Outcomes of Phalangeal Neck Fractures in a Pediatric Population

Cast versus Kirschner wire fixation in type II paediatric phalangeal neck fractures

PURPOSE

To compare the outcomes of type II pediatric phalangeal neck fractures (PPNFs) treated with closed reduction and cast immobilization (CRCI) versus closed reduction percutaneous pinning (CRPP), and evaluated the clinical efficacy of conservative versus surgical treatment of type II PPNFs via meta-analysis.

METHODS

Patients aged ≤ 14 years with type II PPNFs were divided into conservative (CRCI) and operative (CRPP) groups. Radiographs measured angulation and translation; hand function was assessed with total active range of motion (TAM) and Quick-DASH. Complication rates were also compared between the groups. A meta-analysis of conservative versus operative treatment confirmed the clinical results. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 26.0 and R studio 3.0 with two-tailed, chi-squared, and Mann-Whitney U or t-tests, P < 0.05. Meta-analysis used fixed or random effects models, calculating mean differences and odds ratios for outcomes, and assessing heterogeneity with I2 and Q tests.

RESULTS

Final angulation (3.4° ± 3.7° and 4.9° ± 5.4° vs. 3.6° ± 3.7° and 4.2° ± 4.3°) and displacement (6.3% ± 5.8% and 5.7% ± 4.7% vs. 5.8% ± 5.5% and 3.2% ± 4.2%) in the coronal and sagittal planes were not different statistically between the conservative and surgical groups (P > 0.05), but improved significantly compared to preoperative values (P < 0.05). Although Quick-DASH scores were comparable in both groups (P = 0.105), conservatively treated patients had a significantly better TAM at the last follow-up visit (P = 0.005). The complication rates were 24.2% and 41.7% in the surgical and conservatively treated groups respectively (P = 0.162). However, the latter primarily experienced imaging-related complications, whereas the former experienced functional complications (P = 0.046). Our meta-analysis (n = 181 patients) also showed comparable functional (P = 0.49) and radiographic (P = 0.59) outcomes and complication rates (P = 0.21) between the surgical (94 patients) and conservative (87 patients) groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Conservative and surgical treatments are both reliable and safe approaches for managing type II PPNF in children. However, conservatively treated patients generally experience similar radiographic outcomes, lower complication rates, and better functional outcomes than surgically treated ones.

Comparison of splinting immobilization and K-wire fixation in children with type II phalange neck fracture

To compare outcomes of type II phalangeal neck fractures in children who received closed reduction followed by splinting immobilization or by K-wire fixation. Furthermore, we analyzed the remodeling potential of residual deformities and the relationship between age and outcomes. Patients in Children's Hospital of Fudan University, Xiamen Hospital were included in the study from October 2015 to October 2018. We compared outcomes between the conservation group and operation group. Remodeling of residual deformities was calculated on a series of anteroposterior and lateral radiography. The correlation between age and outcomes was analyzed using Spearman's rank correlation coefficient. Forty patients (25 males) were enrolled. Nineteen patients had subtype IIa, 19 subtype IIb, and two subtype IIc fractures. Left hands were affected more than right hands, and small finger and proximal phalanx were more frequently involved. There were no significant differences between conservation group and operation group among excellent, good, and fair outcomes. And the outcomes were not significantly different between the IIa and IIb subtypes. An average sagittal remodeling rate was 88.5%, and coronal remodeling rate was 56.71%, respectively, in 13 patients with residual deformities. There was a significant correlation between age and final outcomes. Closed reduction and stable splint fixation may be an effective and economical initial treatment option. Fracture subtype does not seem to be a key factor for choosing treatment options. The fractured phalangeal neck had remodeling potential whether on sagittal or coronal plane. Younger age might be a predictor of better outcomes in children with type II phalanx neck fractures.

Unique Considerations for Paediatric Proximal Phalanx Fractures

Paediatric hand fracture care presents unique considerations and challenges. The proximal phalanx is the most injured location. This review details pearls for the examination of the injured paediatric hand, immobilisation considerations and treatment strategies. Over-treatment can lead to unnecessary stiffness, missed activities, increased healthcare costs or unnecessary surgical morbidity. Undertreatment can promote malunion and dysfunction. Fracture patterns discussed include those of the phalangeal head, neck, shaft and base. The concepts covered will help optimise the evaluation and treatment of children with injured proximal phalanges. Level of Evidence: Level V (Therapeutic).

Corrective osteotomy for distal condylar malunion of the proximal phalanx in adolescents: comparison of K-wire and locking plate fixation

This retrospective study reviewed 28 patients, aged 10 to 17 years, who underwent corrective osteotomy for malunion of the proximal phalangeal distal condyles at a mean of 9 weeks (range 2-52) from injury. There were 19 patients treated with K-wire and nine patients with locking plates. The two groups were comparable for trauma mechanism, fracture type, time delay from injury and the type of initial treatment. The K-wire group had a shorter duration of operation and shorter time to union than the plating group. For both groups, postoperative radiographs showed significant correction, which remained unchanged until the final follow-up (minimum 12 months), although greater residual coronal angulation was found in the K-wire group. The outcomes in 17 of the 28 patients were graded as excellent or good according to the Al-Qattan classification, with no difference between the groups. The complication rate was also similar between the groups, while the locking plate group had a higher rate of secondary surgery.Level of evidence: III.

A Comparison of Casting Versus Splinting for Nonoperative Treatment of Pediatric Phalangeal Neck Fractures

BACKGROUND

Phalangeal neck fractures account for 13% of pediatric finger fractures. Al Qattan type I (undisplaced) fractures are treated nonoperatively. There is increasing evidence that Type 2 (displaced) fractures achieve remarkable fracture remodeling with nonoperative treatment and patients frequently make a full functional recovery. The options available for nonoperative management of these fractures are either a plaster cast or a removable splint. We hypothesized that there would be no significant difference in radiologic outcome in pediatric phalangeal neck fractures (Types I and II) treated with splint or cast immobilization.

METHODS

This is a retrospective study of patients aged 18 and below with phalangeal neck fractures treated nonoperatively from 2008 to 2017. Radiographs were compared at <1 week and >3 weeks after injury. Translation and angulation in coronal and sagittal planes were measured and compared using Student t tests. Baseline variables were compared using χ or Fisher exact tests.

RESULTS

There were 47 patients with phalangeal neck fractures treated nonoperatively during the study period. There were 9 type I and 38 type II fractures. The mean age was 10 years with 40 males and 7 females. Fractures occurred in 33 dominant and 14 nondominant hands and involved 29 proximal and 18 middle phalanges. Nineteen children were treated in casts and 28 with removable splints. The mean duration of follow-up was similar between the 2 groups. The most affected phalanx was the proximal phalanx of the small finger and the most common fracture pattern was type IIA. There was no significant difference in clinical and radiologic outcomes between children who were treated in casts and those treated in removable splints.

CONCLUSION

There was no difference in the clinical and radiologic outcomes in pediatric phalangeal neck fractures treated with cast or splint immobilization. Splinting has the added benefits of increased comfort and hygiene and we routinely offer splinting as a viable alternative in the nonoperative treatment of Al Qattan type I and type II phalangeal fractures.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III-therapeutic studies.