Capabilities and mechanisms of microalgae on nutrients and florfenicol removing from marine aquaculture wastewater

Innovative microalgae technologies for mariculture wastewater treatment: Single and combined microalgae treatment mechanisms, challenges and future prospects

The discharge of aquaculture wastewater, comprising nitrogen, phosphorus, heavy metals, and antibiotics from large-scale aquaculture, poses a significant threat to marine ecosystems and human health. Consequently, addressing the treatment of marine aquaculture wastewater is imperative. Conventional physicochemical treatment methods have various limitations, whereas microalgae-based biological treatment technologies have gained increasing attention in the field of water purification due to their ability to efficiently absorb organic matter from mariculture wastewater and convert CO₂ into biomass products. Microalgae offer potential for highly efficient and cost-effective mariculture wastewater treatment, with particularly noteworthy advancements in the application of combined microalgae technologies. This paper explores the research hotspots in this field through bibliometric analysis and systematically discusses the following aspects: (1) summarizing the current pollution status of mariculture wastewater, including the types and sources of pollutants in various forms of mariculture wastewater, treatment methods, and associated treatment efficiencies; (2) analyzing the factors contributing to the gradual replacement of single microalgae technology with combined microalgae technology, highlighting its synergistic effects, enhanced pollutant removal efficiencies, resource recovery potential, and alignment with sustainable development goals; (3) exploring the mechanisms of pollutant removal by combined microalgae technologies, focusing on their technical advantages in bacterial-algal coupling, immobilized microalgae systems, and microalgal biofilm technologies; (4) discussing the challenges faced by the three main categories of combined microalgae technologies and proposing future improvement strategies to further enhance their application effectiveness. In conclusion, this paper offers a detailed analysis of these emerging technologies, providing a forward-looking perspective on the future development of microalgae-based mariculture wastewater treatment solutions.

Phytohormones as a novel strategy for promoting phytoremediation in microalgae: Progress and prospects

Microalgal phytoremediation is a promising bioremediation approach that can achieve significant resource recovery while effectively removing pollutants. However, the toxicity of some pollutants in wastewater often induces stress responses in microalgae, reducing their pollutant removal efficiency. Recently, phytohormones have been identified as a novel solution to reduce these stress responses, enhancing microalgae growth and improving their ability to remove various pollutants from wastewater. This advancement significantly boosts the efficiency and viability of microalgal phytoremediation. In this paper, the pathways and challenges related to microalgal phytoremediation were systematically analyzed. On this basis, the promoting effects of phytohormones on the removal of nutrients, heavy metals, and emerging contaminants by microalgae and the related mechanisms were discussed. Additionally, the review also discusses the optimal use strategy of phytohormones, the ecological risks that may be faced in the use of phytohormones, and the feasible strategies to control the use cost of phytohormones. The goal is to provide insights and guidance for future research on the application of phytohormones in microalgal phytoremediation.

Review of recent advances in utilising aquaculture wastewater for algae cultivation and microalgae-based bioproduct recovery

Aquaculture operations produce large amounts of wastewater contaminated with organic matter, nitrogenous compounds, and other emerging contaminants; when discharged into natural water bodies, it could result in ecological problems and severely threaten aquatic habitats and human health. However, using aquaculture wastewater in biorefinery systems is becoming increasingly crucial as advancements in valuable bioproduct production continue to improve economic feasibility. Research on utilising microalgae as an alternative to producing biomass and removing nutrients from aquaculture wastewater has been extensively studied over the past decades. Microalgae have the potential to use carbon dioxide (CO2) effectively and significantly reduce carbon footprint, and the harvested biomass can also be used as aquafeed. Furthermore, aquaculture wastewater enriched with phosphorus (P) is a potential resource for P recovery for the production of biofertiliser. This will reduce the P supply shortage and eliminate the environmental consequences of eutrophication. In this context, the present review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the current state of the art in a generation, as well as the characteristics and environmental impact of aquaculture wastewater reported by the most recent research. Furthermore, the review synthesized recent developments in algal biomass cultivation using aquaculture wastewater and its utilisation as biorefinery feedstocks for producing value-added products, such as aquafeeds, bioethanol, biodiesel, biomethane, and bioenergy. This integrated process provides a sustainable method for recovering biomass and water, fully supporting the framework of a circular economy in aquaculture wastewater treatment via resource recovery.

Sustainable aquaculture and seafood production using microalgal technology - A circular bioeconomy perspective

The aquaculture industry is under the framework of the food-water-energy nexus due to the extensive use of water and energy. Sustainable practices are required to support the tremendous growth of this sector. Currently, the aquaculture industry is challenged by its reliance on capture fisheries for feed, increased use of pharmaceuticals, infectious outbreaks, and solid/liquid waste management. This review posits microalgal technology as a comprehensive solution for the current predicaments in aquaculture in a sustainable way. Microalgae are microscopic, freshwater and marine photosynthetic organisms, capable of carbon mitigation and bioremediation. They are indispensable in aquaculture due to their key role in marine productivity and their position in the marine food chain. Microalgae are nutritious and are currently used as feed in specific sectors of aquaculture. Due to their bioremediation potential, direct application of microalgae in shellfish ponds and in recirculating systems have been adopted to improve water quality and aquatic animal health. The potential of microalgae for integration into various aspects of aquaculture processes, namely hatcheries, feed, and waste management has been critically analyzed. Seamless integration of microalgal technology in aquaculture is feasible, and this review will provide new insights into using microalgal technology for sustainable aquaculture.

Degradation of sulfamethazine in coastal aquaculture tailwater by Na2S2O4@iron-electrode electrooxidation combined with ceramic membrane process

Offshore aquaculture's explosive growth improves the public food chain while also unavoidably adding new pollutants to the environment. Consequently, the protection of coastal marine eco-systems depends on the efficient treatment of wastewater from marine aquaculture. For the sulfamethazine (SMZ) of representative sulfonamides and total organic pollutants removal utilizing in-situ high salinity, this work has established an inventive and systematic treatment process coupled with iron-electrode electrochemical and ultrafiltration. Additionally, the activated dithionite (DTN) was being used in the electrochemical and ultrafiltration processes with electricity/varivalent iron (FeII/FeIII) and ceramic membrane (CM), respectively, indicated by the notations DTN@iron-electrode/EO-CM. Quenching experiments and ESR detection have identified plenty of reactive species including SO4·-, ·OH, 1O2, and O2·-, for the advanced treatment. In addition, the mass spectrometry (MS) and the Gaussian simulation calculation for these primary reaction sites revealed the dominate SMZ degradation mechanisms, including cleavage of S-N bond, hydroxylation, and Smile-type rearrangement in DTN@iron-electrode/EO process. The DTN@iron-electrode/EO effluent also demonstrated superior membrane fouling mitigation in terms of the CM process, owing to its higher specific flux. XPS and SEM confirmed the reducing membrane fouling, which showed the formation of a loose and porous cake layer. This work clarified diverse reactive species formation and detoxification with DTN@iron-electrode/EO system and offers a sustainable and efficient process for treating tailwater from coastal aquaculture.

Recent advances in recirculating aquaculture systems and role of microalgae to close system loop

In recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS), waste management of nutrient-rich byproducts accounts for 30-50% of the whole production costs. Integrating microalgae into RAS offers complementary solutions for transforming waste streams into valuable co-products. This review aims to provide an overview of recent advances in microalgae application to enhance RAS performance and derive value from all waste streams by using RAS effluents as microalgal nutrient sources. Aquaculture solid waste can be converted by hydrothermal liquefaction (HTL), then the resultant aqueous phase of HTL can be used for microalgae cultivation. In addition, microalgae generate the required oxygen while sequestering carbon dioxide. The review suggests a novel integrated system focusing on oxygenation and carbon dioxide capture along with recent technological developments concerning efficient microalgae cultivation and nutrient recovery techniques. In such system, microalgae-based biorefineries provide environmentally-conscious and economically-viable pathways for enhanced RAS performance and conversion of effluents into high-value products.

General performance, kinetic modification, and key regulating factor recognition of microalgae-based sulfonamide removal

Sulfonamides have been widely detected in water treatment plants. Advanced wastewater treatment for sulfonamide removal based on microalgal cultivation can reduce the ecological risk after discharge, achieve carbon fixation, and simultaneously recover bioresource. However, the general removal performance, key factors and their impacts, degradation kinetics, and potential coupling technologies have not been systematically summarized. To guide the construction and enhance the efficient performance of the purification system, this study summarizes the quantified characteristics of sulfonamide removal based on more than 100 groups of data from the literature. The biodegradation potential of sulfonamides from different subclasses and their toxicity to microalgae were statistically analyzed; therefore, a preferred option for further application was proposed. The mechanisms by which the properties of both sulfonamides and microalgae affect sulfonamide removal were comprehensively summarized. Thereafter, multiple principles for choosing optimal microalgae were proposed from the perspective of engineering applications. Considering the microalgal density and growth status, a modified antibiotic removal kinetic model was proposed with significant physical meaning, thereby resulting in an optimal fit. Based on the mechanism and regulating effect of key factors on sulfonamide removal, sensitive and feasible factors (e.g., water quality regulation, other than initial algal density) and system coupling were screened to guide engineering applications. Finally, we suggested studying the long-term removal performance of antibiotics at environmentally relevant concentrations and toxicity interactions for further research.

A Holistic Approach to Producing Anti-Vibrio Metabolites by an Endosymbiotic Dinoflagellate Using Wastewater from Shrimp Rearing

The aquaculture industry requires green solutions to solve several environmental challenges, including adequate wastewater remediation and natural drug applications to treat bacteria- and virus-related diseases. This study investigated the feasibility of cultivating the dinoflagellate Durusdinium glynnii in aquaculture wastewater from shrimp rearing in a synbiotic system (AWW-SS), with different dilutions of f/2 medium (FM). Interestingly, D. glynnii demonstrated enhanced growth in all AWW-SS treatments compared to the control (FM). The highest growth rates were achieved at AWW-SS:FM dilutions of 75:25 and 50:50. The removal of total nitrogen and total phosphorus reached 50.1 and 71.7%, respectively, of the crude AWW-SS. Biomass extracts of D. glynnii grown with AWW-SS were able to inhibit the growth of the bacteria Vibrio parahaemolyticus (inhibition zone of 10.0 ± 1.7 mm) and V. vulnificus (inhibition zone of 11.7 ± 1.5 mm). The presented results demonstrate that the dinoflagellate D. glynnii is a potential candidate for the development of circularity for sustainable aquaculture production, particularly by producing anti-Vibrio compounds at a near-zero cost.

Antimicrobial Resistance in Aquaculture: Risk Mitigation within the One Health Context

The application of antimicrobials in aquaculture primarily aims to prevent and treat bacterial infections in fish, but their inappropriate use may result in the emergence of zoonotic antibiotic-resistant bacteria and the subsequent transmission of resistant strains to humans via food consumption. The aquatic environment serves as a potential reservoir for resistant bacteria, providing an ideal breeding ground for development of antimicrobial resistance (AMR). The mutual inter-connection of intensive fish-farming systems with terrestrial environments, the food processing industry and human population creates pathways for the transmission of resistant bacteria, exacerbating the problem further. The aim of this study was to provide an overview of the most effective and available risk mitigation strategies to tackle AMR in aquaculture, based on the One Health (OH) concept. The stringent antimicrobial use guidelines, promoting disease control methods like enhanced farm biosecurity measures and vaccinations, alternatives to antibiotics (ABs) (prebiotics, probiotics, immunostimulants, essential oils (EOs), peptides and phage therapy), feeding practices, genetics, monitoring water quality, and improving wastewater treatment, rather than applying excessive use of antimicrobials, can effectively prevent the development of AMR and release of resistant bacteria into the environment and food. The contribution of the environment to AMR development traditionally receives less attention, and, therefore, environmental aspects should be included more prominently in OH efforts to predict, detect and prevent the risks to health. This is of particular importance for low and middle-income countries with a lack of integration of the national AMR action plans (NAPs) with the aquaculture-producing environment. Integrated control of AMR in fisheries based on the OH approach can contribute to substantial decrease in resistance, and such is the case in Asia, where in aquaculture, the percentage of antimicrobial compounds with resistance exceeding 50% (P50) decreased from 52% to 22% within the period of the previous two decades.

A vertical-flow constructed wetland-microalgal membrane photobioreactor integrated system for treating high-pollution-load marine aquaculture wastewater: A lab-scale study

Individual biological water treatment techniques often prove ineffective in removing accumulated high concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorus in the late stages of biofloc aquaculture. To address this issue, we integrated a previously developed autotrophic denitrification and nitrification integrated constructed wetland (ADNI-CW) with a microalgal membrane photobioreactor (MPBR). Under high nitrogen and phosphorus pollution loads in the influent, the standalone ADNI-CW system achieved removal rates of only 24.17 % ± 2.82 % for total nitrogen (TN) and 25.30 % ± 2.59 % for total phosphorus (TP). The optimal conditions for TN and TP degradation and microalgal biomass production in the Chlorella MPBR, determined using response surface methodology, were an inoculum OD680 of 0.394, light intensity of 161.583 μmol/m2/s, and photoperiod of 16.302 h light:7.698 h dark. Under the optimal operating conditions, the integrated ADNI-CW-MPBR system achieved remarkable TN and TP removal rates of 92.63 % ± 2.8 % and 77.46 % ± 8.41 %, respectively, and a substantial microalgal biomass yield of 54.58 ± 6.8 mg/L/day. This accomplishment signifies the successful achievement of efficient nitrogen and phosphorus removal from high-pollution-load marine aquaculture wastewater along with the acquisition of valuable microalgal biomass. A preliminary investigation of the microbial community composition and algal-bacterial interactions in different operational stages of the MPBR system revealed that unclassified_d__Bacteria, Chlorophyta, and Planctomycetes were predominant phyla. The collaborative relationships between bacteria and Chlorella surpassed competition, ensuring highly efficient nitrogen and phosphorus removal in the MPBR system. This study laid the foundation for the green and sustainable development of the aquaculture industry.

Algae-Mediated Removal of Prevalent Genotoxic Antibiotics: Molecular Perspective on Algae-Bacteria Consortia and Bioreactor-Based Strategies

Antibiotic pollution poses a potential risk of genotoxicity, as antibiotics released into the environment can induce DNA damage and mutagenesis in various organisms. This pollution, stemming from pharmaceutical manufacturing, agriculture, and improper disposal, can disrupt aquatic ecosystems and potentially impact human health through the consumption of contaminated water and food. The removal of genotoxic antibiotics using algae-mediated approaches has gained considerable attention due to its potential for mitigating the environmental and health risks associated with these compounds. The paper provides an in-depth examination of the molecular aspects concerning algae and bioreactor-driven methodologies utilized for the elimination of deleterious antibiotics. The molecular analysis encompasses diverse facets, encompassing the discernment and profiling of algae species proficient in antibiotic degradation, the explication of enzymatic degradation pathways, and the refinement of bioreactor configurations to augment removal efficacy. Emphasizing the significance of investigating algal approaches for mitigating antibiotic pollution, this paper underscores their potential as a sustainable solution, safeguarding both the environment and human health.

Carbon-negative and high-rate nutrient recovery from municipal wastewater using mixotrophic Scenedesmus acuminatus

The efficiency of mixotrophic microalgae in enhancing the recovery of waste nutrients has been well established; however, the recovery rate is crucial in meeting the needs of field applications. This study evaluated the impact of media characteristics on nutrient recovery under mixotrophic conditions. The mixotrophic N recovery rate with S. acuminatus in modified BG-11 reached 2.59 mg L-1h-1. A mixotrophic growth optimization strategy was applied to achieve a high-rate nutrient recovery from municipal wastewater treatment plant effluents. The contribution of waste chemical oxygen demand (COD) to nutrient recovery was assessed using secondary effluent (SE) under heterotrophy. The results highlighted a significant increase in total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) recovery rates when glucose was supplied, indicating the additional carbon requirements for efficient nutrient recovery. The TN and TP recovery rates under mixotrophic conditions with the addition of trace metals and high cell density were enhanced by 91.94% and 92.53%, respectively, resulting in recovery rates of 3.43 mg L-1h-1 and 0.30 mg L-1h-1. The same conditions were used for nutrient recovery from primary effluent (PE), and the results were more satisfactory as the TN and TP recovery rates reached 4.79 and 0.55 mg L-1h-1, respectively. Additionally, the study estimated the carbon footprints (C-footprints) and areal footprints of mixotrophy-based nitrogen recovery. The findings revealed carbon footprints and areal footprints of -15.93 ± 4.57 tCO2e t-1 N recovery and 0.53 ± 0.19 m3 m-2d-1 wastewater, respectively. This high-rate nutrient recovery, achieved under a carbon-negative (C-negative) budget through mixotrophy, presents a novel strategy for efficiently recovering resources from municipal wastewater, thus facilitating resource recycling and ensuring environmental sustainability.

A review on the antibiotic florfenicol: Occurrence, environmental fate, effects, and health risks

Florfenicol, as a replacement for chloramphenicol, can tightly bind to the A site of the 23S rRNA in the 50S subunit of the 70S ribosome, thereby inhibiting protein synthesis and bacterial proliferation. Due to the widespread use in aquaculture and veterinary medicine, florfenicol has been detected in the aquatic environment worldwide. Concerns over the effects and health risks of florfenicol on target and non-target organisms have been raised in recent years. Although the ecotoxicity of florfenicol has been widely reported in different species, no attempt has been made to review the current research progress of florfenicol toxicity, hormesis, and its health risks posed to biota. In this study, a comprehensive literature review was conducted to summarize the effects of florfenicol on various organisms including bacteria, algae, invertebrates, fishes, birds, and mammals. The generation of antibiotic resistant bacteria and spread antibiotic resistant genes, closely associated with hormesis, are pressing environmental health issues stemming from overuse or misuse of antibiotics including florfenicol. Exposure to florfenicol at μg/L-mg/L induced hormetic effects in several algal species, and chromoplasts might serve as a target for florfenicol-induced effects; however, the underlying molecular mechanisms are completely lacking. Exposure to high levels (mg/L) of florfenicol modified the xenobiotic metabolism, antioxidant systems, and energy metabolism, resulting in hepatotoxicity, renal toxicity, immunotoxicity, developmental toxicity, reproductive toxicity, obesogenic effects, and hormesis in different animal species. Mitochondria and the associated energy metabolism are suggested to be the primary targets for florfenicol toxicity in animals, albeit further in-depth investigations are warranted for revealing the long-term effects (e.g., whole-life-cycle impacts, multigenerational effects) of florfenicol, especially at environmental levels, and the underlying mechanisms. This will facilitate the evaluation of potential hormetic effects and construction of adverse outcome pathways for environmental risk assessment and regulation of florfenicol.

Effect of external acetate added in aquaculture wastewater on mixotrophic cultivation of microalgae, nutrient removal, and membrane contamination in a membrane photobioreactor

The mixotrophic cultivation of microalgae in wastewater has attracted extensive attention due to its many advantages. In this study, acetate, which can be prepared by hydrolysis of aquaculture waste, was used as exogenous organic matter to promote the growth of Chlorella pyrenoidosa cultured in aquaculture wastewater. Microalgae cultivation was carried out in a membrane photobioreactor (MPBR) with continuous inflow and outflow mode. The results showed that exogenous acetate greatly promoted the mixotrophic growth of C. pyrenoidosa. When the dosage of acetate reached 1.0 g L-1, the relative growth rate of microalgae in the logarithmic stage reached 0.31 d-1, which was 4.4 times that of the control. As a result, exogenous acetate also promoted the removal of nutrients from aquaculture wastewater. During the stable operation stage of the MPBR with acetate added in the influent, an average of 87.41%-93.93% nitrogen and 76.34%-88.55% phosphorus was removed from the aquaculture wastewater containing 19.41 mg L-1 total inorganic nitrogen and 1.31 mg L-1 total inorganic phosphorus. However, it was worth noting that adding exogenous acetate also led to an increase in the membrane resistance of the membrane module in the MPBR. Membrane resistance was mainly composed of internal resistance (Ri) and cake resistance (Rc), and with the increase of acetate content in the influent, their proportion in the total resistance gradually increased. Ri contributed the major membrane resistance and was most affected by acetate dosage. Ri reached 32.04 × 1012 m-1 with 1 g L-1 acetate, which accounted for 69.49% of total resistance. Moreover, with the increase of influent acetate concentration of the MPBRs, both the number of insoluble contaminants and dissolved organic contaminants in the membrane modules increased. In addition, the composition of proteins, polysaccharides, and humus in dissolved organic contaminants was close to that in extracellular polymeric substances and soluble microbial products secreted by microalgae. These results suggested that the membrane fouling of membrane modules was closely related to the algal biomass content in the MPBRs. The above results provided a theoretical basis for reducing membrane fouling of MPBR.

Biotreatment of Industrial Wastewater using Microalgae: A Tool for a Sustainable Bioeconomy

Fresh water is one of the essential sources of life, and its requirement has increased in the past years due to population growth and industrialization. Industries use huge quantities of fresh water for their processes, and generate high quantities of wastewater rich in organic matter, nitrates, and phosphates. These effluents have contaminated the freshwater sources and there is a need to recycle this wastewater in an ecologically harmless manner. Microalgae use the nutrients in the wastewater as a medium for growth and the biomass produced are rich in nutrition that can cater growing food and energy needs. The primary and secondary metabolites of microalgae are utilized as biofuel and as active ingredients in cosmetics, animal feed, therapeutics, and pharmaceutical products. In this review, we explore food processing industries like dairy, meat, aquaculture, breweries, and their wastewater for the microalgal growth. Current treatment methods are expensive and energy demanding, which indirectly leads to higher greenhouse gas emissions. Microalgae acts as a potential biotreatment tool and mitigates carbon dioxide due to their high photosynthetic efficiency. This review aims to address the need to recycle wastewater generated from such industries and potentiality to use microalgae for biotreatment. This will help to build a circular bioeconomy by using wastewater as a valuable resource to produce valuable products.