An Alternative Thumb Reconstruction by Double Microsurgical Transfer From the Great and Second Toe for a Carpometacarpal Amputation

Radiocarpal Joint Reconstruction with a Double Free Metatarsophalangeal Joint Transfer

Background

Destruction of the radiocarpal and midcarpal joints causes loss of wrist motion, pain, and reduced grip strength. A novel technique for radiocarpal reconstruction is presented.

Methods

Two patients who had radiocarpal and midcarpal destruction and osteoarthritis underwent reconstruction using simultaneous bilateral microvascular second metatarsophalangeal joint transfer. The insetting was performed, inverting the distal-proximal orientation of both metatarsophalangeal joints and fixing them with two 2.0 screws in proximal and Kirschner wires in distal.

Results

Radiocarpal extension and flexion without pain were preserved after a minimum of 4 years follow-up. Both patients could return to recreational activities. No secondary procedures were needed.

Conclusions

This technique could be an alternative for radiocarpal reconstruction, although longer follow-up and more cases are needed.

A Demonstration of Long-Term Outcomes in a Case of Toe to Thumb Transfer Following Traumatic Amputation

The thumb is pivotal to many functions of the hand. Loss or absence of the thumb can be catastrophic to a patient’s functioning. Different methods can be employed to surgically fashion a new thumb. This case report aims to demonstrate one patient’s 34-year experience, reporting objective measures for a toe to thumb transfer, and documenting aesthetic outcomes. A semi-structured interview was conducted to gain insight into the patient's personal experiences. Validated assessment tools were used to assess range of movement and power, including Kapandji test, Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) questionnaire, Cochin Hand Function Scale, Qingfeng Hand Dynamometer, Self-Administered Foot Evaluation Questionnaire (SAFE-Q). A physical examination on the neothumb was performed, along with photography to document aesthetic outcome. A 55-year-old white British male injured his right thumb whilst on a placement year in a sugar refinery in the Netherlands. The thumb was traumatically amputated proximal to the metacarpophalangeal joint. The patient lived for a year without a thumb on his dominant hand, which had a huge effect on his functioning, with extensive input from physiotherapists to help increase his handgrip strength. He then underwent a transfer operation, with the removal of the second toe which was transferred to create a right neothumb. The patient has high physical functioning of his neothumb, however, he is still mildly limited due to pain 34 years post-operation. The objective assessment tools demonstrate a high functioning of the neothumb, with only mild deficits in the dexterity and the physical functioning of the right hand. He experiences mild pain and reduced function of the donor foot. Light touch was found to be absent on the right thumb, but present on the left. Two-point discrimination was 7 mm on the right thumb, and 0.5 mm on the left. In this case, we present a toe to thumb transfer that had very good outcomes after 34 years with few complications. This case demonstrates that great adaptation can occur over long periods of time, restoring near-normal function. Measures of functional outcomes were generally high, with main deficiencies in fine motor skills such as picking up a penny from a flat surface and undoing small buttons. Additionally, there can be good long term outcomes from toe to thumb transfer despite moderate impairment of function. There is hope that this can be used to encourage and reassure patients and surgeons alike that the neothumb is likely to give good outcomes both functionally and aesthetically for many years. 

Use of single-staged transmetatarsal trimmed great toe transfer for reconstruction of a thumb amputation at the carpometacarpal joint

BACKGROUND

Reconstruction for proximal thumb amputation at the carpometacarpal (CMC) joint level is extremely challenging. All thenar muscles are lost and other fingers might be lost or injured. Transmetatarsal trimmed great toe (TGT) transfer may be an option in such cases.

METHODS

Between 2012 and 2018, 11 patients who had amputation of the thumb at the CMC joint level were reconstructed by transmetatarsal TGT transfer in a single stage. There were seven cases in which the right hand was affected and four cases in which the left hand was affected. Three cases involved a contracture scar at the thumb stump and required web space reconstruction. Average follow-up was 33.9 months (range: 12-76 months) RESULTS: All toe transfers survived. The average of static two-point discrimination (S2PD) was 14.6 mm; the average scores of the Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (quickDASH) questionnaire and the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire (MHQ) were 18.6 and 73.8, respectively. Two cases did not achieve opposition due to mispositioning of the neothumb. In nine cases achieving opposition, the Kapandji score ranged from 4 to 9, pinch ranged from 3 to 11 lbs, and grip ranged from 15 to 86 lbs. In the donor foot, three patients had neuroma and two had a new callus on the palmar side of the second and third metatarsal heads. The average foot and ankle disability index score was 91.6.

CONCLUSION

Single-staged transmetatarsal TGT transfer is safe and useful for thumb reconstruction at the CMC joint level. This reconstructive method is suitable for manual workers, especially in the developing countries.

Cosmetic and functional results of a newly reconstructed thumb by combining the phalanx of second toe and the great toenail flap transplantation

Background

Microsurgical toe-to-hand transfer is a gold standard when it comes to repairing a thumb defect. Great toenail flap, thumbnail valva flap, free great toe, and second toe transplantation are the common methods in thumb reconstruction. Second toe transplantation achieves good function, but poor esthetics. Great toe transplantation achieves better esthetics, but hindered walking, due to the foot’s loss of the great toe and moreover suboptimal thumb function. It is difficult to maintain both functional and esthetic satisfaction in thumb reconstruction.

Methods

We experimented with three different methods of toe to hand transfer. From October 2009 to July 2019, 30 patients with traumatic thumb defects received one of 3 different kinds of thumb reconstruction in our clinic according to their level of amputation. Divided evenly into three groups of ten, group one received a great toe transplantation, group two received a second toe transplantation, and group three received a combined great toenail flap and second toe phalanx transplantation. Each of the patients’ thumbs had different levels of amputation at the metatarsophalangeal joint (MPJ) or distal interphalangeal joint (DIPJ).

Results

One patient suffered from a partial flap necrosis and received a groin flap to cover the defect. No other thumbs had any complications. The functional and esthetic results of both the donor and the recipient sites were satisfactory. Results show that, for patients with traumatic thumb defects, the combined transfer of flap and second toe phalanx was the best option.

Conclusions

Compared to the great toe or second toe transfer, combined free transfer of the great toenail flap and second toe phalanx achieved a substantially better functional and esthetic result in the thumb reconstruction.

A simple approach to thumb amputation reconstruction at metacarpal base with toe transfer, two case reports

•

Reconstruction for thumb amputation at the metacarpal base by toe transfer is challenging.

•

To restore a thumb with normal or near-normal length, the reconstruction plan usually involves a complicated and challenging process either in two stages (stage 1: resolving soft tissue and bone defect; stage 2: toe transfer) or a single stage by using two free flaps (one free soft tissue flap and one toe flap).

•

We accepted the shortened metacarpal length and performed reconstruction in a single stage by trimmed great toe flap, at the level of the metatarsophalangeal joint. The first phalanx of toe flap was fused with the first metacarpal base.

•

The reconstructed thumbs were functional similarly to a thumb amputation group 1 of Campbell-Reid. The tip of the reconstructed thumb looks like that of a normal thumb.

•

With this technique, the reconstruction process could be done more easily and simply in a single stage.

Introduction

Reconstruction for thumb amputation at the metacarpal base by toe transfer is challenging. To restore a thumb with normal or near-normal length, the reconstruction plan usually involves a complicated and challenging process either in two stages (stage 1: resolving soft tissue and bone defect; stage 2: toe transfer) or a single stage by using two free flaps (one free soft tissue flap and one toe flap). However, is it necessary to restore the full length of the thumb for functional and aesthetic achievement?

Presentation of cases

Two male patients (21 and 22 years old) had a thumb amputation at the metacarpal base. We accepted the shortened metacarpal length and performed reconstruction in one stage by trimmed great toe flap, at the level of the metatarsophalangeal joint. The first phalanx of toe flap was fused with the first metacarpal base. On long-term follow-up, both patients were able to return to daily activities, work and had a good cosmesis.

Discussion

With our reconstruction technique, two reconstructed thumbs were functionally similar to a thumb amputation group 1 of Campbell-Reid. Using trimmed great toe flap, the tip of our reconstructed thumbs looks like that of a normal thumb. Both patients were satisfied.

Conclusion

Accepting length shortening, the reconstruction for thumb amputation at the metacarpal base by toe transfer could be done more easily and simply in a single stage.

Gait Improvement and Ulcer Prevention With Second-to-Great Toe Transposition at the Donor Site: A Case Report

A young male patient, who sustained a severe burn injury 6 years ago, received amputation of left hand at the level of metacarpal shaft of the thumb and base of proximal phalanxes of the rest of the fingers. Staged operations, including combined second- and third-toe transfer from the right foot to middle and ring fingers of the left hand, and harvest of great toe from the left foot for reconstruction of left thumb, were successively executed. Unfortunately, callus and ulcer were found at the plantar area of first metatarsophalangeal joint of left donor foot in the following 2 years, which caused troublesome disturbance during ambulation. We hereby present how second toe transposition can decrease the donor foot pain and prevent the recurrence of plantar ulcer after 21 months of follow-up.

Clinical effect of thumb finger reconstruction using dorsal foot flap transplant for treating thumb defects

It was found that conventional toe graft alone could not meet the patients' needs for wound repair, so we hypothesized that it would be more effective to treat thumb and finger defect by toe graft with dorsalis foot flap. This prospective study was conducted in 104 thumb defect patients to investigate the clinical effect of thumb reconstruction using toe graft with dorsal foot flap for the treatment of thumb defects. These patients were randomly divided into the dorsal foot group and the control group by randomized double-blind method, with 52 patients in each group. The second toe was used for thumb reconstruction transplant in both the groups. After thumb reconstruction, the abdominal pedicled flap was used to repair the surgical wound in the control group whereas the dorsal foot flap was used to repair the surgical wound in the dorsal foot group. Three months after surgery, the efficacy of surgical treatment, evaluation of two-point discrimination, postoperative complications, function of reconstructed thumb, operation time, and hospitalization time were recorded and compared between the two groups. MHOQ questionnaire was used to evaluate and compare the patients' satisfaction with finger reconstruction in both the groups. The surgical therapeutic effect, the function of the reconstructed thumb, and satisfaction with finger reconstruction were significantly higher in the dorsal foot group compared to the control group (all p < 0.05). The postoperative two-point discrimination, postoperative complication rate, operation time, and hospitalization time of patients in the dorsal foot group were significantly lower compared to the control group (all p < 0.05). Thumb finger reconstruction using the second toe transplant with dorsal foot flap had a beneficial effect on thumb defect patients. It can effectively improve finger function and sensory recovery of patients while reducing complications.