Comparative Accuracy of 1.5T MRI, 3T MRI, and Static Ultrasound in Diagnosis of Small Gaps in Repaired Flexor Tendons: A Cadaveric Study

Diagnosis and treatment of flexor tendon injuries of the hand: what the radiologist needs to know

This article reviews the diagnosis and treatment of flexor tendon injuries of the hand highlighting flexor tendon anatomy, important pre-operative imaging findings, surgical options, and post-operative complications. Imaging plays a key role in guiding treatment of these difficult to manage injuries. Thus, it is important for radiologists to have a sound understanding of factors important in treatment decision-making. In the pre-operative setting, accurately identifying the location of the torn proximal tendon stump in subacute and chronic injuries helps dictate whether the patient is a candidate for a primary flexor tendon repair or may require a tendon reconstruction to restore function. In the post-operative setting, the status of the repair and presence of surrounding adhesions help dictate if and when the patient will require subsequent surgery and whether that surgery will be a tenolysis, revision repair, reconstruction, or fusion.

Sensitivity and Accuracy of High-Resolution Ultrasound for Diagnosis of Flexor Tendon Repair Integrity

BACKGROUND

The authors examined whether ultrasound sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy in identifying intact repairs or flexor tendon gapping after zone 2 repair are affected by the number of suture strands crossing the repair or gap or imaging modality (static versus dynamic).

METHODS

A total of 144 fresh-frozen cadaveric digits (thumbs excluded) were randomized to either an intact repair (0-mm gap) or simulated failed repair (4-mm gap), as well as to either a two- or eight-strand locked-cruciate repair of a zone 2 flexor digitorum profundus tendon laceration using 4-0 Fiberwire. Examinations were performed by a blinded musculoskeletal ultrasonographer in static and dynamic modes using an 18-MHz transducer. Gaps were remeasured after scanning, and the final gap width recorded. McNemar exact test was used to determine whether there were differences in sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy affected by modality (static versus dynamic), and chi-square test was used to compare sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy between number of strands (two versus eight) crossing the intact repair or repair gap (≥4 mm).

RESULTS

Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy improved with increased number of suture strands crossing the repair or gap (eight versus two), irrespective of modality (static versus dynamic), and dynamic compared with static scanning modes, irrespective of number of suture strands crossing the repair or gap site.

CONCLUSIONS

The most sensitive and accurate means of assessing flexor tendon repair integrity and gapping were seen using the dynamic scanning mode. Increased number of suture strands did not negatively affect sensitivity, specificity, or accuracy, regardless of scanning mode (dynamic or static).

Investigating the reliability and validity of subacromial space measurements using ultrasound and MRI

BACKGROUND

While ultrasound (US) measures of the subacromial space (SAS) have demonstrated excellent reliability, measurements are typically captured by experts with extensive ultrasound experience. Further, the agreement between US measured SAS width and other imaging modalities has not been explored. This research evaluated the agreement between SAS measures captured by novice and expert raters and between US and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). This study also evaluated the effect of US transducer tilt on measured SAS.

METHODS

Nine men and nine women participated in this study. US images were captured by a novice and expert with the participant in both seated and supine positions. An inclinometer was fixed to the US probe to measure transducer tilt. SAS width was measured in real time from freeze framed images. MRI images were captured, and the humerus and acromion manually segmented. The SAS width was measured using a custom algorithm.

RESULTS

Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) between novice and expert raters were 0.74 and 0.63 for seated and supine positions, respectively. Intra-rater agreement was high for both novice (ICC = 0.83-0.84) and expert (ICC ≥ 0.94) raters. Agreement between US and MRI was poor (ICC = 0.21-0.49) but linearly related.

CONCLUSIONS

Moderate agreement between novice and expert raters was demonstrated, while the agreement between US and MRI was poor. High intra-rater reliability within each rater suggests that US measures of the SAS may be completed by a novice with introductory training.

Comparative sensitivity and accuracy of 24 vs. 18 MHz ultrasound probes for the diagnosis of flexor tendon repair integrity

Purpose

To determine whether a 24 MHz transducer significantly improves sensitivity, specificity and accuracy in evaluating flexor tendon repair integrity compared with an 18 MHz transducer.

Methods

One hundred and twelve cadaveric digits were randomised to an intact repair or simulated 'failed' repair, and to a two- or eight-strand repair of a flexor digitorum profundus laceration. A blinded sonologist evaluated specimens in static mode using 18 and 24 MHz transducers. Gaps were remeasured after scanning, and final gap width recorded. McNemar's exact test calculated differences between sensitivity, specificity and accuracy, and chi-squared test to compare sensitivity, specificity and accuracy between number of strands (2 vs. 8) and repair gap (≥4 mm).

Results

The 24 MHz transducer had higher sensitivity (81 vs. 59%), lower specificity (67 vs. 70%) and higher overall accuracy (74 vs. 64%), than the 18 MHz transducer. The difference for sensitivity was significant (P = 0.011), but not differences for specificity and overall accuracy (P > 0.05). Pearson's correlation (r = 0.61) demonstrated a moderate-to-strong positive correlation between measured and true gap sizes. Increased number of suture strands (2 vs. 8) did not impair sensitivity, specificity nor accuracy.

Discussion

Ultrasound may tend to overestimate gap width, and a slight risk that some intact repairs, or those with small, clinically insignificant gaps may undergo surgical exploration that may not be indicated.

Conclusions

A 24 MHz transducer is a more sensitive and accurate transducer for assessing flexor tendon repair integrity and measuring small gaps.

Utilization of Portable Brain Magnetic Resonance Imaging in an Acute Care Setting

Background Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an important noninvasive diagnostic tool used in multiple facets of medicine, especially in the assessment of the neurological system with increasing usage over the past decades. Advancement in technology has led to the creation of portable MRI (pMRI) that was cleared for use recently. Methodology A prospectively collected retrospective study was conducted at a single institution to include patients aged >18 years, admitted to the hospital, and requiring MRI for any brain pathology. pMRI was completed using portable MRI. Traditional MRI was completed with a standard 1.5T MRI, and when possible, the results of the two studies were compared. Results We obtained pMRI on 20 patients, with a total of 22 scans completed. Notably, on the pMRI, we were able to identify midline structures to determine midline shifts, identify the size of ventricles, and see large pathologies, including ischemic and hemorrhagic strokes, edema, and tumors. Patients with implants or electrodes in and around the calvarium sometimes pose challenges to image acquisition. Conclusions Portable brain MRI is a practical and useful technology that can provide immediate information about the head, especially in an acute care setting. Portable brain MRI has a lower resolution and quality of imaging compared to that of transitional MRI, and therefore, it is not a replacement for traditional MRI.