Role of the extensor carpi ulnaris in the stabilization of the lunotriquetral joint. An experimental study

Scapholunate and lunotriquetral joint dynamic stabilizers and their role in wrist neuromuscular control and proprioception

BACKGROUND

Recent research interest has grown in exploring the role of muscles, isometric contraction, proprioception, and neuromuscular control in addressing dynamic scapholunate and lunotriquetral joint instability, marking a shift in the understanding of wrist stability.

PURPOSE

To present a comprehensive review of the carpal ligaments anatomy and wrist biomechanics, with a particular focus on the role of proprioception in dynamic carpal stability and their role in managing scapholunate (SL) and lunotriquetral (LTq) dynamic instabilities.

STUDY DESIGN

We conducted a systematic search of the literature and review of the most relevant papers published and indexed in pubmed, related to wrist biomechanics, proprioception and its contribution to carpal dynamic stability.

METHODS

The study involved a comprehensive review of neuromuscular mechanisms in dynamic stabilization of the carpus, based on cadaver studies. The 3D position of the scaphoid, triquetrum, and capitate was monitored before and after tendon loading.

RESULTS

The extensor carpi ulnaris (ECU) and the flexor carpi radialis (FCR) are identified as the primary pronators of the midcarpal joint. The ECU's pronation effect can potentially strain the scapholunate ligament, while the supinator muscles, the abductor pollicis longus (APL), the extensor carpi radialis longus (ECRL), and the flexor carpi ulnaris (FCU), have a protective role, particularly in cases of scapholunate ligament dysfunctions. The FCR, despite being a pronator of the distal row, has a beneficial effect as it provokes supination of the scaphoid.

CONCLUSIONS

Comprehending carpal dysfunctions and instabilities hinges on understanding carpal anatomy and normal biomechanics. Proprioception, encompassing joint position sensation and neuromuscular control, is pivotal for stability. Biomechanical research informs tailored muscle strengthening for specific carpal issues. Supinator muscles should be strengthened for SL injuries, and ECU-focused strengthening and proprioceptive training are key for dynamic LTq instabilities. Ongoing research should delve into the intricate relationship between carpal ligaments, muscles, and proprioception to enhance wrist stability.

Wrist proprioception-An update on scientific insights and clinical implications in rehabilitation of the wrist

The field of wrist proprioception, as it relates to rehabilitation and surgery, has gone through a period of intense growth in the past decade. From being primarily focused on the function of the joint and ligaments in patients with wrist trauma or after wrist surgery, the understanding is now that of a greater complexity in treating not just the wrist but the hand and arm as a whole. Proprioception is derived from the Latin words "proprius" - belonging to (oneself) and "-ception" to sense. In other words, how to sense ourselves. To have a complete sense of self, multiple sensory afferents originating from joints, ligaments, muscles, tendons, nerves, skin, vision, and hearing work together to orchestrate a balanced integration of sensorimotor functions, with the true goal to perceive and adapt to the physical world around us. In this update on wrist proprioception, we review current developments in the understanding of proprioception, with an implication for our everyday work as hand therapists and hand surgeons. Each contributing sense-joint, ligaments, muscles, skin, and brain-will be reviewed, and the clinical relevance will be discussed. An updated wrist rehabilitation protocol is proposed where the therapist is guided to rehabilitate a patient after wrist trauma and/or surgery in 4 stages: (1) basic hand and wrist rehabilitation with a focus on reducing edema, pain, and scar formation; (2) proprioception awareness to improve the sense of joint motion and position; (3) conscious neuromuscular rehabilitation where isometric exercises of muscles that are beneficial for a particular injury are promoted, whereas others that are potentially harmful are avoided; and (4) unconscious neuromuscular rehabilitation with training of the reflex and joint protective senses.

Exercise-based intervention as a nonsurgical treatment for patients with carpal instability: A case series

BACKGROUND

Although the important roles of proprioception and neuromuscular control in carpal instabilities under laboratory conditions have been recognized, only a few studies have translated this knowledge into a routine clinical practice.

PURPOSE

This study aimed to evaluate the results of a personalized rehabilitation in patients with carpal instability on functionality and pain intensity.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a case series study.

METHODS

This case series included 39 adults (mean age: 38.2 ± 14.0 years; 16/23 females/males) diagnosed with carpal instability (radial or ulnar) with indication for orthopedic treatment. The disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand questionnaire was used to assess upper limb functionality. Pain perception was assessed using a visual analog scale. Exercise-based physiotherapy interventions were performed according to the clinical needs of the patients for at least 6 weeks (2-3 sessions per week). For the treatment of radial instability (n = 13), strengthening exercises of the abductor pollicis longus, extensor carpi radialis longus, flexor carpi radialis, and pronator quadratus muscles were prescribed. For the treatment of ulnar instability (n = 24), extensor carpi ulnaris and pronator quadratus were trained. All patients underwent proprioceptive training in open kinetic chain and closed kinetic chain, as well as strengthening of the unaffected hand. Changes before and after treatment were compared using the nonparametric Wilcoxon signed rank test.

RESULTS

A significant improvement with a large effect size in disabilities of the arm, shoulder, and hand (P < .001; d = 2.9) and visual analog scale (P < .001; d = 3.2) scores were obtained after treatment. Moreover, the changes were greater than the minimal clinically important difference of 10.8 and 1.4, respectively. Similar results were found when patients with radial instability and ulnar instability were analyzed separately.

CONCLUSIONS

Personalized training with specific proprioception and strengthening exercises produces improvements in functionality and pain perception in our cohort of people with carpal instability. These results highlight the importance of multicomponent exercise in the treatment of wrist instability. Future randomized clinical trials should further investigate the effectiveness of this protocol.

An in vitro hand simulator for simultaneous control of hand and wrist movements

A human hand is a complex biomechanical system, in which bones, ligaments, and musculotendon units dynamically interact to produce seemingly simple motions. A new physiological hand simulator has been developed, in which electromechanical actuators apply load to the tendons of extrinsic hand and wrist muscles to recreate movements in cadaveric specimens in a biofidelic way. This novel simulator simultaneously and independently controls the movements of the wrist (flexion/extension and radio-ulnar deviation) and flexion/extension of the fingers and thumb. Control of these four degrees of freedom (DOF) is made possible by actuating eleven extrinsic muscles of the hand. The coupled dynamics of the wrist, fingers, and thumb, and the over-actuated nature of the human musculoskeletal system make feedback control of hand movements challenging. Two control algorithms were developed and tested. The optimal controller relies on an optimization algorithm to calculate the required tendon tensions using the collective error in all DOFs, and the action-based controller loads the tendons solely based on their actions on the controlled DOFs (e.g., activating all flexors if a flexing moment is required). Both controllers resulted in hand movements with small errors from the reference trajectories (<3.4); however, the optimal controller achieved this with 16% lower total force. Owing to its simpler structure, the action-based controller was extended to enable feedback control of grip force. This simulator has been shown to be a highly repeatable tool (<0.25 N and <0.2 variations in force and kinematics, respectively) for in vitro analyses of human hand biomechanics.

Demystifying Palmar Midcarpal Instability

Palmar midcarpal instability is an uncommon condition diagnosed clinically with a painful pathognomonic clunk on terminal ulnar deviation of the wrist. Various causes have been described, but congenital laxity of the carpal ligaments is thought to be a key contributor. Treatment commences with conservative measures. This includes proprioceptive training based on more recent concepts on the sensorimotor function of the wrist. When these measures plateau, surgery is considered. The lack of high-level evidence and consensus on its cause continue to hamper our understanding and knowledge of this condition. The purpose of this review is to examine the current evidence to conceptualize this mysterious, yet infrequent phenomenon, and to provide an algorithm on its management.

El papel de la propiocepción y el control neuromuscular en las inestabilidades del carpo

La congruencia articular, la integridad ligamentaria y la compresión de las superficies articulares ocasionada por la contracción muscular se han considerado históricamente los tres pilares básicos para la estabilidad del carpo. En los últimos años se ha propuesto un nuevo factor para explicar los mecanismos de estabilización carpiana, la propiocepción y el control neuromuscular. La propiocepción en la muñeca se origina en órganos sensoriales localizados en los ligamentos y cápsulas articulares (los mecanorreceptores). La estimulación de los mismos inicia un reflejo involuntario que provoca una respuesta muscular selectiva dirigida a proteger la zona de la muñeca donde se ha originado la señal aferente. En este trabajo de revisión se pretende dar a conocer el concepto de propiocepción y control neuromuscular, el papel que tienen en la estabilidad del carpo y las posibles aplicaciones en la práctica clínica.

Inestabilidad lunopiramidal

Históricamente, la inestabilidad en el lado radial de la muñeca ha recibido mucha más atención que la inestabilidad en el lado ulnar, a pesar de ser una patología relativamente frecuente. Como consecuencia de ello, suele darse un retraso en el diagnóstico correcto y el tratamiento apropiado. Las lesiones del ligamento lunopiramidal pueden ser parciales o completas, y estas últimas pueden estar asociadas a lesión de los estabilizadores secundarios. Cuando se lesionan estos estabilizadores es cuando se produce una inestabilidad estática del carpo conocida como Volar Intercalated Segmentary Instability (VISI). Entre los test clínicos más utilizados para detectar una inestabilidad del ligamento lunopiramidal están el Ballottement test, descrito por Reagan, y el Shear test, descrito por Kleinman, aunque ambos poseen una sensibilidad y una especificidad bajas. Para el diagnóstico de estas lesiones se emplean técnicas como la radiografía simple (que suele ser normal si no hay una inestabilidad estática del carpo), la artrografía y la RMN, entre otras, aunque el gold standard lo constituye la artroscopia de muñeca. No existe un consenso en cuanto al tipo de tratamiento óptimo, ya que la mayoría de los estudios publicados son retrospectivos de nivel iv sin medidas objetivas estandarizadas mediante instrumentos validados. Además, en su mayoría describen los resultados del tratamiento tardío, ya que no se suelen diagnosticar en la fase aguda. Dentro de los tratamientos descritos se encuentran el tratamiento artroscópico (desbridamiento/termocoagulación asociados o no a estabilización con agujas de Kirscher), la reparación abierta, la reconstrucción del ligamento y la artrodesis del ligamento lunopiramidal.

Rehabilitation strategies for wrist sensorimotor control impairment: From theory to practice

This clinical review discusses the organization, neuroanatomy, assessment, clinical relevance, and rehabilitation of sensorimotor (SM) control impairment after wrist trauma. The wrist SM control system encompasses complex SM pathways that control normal wrist active range of motion and mediate wrist joint neuromuscular stability for maintaining joint function. Among various known assessment methods of wrist SM control impairment, the active wrist joint position sense test is determined to be a clinically meaningful and responsive measure for wrist SM control impairment after wrist fracture. Wrist trauma may involve significant soft tissue injury (ie, skin, ligament, muscle), which could disrupt the generation and transmission of adequate proprioceptive input from wrist mechanoreceptors, thus leading to significant joint SM impairment. Various clinical examples of wrist trauma (eg, distal radius fracture, scapholunate joint injury) along with known prognostic factors (eg, pain) that may influence wrist SM control impairment recovery are discussed to illustrate this point. This article proposes promising rehabilitation strategies toward restoring wrist joint conscious and unconscious SM control impairments, integrating current research evidence with clinical practice. These strategies require more rigorous evaluation in clinical trials.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

5.

Role of muscles in the stabilization of ligament-deficient wrists

This article reviews the results of a series of cadaver investigations aimed at clarifying the role of muscles in the stabilization of ligament-deficient wrists. According to these studies, isometric contraction of some forearm muscles induces midcarpal (MC) supination (ie, the abductor pollicis longus, extensor carpi radialis longus, and flexor carpi ulnaris), whereas other muscles induce MC pronation (ie, the extensor carpi ulnaris). Because MC supination implies tightening of the volar scaphoid-distal row ligaments, the MC supination muscles are likely to prevent scaphoid collapse of wrists with scapholunate ligament insufficiency. MC pronator muscles, by contrast, would be beneficial in stabilizing wrists with ulnar-sided ligament deficiencies owing to their ability to tighten the triquetrum-distal row ligaments. Should these laboratory findings be validated by additional clinical research, proprioceptive reeducation of selected muscles could become an important tool for the treatment of dynamic carpal instabilities.

Traumatic Extensor Tendon Injuries to the Hand: Clinical Anatomy, Biomechanics, and Surgical Procedure Review

The extensor apparatus is a complex muscle-tendon system that requires integrity or optimal reconstruction to preserve hand function. Anatomical knowledge and the understanding of physiopathology of extensor tendons are essential for an accurate diagnosis of extensor tendon injuries (ETIs) of the hand and wrist, because these lesions are complex and commonly observed in clinical practice. A careful clinical history and assessment still remain the first step for the diagnosis, followed by US and MR to confirm the suspect of ETI or to investigate some doubtful conditions and rule out associate lesions. During last decades the evolution of surgical techniques and rehabilitative treatment protocol led to gradual improvement in clinical results of ETI treatment and surgical repair. Injury classification into anatomical zones and the evaluation of the characteristics of the lesions are considered key points to select the appropriate treatment for ETI. Both conservative and surgical management can be indicated in ETI, depending on the anatomical zone and on the characteristics of the injuries. As a general rule, an attempt of conservative treatment should be performed when the lesion is expected to have favorable result with nonoperative procedure. Many surgical techniques have been proposed over the time and with favorable results if the tendon injury is not underestimated and adequately treated. Despite recent research findings, a lack of evidence-based knowledge is still observed in surgical treatment and postoperative management of ETI. Further clinical and biomechanical investigations would be advisable to clarify this complex issue.

Conservative management of midcarpal instability

Midcarpal instability is a complex condition that can present in various forms, from mild pain to debilitating subluxation. Once diagnosed, treatment guidelines for hand therapy are limited by the scarcity of high-level evidence. Evidence does exist for use of proprioceptive awareness and neuromuscular rehabilitation for instability of the knee, shoulder and ankle joint, but studies of similar programmes for the wrist joint have not been published. The purpose of this review is to examine the evidence supporting current concepts in the non-operative management of midcarpal instability, and to provide recommendations for the management of this condition with hand therapy.

The role of proprioception and neuromuscular stability in carpal instabilities

Carpal stability has traditionally been defined as dependent on the articular congruity of joint surfaces, the static stability maintained by intact ligaments, and the dynamic stability caused by muscle contractions resulting in a compression of joint surfaces. In the past decade, a fourth factor in carpal stability has been proposed, involving the neuromuscular and proprioceptive control of joints. The proprioception of the wrist originates from afferent signals elicited by sensory end organs (mechanoreceptors) in ligaments and joint capsules that elicit spinal reflexes for immediate joint stability, as well as higher order neuromuscular influx to the cerebellum and sensorimotor cortices for planning and executing joint control. The aim of this review is to provide an understanding of the role of proprioception and neuromuscular control in carpal instabilities by delineating the sensory innervation and the neuromuscular control of the carpus, as well as descriptions of clinical applications of proprioception in carpal instabilities.

Functional kinematics of the wrist

The purpose of this article is to review past and present concepts concerning functional kinematics of the healthy and injured wrist. To provide a context for students of the wrist, we describe the progression of techniques for measuring carpal kinematics over the past century and discuss how this has influenced today's understanding of functional kinematics. Next, we provide an overview of recent developments and highlight the clinical relevance of these findings. We use these findings and recent evidence that supports the importance of coupled motion in early rehabilitation of radiocarpal injuries to develop the argument that coupled motion during functional activities is a clinically relevant outcome; therefore, clinicians should develop a framework for its dynamic assessment. This should enable a tailored and individualized approach to the treatment of carpal injuries.

Diagnosis and Treatment of Chronic Lunotriquetral Ligament Injuries

Chronic lunotriquetral (LT) injuries are less common than scapholunate ligament injuries and difficult to diagnose. They may be associated with positive ulnar variance. Clinical diagnostic tests elicit pain at the LT interval. Although radiographs are typically normal, MRI and wrist arthroscopy can help confirm the diagnosis. When conservative treatments fail, surgical options include LT ligament reconstruction, LT arthrodesis, and ulnar-shortening osteotomy (in patients with positive ulnar variance).