Can radicals-orientated chemical oxidation improve the reduction of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) by mesophilic anaerobic digestion of sludge?

Pre-exposure of Triclosan compromise tetracycline-derived antibiotic resistance in methanogenic digestion microbiome

Triclosan (TCS) and tetracycline (TC) are commonly detected antibacterial agents in sewage and environment matrices. Nonetheless, the impact of sequential exposure to TCS and TC on the methanogenic digestion microbiome remains unknown. In this study, TCS was shown to reduce COD removal efficiency to 69.8%, but alleviated the inhibitive effect of consequent TC-amendment on the digestion microbiome. Interestingly, TCS pre-exposure resulted in abundance increase of acetotrophic Methanosaeta to 2.68%, being 2.91 folds higher than that without TCS amendment. Microbial network analyses showed that TCS pre-exposure caused microorganisms to establish a co-ecological relationship against TC disturbance. Further analyses of total antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) showed the TCS-derived compromise of TC-induced ARGs enrichment in digestion microbiomes, e.g., 238.2% and 152.1% ARGs increase upon TC addition in digestion microbiomes without and with TCS pre-exposure, respectively. This study provides new insights into the impact of antibacterial agents on the methanogenic digestion microbiome.

Assessing impacts of municipal wastewater treatment plant upgrades on bacterial hazard contributions to the receiving urban river using SourceTracker

Upgrading municipal wastewater treatment plants (MWTPs) has been implemented in many megacities of China to reduce the discharges of nutrients and other pollutants and improve water quality of highly urbanized rivers. However, the contribution of MWTP discharge to bacterial hazards in the receiving rivers after upgrades has been largely unknown. In this study, high-throughput sequencing and shotgun metagenomics were applied to investigate the changes in the abundance, composition, potential risks, and contributions of bacteria and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) from effluent to receiving river after upgrading the third-largest MWTP in China with denitrification biofilters, ultrafiltration, ozonation, and disinfection processes. The annual loadings of total nitrogen and 27 types of pharmaceuticals were reduced by 42.4% ± 13.2% and 46.2% ± 15.4%, respectively. Bacterial biomass decreased from (3.58 ± 0.49) to (1.23 ± 0.27) × 107 16S rRNA gene copies/mL, and identified biomarkers in effluent and downstream shifted due to the adopted processes. Opportunistic pathogen bacteria downstream were also reduced. Although the relative abundance of total ARGs in MWTP effluent increased from 1.10 ± 0.02 to 2.19 ± 0.03 copies/16S rRNA gene after upgrades, that of total and high-risk ARGs downstream showed no significant difference. More importantly, the Bayesian-based SourceTracker method provided valuable insight by revealing that the contributions of MWTP discharge to downstream bacteria (from 44.2% ± 1.5%-31.4% ± 0.9%) and ARGs (from 61.2% ± 5.3%-47.6% ± 4.1%) were significantly reduced following the upgrades, indicating upgrading MWTP showed integrated benefits to the bacterial hazards in the receiving river. This study provides useful information for better control of bacterial hazard risks and operational strategy for the improvement of the urban aquatic ecosystem.

Variations in antibiotic resistance genes during long-term operation of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) have been widely detected in the environment. Anaerobic digestion (AD) has the potential ability to remove ARGs, and a comprehensive study is needed on the variations in ARGs during AD. In this study, variations in antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and microbial communities were investigated during the long-term operation of an upflow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) reactor. An antibiotic mixture of erythromycin, sulfamethoxazole and tetracycline was added to the UASB influent and the operation period was 360 days. The abundances of 11 ARGs and class 1 integron-integrase gene were detected in the UASB reactor, and the correlation between the ARGs and the microbial community was analyzed. The composition of ARGs indicated that the main ARGs in the effluent were sul1, sul2, and sul3, whereas the main ARG in the sludge was tetW. Correlation analysis indicated a negative correlation between microorganisms and ARGs in the UASB. In addition, most of ARGs showed a positive correlation with norank_f_Propionibacteriaceae and Clostridum_sensu_stricto_6, which were identified as potential hosts. These findings may help develop a feasible strategy for removing ARGs from aquatic environments during anaerobic digestion.

Performance of sewage sludge treatment for the removal of antibiotic resistance genes: Status and prospects

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) receive wastewater containing antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and antibiotic resistant genes (ARGs), which are predominant contributors to environmental pollution in water and soil. Of these sources, sludge is a more significant contributor than effluent. Knowing how sludge treatment affects the fate of ARGs is vital for managing the risk of these genes in both human and natural environments. This review therefore discusses the sources and transmission of ARGs in the environment and highlights the risks of ARGs in sludge. The effects of co-existing constituents (heavy metals, microplastics, etc.) on sludge and ARGs during treatment are collated to highlight the difficulty of treating sludge with complex constituents in ARGs. The effects of various sludge treatment methods on the abundances of ARGs in sludge and in soil from land application of treated sludge are discussed, pointing out that the choice of sludge treatment method should take into account various potential factors, such as soil and soil biology in subsequent land application. This review offers significant insights and explores the abundances of ARGs throughout the process of sludge treatment and disposal. Unintentional addition of antibiotic residues, heavy metals, microplastics and organic matter in sludge could significantly increase the abundance and reduce the removal efficiency of ARGs during treatment, which undoubtedly adds a barrier to the removal of ARGs from sludge treatment. The complexity of the sludge composition and the diversities of ARGs have led to the fact that no effective sludge treatment method has so far been able to completely eliminate the ecological risk of ARGs. In order to reduce risks resulting by transmission of ARGs, technical and management measures need to be implemented.

Distinct effects of typical sludge pretreatment approaches on the antibiotic resistance genes variations, associated bacterial community dynamics and metabolic activities during anaerobic fermentation process

Anaerobic fermentation is effective for waste activated sludge (WAS) disposal to realize resource generation and pollutants reduction, and various pretreatments were commonly applied to improve the performance. This work mainly investigated the effects of typical WAS pretreatment approaches on the antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs, as emerging contaminants) removal during anaerobic fermentation processes and unveiled the underlying mechanisms. The results indicated that all the pretreatment strategies exhibited evident effects on the overall ARGs removal with the order of Fe²⁺ activated persulfate (PS/Fe²⁺) > pH 10 > Ultrasonication > Heat, and showed selective removal tendency for the specific ARGs (namely easily removed (aadA1 and sul1) and persistent ARGs). Mechanistic analysis demonstrated that the pretreatments disrupted the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and rose the cell membrane permeability (particularly for PS/Fe²⁺ and Heat). Then the increased ARGs release benefitted the subsequent reduction of mobile genetic elements (MGEs) and extracellular ARGs (especially for PS/Fe²⁺ and pH10), resulting the ARGs attenuation. Pretreatments significantly shifted the microbial community structure and the abundances of potential ARGs hosts (i.e., Sulfuritalea, and Denitratisoma). Also, the different pretreatments exhibited distinct effects on the microbial metabolic traits related with ARGs proliferation (i.e., ABC transporters, two-component system and bacterial secretion systems), which also contributed to the ARGs attenuations during WAS fermentation. The partial least-squares path modeling (PLS-PM) analysis indicated that the bacterial community (total effects = 0.968) was key factor determining ARGs fates.

Microalgae simultaneously promote antibiotic removal and antibiotic resistance genes/bacteria attenuation in algal-bacterial granular sludge system

This study investigated the effects of microalgae growth on antibiotic removal and the attenuation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs)/ARGs host bacteria in algal-bacterial granular sludge (ABGS) system. In the presence of tetracycline (TC) and sulfadiazine (SDZ) mixture (2-4 mg/L), microalgae could grow on bacterial granular sludge (BGS) to form ABGS, with a chlorophyll-a content of 7.68-8.13 mg/g-VSS being achieved. The removal efficiencies of TC and SDZ by ABGS were as high as 79.0 % and 94.0 %, which were 4.3-5.0 % higher than those by BGS. Metagenomic analysis indicated that the relative abundances of TC/SDZ- related ARGs and mobile genetic elements (MGEs) in BGS were 56.1 % and 22.1 % higher than those in ABGS. A total of 26 ARGs were detected from the granules, and they were identified to associate with 46 host bacteria. 13 out of 26 ARGs and 13 out of 46 hosts were shared ARGs and hosts, respectively. The total relative abundance of host bacteria in BGS was 30.8 % higher than that in ABGS. Scenedesmus and Chlorella were the dominant microalgae that may reduce the diversity of ARGs hosts. Overall, ABGS is a promising biotechnology for antibiotic-containing wastewater treatment.

Electron shuttles enhanced the removal of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes in anaerobic systems: A review

The environmental and epidemiological problems caused by antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes have attracted a lot of attention. The use of electron shuttles based on enhanced extracellular electron transfer for anaerobic biological treatment to remove widespread antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes efficiently from wastewater or organic solid waste is a promising technology. This paper reviewed the development of electron shuttles, described the mechanism of action of different electron shuttles and the application of enhanced anaerobic biotreatment with electron shuttles for the removal of antibiotics and related genes. Finally, we discussed the current issues and possible future directions of electron shuttle technology.