A comparative study of KOH test, PAS staining and fungal culture in diagnosis of onychomycosis in Taiwan

Comparison of diagnostic methods in onychomycosis

Aim: Onychomycosis is a chronic fungal infection of the nail bed, plate, or matrix. This study aimed to compare the sensitivity of three diagnostic methods in the diagnosis of onychomycosis. Material and Method: This study included 39 patients with a clinical diagnosis of onychomycosis of the toenails, who presented to Medipol Mega University Hospital between May 2019 and August 2022. Using the nail samples taken from the patients, the results of the direct microscopic examination with standard potassium hydroxide (KOH), histopathological examination performed with periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) staining, and fungal agents that grew in fungal culture were noted. Results: Eleven (28.2%) patients were female, and 28 (71.8%) were male, with the mean age being 43.1±13.9 years. Of the patients, 53.8% had distal subungual onychomycosis and 46.2% had total subungual onychomycosis. The mean disease duration was 38.8±24.5 (12-120) months. Fungal infection was detected on direct microscopic examination with standard KOH in 66.7% of the patients, culture growth in 38.5%, and PAS staining on histopathological examination in 71.8%, and the sensitivities of these methods were determined as 74.3%, 49.2%, and 80%, respectively, with the negative predictive values being 30.8%, 16.7%, and 36.4%, respectively. Conclusion: Among the investigated methods, histopathological examination with PAS staining was found to have the highest sensitivity and negative predictive value in the diagnosis of onychomycosis.

Diagnosing Onychomycosis: What’s New?

An overview of the long-established methods of diagnosing onychomycosis (potassium hydroxide testing, fungal culture, and histopathological examination) is provided followed by an outline of other diagnostic methods currently in use or under development. These methods generally use one of two diagnostic techniques: visual identification of infection (fungal elements or onychomycosis signs) or organism identification (typing of fungal genus/species). Visual diagnosis (dermoscopy, optical coherence tomography, confocal microscopy, UV fluorescence excitation) provides clinical evidence of infection, but may be limited by lack of organism information when treatment decisions are needed. The organism identification methods (lateral flow techniques, polymerase chain reaction, MALDI-TOF mass spectroscopy and Raman spectroscopy) seek to provide faster and more reliable identification than standard fungal culture methods. Additionally, artificial intelligence methods are being applied to assist with visual identification, with good success. Despite being considered the ‘gold standard’ for diagnosis, clinicians are generally well aware that the established methods have many limitations for diagnosis. The new techniques seek to augment established methods, but also have advantages and disadvantages relative to their diagnostic use. It remains to be seen which of the newer methods will become more widely used for diagnosis of onychomycosis. Clinicians need to be aware of the limitations of diagnostic utility calculations as well, and look beyond the numbers to assess which techniques will provide the best options for patient assessment and management.

Pathology of the Nail Unit

This article discusses the histologic findings in key nail unit diseases, including inflammatory, infectious, and neoplastic conditions. The emphasis is on clinicopathologic correlates, best practices to demonstrate the relevant histopathologic features, and pitfalls in diagnosis. Understanding the pathology of these disorders enhances clinical acumen and may affect the choice of biopsy procedures and treatment measures, with the outcome of better clinical care for patients with nail disease.

Direct examination, histopathology and fungal culture for the diagnosis of onychomycosis: A retrospective, comparative study on 2245 specimens

BACKGROUND

Onychomycosis affects 5.5% of the general population and represents up to 50% of all nail diseases. Diagnosis and pathogen identification are essential in order to plan an adequate treatment. Many diagnostic techniques are available, and however, no solid data regarding comparison between different techniques over a large number of specimens are available to date.

OBJECTIVES

To compare sensitivity and specificity of direct examination, histopathology and fungal culture in our referral mycology laboratory.

METHODS

Nail specimens received at the cutaneous pathology and mycology laboratory of the University Hospital Saint-Pierre (Brussels, Belgium) between 1 January and 15 May 2018 were retrospectively analysed. All specimens were submitted to direct examination and culture. In cases of adequate specimen size, histopathology was performed. Fungal culture was considered the gold standard for diagnosis.

RESULTS

A total of 2245 nail samples were included in the study. Onychomycosis was diagnosed in 1266 specimens. Sensitivity and positive predictive value were found to be higher for direct examination compared to histopathology, while sensitivity of direct examination was found to be lower. Combined approach with all the three techniques showed the highest rate of positivity, followed by the association of direct examination and histopathology.

CONCLUSIONS

To our knowledge, this study included the largest number of nail specimens to date, allowing a comparison between direct examination, culture and histopathology. Direct examination showed to be the most performing technique in routine practice. Histopathology represents the most effective option in cases where both specimen size and laboratory resources are adequate. Our paper adds to the literature the 'real-life' experience of the mycology laboratory of a referral centre for nail diseases.

PAS and GMS utility in dermatopathology: Review of the current medical literature

The American Society of Dermatopathology has established an Appropriate Use Criteria (AUC) Committee with the intention of establishing evidence-based recommendations regarding the appropriateness of various ancillary tests commonly utilized by dermatopathologists. Periodic acid Schiff (PAS) and Grocott (or Gomori) methenamine silver (GMS) stains represent some of the most commonly employed ancillary tests in dermatopathology. The utility of these tests was targeted for evaluation by the AUC. This literature review represents a comprehensive evaluation of available evidence for the utility of PAS and/or GMS staining of skin and nail biopsies. In concert with expert opinion, these data will be incorporated into future recommendations by the AUC for PAS and GMS staining in routine dermatopathology practice.

[Evaluation of the usefulness of nail biopsy in the diagnosis of onychomycosis]

BACKGROUND

Onychomycosis affects between 2% to 30% of the world population. Nail biopsy may help in making a diagnosis and can distinguish between invasion and colonisation.

AIMS

To evaluate the diagnostic usefulness of nail biopsy with Periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) staining for onychomycosis, compared to direct KOH examination, culture and its combination in a reference laboratory in Colombia.

METHODS

The study included 66 patients in whom a blind and independent reading of the three tests was performed. The usefulness was defined based on the validity (sensitivity, specificity, Youden's index, likelihood ratios), performance (predictive values) efficiency (proportion of correctly diagnosed patients), and reproducibility (kappa coefficient).

RESULTS

The mean age of the patients was 55±16 years, and included 76% women. The direct tests with KOH were positive in 66.7% (n=44), 62.1% (n=41) were positive with culture, and 56.1% (n=37) with the biopsy. The main causal agents were non-dermatophytes moulds in 36.4% (n=24). The most frequent species were Neoscytalidium dimidiatum (n=11), Trichophyton rubrum (n=11), and Candida parapsilosis (n=13). The sensitivity of nail biopsy, when compared to the standard (KOH and/or culture), was 71%, specificity 83%, Youden's index 0.54, positive likelihood ratio 4.25, negative likelihood ratio 0.35, positive predictive value 92%, negative predictive value 52%, efficiency 74% and kappa coefficient 0.45. When biopsy was evaluated only in patients with onycholysis of the nail plate greater than 50%, all the parameters of diagnostic usefulness increased.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall usefulness of the biopsy was moderate for patients with more severe symptomatology, which makes its use advisable in cases of extensive onycholysis, and when discriminating colonisation from invasion is required.

Inhibitory Effects of Berberine Hydrochloride on Trichophyton mentagrophytes and the Underlying Mechanisms

BACKGROUND

T. mentagrophytes can infect all mammals, including rabbits, causing serious infections with remarkable economic losses for rabbit farmers. Berberine is an alkaloid that is effective against a variety of microbial infections such as T. mentagrophytes. Growth curve by dry weight determination and in-vivo antifungal assay were carried out to clarify the inhibitory effect of berberine hydrochloride against T. mentagrophytes. Transcriptomics analyses were also carried out for better understanding of the underlying mechanisms.

RESULTS

The growth rate of T. mentagrophytes was significantly higher in control condition than under berberine hydrochloride or clotrimazole for 60 h. The growth rate of T. mentagrophytes was significantly slighter higher in berberine condition (1 mg) than under clotrimazole for 46 h. T. mentagrophytes seriously shrunk after berberine or clotrimazole treatment, as observed by TEM and in SEM. Significant recovery was evident in three berberine groups on day 6 compared with the DMSO group. Results from transcriptomics analyses showed 18,881 identified unigenes, including 18,754 and 12,127 in the NT and SwissProt databases. Among these, 12,011, 9174, and 11,679 unigenes belonged to 3 Gene Ontology (GO), 43 KEGG, and 25 KOG categories, respectively. Interestingly, we found that down-regulation of 14α-demethylase exposed to various medicines was slightly different, i.e., berberine hydrochloride (fold change -3.4956) and clotrimazole (fold change -2.1283) caused various degrees of alteration.

CONCLUSIONS

Berberine hydrochloride could inhibit the growth of T. mentagrophytes. Berberine hydrochloride could also cure dermatosis induced by T. mentagrophytes. Down-regulation of 14α-demethylase exposed to various medicines was slightly different and might be one of the anti-resistance mechanisms of berberine hydrochloride in T. mentagrophytes. The present investigation provides considerable transcript sequence data that would help further assess the antifungal mechanisms against T. mentagrophytes, for antifungal medicine development.

Meta-analysis of the utility of culture, biopsy, and direct KOH examination for the diagnosis of onychomycosis

Background

Onychomycosis is a highly prevalent disease worldwide. There is no standard test for its diagnosis, which remains costly, wasteful, and is sometimes delayed. The diagnostic tests for this disease are few and discordant. The objective was to evaluate the diagnostic validity, performance, and accuracy of culture, nail clipping with Periodic Acid-Schiff –PAS- staining (biopsy), and direct potassium hydroxide (KOH) examination for the study of onychomycosis.

Methods

A systematic review was conducted via meta-analysis using 5 databases and 21 search strategies. An ex ante protocol was applied with inclusion and exclusion criteria. Quality was assessed with the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS) tool, and the sensitivity, specificity, predictive values, likelihood ratios, diagnostic odds ratios, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves, and proportion of correctly diagnosed patients were evaluated with the meta-analysis of studies of evaluations of diagnostic and screening tests (Meta-DiSc) and Epidat using a random effects model.

Results

The efficiency or accuracy of the three tests is influenced by the methodological quality of the studies. These values are lower for KOH and culture and higher for biopsy in moderate quality studies.

Conclusion

The diagnostic tests evaluated in this meta-analysis independently showed acceptable validity, performance, and efficiency, with nail clipping with PAS staining outperforming the other two tests.

Tinea incognito in Korea and its risk factors: nine-year multicenter survey

Tinea incognito (TI) is a dermatophytic infection which has lost its typical clinical appearance because of improper use of steroids or calcineurin inhibitors. The incidence of TI is increasing nowadays. We conducted retrospective review on 283 patients with TI from 25 dermatology training hospitals in Korea from 2002-2010 to investigate the demographical, clinical, and mycological characteristics of TI, and to determine the associated risk factors. More than half (59.3%) patients were previously treated by non-dermatologists or self-treated. The mean duration of TI was 15.0 ± 25.3 months. The most common clinical manifestations were eczema-like lesion, psoriasis-like, and lupus erythematosus-like lesion. The trunk and face were frequently involved, and 91 patients (32.2%) also had coexisting fungal infections. Among 67 isolated strains, Trichophyton rubrum was the most frequently detected (73.1%). This is the largest study of TI reported to date and the first investigational report concerning TI in Korea. We suggest that doctors should consider TI when a patient has intractable eczema-like lesions accompanied by tinea pedis/unguium. Furthermore, there should be a policy change, which would make over-the-counter high-potency topical steroids less accessible in some countries, including Korea.