Ionic Interactions Promote Transmembrane Helix–Helix Association Depending on Sequence Context

Small Residues Inhibit Homo-Dimerization of the Human Carbonic Anhydrase XII Transmembrane Domain

Amino acids with small side chains and motifs of small residues in a distance of four are rather abundant in human single-span transmembrane helices. While interaction of such helices appears to be common, the role of the small residues in mediating and/or stabilizing transmembrane helix oligomers remains mostly elusive. Yet, the mere existence of (small)xxx(small) motifs in transmembrane helices is frequently used to model dimeric TM helix structures. The single transmembrane helix of the human carbonic anhydrases XII contains a large number of amino acids with small side chains, and critical involvement of these small amino acids in dimerization of the transmembrane domain has been suggested. Using the GALLEX assay, we show here that the transmembrane domain indeed forms a strong transmembrane helix oligomer within a biological membrane. However, single or multiple mutations of small residue(s) to isoleucine almost always increased, rather than decreased, the interaction propensities. Reduction of helix flexibility and of protein–lipid contacts caused by a reduced lipid accessible surface area likely results in stabilization of helix–helix interactions within the membrane.

Experimental determination and data-driven prediction of homotypic transmembrane domain interfaces

•

Homotypic TMD interfaces identified by different techniques share strong similarities.

•

The GxxxG motif is the feature most strongly associated with interfaces.

•

Other features include conservation, polarity, coevolution, and depth in the membrane

•

The role of each of each feature strongly depends on the individual protein.

•

Machine-learning helps predict interfaces from evolutionary sequence data

Interactions between their transmembrane domains (TMDs) frequently support the assembly of single-pass membrane proteins to non-covalent complexes. Yet, the TMD-TMD interactome remains largely uncharted. With a view to predicting homotypic TMD-TMD interfaces from primary structure, we performed a systematic analysis of their physical and evolutionary properties. To this end, we generated a dataset of 50 self-interacting TMDs. This dataset contains interfaces of nine TMDs from bitopic human proteins (Ire1, Armcx6, Tie1, ATP1B1, PTPRO, PTPRU, PTPRG, DDR1, and Siglec7) that were experimentally identified here and combined with literature data. We show that interfacial residues of these homotypic TMD-TMD interfaces tend to be more conserved, coevolved and polar than non-interfacial residues. Further, we suggest for the first time that interface positions are deficient in β-branched residues, and likely to be located deep in the hydrophobic core of the membrane. Overrepresentation of the GxxxG motif at interfaces is strong, but that of (small)xxx(small) motifs is weak. The multiplicity of these features and the individual character of TMD-TMD interfaces, as uncovered here, prompted us to train a machine learning algorithm. The resulting prediction method, THOIPA (www.thoipa.org), excels in the prediction of key interface residues from evolutionary sequence data.

Lipid Binding Controls Dimerization of the Coat Protein p24 Transmembrane Helix

Coat protein (COP) I and COP II complexes are involved in the transport of proteins between the endoplasmic reticulum and the Golgi apparatus in eukaryotic cells. The formation of COP I/II complexes at membrane surfaces is an early step in vesicle formation and is mastered by p24, a type I transmembrane protein. Oligomerization of p24 monomers was suggested to be mediated and/or stabilized via interactions within the transmembrane domain, and the p24 transmembrane helix appears to selectively bind a single sphingomyelin C18:0 molecule. Furthermore, a potential cholesterol-binding sequence has also been predicted in the p24 transmembrane domain. Thus, sphingomyelin and/or cholesterol binding to the transmembrane domain might directly control the oligomeric state of p24 and, thus, COP vesicle formation. In this study, we show that sequence-specific dimerization of the p24 transmembrane helix is mediated by a LQ7 motif, with Gln¹⁸⁷ being of special importance. Whereas cholesterol has no direct impact on p24 dimerization, binding of the sphingolipid can clearly control dimerization of p24 in rigid membrane regions. We suggest that specific binding of a sphingolipid to the p24 transmembrane helix affects p24 dimerization in membranes with increased cholesterol contents. A clearly defined p24 dimerization propensity likely is crucial for the p24 activity, which involves shuttling in between the endoplasmic reticulum and the Golgi membrane, in which cholesterol and SM C18:0 concentrations differ.

The Third Transmembrane Domain of EscR Is Critical for Function of the Enteropathogenic Escherichia coli Type III Secretion System

Many Gram-negative bacterial pathogens that cause life-threatening diseases employ a type III secretion system (T3SS) for their virulence. The T3SS comprises several proteins that assemble into a syringe-like structure dedicated to the injection of bacterial virulence factors into the host cells. Although many T3SS proteins are transmembrane proteins, our knowledge of these proteins is limited mostly to their soluble domains. In this study, we found that the third transmembrane domain (TMD) of EscR, a central protein of the T3SS in enteropathogenic E. coli, contributes to protein self-oligomerization. Moreover, we demonstrated that a single aspartic acid residue, located at the core of this TMD, is critical for the activity of the full-length protein and the function of the entire T3SS, possibly due to its involvement in mediating TMD-TMD interactions. Our findings should encourage the mapping of the entire interactome of the T3SS components, including interactions mediated through their TMDs.

Many Gram-negative bacterial pathogens utilize a specialized protein delivery system, called the type III secretion system (T3SS), to translocate effector proteins into the host cells. The translocated effectors are crucial for bacterial infection and survival. The base of the T3SS transverses both bacterial membranes and contains an export apparatus that comprises five membrane proteins. Here, we study the export apparatus of enteropathogenic Escherichia coli (EPEC) and characterize its central component, called the EscR protein. We found that the third transmembrane domain (TMD) of EscR mediates strong self-oligomerization in an isolated genetic reporter system. Replacing this TMD sequence with an alternative hydrophobic sequence within the full-length protein resulted in a complete loss of function of the T3SS, further suggesting that the EscR TMD3 sequence has another functional role in addition to its role as a membrane anchor. Moreover, we found that an aspartic acid residue, located at the core of EscR TMD3, is important for the oligomerization propensity of TMD3 and that a point mutation of this residue within the full-length protein abolishes the T3SS activity and the ability of the bacteria to translocate effectors into host cells.

IMPORTANCE Many Gram-negative bacterial pathogens that cause life-threatening diseases employ a type III secretion system (T3SS) for their virulence. The T3SS comprises several proteins that assemble into a syringe-like structure dedicated to the injection of bacterial virulence factors into the host cells. Although many T3SS proteins are transmembrane proteins, our knowledge of these proteins is limited mostly to their soluble domains. In this study, we found that the third transmembrane domain (TMD) of EscR, a central protein of the T3SS in enteropathogenic E. coli, contributes to protein self-oligomerization. Moreover, we demonstrated that a single aspartic acid residue, located at the core of this TMD, is critical for the activity of the full-length protein and the function of the entire T3SS, possibly due to its involvement in mediating TMD-TMD interactions. Our findings should encourage the mapping of the entire interactome of the T3SS components, including interactions mediated through their TMDs.

Transmembrane Interactions of Full-length Mammalian Bitopic Cytochrome-P450-Cytochrome-b5 Complex in Lipid Bilayers Revealed by Sensitivity-Enhanced Dynamic Nuclear Polarization Solid-state NMR Spectroscopy

The dynamic protein-protein and protein-ligand interactions of integral bitopic membrane proteins with a single membrane-spanning helix play a plethora of vital roles in the cellular processes associated with human health and diseases, including signaling and enzymatic catalysis. While an increasing number of high-resolution structural studies of membrane proteins have successfully manifested an in-depth understanding of their biological functions, intact membrane-bound bitopic protein-protein complexes pose tremendous challenges for structural studies by crystallography or solution NMR spectroscopy. Therefore, there is a growing interest in developing approaches to investigate the functional interactions of bitopic membrane proteins embedded in lipid bilayers at atomic-level. Here we demonstrate the feasibility of dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) magic-angle-spinning NMR techniques, along with a judiciously designed stable isotope labeling scheme, to measure atomistic-resolution transmembrane-transmembrane interactions of full-length mammalian ~72-kDa cytochrome P450-cytochrome b5 complex in lipid bilayers. Additionally, the DNP sensitivity-enhanced two-dimensional 13C/13C chemical shift correlations via proton driven spin diffusion provided distance constraints to characterize protein-lipid interactions and revealed the transmembrane topology of cytochrome b5. The results reported in this study would pave ways for high-resolution structural and topological investigations of membrane-bound full-length bitopic protein complexes under physiological conditions.

Identifying ionic interactions within a membrane using BLaTM, a genetic tool to measure homo- and heterotypic transmembrane helix-helix interactions

The assembly of integral membrane protein complexes is frequently supported by transmembrane domain (TMD) interactions. Here, we present the BLaTM assay that measures homotypic as well as heterotypic TMD-TMD interactions in a bacterial membrane. The system is based on complementation of β-lactamase fragments genetically fused to interacting TMDs, which confers ampicillin resistance to expressing cells. We validated BLaTM by showing that the assay faithfully reports known sequence-specific interactions of both types. In a practical application, we used BLaTM to screen a focussed combinatorial library for heterotypic interactions driven by electrostatic forces. The results reveal novel patterns of ionizable amino acids within the isolated TMD pairs. Those patterns indicate that formation of heterotypic TMD pairs is most efficiently supported by closely spaced ionizable residues of opposite charge. In addition, TMD heteromerization can apparently be driven by hydrogen bonding between basic or between acidic residues.

Role of GxxxG Motifs in Transmembrane Domain Interactions

Transmembrane (TM) helices of integral membrane proteins can facilitate strong and specific noncovalent protein-protein interactions. Mutagenesis and structural analyses have revealed numerous examples in which the interaction between TM helices of single-pass membrane proteins is dependent on a GxxxG or (small)xxx(small) motif. It is therefore tempting to use the presence of these simple motifs as an indicator of TM helix interactions. In this Current Topic review, we point out that these motifs are quite common, with more than 50% of single-pass TM domains containing a (small)xxx(small) motif. However, the actual interaction strength of motif-containing helices depends strongly on sequence context and membrane properties. In addition, recent studies have revealed several GxxxG-containing TM domains that interact via alternative interfaces involving hydrophobic, polar, aromatic, or even ionizable residues that do not form recognizable motifs. In multipass membrane proteins, GxxxG motifs can be important for protein folding, and not just oligomerization. Our current knowledge thus suggests that the presence of a GxxxG motif alone is a weak predictor of protein dimerization in the membrane.

A designed buried salt bridge modulates heterodimerization of a membrane peptide

Specific helix-helix interactions underpin the correct assembly of multipass membrane proteins. Here, we show that a designed buried salt bridge mediates heterodimer formation of model transmembrane helical peptides in a pH-dependent manner. The model peptides bear side chains functionalized with either a carboxylic acid or a primary amine within a hydrophobic segment. The association behavior was monitored by Förster resonance energy transfer, revealing that heterodimer formation is maximized at a pH close to neutrality (pH 6.5), at which each peptide is found in a charged state. In contrast, heterodimerization is disfavored at low and high values of pH, because either the carboxylic acid or the primary amine is present in its neutral state, thus preventing the formation of a salt bridge. These findings provide a blueprint for the design and modulation of protein-protein interactions in membrane proteins.

A Gly-zipper motif mediates homodimerization of the transmembrane domain of the mitochondrial kinase ADCK3

Interactions between α-helices within the hydrophobic environment of lipid bilayers are integral to the folding and function of transmembrane proteins; however, the major forces that mediate these interactions remain debated, and our ability to predict these interactions is still largely untested. We recently demonstrated that the frequent transmembrane association motif GASright, the GxxxG-containing fold of the glycophorin A dimer, is optimal for the formation of extended networks of Cα-H hydrogen bonds, supporting the hypothesis that these bonds are major contributors to association. We also found that optimization of Cα-H hydrogen bonding and interhelical packing is sufficient to computationally predict the structure of known GASright dimers at near atomic level. Here, we demonstrate that this computational method can be used to characterize the structure of a protein not previously known to dimerize, by predicting and validating the transmembrane dimer of ADCK3, a mitochondrial kinase. ADCK3 is involved in the biosynthesis of the redox active lipid, ubiquinone, and human ADCK3 mutations cause a cerebellar ataxia associated with ubiquinone deficiency, but the biochemical functions of ADCK3 remain largely undefined. Our experimental analyses show that the transmembrane helix of ADCK3 oligomerizes, with an interface based on an extended Gly-zipper motif, as predicted by our models. The data provide strong evidence for the hypothesis that optimization of Cα-H hydrogen bonding is an important factor in the association of transmembrane helices. This work also provides a structural foundation for investigating the role of transmembrane association in regulating the biological activity of ADCK3.

Life at the border: adaptation of proteins to anisotropic membrane environment

This review discusses main features of transmembrane (TM) proteins which distinguish them from water-soluble proteins and allow their adaptation to the anisotropic membrane environment. We overview the structural limitations on membrane protein architecture, spatial arrangement of proteins in membranes and their intrinsic hydrophobic thickness, co-translational and post-translational folding and insertion into lipid bilayers, topogenesis, high propensity to form oligomers, and large-scale conformational transitions during membrane insertion and transport function. Special attention is paid to the polarity of TM protein surfaces described by profiles of dipolarity/polarizability and hydrogen-bonding capacity parameters that match polarity of the lipid environment. Analysis of distributions of Trp resides on surfaces of TM proteins from different biological membranes indicates that interfacial membrane regions with preferential accumulation of Trp indole rings correspond to the outer part of the lipid acyl chain region-between double bonds and carbonyl groups of lipids. These "midpolar" regions are not always symmetric in proteins from natural membranes. We also examined the hydrophobic effect that drives insertion of proteins into lipid bilayer and different free energy contributions to TM protein stability, including attractive van der Waals forces and hydrogen bonds, side-chain conformational entropy, the hydrophobic mismatch, membrane deformations, and specific protein-lipid binding.

The pathogenic A391E mutation in FGFR3 induces a structural change in the transmembrane domain dimer

Fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 (FGFR3) is a single-pass membrane protein and a member of the receptor tyrosine kinase family of proteins that is involved in the regulation of skeletal growth and development. FGFR3 has three distinct domains: the ligand binding extracellular domain, the cytosolic kinase domain and the transmembrane domain (TMD). Previous work with the isolated FGFR3 TMD has shown that it has the ability to dimerize. Clinical and genetic studies have also correlated mutations in the TMD with a variety of skeletal and cranial dysplasias and cancer. Although the structures of the extracellular and cytosolic domains of FGFR3 have been solved, the structure of the TMD dimer is still unknown. Furthermore, very little is known regarding the effects of pathogenic mutations on the TMD dimer structure. We, therefore, carried out ToxR activity assays to determine the role of the SmXXXSm motif in the dimerization of the FGFR3 TMD. This motif has been shown to drive the association of many transmembrane proteins. Our results indicate that the interaction between wild-type FGFR3 TMDs is not mediated by two adjacent SmXXXSm motifs. In contrast, studies using the TMD carrying the pathogenic A391E mutation suggest that the motifs play a role in the dimerization of the mutant TMD. Based on these observations, here we report a new mechanistic model in which the pathogenic A391E mutation induces a structural change that leads to the formation of a more stable dimer.

Self-interaction of transmembrane helices representing pre-clusters from the human single-span membrane proteins

MOTIVATION

Most integral membrane proteins form dimeric or oligomeric complexes. Oligomerization is frequently supported by the non-covalent interaction of transmembrane helices. It is currently not clear how many high-affinity transmembrane domains (TMD) exist in a proteome and how specific their interactions are with respect to preferred contacting faces and their underlying residue motifs.

RESULTS

We first identify a threshold of 55% sequence similarity, which demarcates the border between meaningful alignments of TMDs and chance alignments. Clustering the human single-span membrane proteome using this threshold groups ~40% of the TMDs. The homotypic interaction of the TMDs representing the 33 largest clusters was systematically investigated under standardized conditions. The results reveal a broad distribution of relative affinities. High relative affinity frequently coincides with (i) the existence of a preferred helix-helix interface and (ii) sequence specificity as indicated by reduced affinity after mutating conserved residues.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Genetic systems for monitoring interactions of transmembrane domains in bacterial membranes

In recent years several systems have been developed to study interactions of TM domains within the inner membrane of the Gram-negative bacterium Escherichia coli. Mostly, a transmembrane domain of interest is fused to a soluble DNA-binding domain, which dimerizes in E. coli cytoplasm after interactions of the transmembrane domains. The dimeric DNA-binding domain subsequently binds to a promoter/operator region and thereby activates or represses a reporter gene. In 1996 the first bacterial system has been introduced to measure interactions of TM helices within a bacterial membrane, which is based on fusion of a transmembrane helix of interest to the DNA-binding domain of the Vibrio cholerae ToxR protein. Interaction of a transmembrane helix of interest within the membrane environment results in dimerization of the DNA-binding domain in the bacterial cytoplasm, and the dimeric DNA-binding domain then binds to the DNA and activates a reporter gene. Subsequently, systems with improved features, such as the TOXCAT- or POSSYCCAT system, which allow screening of TM domain libraries, or the GALLEX system, which allows measuring heterotypic interactions of TM helices, have been developed and successfully applied. Here we briefly introduce the currently most applied systems and discuss their advantages together with their limitations.

Polar/Ionizable residues in transmembrane segments: effects on helix-helix packing

The vast majority of membrane proteins are anchored to biological membranes through hydrophobic α-helices. Sequence analysis of high-resolution membrane protein structures show that ionizable amino acid residues are present in transmembrane (TM) helices, often with a functional and/or structural role. Here, using as scaffold the hydrophobic TM domain of the model membrane protein glycophorin A (GpA), we address the consequences of replacing specific residues by ionizable amino acids on TM helix insertion and packing, both in detergent micelles and in biological membranes. Our findings demonstrate that ionizable residues are stably inserted in hydrophobic environments, and tolerated in the dimerization process when oriented toward the lipid face, emphasizing the complexity of protein-lipid interactions in biological membranes.

Transmembrane domains interactions within the membrane milieu: principles, advances and challenges

Protein-protein interactions within the membrane are involved in many vital cellular processes. Consequently, deficient oligomerization is associated with known diseases. The interactions can be partially or fully mediated by transmembrane domains (TMD). However, in contrast to soluble regions, our knowledge of the factors that control oligomerization and recognition between the membrane-embedded domains is very limited. Due to the unique chemical and physical properties of the membrane environment, rules that apply to interactions between soluble segments are not necessarily valid within the membrane. This review summarizes our knowledge on the sequences mediating TMD-TMD interactions which include conserved motifs such as the GxxxG, QxxS, glycine and leucine zippers, and others. The review discusses the specific role of polar, charged and aromatic amino acids in the interface of the interacting TMD helices. Strategies to determine the strength, dynamics and specificities of these interactions by experimental (ToxR, TOXCAT, GALLEX and FRET) or various computational approaches (molecular dynamic simulation and bioinformatics) are summarized. Importantly, the contribution of the membrane environment to the TMD-TMD interaction is also presented. Studies utilizing exogenously added TMD peptides have been shown to influence in vivo the dimerization of intact membrane proteins involved in various diseases. The chirality independent TMD-TMD interactions allows for the design of novel short d- and l-amino acids containing TMD peptides with advanced properties. Overall these studies shed light on the role of specific amino acids in mediating the assembly of the TMDs within the membrane environment and their contribution to protein function. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein Folding in Membranes.

Transmembrane helix dimerization: beyond the search for sequence motifs

Studies of the dimerization of transmembrane (TM) helices have been ongoing for many years now, and have provided clues to the fundamental principles behind membrane protein (MP) folding. Our understanding of TM helix dimerization has been dominated by the idea that sequence motifs, simple recognizable amino acid sequences that drive lateral interaction, can be used to explain and predict the lateral interactions between TM helices in membrane proteins. But as more and more unique interacting helices are characterized, it is becoming clear that the sequence motif paradigm is incomplete. Experimental evidence suggests that the search for sequence motifs, as mediators of TM helix dimerization, cannot solve the membrane protein folding problem alone. Here we review the current understanding in the field, as it has evolved from the paradigm of sequence motifs into a view in which the interactions between TM helices are much more complex. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Membrane protein structure and function.

Apoptogenic interactions of plasmalemmal type-1 VDAC and Aβ peptides via GxxxG motifs induce Alzheimer's disease - a basic model of apoptosis?

Human type-1 porin/VDAC (voltage-dependent anion channel) carries a GxxxG motif in its N-terminal part, traversing the β-barrel, while the Alzheimer's disease (AD) relevant amyloid peptides Aβ1-42 and Aβ1-40 show a series of corresponding motifs close to their C-terminus. GxxxG motifs are established as aggregation/membrane perturbation motifs. These peptide primary structure data support a proposal I recently made on the basis of a synopsis of recent literature. Accordingly, amyloid Aβ, cut from APP by beta-secretase BACE1 and gamma-secretase, has been insinuated to induce Alzheimer's disease via apoptosis by opening type-1 porin/VDAC in cell membranes of hypometabolic neuronal cells. Considering the ubiquitous expression modus of APP, beta- and gamma-secretases and type-1 VDAC/eukaryotic porin a basic model of apoptosis might be given.

Single-spanning transmembrane domains in cell growth and cell-cell interactions: More than meets the eye?

As a whole, integral membrane proteins represent about one third of sequenced genomes, and more than 50% of currently available drugs target membrane proteins, often cell surface receptors. Some membrane protein classes, with a defined number of transmembrane (TM) helices, are receiving much attention because of their great functional and pharmacological importance, such as G protein-coupled receptors possessing 7 TM segments. Although they represent roughly half of all membrane proteins, bitopic proteins (with only 1 TM helix) have so far been less well characterized. Though they include many essential families of receptors, such as adhesion molecules and receptor tyrosine kinases, many of which are excellent targets for biopharmaceuticals (peptides, antibodies, et al.). A growing body of evidence suggests a major role for interactions between TM domains of these receptors in signaling, through homo and heteromeric associations, conformational changes, assembly of signaling platforms, etc. Significantly, mutations within single domains are frequent in human disease, such as cancer or developmental disorders. This review attempts to give an overview of current knowledge about these interactions, from structural data to therapeutic perspectives, focusing on bitopic proteins involved in cell signaling.

Helix-helix interaction patterns in membrane proteins

Membrane-spanning α-helices represent major sites of protein-protein interaction in membrane protein oligomerization and folding. As such, these interactions may be of exquisite specificity. Specificity often rests on a complex interplay of different types of residues forming the helix-helix interfaces via dense packing and different non-covalent forces, including van der Waal’s forces, hydrogen bonding, charge-charge interactions, and aromatic interactions. These interfaces often contain complex residue motifs where the contribution of constituent amino acids depends on the context of the surrounding sequence. Moreover, transmembrane helix-helix interactions are increasingly recognized as being dynamic and dependent on the functional state of a given protein.