Biomechanical study of cross-locked cruciate versus Strickland flexor tendon repair

The influence of oblique sutures and tendon-suture anchorages on tensile resistance and ultimate strength of 4-strand tendon repairs

This study investigated whether the integration of the oblique sutures contributes to the resistance to gapping in 4-strand flexor tendon repairs. In 72 porcine tendons, we compared repairs incorporating oblique sutures against those without using three distinct anchorage types. The studied suture configurations were longitudinal and oblique, modified Savage and Adelaide, and modified Kessler and Lahey. The number of tendons that formed the first gap or a 2 mm gap at the repair site during cyclic loading, stiffness at the 1st and 20th cycles, gap size between tendon ends and ultimate strength were recorded. No significant differences were found between core sutures with and without oblique sutures except between the modified Savage and Adelaide sutures. The Kessler-type anchorage was inferior in resisting gap formation than simple grasping or cross-locking sutures. We conclude that an oblique suture does not increase the gap resistance of 4-strand tendon repairs when using grasping or Kessler-type anchorages, but it does when using a cross-locking anchorage, such as the Adelaide suture. Simple grasping anchorage is comparable to cross-locking in resisting gap formation.

A 3-Dimensional Suture Technique for Flexor Tendon Repair: A Biomechanical Study

PURPOSE

Flexor tendon injury continues to pose a number of challenges for hand surgeons. Improving mechanical properties of repairs should allow for earlier and unprotected rehabilitation. A 3-dimensional (3D) 4-strand suture technique has been proposed to combine high tensile strength and low gliding resistance without causing suture pullout due to tendon delamination. Our hypothesis is that the 3D technique can result in better mechanical properties than the Adelaide technique.

METHODS

Four groups of 10 porcine flexor tendons were sutured using the 3D or Adelaide technique with a 3-0 polypropylene or ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) suture. The axial traction test to failure was performed on each tendon to measure 2-mm gap force and ultimate tensile strength.

RESULTS

The mean 2-mm gap force was 49 N for group A (3D + polypropylene), 145 N for group B (3D + UHMWPE), 47 N for group C (Adelaide + polypropylene), and 80 N for group D (Adelaide + UHMWPE). Failure mode was caused by suture breakage for group A (10/10) and mainly by suture pullout for the other groups (8/10 up to 10/10). With the UHMWPE suture, the mean ultimate tensile strength was 145 N for the 3D technique and 80 N for the Adelaide technique.

CONCLUSIONS

Porcine flexor tendons repaired using the 3D technique and UHMWPE suture exceeded a 2-mm gap force and tensile strength of 140 N. The ultimate tensile strength was superior to that of the Adelaide technique, regardless of the suture material.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This in vitro study on porcine flexor tendon suture highlights that the mechanical properties of 3D repair are better than those of 3D repair using the Adelaide technique when a UHMWPE suture is used.

Traumatic Zone II Flexor Tendon Injury Repair Through a Traumatic Dorsal Approach

Zone II flexor tendons present unique challenges for repair because of their complex anatomy in a confined space. The approach for zone II injuries is often dictated by preexisting traumatic skin lacerations, with a midaxial or volar approach being most common. In some injuries, this approach is not viable, and alternative approaches must be considered. A 45-year-old man presented with a traumatic crush injury that caused complete disruption of the skin, tendon, capsule, collateral ligament, and volar plate and laceration of the flexor digitorum profundus in zone II near the proximal interphalangeal joint. Given the large, near-circumferential zone of injury, we used the traumatic dorsal wound for the flexor tendon for repair. There are no reports of this approach in the literature. Postoperatively, the proximal interphalangeal joint was immobilized for 6 weeks with a K-wire. The patient was followed in the clinic and prescribed occupational therapy. At the 4-month postoperative visit, the patient had a healed incision, no signs of infection, and intact median/radial sensations. Functional testing showed a loose composite fist, improved range of motion, and 2-cm tip-to-palm deficiency of the index finger. Grip strength was 85 lb in the right hand and 60 lb in the left hand. Although patients are not always expected to regain full function, their postoperative course may be further complicated by adhesion and the need for tenolysis. Given these historical complications of tendon repair and our patient's ability to return to work with satisfactory functional outcomes, this approach may be a viable option for treating this unique injury pattern. [Orthopedics. 2022;45(4):e216-e219.].

Biomechanical evaluation of a novel barbed suture pattern with epitendinous suture augmentation in a canine flexor tendon model

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effect of a novel barbed suture pattern (NBSP) compared to a three-loop-pulley (3LP) with and without epitendinous suture (ES) augmentation on the biomechanical strength and gap formation of repaired canine tendons.

STUDY DESIGN

Ex vivo, cadaveric, randomized, experimental study.

SAMPLE POPULATION

Forty, adult superficial digital flexor tendons (SDFT).

METHODS

SDFT were randomly assigned to one of four groups (n = 10/group). Sharp tenotomy was performed and repaired with 3LP, NBSP, 3LP + ES, and NBSP + ES. Constructs were tested to failure while evaluating yield, peak, and failure loads, loads at 1 and 3 mm gap formation, and failure mode.

RESULTS

Constructs augmented with ES sustained 80% greater yield (p < .001), peak (p < .001), and failure (p < .001) loads, with no difference between 3LP + ES and NBSP + ES constructs regarding peak (p = .614), and failure forces (p = .865). Loads resulting in 1 and 3 mm gap formation were greater when constructs were augmented with an ES (p ≤ .003). Failure mode differed between groups (p < .001), occurring predominantly due to suture pull-through in 3LP and NBSP groups compared to tissue failure distant to the repair site in ES augmented constructs.

CONCLUSION

Tendons repaired with the NBSP used in this study resisted similar forces as those repaired with 3LP. Augmentation with an ES improved the biomechanical properties of repaired constructs, including resistance to gap formation.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The NBSP repair tested here may be advantageous over monofilament suture repair as it uses a similar-sized barbed core suture but eliminates the requirement for knot tying.

Comparative Accuracy of 1.5T MRI, 3T MRI, and Static Ultrasound in Diagnosis of Small Gaps in Repaired Flexor Tendons: A Cadaveric Study

PURPOSE

We hypothesized that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) would more accurately diagnose small gaps (<6 mm) after flexor tendon repair than static ultrasound (US) and that suture artifact would negatively impair accuracy.

METHODS

A laceration of the flexor digitorum profundus was created in 160 fresh-frozen cadaveric digits and randomized to either an intact repair (0-mm gap) or repairs using a locked 4-strand suture repair with either 4-0 Prolene, Ethibond, or and gaps of 2, 4,or 6 mm; or no suture in which 2-, 4-, or 6-mm gaps were created without a suture crossing the repair site. We performed 1.5T and 3T MRI and static US studies; gap widths were estimated by radiologists blinded to suture presence and true gap widths.

RESULTS

The 1.5 and 3.0T MRI had a lower mean error than US for gap sizes 0 and 2 mm. All 3 modalities performed similarly for 4- and 6-mm gaps. Documentation of imaging artifact worsened error, and odds of seeing artifacts were 1.72 higher with MRI than with US. Suture did not worsen artifact nor impair accuracy for any of the 3 modalities. When no suture was used, all 3 modalities significantly overestimated the true gap.

CONCLUSIONS

MRI is most accurate for small gaps less than 4 mm. Although all modalities overestimated gap sizes in specimens with a 0-mm gap (intact tendon repair), mean overestimation (<2 mm) was not clinically relevant. Ultrasound overestimated 2-mm gaps (clinically intact repairs), whereas MRIs did not. We recommend MRI for evaluation of gaps after flexor tendon repair. The 1.5T has slightly better sensitivity and specificity for distinguishing clinically intact (gap < 3 mm) from clinically impaired (gap > 3 mm) repairs than the 3T.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Accurate diagnosis of intact repairs or small gaps (<3 mm) might prevent unnecessary exploration or allow modification of rehabilitation protocols. Diagnosis of clinically relevant gaps (3-6 mm) may allow for earlier revision surgery before significant tendon retraction and adhesions develop, possibly necessitating a staged reconstruction.

Comparative Sensitivity and Specificity of Static and Dynamic High-Resolution Ultrasound in Diagnosis of Small Gaps in Repaired Flexor Tendons: A Cadaveric Study

PURPOSE

To compare the sensitivity and specificity of high-resolution static and dynamic ultrasound (US) for diagnosing intact repairs and small, clinically relevant gaps (≥4 mm) in repaired flexor digitorum profundus tendons within zone 2 and, secondarily, to evaluate the effect of suture artifact from 3 commonly used suture types.

METHODS

Eighty-eight fresh-frozen cadaveric digits (thumbs excluded) were randomized to either an intact repair (0-mm gap) or repairs using a locked 4-strand suture repair with either 4-0 Prolene, Ethibond, or FiberWire and gaps of 2, 4, or 6 mm and no suture in which 2-, 4-, or 6-mm gaps were created without a suture crossing the repair site. Gap widths were estimated by a blinded musculoskeletal ultrasonographer in static and dynamic modes.

RESULTS

Both static and dynamic modalities tended to overestimate actual gap sizes. For the suture gaps, both modalities had poor sensitivity (29% static; 42% dynamic) for accurately diagnosing a clinically intact repair (<4 mm), but better specificity (83% static; 75% dynamic) for diagnosing a clinically failed repair (≥4-mm gap). Although suture presence decreased the sensitivity of gap width measurement for both modalities, no differences were seen between suture types.

CONCLUSIONS

Static and dynamic US have poor sensitivity for diagnosing clinically intact repairs (gaps < 4 mm) because they typically overestimate gap size. The ability to diagnose failed repairs (gap ≥ 4 mm), based on greater specificity, is much better, but still suboptimal.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Based on a receiver operating characteristic analysis cutoff of 5 mm, if a gap of 5 mm or larger is identified with US when evaluating a zone 2 flexor digitorum profundus tendon repair, a failed repair is likely in about 80% of cases. A gap measurement of less than 5 mm may miss a high percentage of repairs that are clinically failed.

Repair of flexor tendon injuries by four strands cruciate technique versus two strands kessler technique

BACKGROUND

Flexor tendon injuries are commonly encountered and the surgical repair still represents a challenging problem. Many repair techniques are present but there is still no ideal one that achieves the best functional outcome. This study was undertaken to compare four-strand locked cruciate repair technique and modified Kessler technique in forty eight patients by assessing the functional outcome.

METHODS

Forty eight patients (114 digits) with flexor tendon injury were assigned into two groups based on suture repair technique; Group A: 24 cases by Modified Kessler repair (50%). Group B: 24cases by 4-strand cruciate repair (50%). Adults in Both groups were rehabilitated by combined Duran protocol and early active mobilization while no specific rehabilitation program was used for pediatric age group. Follow up was from 6 to 36 months (mean 21.5). Functional outcome was assessed by White criteria to all patients after 6 months.

RESULTS

Functional outcome was better in 4 strand cruciate repair with excellent result in 66.6%, good in 29.1% and fair in 4.1%, as compared to modified Kessler technique in which excellent results were found in 45.8%, good in 37.5%, fair in 12.5% and poor in 4.1% of cases. A better functional result was achieved in 4 strand cruciate repair especially in zone II, with excellent results in 33.3%, good in 50% and fair in 16.6% of cases, as compared to modified Kessler repair with no excellent results, 33.3% good, 50% fair and 16.6% poor results. In zone III, 4 strand cruciate technique showed a better functional outcome with 77.7% excellent and 22.2% good results, as compared to 55.5% excellent and 44.4% good results found in Modified Kessler repair. Zone V showed almost comparable results between the two types of repairs.

CONCLUSION

The 4-strand cruciate repair technique had better functional outcome compared to modified Kessler repair technique, especially in zone II and III.

Flexor Subzone II A-D Range of Motion Progression during Healing on a No-Splint, No-Tenodesis Protection, Immediate Full Composite Extension Regimen

Background: The objective was to study the hypotheses that an advanced zone II flexor tendon rehabilitation protocol would avoid rupture, achieve a high range of excursion, and minimize interphalangeal contracture during both the early phases and at the conclusion of healing. We also proposed the null hypothesis of no difference between any two of the zone II subdivisions. Methods: Fifty-one consecutive adult patients with zone II flexor tendon repairs of a single finger were retrospectively evaluated on an active contraction rehabilitation protocol with no splint, no tenodesis protection, and immediate full composite extension. There were 38 males and 13 females with a mean age of 39 years (range 18-69) involving 15 index, 7 long, 6 ring, and 23 small fingers. Repairs were located in flexor subzone IIA for 8 fingers; subzone IIB, 14; subzone IIC, 19; and subzone IID, 10. Differences in outcome between any two subzones were compared by T-test with p < 0.05. Results: Mean active arcs of motion in degrees at 3 weeks post repair were PIP 1-93; DIP 0-44; and total active motion (TAM) 221. At 6 weeks PIP 2-98; DIP 1-51; and TAM 236. At 10-12 weeks PIP 1-101; DIP 1-56; and TAM 246. Final TAM by flexor subzone IIA was 243; IIB, 251; IIC, 246; and IID, 246. There were no significant differences between any two subzones. Mean final DASH score was 5. There were no ruptures. Conclusions: The results support the hypotheses. Outcomes of the therapy protocol demonstrated the lack of interphalangeal joint flexion contractures, high range of total active motion achieved early and sustained, and no ruptures. No differences were identified between and two of the flexor subzones.

Effect of a continuous epitendinous suture as adjunct to three-loop pulley and locking-loop patterns for flexor tendon repair in a canine model

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effect of combining a continuous epitendinous suture with three-loop pulley (3LP) and locking-loop (LL) core patterns for flexor tendon repair.

STUDY DESIGN

Ex vivo biomechanical study.

SAMPLE POPULATION

Seventy-two cadaveric superficial digital flexor musculotendon (SDFT) units.

METHODS

Tendons were divided into four groups (n = 18/group). After sharp transection, SDFT were repaired with 3LP, LL, 3LP + epitendinous (E), or LL + E suture patterns. After preloading, repaired constructs were tested to failure. Video data acquisition allowed evaluation of failure mode and quantitation of gap formation. Yield, peak, and failure force were measured from force-displacement data. Significance was set at P < .05.

RESULTS

Mode of failure did not differ between repairs with or without an epitendinous suture (P = .255). Gap formation was best prevented with 3LP compared with LL when used alone (P = .001). Mean yield force for 3LP, LL, 3LP + E, and LL + E were 91.4 N ± 25.4, 61.3 N ± 18.4, 195.2 N ± 66.0, 165.3 N ± 46.8, respectively. Tenorrhaphies combined with an epitendinous suture achieved higher yield (P < .0001), peak (P < .0001), and failure forces (P < .0001), without gapping between tendon ends.

CONCLUSION

Addition of an epitendinous suture eliminated gapping between tendon ends until failure and increased resistance to loads tolerated at the repair site.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

The addition of an epitendinous suture may increase the strength of tendon repairs and resistance to gap formation over core suture use alone. The influence of epitendinous suture placement on tendinous healing and blood supply warrants in-vivo testing.

Biomechanical comparison of three epitendinous suture patterns as adjuncts to a core locking loop suture for repair of canine flexor tendon injuries

OBJECTIVE

To determine the effects of different epitendinous sutures (ES) in addition to core locking-loop (LL) sutures on the mechanical properties and gap formation in a canine cadaveric tendon model.

STUDY DESIGN

Experimental, ex vivo, biomechanical study.

SAMPLE POPULATION

Seventy-two cadaveric superficial digital flexor tendon specimens.

METHODS

Superficial digital flexor tendon specimens were divided into four groups (n = 18): sharply transected and repaired with LL, LL + simple continuous ES, LL + Silfverskiöld cross-stitch ES, and LL + interlocking horizontal mattress ES. Constructs were loaded to monotonic failure. Failure modes, gapping, yield, peak, and failure forces were analyzed. Significance was set at P < .05.

RESULTS

Yield, peak, and failure forces increased by 2.5-fold, two-fold, and twofold, respectively when ES groups were compared with core LL suture patterns alone (P < .0001). Resistance to 1- and 3-mm gap formation was greater in ES groups compared with core LL constructs alone (P < .0001). No differences in yield, peak, failure force, or gapping were observed among ES patterns (P > .827).

CONCLUSION

Adding an ES reduced gap formation and increased yield, peak, and failure forces of tenorrhaphies. No difference was detected between the epitendinous patterns tested in this study.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

The addition of an ES seems more relevant than the specific type of pattern to improve the biomechanical properties of flexor tendon repairs. In vivo studies are warranted to determine the biological implications of the patterns tested here.

Comparison of the strength of two multi-strand tendon repair configurations in a chicken model

We sought to investigate the strength of two multi-strand tendon repair configurations in a chicken model. Fifty-six chicken flexor tendons were repaired with one to two different four-strand configurations: 1) a four-strand repair consisting of a two-strand core modified Kessler suture with a circle loop repair and 2) a four-strand core Kessler suture repair with three separate peripheral suture points. The strength of the repaired tendons were measured 2, 3 and 4 weeks after the surgical repair and were analyzed statistically. The strength of the two repair methods was not statistically different 2 weeks after surgery. The tendons repaired with the four-strand core Kessler suture repair and three separate peripheral suture points were significantly stronger than those repaired with a two-strand core modified Kessler suture and a circle loop repair at 3 weeks (P = 0.033) and 4 weeks (P = 0.039). The four-strand repair with three separate peripheral suture points had greater strength than a two-strand repair with one circle loop suture based on an in vivo chicken flexor tendon model.

Growth Factor and Intense Pulse Light in Flexor Tendon Repair: A Biomechanical Study at Strength and Gap Resistance

BACKGROUND

Flexor tendon injuries are extremely common and they are usually the result of incised traumatic glass or knife injury. The process of tendon healing is a complicated and exceptionally-regimented mechanism that is originated and monitored by a vast number of diverse molecules. One of the most pivotal groups of mediators that are crucial to the healing process are growth factors (GF). Intense pulse light (IPL) can lead to evidence of new collagen formation with associated clinical improvement in tissue healing. The biological benefit of Intense pulse light (IPL) relies on judicious photothermolysis, where heat driven radiation is dissipated and focused at the cellular level. The aims of this study is to set out the effect of growth factor and IPL on healing following a tendon repair.

METHODS

Bovine common digital extensor tendons (CDET) were used as an ex vivo model. 44 tendon repairs were performed by the lead author using 2.5 × magnification loupes and standard instruments. Clamped tendons were assigned into the following groups; control, IPL, GF, IPL and GF. After culturing, biomechanical testing was carried out using monotonic tensile testing with displacement-controlled uniaxial tension to failure.

RESULTS

The mean values for ultimate tensile stress (UTS) for the control group was 53.51 N, for IPL it was 51.15 N, for growth factor was 70.10 N and for combined growth factor and IPL it was 75.16 N.

CONCLUSIONS

This study showed significant improvement in UTS when repaired tendons were cultured with growth factor compared to control and IPL. This would suggest a biomechanical advantage for tendon healing.

Zone II Flexor Tendon Repairs in the United States: Trends in Current Management

PURPOSE

The repair of zone II flexor tendon injuries is an evolving topic in hand surgery with current literature suggesting the use of a 4-strand repair; 3-0 or 4-0 braided, nonabsorbable sutures; and an epitendinous repair. It was hypothesized that variability would exist within the hand surgeon community in treatment of zone II flexor tendon repairs in surgical material used, surgical technique, and postoperative rehabilitation protocol.

METHODS

An online single-answer multiple-choice survey was distributed to the American Society for Surgery of the Hand members' database. Surgeons were asked questions about demographics, surgical technique, suture type, common complications, postoperative management, and the factor that plays the largest role in guiding their surgical preferences. Responses were compared with current medical evidence.

RESULTS

A total of 410 individuals responded to the survey. In regards to technique, the majority of surgeons reported using a 4-strand repair; with 3-0 or 4-0 core braided, nonabsorbable sutures; and performing an epitendinous repair. Only 20% of surgeons surveyed reported ever using wide-awake local anesthesia, no tourniquet and postoperative protocols were split between early active and early passive rehabilitation. Senior surgeons (≥ 15 years in practice) were more likely than their colleagues to use a 2-strand repair and a passive rehabilitation protocol.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that the majority of respondents are performing zone II flexor tendon repairs in accordance with the best currently available evidence, although there is variability with respect to suture material, surgical technique, and rehabilitation protocols.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

There is still a need for high-quality studies on surgical technique and rehabilitation protocols.

Eight-strand Cross-locked Cruciate Flexor Tendon Repair Using Double-stranded Suture: A Description of the Surgical Technique

This article describes a technique for improved repair of digital flexor tendon laceration. Eight-strand cross-locked cruciate repair using 4-0 caliber double-stranded suture is not bulky and has a smooth configuration for tendon gliding. Additionally, it has sufficient strength for early postoperative active motion exercise.

In vivo flexor tendon forces generated during different rehabilitation exercises

We measured in vivo forces in the flexor digitorum profundus and the flexor digitorum superficialis tendons during commonly used rehabilitation manoeuvres after flexor tendon repair by placing a buckle force transducer on the tendons of the index finger in the carpal canal during open carpal tunnel release of 12 patients. We compared peak forces for each manoeuvre with the reported strength of a flexor tendon repair. Median flexor digitorum profundus force (24 N) during isolated flexor digitorum profundus flexion and median flexor digitorum superficialis force (13 N) during isolated flexor digitorum superficialis flexion were significantly higher than during the other manoeuvres. Significantly higher median forces were observed in the flexor digitorum superficialis with the wrist at 30° flexion (6 N) compared with the neutral wrist position (5 N). Median flexor digitorum profundus forces were significantly higher during active finger flexion (6 N) compared with place and hold (3 N). Place and hold and active finger flexion with the wrist in the neutral position or tenodesis generated the lowest forces; isolated flexion of these tendons generated higher forces along the flexor tendons.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III (controlled trial without randomization).

The Effect of the Epitendinous Suture on Gliding in a Cadaveric Model of Zone II Flexor Tendon Repair

PURPOSE

We hypothesized that increasing core sutures (4-6) may be preferable in terms of gliding coefficient (GC) measurements when compared with adding an epitendinous suture to zone II flexor tendon repairs. We hypothesized that the inclusion of epitendinous suture in 2 standard repairs would contribute negatively to the GC of the repaired tendon.

METHODS

Nineteen fresh-frozen cadaveric fingers were used for testing. We compared a control group (dissected digits without repair) and 4-strand or 6-strand core tendon repairs with and without epitendinous suture. Arc of motion was driven by direct loading, and digital images were acquired and analyzed. Outcomes were defined as the difference in GC between the native uninjured and the repaired state at each load. A linear mixed-model analysis was performed with comparisons between repairs to evaluate the statistically relevant differences between groups.

RESULTS

The test of fixed effects in the linear model revealed that repair type and the use of epitendinous suture significantly affected the change in GC. The addition of an epitendinous suture produced a significant decrement in gliding regardless of repair type.

CONCLUSIONS

There was significant improvement in GC with the omission of the epitendinous suture in both repair types (4- or 6-strand).

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The epitendinous suture used in this model resulted in poorer gliding of the repair, which may correspond with an expected increase in catching or triggering.

Update on Zone II Flexor Tendon Injuries

Flexor tendon repair in zone II is particularly challenging because tendon gliding must be restored within a tight fibro-osseous sheath while minimizing the formation of adhesions in surrounding tissues. Meticulous surgical technique using a multistrand core suture and a peripheral suture is needed to produce a tendon that is strong enough to withstand early mobilization. Mechanical strength increases with the number of strands crossing the repair, regardless of the core suture configuration. Early mobilization after flexor tendon repair enhances the strength of the repair and decreases the risk of adhesions and joint stiffness. Satisfactory results have been achieved with either early passive or early active motion rehabilitation protocols; therefore, the choice of postoperative rehabilitation program is at the discretion of the surgeon. Factors such as repair integrity, concurrent injuries, and anticipated patient compliance should be considered in the decision-making process.

Flexor tendon repairs: techniques, eponyms, and evidence

The evolution in surgical technique and suture technology has provided an abundance of options for flexor tendon repairs. Multiple biomechanical studies have attempted to identify the best surgical technique based on suture properties, technical modifications, and repair configurations. However, the burgeoning amount of research on flexor tendon repairs has made it difficult to follow, and no gold standard has been determined for the optimal repair algorithm. Therefore, it seems that repairs are usually chosen based on a combination of familiarity from training, popularity, and technical difficulty. We will discuss the advantages, disadvantages, and technical aspects of some of the most common core flexor tendon repairs in the literature. We will also highlight the nomenclature carried through the years, drawings of the repairs referred to by that nomenclature, and the data that support those repairs.

The Interlocking Modification of the Cross Locked Cruciate Tendon Repair (Modified Adelaide Repair): A Static and Dynamic Biomechanical Assessment

The 4-strand cross-locked cruciate flexor tendon repair technique (Adelaide technique) has been shown to have comparably high resistance to gap formation and ultimate tensile strength. This study aimed to determine whether an interlocking modification to the Adelaide repair would impart improved biomechanical characteristics. Twenty four sheep flexor tendons were harvested, transected and repaired using either standard or modified Adelaide techniques. Repaired tendons were cyclically loaded. Gap formation and ultimate tensile strength were measured. Additionally, suture exposure on the tendon surface was determined. There was a statistically significant increase in resistance to gap formation in the early phase of cyclic loading within the modified Adelaide group. In the later stages of testing no significant difference could be noted. The average final load to failure in the modified group was higher than the standard group but this did not achieve statistical significance. Interlocking suture techniques in four strand tendon repair constructs can improve gapping behavior in the early phase of cyclic loading.

Flexor Tendon Injuries in the Hand: A UK Survey of Repair Techniques and Suture Materials—Are We Following the Evidence?

Introduction. Injuries to the hand are common, and poor functional outcomes can have significant long-term consequences affecting both work and social activities. Good outcomes following flexor tendon lacerations in the hand are dependent on a sound surgical repair allowing early active mobilisation. Materials and Methods. We reviewed the literature regarding the choice of suture material and repair technique. We then carried out a nationwide postal survey of plastic surgery hand units to assess the level of compliance with the evidence. Results. Fifty-four units were surveyed. The response rate was 72%, with the most popular core suture being Prolene (64%) and the most popular technique being the Kessler repair (36%). Discussion. Current evidence advocates a multistrand repair using Ethibond. We found that the majority of units are not following the evidence. We suggest the use of evidence-based departmental guidelines to improve the practice and outcomes following these common injuries.

Performance of a knotless four-strand flexor tendon repair with a unidirectional barbed suture device: a dynamic ex vivo comparison

With increased numbers of reports using barbed sutures for tendon repairs we felt the need to design a specific tendon repair method to draw the best utility from these materials. We split 30 sheep deep flexor tendons in two groups of 15 tendons. One group was repaired with a new four-strand barbed suture repair method without knot. The other group was repaired with a conventional four-strand cross-locked cruciate repair method (Adelaide repair) with knot. Dynamic testing (3-30 N for 250 cycles) and additional static pull to failure was performed to investigate gap formation and final failure forces. The barbed suture repair group showed higher resistance to gap formation throughout the test. Additionally final failure force was higher for the barbed suture group compared with the conventional repair group. When used appropriately, barbed suture materials could be beneficial to use in tendon surgery, especially with regard to early loading of the repair site and gap formation.

Recent developments in flexor tendon repair techniques and factors influencing strength of the tendon repair

Over the last decade, both basic researchers and surgeons have sought to identify the most appropriate techniques to be applied in flexor tendon repairs. Recent developments in experimental tendon repairs and clinical outcomes of newer repair techniques have been reviewed in an attempt to comprehensively summarize the most critical mechanical factors affecting the performance of tendon repairs and the surgical factors influencing clinical outcomes. Among them, attention to annular pulleys, the purchase and tension of the core suture, and the direction and curvature of the path of tendon motion have been found to be determining factors in the results of tendon repair.

Biomechanical comparison of the four-strand cruciate and Strickland techniques in animal tendons

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to compare two four-strand techniques: the traditional Strickland and cruciate techniques.

METHODS

Thirty-eight Achilles tendons were removed from 19 rabbits and were assigned to two groups based on suture technique (Group 1, Strickland suture; Group 2, cruciate repair). The sutured tendons were subjected to constant progressive distraction using a universal testing machine (Kratos®). Based on data from the instrument, which were synchronized with the visualized gap at the suture site and at the time of suture rupture, the following data were obtained: maximum load to rupture, maximum deformation or gap, time elapsed until failure, and stiffness.

RESULTS

In the statistical analysis, the data were parametric and unpaired, and by Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, the sample distribution was normal. By Student's t-test, there was no significant difference in any of the data: the cruciate repair sutures had slightly better mean stiffness, and the Strickland sutures had longer time-elapsed suture ruptures and higher average maximum deformation.

CONCLUSIONS

The cruciate and Strickland techniques for flexor tendon sutures have similar mechanical characteristics in vitro.

Analysis of a knotless flexor tendon repair using a multifilament stainless steel cable-crimp system

PURPOSE

To compare the biomechanical and technical properties of flexor tendon repairs using a 4-strand cruciate FiberWire (FW) repair and a 2-strand multifilament stainless steel (MFSS) single cross-lock cable-crimp system.

METHODS

Eight tests were conducted for each type of repair using cadaver hand flexor digitorum profundus tendons. We measured the required surgical exposure, repair time, and force of flexion (friction) with a custom motor system with an inline load cell and measured ultimate tensile strength (UTS) and 2-mm gap force on a servo-hydraulic testing machine.

RESULTS

Repair time averaged less than 7 minutes for the 2-strand MFSS cable crimp repairs and 12 minutes for the FW repairs. The FW repair was performed with 2 cm of exposure and removal of the C-1 and A-3 pulleys. The C-1 and A-3 pulleys were retained in each of the MFSS cable crimp repairs with less than 1 cm of exposure. Following the FW repair, the average increase in friction was 89% compared with an average of 53% for the MFSS repairs. Six of the 8 MFSS specimens achieved the UTS before any gap had occurred, whereas all of the FW repairs had more than 2 mm of gap before the UTS, indicating that the MFSS was a stiffer repair. The average UTS appeared similar for both groups.

CONCLUSIONS

We describe a 2-strand multifilament stainless steel single cross-lock cable crimp flexor repair system. In our studies of this cable crimp system, we found that surgical exposure, average repair times, and friction were reduced compared to the traditional 4-strand cruciate FW repair. While demonstrating these benefits, the crimp repair also produced a stiff construct and high UTS and 2-mm gap force.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

A cable crimp flexor tendon repair may offer an attractive alternative to current repair methods. The benefits may be important especially for flexor tendon repair in zone 2 or for the repair of multiple tendons.

Epitendinous suture techniques in extensor tendon repairs--an experimental evaluation

PURPOSE

The tension-band principle might be relevant to extensor tendon repairs, and a dorsal-only Silfverskiöld epitendinous repair is stronger and stiffer than more conventional techniques in vitro. We aimed to evaluate the strength and stiffness of the strongest epitendinous sutures described, using an in vitro model that subjects the repair to angular force over a pulley, thereby creating a tension-band model.

METHODS

Silfverskiöld dorsal-only epitendinous extensor tendon repairs in porcine foot tendons (n = 8) were compared to reverse (buried) Silfverskiöld (n = 8), Halsted (n = 8), and interrupted horizontal mattress (IHM) repairs (n = 6) in vitro with a tensiometer around a 45° pulley. Thirty tendons total were tested to assess the force required for 2-mm gapping and ultimate tensile strength.

RESULTS

The IHM repair had a significantly higher ultimate tensile strength (43 N; SD, 10 N) than the other repairs, which had strengths between 27 N (SD, 4 N) and 31 N (SD, 7 N). The IHM was also significantly more resistant to gapping than the Silfverskiöld and Halsted repairs.

CONCLUSIONS

Interlocking horizontal mattress, dorsal-only extensor tendon repairs were significantly stronger and more resistant to gapping than Silfverskiöld and Halsted repairs. Other repairs were still strong and resistant to gapping in comparison to previously published data for conventional repairs.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The IHM is a relatively difficult technique to perform, and it remains to be seen whether the additional strength translates to clinical benefits over the easier Silfverskiöld technique.

How much does a Pennington lock add to strength of a tendon repair?

Pennington advocated adding locking components to the Kessler-type repair to increase the repair strength, but did not actually test the repairs with this lock. Subsequent investigators have extensively cited that a Pennington lock is beneficial to the gain of repair strength. Thirty-three tendons were used to determine the exact strength differences between two grasping Kessler repairs and a Kessler repair with Pennington locks complemented with running peripheral suture. Two types of grasping repairs only had slightly lower resistance to gap formation compared with the repair with Pennington locks, and their ultimate strengths were not significantly different. We also compared the strength of four-strand Kessler repair with and without Pennington locks using 20 tendons, and found no difference in either gapping or ultimate strength. We conclude that a Pennington lock adds only a little to the capacity to gap resistance of a repair, but does not increase the ultimate strength.

Active mobilisation following single cross grasp four-strand flexor tenorrhaphy (Adelaide repair)

This paper presents our initial experience using a single cross grasp, four-strand repair with an active mobilization regimen in a general trauma hospital setting. Variably experienced members of the trauma service of a large general hospital used a four-strand single cross grasp tenorrhaphy technique for acute repair of 73 zone one and two flexor digitorum profundus tendon lacerations in 53 patients. Postoperatively, all patients commenced an active mobilization program within 12 hours of the surgical repair. With a minimum 3 months post-repair follow-up of 89% of the repaired flexor digitorum profundus tendons, 71% of fingers achieved a good or excellent outcome. There were three (4.6%) flexor digitorum profundus ruptures post surgery. A four-strand single cross grasp repair using 3-0 braided polyester suture and active post-repair mobilization can achieve satisfactory outcomes in the general trauma service setting; however, patient compliance remains a problem.

Impact of Smad3 loss of function on scarring and adhesion formation during tendon healing

Studies were performed evaluating the role of Smad3, a transcription factor mediating canonical TGF-β signaling, on scarring and adhesion formation using an established flexor digitorum longus (FDL) tendon repair model. In unoperated animals the metatarsophalangeal (MTP) range of motion (ROM) was similar in Smad3(-/-) and wild-type (WT) mice while the basal tensile strength of Smad3(-/-) tendons was significantly (39%) lower than in WT controls. At 14 and 21 days following repair Smad3(-/-) MTP ROM reached approximately 50% of the basal level and was twice that observed in WT tendon repairs, consistent with reduced adhesion formation. Smad3(-/-) and WT maximal tensile repair strength on post-operative day 14 was similar. However, Smad3(-/-) tendon repairs maximal tensile strength on day 21 was 42% lower than observed in matched WT mice, mimicking the relative decrease in strength observed in Smad3(-/-) FDL tendons under basal conditions. Histology showed reduced "healing callus" in Smad3(-/-) tendons while quantitative PCR, in situ hybridization, and immunohistochemistry showed decreased col3a1 and col1a1 and increased MMP9 gene and protein expression in repaired Smad3(-/-) tendons. Thus, Smad3(-/-) mice have reduced collagen and increased MMP9 gene and protein expression and decreased scarring following tendon FDL tendon repair.

Biomechanical comparisons of four-strand tendon repairs with double-stranded sutures: effects of different locks and suture geometry

Multi-strand repairs are often used in flexor tendon surgery. We evaluated the strength of four four-strand tendon repairs with different locks and suture geometry. Forty-eight pig flexor tendons were repaired with the following methods: a cross-lock four-strand repair; a U-shaped repair with circle-locks; a modified Kessler repair with Pennington locks (with longitudinal sutures located more centrally; and another modified Kessler (with longitudinal sutures located more laterally). The tendons were loaded to complete failure of the repairs. The two Kessler repairs showed a 35% lower 2 mm gap force, and 15% lower ultimate strength compared with the other two repairs; the differences were of statistical significance. The failure pattern was breakage of sutures in almost all tendons. These four-strand repairs differed in gapping and ultimate strengths. The Kessler-type repairs with different geometry in the longitudinal sutures produced identical strengths. The Kessler-type repairs with Pennington locks were weaker than the two repairs with either cross-locks or circle-locks.

Strength of tendon repair decreases in the presence of an intact A2 pulley: biomechanical study in a chicken model

PURPOSE

Pulleys have an important role in digital flexion, but little is known about how the strength of a tendon repair is affected by a major pulley. We evaluated the difference in strengths of flexor tendon repairs in the pulley area when the pulley was intact or divided in a chicken tendon injury model.

METHODS

In each of 100 long toes of 50 Leghorn chickens, a complete, transverse laceration of the flexor digitorum profundus tendon was made in the region of the A2 pulley and was repaired surgically. The A2 pulley was preserved or was completely divided longitudinally. The toes were harvested by disarticulating through the knee joint, and placed at full extension, at 20 degrees , 40 degrees , or 60 degrees of distal interphalangeal (DIP) joint flexion, and at 40 degrees , 80 degrees , or 120 degrees of combined DIP and proximal interphangeal (PIP) joint flexion, and tendon repairs were loaded to failure in a materials testing machine. The force required for ultimate failure was statistically compared for each group.

RESULTS

Ultimate tendon repair strength was significantly lower in toes with the A2 pulley intact than in those with the pulley vented when the toes were placed at full extension and at all tested degrees of DIP and PIP joint flexion, except at the most marked flexion. After A2 pulley division, tendon repair strength was 30% to 60% higher than flexed toes with the pulley intact. With an intact pulley, the tendon repair strength in the flexed toes was significantly lower than that in the fully extended toes, but after A2 pulley division, the strength was similar at all toe positions except at the most marked flexion.

CONCLUSIONS

Chicken tendon repairs are substantially weaker when the A2 pulley is intact than when the pulley is completely divided. Loading of the tendon repair against an intact major pulley adversely affects repair strength. These findings suggest that tendon repair is less likely to fail when the A2 pulley is divided than when the pulley is intact; pulley venting may decrease the likelihood of repair ruptures.