The genesis of ribosome structure: how a protein generates RNA structure in real time

Paradigms of ribosome synthesis: Lessons learned from ribosomal proteins

The proteome in all cells is manufactured via the intricate process of translation by multimolecular factories called ribosomes. Nevertheless, these ribonucleoprotein particles, the largest of their kind, also have an elaborate assembly line of their own. Groundbreaking discoveries that bacterial ribosomal subunits can be self-assembled in vitro jumpstarted studies on how ribosomes are constructed. Until recently, ribosome assembly has been investigated almost entirely in vitro with bacterial small subunits under equilibrium conditions. In light of high-resolution ribosome structures and a more sophisticated toolkit, the past decade has been defined by a burst of kinetic studies in vitro and, importantly, also a shift to examining ribosome maturation in living cells, especially in eukaryotes. In this review, we summarize the principles governing ribosome assembly that emerged from studies focusing on ribosomal proteins and their interactions with rRNA. Understanding these paradigms has taken center stage, given the linkage between anomalous ribosome biogenesis and proliferative disorders.

Deletion of L4 domains reveals insights into the importance of ribosomal protein extensions in eukaryotic ribosome assembly

Numerous ribosomal proteins have a striking bipartite architecture: a globular body positioned on the ribosomal exterior and an internal loop buried deep into the rRNA core. In eukaryotes, a significant number of conserved r-proteins have evolved extra amino- or carboxy-terminal tail sequences, which thread across the solvent-exposed surface. The biological importance of these extended domains remains to be established. In this study, we have investigated the universally conserved internal loop and the eukaryote-specific extensions of yeast L4. We show that in contrast to findings with bacterial L4, deleting the internal loop of yeast L4 causes severely impaired growth and reduced levels of large ribosomal subunits. We further report that while depleting the entire L4 protein blocks early assembly steps in yeast, deletion of only its extended internal loop affects later steps in assembly, revealing a second role for L4 during ribosome biogenesis. Surprisingly, deletion of the entire eukaryote-specific carboxy-terminal tail of L4 has no effect on viability, production of 60S subunits, or translation. These unexpected observations provide impetus to further investigate the functions of ribosomal protein extensions, especially eukaryote-specific examples, in ribosome assembly and function.

Yeast polypeptide exit tunnel ribosomal proteins L17, L35 and L37 are necessary to recruit late-assembling factors required for 27SB pre-rRNA processing

Ribosome synthesis involves the coordinated folding and processing of pre-rRNAs with assembly of ribosomal proteins. In eukaryotes, these events are facilitated by trans-acting factors that propel ribosome maturation from the nucleolus to the cytoplasm. However, there is a gap in understanding how ribosomal proteins configure pre-ribosomes in vivo to enable processing to occur. Here, we have examined the role of adjacent yeast r-proteins L17, L35 and L37 in folding and processing of pre-rRNAs, and binding of other proteins within assembling ribosomes. These three essential ribosomal proteins, which surround the polypeptide exit tunnel, are required for 60S subunit formation as a consequence of their role in removal of the ITS2 spacer from 27SB pre-rRNA. L17-, L35- and L37-depleted cells exhibit turnover of aberrant pre-60S assembly intermediates. Although the structure of ITS2 does not appear to be grossly affected in their absence, these three ribosomal proteins are necessary for efficient recruitment of factors required for 27SB pre-rRNA processing, namely, Nsa2 and Nog2, which associate with pre-60S ribosomal particles containing 27SB pre-rRNAs. Altogether, these data support that L17, L35 and L37 are specifically required for a recruiting step immediately preceding removal of ITS2.

Real-time evidence for EF-G-induced dynamics of helix 44 in 16S rRNA

The penultimate stem-loop of 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA), helix 44, plays a central role in ribosome function. Using time-resolved dimethyl sulfate (DMS) probing, we have analyzed time-dependent modifications that occur at specific bases in this helix near the decoding region, resulting from the binding of elongation factor G (EF-G) in various forms. When EF-G-GTP is bound to 70S ribosomes, bases A1492 and A1493 are immediately protected, while other bases in the region show either no change or enhanced modification. When apo-EF-G is bound to 70S ribosomes and GTP is added, substantial transient time-dependent enhancement occurs at bases A1492 and A1493, with somewhat less enhancement occurring at base A1483, all in the first 45 ms. When mRNA and deacylated tRNAs are bound to the 70S ribosome and EF-G-GTP is added, bases A1492 and A1493 again show substantial and continued enhancement, while bases A1408, A1413, and A1418 all show time-dependent protection. These results provide primary, real-time evidence that EF-G induces direct or indirect structural changes in this region as EF-G is bound and as GTP is hydrolyzed.

The formation of a potential spring in the ribosome

Time-dependent chemical modification and cleavage results have provided intriguing insights into structural changes that occur in the distal loop of helix 11 in 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA). Located distant from the decoding region, between proteins S17 and S20, the results of this study suggest that this region of rRNA may act as a buffer or a spring between these two proteins during protein biosynthesis. During the assembly process, protein S17 apparently produces the major structural deformations in this region, causing it to be folded in a spring-like structure. Base C264 in this region shows erratic behavior during assembly and also shows time-dependent enhancement when elongation factor G with GTP is added to 70S ribosomes. Evidence is presented to suggest that this region of rRNA may be used to allow relative motion to occur between proteins S17 and S20 during translocation.

A-minor tertiary interactions in RNA kink-turns. Molecular dynamics and quantum chemical analysis

The RNA kink-turn is an important recurrent RNA motif, an internal loop with characteristic consensus sequence forming highly conserved three-dimensional structure. Functional arrangement of RNA kink-turns shows a sharp bend in the phosphodiester backbone. Among other signature interactions, kink-turns form A-minor interaction between their two stems. Most kink-turns possess extended A-minor I (A-I) interaction where adenine of the second A•G base pair of the NC-stem interacts with the first canonical pair of the C-stem (i.e., the receptor pair) via trans-sugar-edge/sugar-edge (tSS) and cis-sugar-edge/sugar-edge (cSS) interactions. The remaining kink-turns have less compact A-minor 0 (A-0) interaction with just one tSS contact. We show that kink-turns with A-I in ribosomal X-ray structures keep G═C receptor base pair during evolution while the inverted pair (C═G) is not realized. In contrast, kink-turns with A-0 in the observed structures alternate G═C and C═G base pairs in sequences. We carried out an extended set (~5 μs) of explicit-solvent molecular dynamics simulations of kink-turns to rationalize this structural/evolutionary pattern. The simulations were done using a net-neutral Na(+) cation atmosphere (with ~0.25 M cation concentration) supplemented by simulations with either excess salt KCl atmosphere or inclusion of Mg(2+). The results do not seem to depend on the treatment of ions. The simulations started with X-ray structures of several kink-turns while we tested the response of the simulated system to base substitutions, modest structural perturbations and constraints. The trends seen in the simulations reveal that the A-I/G═C arrangement is preferred over all three other structures. The A-I/C═G triple appears structurally entirely unstable, consistent with the covariation patterns seen during the evolution. The A-0 arrangements tend to shift toward the A-I pattern in simulations, which suggests that formation of the A-0 interaction is likely supported by the surrounding protein and RNA molecules. A-0 may also be stabilized by additional kink-turn nucleotides not belonging to the kink-turn consensus, as shown for the kink-turn from ribosomal Helix 15. Quantum-chemical calculations on all four A-minor triples suggest that there is a different balance of electrostatic and dispersion stabilization in the A-I/G═C and A-I/C═G triples, which may explain different behavior of these otherwise isosteric triples in the context of kink-turns.

Protein S20 binds two 16S rRNA sites as assembly is initiated

Ribosomal protein S20 is a primary binding protein that bridges the 5' domain and the 3' minor domain of the 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) in the 30S ribosomal subunit. Using time-dependent dimethyl sulfate modification, we have determined that as it is bound to 16S rRNA, protein S20 causes rapid protection of bases A246, A274, A279, and A282 in the stem region of helix 11 in the 5' domain and moderately fast modifications of helix 44 bases A1433 and A1434 in the 3' minor domain. At a later time, enhancements occur with bases A181and A190 in helix 9, bases A325 and A327 in helix 13, and base C264 at the distal end of helix 11 in the 5' domain of 16S rRNA. The modifications that occur in the stem region of helix 11 are distant from the binding site of protein S20, as determined from the crystal structure. Simultaneous addition of protein S17 with S20 to the complex significantly alters the modifications caused by protein S20 in the stem region of helix 11 but does not alter the remaining modifications. Our results indicate that protein S20 is binding to at least two alternate 16S rRNA sites during the early assembly process.