiliar with the kit performed the test on blinded samples (2 blood specimens; 5 codons/sample). Steps guided by Aquarium included: CD4+ T-Cell separation, PCR, ligation, detection, and interpretation of test results. Participants filled out a short survey regarding their demographics and experience with the software and kit. None of the laboratory technicians had prior experience performing CD4+ separation and 7/12 had no experience performing laboratory-based molecular assays. 12/12 isolated CD4+ T cells from whole blood with yields comparable to isolations performed by trained personnel. The OLA-Simple workflow was completed by all, with genotyping results interpreted correctly by unaided-eye in 108/120 (90%) and by software in 116/120 (97%) of codons analyzed. In the surveys, participants favorably assessed the use of software guidance. The Aquarium digital instructions enabled first-time users in Kenya to complete the OLA-simple kit workflow with minimal training. Aquarium could increase the accessibility of laboratory assays in low-resource-settings and potentially standardize implementation of clinical laboratory tests.

Implementation of an interactive mobile application to pilot a rapid assay to detect HIV drug resistance mutations in Kenya

Usability is an overlooked aspect of implementing lab-based assays, particularly novel assays in low-resource-settings. Esoteric instructions can lead to irreproducible test results and patient harm. To address these issues, we developed a software application based on "Aquarium", a laboratory-operating system run on a computer tablet that provides step-by-step digital interactive instructions, protocol management, and sample tracking. Aquarium was paired with a near point-of-care HIV drug resistance test, "OLA-Simple", that detects mutations associated with virologic failure. In this observational study we evaluated the performance of Aquarium in guiding untrained users through the multi-step laboratory protocol with little supervision. To evaluate the training by Aquarium software we conducted a feasibility study in a laboratory at Coptic Hope Center in Nairobi, Kenya. Twelve volunteers who were unfamiliar with the kit performed the test on blinded samples (2 blood specimens; 5 codons/sample). Steps guided by Aquarium included: CD4+ T-Cell separation, PCR, ligation, detection, and interpretation of test results. Participants filled out a short survey regarding their demographics and experience with the software and kit. None of the laboratory technicians had prior experience performing CD4+ separation and 7/12 had no experience performing laboratory-based molecular assays. 12/12 isolated CD4+ T cells from whole blood with yields comparable to isolations performed by trained personnel. The OLA-Simple workflow was completed by all, with genotyping results interpreted correctly by unaided-eye in 108/120 (90%) and by software in 116/120 (97%) of codons analyzed. In the surveys, participants favorably assessed the use of software guidance. The Aquarium digital instructions enabled first-time users in Kenya to complete the OLA-simple kit workflow with minimal training. Aquarium could increase the accessibility of laboratory assays in low-resource-settings and potentially standardize implementation of clinical laboratory tests.

Dry Panels Supporting External Quality Assessment Programs for Next Generation Sequencing-Based HIV Drug Resistance Testing

External quality assessment (EQA) is a keystone element in the validation and implementation of next generation sequencing (NGS)-based HIV drug resistance testing (DRT). Software validation and evaluation is a critical element in NGS EQA programs. While the development, sharing, and adoption of wet lab protocols is coupled with the increasing access to NGS technology worldwide, rendering it easy to produce NGS data for HIV-DRT, bioinformatic data analysis remains a bottleneck for most of the diagnostic laboratories. Several computational tools have been made available, via free or commercial sources, to automate the conversion of raw NGS data into an actionable clinical report. Although different software platforms yield equivalent results when identical raw NGS datasets are analyzed for variations at higher abundance, discrepancies arise when variations at lower frequencies are considered. This implies that validation and performance assessment of the bioinformatics tools applied in NGS HIV-DRT is critical, and the origins of the observed discrepancies should be determined. Well-characterized reference NGS datasets with ground truth on the genotype composition at all examined loci and the exact frequencies of HIV variations they may harbor, so-called dry panels, would be essential in such cases. The strategic design and construction of such panels are challenging but imperative tasks in support of EQA programs for NGS-based HIV-DRT and the validation of relevant bioinformatics tools. Here, we present criteria that can guide the design of such dry panels, which were discussed in the Second International Winnipeg Symposium themed for EQA strategies for NGS HIVDR assays.

Are We Ready for NGS HIV Drug Resistance Testing? The Second "Winnipeg Consensus" Symposium

HIV drug resistance is a major global challenge to successful and sustainable antiretroviral therapy. Next-generation sequencing (NGS)-based HIV drug resistance (HIVDR) assays enable more sensitive and quantitative detection of drug-resistance-associated mutations (DRMs) and outperform Sanger sequencing approaches in detecting lower abundance resistance mutations. While NGS is likely to become the new standard for routine HIVDR testing, many technical and knowledge gaps remain to be resolved before its generalized adoption in regular clinical care, public health, and research. Recognizing this, we conceived and launched an international symposium series on NGS HIVDR, to bring together leading experts in the field to address these issues through in-depth discussions and brainstorming. Following the first symposium in 2018 (Winnipeg, MB Canada, 21-22 February, 2018), a second "Winnipeg Consensus" symposium was held in September 2019 in Winnipeg, Canada, and was focused on external quality assurance strategies for NGS HIVDR assays. In this paper, we summarize this second symposium's goals and highlights.

Development of a new comprehensive HIV-1 genotypic drug resistance assay for all commercially available reverse transcriptase, protease and integrase inhibitors in patients infected with group M HIV-1 strains

Comprehensive PCR assays for the genotypic drug resistance analysis of all HIV-1 antiretroviral agents (reverse transcriptase, protease and integrase inhibitors) are increasingly in demand due to introduction of integrase inhibitors in the first line regimens and the increasing presence of non-B HIV-1 clades around the world. This study focused on the development and evaluation of a new PCR-based assay for the amplification and sequencing of the entire HIV-1 pol region of major circulating group M HIV-1 strains in Europe for genotypic drug resistance analysis. The comprehensive touchdown PCR assay developed in this study utilized HIV-1 RNA extracted from the plasma of blood samples of consenting HIV-1 infected patients in Cyprus, collected from 2017 to 2019. The HIV-1 pol region was amplified by touchdown PCR for both the primary RT-PCR and the secondary PCR steps. Successful PCR amplicons were determined by population DNA sequencing, using the Sanger method and the genotypic drug resistance analysis was performed with the Stanford University HIV Drug Resistance Database Program. The newly developed assay successfully amplified the entire HIV-1 pol region (2844 nucleotides long) of 141 out of 144 samples of group M HIV-1 subtypes and recombinant strains of the Cyprus HIV-1 Transmission Cohort Study (CHICS) isolated from 2017 to 2019 and genotypic analyses were conducted for all currently available HIV-1 reverse transcriptase, protease and integrase inhibitors. The drug resistance, epidemiological and demographic data of these study subjects will be expanded upon in the CHICS (L.G. Kostrikis et al., manuscript in preparation for publication). The newly developed HIV-1 genotypic drug resistance assay would benefit clinical settings, and research focusing on the world-wide spread of HIV-1 drug-resistant strains, especially in geographic regions characterized by polyphyletic HIV-1 infections.