Optimization and comparison of two methods for spike train estimation in an unfused tetanic contraction of low threshold motor units

Spatial decomposition of ultrafast ultrasound images to identify motor unit activity - A comparative study with intramuscular and surface EMG

The smallest voluntarily controlled structure of the human body is the motor unit (MU), comprised of a motoneuron and its innervated fibres. MUs have been investigated in neurophysiology research and clinical applications, primarily using electromyographic (EMG) techniques. Nonetheless, EMG (both surface and intramuscular) has a limited detection volume. A recent alternative approach to detect MUs is ultrafast ultrasound (UUS) imaging. The possibility of identifying MU activity from UUS has been shown by blind source separation (BSS) of UUS images, using optimal separation spatial filters. However, this approach has yet to be fully compared with EMG techniques for a large population of unique MU spike trains. Here we identify individual MU activity in UUS images using the BSS method for 401 MU spike trains from eleven participants based on concurrent recordings of either surface or intramuscular EMG from forces up to 30% of the maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) force. We assessed the BSS method's ability to identify MU spike trains from direct comparison with the EMG-derived spike trains as well as twitch areas and temporal profiles from comparison with the spike-triggered-averaged UUS images when using the EMG-derived spikes as triggers. We found a moderate rate of correctly identified spikes (53.0 ± 16.0%) with respect to the EMG-identified firings. However, the MU twitch areas and temporal profiles could still be identified accurately, including at 30% MVC force. These results suggest that the current BSS methods for UUS can accurately identify the location and average twitch of a large pool of MUs in UUS images, providing potential avenues for studying neuromechanics from a large cross-section of the muscle. On the other hand, more advanced methods are needed to address the convolutive and partly non-linear summation of velocities for recovering the full spike trains.

Spatially repeatable components from ultrafast ultrasound are associated with motor unit activity in human isometric contractions. J Neural Eng 2023;20:046016. [PMID: 37437598 DOI: 10.1088/1741-2552/ace6fc]

Objective.Ultrafast ultrasound (UUS) imaging has been used to detect intramuscular mechanical dynamics associated with single motor units (MUs). Detecting MUs from ultrasound sequences requires decomposing a velocity field into components, each consisting of an image and a signal. These components can be associated with putative MU activity or spurious movements (noise). The differentiation between putative MUs and noise has been accomplished by comparing the signals with MU firings obtained from needle electromyography (EMG). Here, we examined whether the repeatability of the images over brief time intervals can serve as a criterion for distinguishing putative MUs from noise in low-force isometric contractions.Approach.UUS images and high-density surface EMG (HDsEMG) were recorded simultaneously from 99 MUs in the biceps brachii of five healthy subjects. The MUs identified through HDsEMG decomposition were used as a reference to assess the outcomes of the ultrasound-based components. For each contraction, velocity sequences from the same eight-second ultrasound recording were separated into consecutive two-second epochs and decomposed. To evaluate the repeatability of components' images across epochs, we calculated the Jaccard similarity coefficient (JSC). JSC compares the similarity between two images providing values between 0 and 1. Finally, the association between the components and the MUs from HDsEMG was assessed.Main results.All the MU-matched components had JSC > 0.38, indicating they were repeatable and accounted for about one-third of the HDsEMG-detected MUs (1.8 ± 1.6 matches over 4.9 ± 1.8 MUs). The repeatable components (JSC > 0.38) represented 14% of the total components (6.5 ± 3.3 components). These findings align with our hypothesis that intra-sequence repeatability can differentiate putative MUs from noise and can be used for data reduction.Significance.This study provides the foundation for developing stand-alone methods to identify MU in UUS sequences and towards real-time imaging of MUs. These methods are relevant for studying muscle neuromechanics and designing novel neural interfaces.

Estimating the neural spike train from an unfused tetanic signal of low-threshold motor units using convolutive blind source separation

BACKGROUND

Individual motor units have been imaged using ultrafast ultrasound based on separating ultrasound images into motor unit twitches (unfused tetanus) evoked by the motoneuronal spike train. Currently, the spike train is estimated from the unfused tetanic signal using a Haar wavelet method (HWM). Although this ultrasound technique has great potential to provide comprehensive access to the neural drive to muscles for a large population of motor units simultaneously, the method has a limited identification rate of the active motor units. The estimation of spikes partly explains the limitation. Since the HWM may be sensitive to noise and unfused tetanic signals often are noisy, we must consider alternative methods with at least similar performance and robust against noise, among other factors.

RESULTS

This study aimed to estimate spike trains from simulated and experimental unfused tetani using a convolutive blind source separation (CBSS) algorithm and compare it against HWM. We evaluated the parameters of CBSS using simulations and compared the performance of CBSS against the HWM using simulated and experimental unfused tetanic signals from voluntary contractions of humans and evoked contraction of rats. We found that CBSS had a higher performance than HWM with respect to the simulated firings than HWM (97.5 ± 2.7 vs 96.9 ± 3.3, p < 0.001). In addition, we found that the estimated spike trains from CBSS and HWM highly agreed with the experimental spike trains (98.0% and 96.4%).

CONCLUSIONS

This result implies that CBSS can be used to estimate the spike train of an unfused tetanic signal and can be used directly within the current ultrasound-based motor unit identification pipeline. Extending this approach to decomposing ultrasound images into spike trains directly is promising. However, it remains to be investigated in future studies where spatial information is inevitable as a discriminating factor.