Taper junctions in modular hip joint replacements: What affects their stability?

The force at the implant cannot be assessed by the mallet force-Unless supported by a model

The implantation of uncemented prostheses requires the application of sufficient forces to achieve a press-fit of the implant in the bone. Excessive forces have to be omitted to limit bone damage. Force measurements along the force transmission path between mallet and implant are frequently used to investigate this trade-off. Placing a load cell at a position of interest (PoI), which might be the implant bone interface or the head taper junction, is technically challenging or even impossible so that nearby positions are chosen. Thus, a certain inertia and stiffness remain between the PoI and the sensor, and consequently the measured dynamic forces differ from those at the PoI. This experimental and numerical study aimed to investigate the amount of force reduction along the transmission path while joining femoral heads to stem tapers. Forces were measured in vitro at the tip of the mallet, directly above the polymer tip of the impactor and below the stem taper. Springs and masses were used to represent the responding tissue of a patient. A semi-empirical numerical model of the force transmission path was developed and validated in order to simulate a larger range of responding tissue properties than experimentally possible and to investigate the influence of different surgical instruments. A distinct attenuation was observed since the peak forces at the impactor reached 35% of the applied peak forces and 21% at the stem taper, respectively. The force curves were replicated with a median root mean square error of 3.8% of the corresponding mallet blow for the impactor and 3.6% for the stem. The force measurement position and the used surgical instruments have a strong influence on the measured forces. Consequently, the exact measurement conditions with regard to sensor positioning and used surgical instruments have to be specified and hence only studies with similar setups should be compared to avoid misestimation of the forces at the PoI. The proposed dynamic numerical model is a useful tool to calculate the impact of the chosen or changed mechanical parameters prior to executing experiments and also to extrapolate the effect of changing the applied forces to the resulting forces at the PoI.

The influence of surgical technique guidance and surgeon's experience on the femoral head assembly in total hip arthroplasty

INTRODUCTION

The importance of the assembly procedure on the taper connection strength is evident. However, existent surgical technique guides frequently lack comprehensive and precise instructions in this regard. The aim of our experimental study was to evaluate the influence of the surgical technique guide on the femoral head assembly procedure in surgeons with differing levels of experience in total hip arthroplasty.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-eight participants, divided into four groups based on their lifetime experience in total hip arthroplasty, conducted a femoral head assembly procedure in a simulated intraoperative environment before and after reviewing the surgical technique guide. Demographic information and the number of hammer blows were documented. Hammer velocity and impaction angle were recorded using an optical motion capturing system, while the impaction force was measured using a dynamic force sensor within the impactor.

RESULTS

We observed a high variation in the number of hammer blows, maximum force, and impaction angle. Overall, the number of hammer blows decreased significantly from 3 to 2.2 after reviewing the surgical technique guide. The only significant intragroup difference in the number of hammer blows was observed in the group with no prior experience in total hip arthroplasty. No correlation was found between individual factors (age, weight, height) or experience and the measured parameters (velocity, maximum force and angle).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study demonstrated a high variation in the parameters of the femoral head assembly procedure. Consideration of the surgical technique guide was found to be a limited factor among participants with varying levels of experience in total hip arthroplasty. These findings underline the importance of sufficient preoperative training, to standardize the assembly procedure, including impaction force, angle, and use of instruments.

Computer-based analysis of the taper connection strength of different revision head and adapter sleeve designs

OBJECTIVES

Ceramic revision heads, equipped with titanium adapter sleeves, are used in femoral head revision in total hip arthroplasty to avoid ceramic fracture due to the damaged taper.

METHODS

A finite element analysis of the taper connection strength of revision heads with varying head diameters combined with adapter sleeves of different lengths was conducted. The influence of various assembly forces, head diameter, and length of the adapter sleeves was evaluated. For two combinations, the pattern of contact pressure was evaluated when applying a simplified joint load (3 kN, 45° load angle). Experimental validation was conducted with 36 mm heads and adapter sleeves in size S, as well as 28 mm heads and adapter sleeves in size XL.

RESULTS

The pull-off force increased with higher assembly forces. Using larger head diameters and adapter sleeves led to decreased pull-off forces, a reduced contact surface, and less contact pressure. The contact pressure showed significant peaks and a diagonal pattern under 45° angle loading when assembly forces were less than 4 kN, and larger adapter sleeves were utilized.

CONCLUSION

A sufficient assembly force should be ensured intraoperatively, especially with an increasing head diameter and adapter sleeve size, as lower assembly forces might lead to reduced taper connection strength.

Influence of a Modified Procedure of Joining Ceramic Head and Adapter Sleeve on the Stem Taper in Revision: An Experimental Study

In revision operations, ceramic heads of modular hip implants can be replaced. As the surface of the stem taper can be damaged, additional adapter sleeves are applied. The components are usually connected manually by the surgeon in a one-step procedure by hammer impacts. In this study, we investigated a two-step joining procedure with reproducible impaction force. First, the adapter sleeve and head were joined quasi-statically with a force of 2 kN using an assembly device. In the second step, these components were applied to the stem taper using a pulse-controlled instrument. For reference, the joints were assembled according to standard conditions using a tensile testing machine. An average pull-off force of 1309 ± 201 N was achieved for the components joined by the instrument, and the average measured values for the components joined by the testing machine were 1290 ± 140 N. All specimens achieved a force >350 N when released and therefore met the acceptance criterion defined for this study. This study showed that a modified procedure in two steps with a defined force has a positive effect on the reproducibility of the measured joining forces compared to previous studies.

Influence of Taper surface topographies on contact deformation and stresses

The role of bore and trunnion surface topography on the failure rate of total hip joint replacements due to trunnionosis is not clear despite significant variations in the design of taper components between manufacturers. Taper surface topography, along with other taper design parameters such as clearance, diameter, and assembly force, determine the initial interlock of the contacting surfaces after assembly; this has been related to relative motions that can cause fretting and corrosion at the taper interface. However, in most in-silico parametrical taper studies associated with taper micromotions, the bore and trunnion surfaces have been simplified using a flat surface and/or sinusoidal functions to mimic the surface roughness. The current study tests the hypothesis that the use of simple geometrical functions for the taper surface topography can predict the surface mechanics developed in assembled tapers. Measured and simulated surfaces of bores and trunnions were characterised using common roughness parameters and spectral density estimations. Using the same characterised surface profiles, 2D Finite Element (FE) models of CoCr alloy femoral heads and Ti alloy trunnions were developed. Models simulated assembly conditions at different resultant forces ranging from 0.5 to 4.0 kN, contact conditions were determined and associated with their topographical characteristics. Measured surfaces of bore and trunnion components comprise up to seven dominant spatial frequencies. Flattening of the trunnion microgrooved peaks was observed during the assembly of the taper. When the femoral head bore and trunnion topography were both considered a reduced number of microgrooved peaks were in contact, from 51 in an idealised taper surfaces to 35 in measured surfaces using an assembly reaction force of 4 kN. The contact points in the models developed high plastic strains, which were greater than that associated with failure of the material. Results showed that line and sine wave functions over estimate contact points at the taper interface compared to those surfaces that consider roughness and peak variation. These findings highlight the important role of modelling the full surface topography on the taper contact mechanics, as surface variations in the roughness and waviness change the performance of tapers.

An Overview of the Stability and Fretting Corrosion of Microgrooved Necks in the Taper Junction of Hip Implants

Fretting corrosion at the head-neck interface of modular hip implants, scientifically termed trunnionosis/taperosis, may cause regional inflammation, metallosis, and adverse local tissue reactions. The severity of such a deleterious process depends on various design parameters. In this review, the influence of surface topography (in some cases, called microgrooves/ridges) on the overall performance of the microgrooved head-neck junctions is investigated. The methodologies together with the assumptions and simplifications, as well as the findings from both the experimental observations (retrieval and in vitro) and the numerical approaches used in previous studies, are presented and discussed. The performance of the microgrooved junctions is compared to those with a smooth surface finish in two main categories: stability and integrity; wear, corrosion, and material loss. Existing contradictions and disagreements among the reported results are reported and discussed in order to present a comprehensive picture of the microgrooved junctions. The current research needs and possible future research directions on the microgrooved junctions are also identified and presented.

Parametric analysis of the effect of impaction load on the stability of head-neck junction in total hip arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Tribocorrosion at head-neck interface is one of the main causes leading to the failure of hip implants in total hip arthroplasty. Impaction load has been acknowledged as one of the key factors influencing the stability of the taper junction. It is understood that the magnitude of impaction force differs from the surgeon to surgeon in primary total hip arthroplasty or revision. Clinically, it is sufficient enough to keep the male and female tapers inseparable utilizing a low impaction, which seems to contradict previous researches. The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of impaction loads on the stability of taper junction during assembly and gaits.

METHODS

A finite element model with 12/14 taper and the taper mismatch of 4' was developed for investigation. The impaction force profiles were collected from surgeon as the inputs, and then the contact mechanics over one or multiple gaits was further analyzed and validated utilizing hip simulator test.

FINDINGS

Impaction force ranging from 200 to 2000 N could provide the same taper connection effect after the first gait due to the secondary seating. As for impaction loads of 3000 N and above, an increased impaction force would lead to the tighter taper connection.

INTERPRETATION

The effect of impaction load on the stability of head-neck junction is a piecewise function, indicating that the stability of taper junction is not affected by different impaction loads and tends to be consistent while its magnitude is below the threshold. Instead, the stability of taper junction is positively correlated with impaction force.

Importance of surgical assembly technique on the engagement of 12/14 modular tapers

Fretting-corrosion at the modular taper junction in total hip replacements (THR), leading to implant failure, has been identified as a clinical concern and has received increased interest in recent years. There are many parameters thought to affect the performance of the taper junction, with the assembly process being one of the few consistently identified to have a direct impact. Despite this, the assembly process used by surgeons during THR surgery differs from a suggested 'ideal' process. For example, taper junctions of cutting tools should be pushed together rather than impacted, while ensuring as much concentricity as possible between the male and female taper and loading axis. This study devised six simple assembly methodologies to investigate how surgical variations affect the success of the compressive fit achieved at the taper interface compared to a controlled assembly method, designed to represent a more 'ideal' scenario. Key findings from this study suggest that a more successful and repeatable engagement can be achieved by quasi-statically loading the male and female taper concentrically with the loading axis. This was shown by a greater disassembly to assembly force ratio of 0.626 ± 0.07 when assembled using the more 'ideal' process, compared to 0.480 ± 0.05 when using a method closer to that used by a surgeon intraoperatively. Findings from this study can be used to help inform new surgical instrumentation and an improved surgical assembly method.

EFORT recommendations for off-label use, mix & match and mismatch in hip and knee arthroplasty

Off-label use is frequently practiced in primary and revision arthroplasty, as there may be indications for the application of implants for purposes outside the one the manufacturers intended.

Under certain circumstances, patients may benefit from selective application of mix & match. This can refer to primary hip arthroplasty (if evidence suggests that the combination of devices from different manufacturers has superior results) and revision hip or knee arthroplasty (when the exchange of one component only is necessary and the invasiveness of surgery can be reduced).

Within the EFORT ‘Implant and Patient Safety Initiative’, evidence- and consensus-based recommendations have been developed for the safe application of off-label use and mix & match in primary as well as revision hip and knee arthroplasty.

Prior to the application of a medical device for hip or knee arthroplasty off-label and within a mix & match situation, surgeons should balance the risks and benefits to the patient, obtain informed consent, and document the decision process appropriately.

Nevertheless, it is crucial for surgeons to only combine implants that are compatible. Mismatch of components, where their sizes or connections do not fit, may have catastrophic effects and is a surgical mistake.

Surgeons must be fully aware of the features of the components that they use in off-label indications or during mix & match applications, must be appropriately trained and must audit their results.

Considering the frequent practice of off-label and mix & match as well as the potential medico-legal issues, further research is necessary to obtain more data about the appropriate indications and outcomes for those procedures.

Cite this article: EFORT Open Rev 2021;6:982-1005. DOI: 10.1302/2058-5241.6.210080

Variability in stem taper surface topography affects the degree of corrosion and fretting in total hip arthroplasty

Degradation at the modular head-neck interface in total hip arthroplasty (THA) is predominately expressed in the form of corrosion and fretting, potentially causing peri-prosthetic failure by adverse reactions to metal debris. This retrieval study aimed to quantify variations in stem taper surface topographies and to assess the influence on the formation of corrosion and/or fretting in titanium alloy stem tapers combined with metal and ceramic heads. Four hip stem designs (Alloclassic, CLS, Bicontact and SL-Plus) were characterized using high-resolution 3D microscopy, and corrosion and fretting were rated using the Goldberg scoring scheme. Quantification of the taper surface topographies revealed a high variability in surface characteristics between threaded stem tapers: Alloclassic and CLS tapers feature deeply threaded trapezoid-shaped profiles with thread heights over 65 µm. The sawtooth-shaped Bicontact and triangular SL-Plus taper are characterized by low thread heights below 14 µm. Significantly lower corrosion and fretting scores were observed in lightly threaded compared to deeply threaded tapers in ceramic head combinations. No significant differences in corrosion or fretting scores with thread height were found in pairings with metal heads. Understanding the relationship between stem taper surface topography and the formation of corrosion and fretting could help to improve the performance of modern THAs and lead to longer-lasting clinical results.