Finite element analysis of transcatheter aortic valve implantation: Insights on the modelling of self-expandable devices

Validation evidence with experimental and clinical data to establish credibility of TAVI patient-specific simulations

PURPOSE

The objective of this study is to validate a novel workflow for implementing patient-specific finite element (FE) simulations to virtually replicate the Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation (TAVI) procedure.

METHODS

Seven patients undergoing TAVI were enrolled. Patient-specific anatomical models were reconstructed from pre-operative computed tomography (CT) scans and subsequentially discretized, considering the native aortic leaflets and calcifications. Moreover, high-fidelity models of CoreValve Evolut R and Acurate Neo2 valves were built. To determine the most suitable material properties for the two stents, an accurate calibration process was undertaken. This involved conducting crimping simulations and fine-tuning Nitinol parameters to fit experimental force-diameter curves. Subsequently, FE simulations of TAVI procedures were conducted. To validate the reliability of the implemented implantation simulations, qualitative and quantitative comparisons with post-operative clinical data, such as angiographies and CT scans, were performed.

RESULTS

For both devices, the simulation curves closely matched the experimental data, indicating successful validation of the valves mechanical behaviour. An accurate qualitative superimposition with both angiographies and CTs was evident, proving the reliability of the simulated implantation. Furthermore, a mean percentage difference of 1,79 ± 0,93 % and 3,67 ± 2,73 % between the simulated and segmented final configurations of the stents was calculated in terms of orifice area and eccentricity, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This study shows the successful validation of TAVI simulations in patient-specific anatomies, offering a valuable tool to optimize patients care through personalized pre-operative planning. A systematic approach for the validation is presented, laying the groundwork for enhanced predictive modeling in clinical practice.

Interaction of a self-expandable stent with the arterial wall in the presence of hypocellular and calcified plaques

Self-expandable stents manufactured from nitinol alloys are commonly utilized alongside traditional balloon-expandable stents to provide scaffolding to stenosed arteries. However, a significant limitation hampering stent efficacy is restenosis, triggered by neointimal hyperplasia and resulting in the loss of gain in lumen size, post-intervention. In this study, a nonlinear finite element model was developed to simulate stent crimping and expansion and its interaction with the surrounding vessel in the presence of a plaque. The main aim was to determine contact pressures and forces induced at the interface between an artery wall with hypocellular and calcified plaques and an expanded stent. The results demonstrated the drawbacks of plaque calcification, which triggered a sharp contact pressure and radial force surge at the interface as well as a significant rise in von Mises stress within the vessel, potentially leading to rupture and restenosis. A regression line was then established to relate hypocellular and calcified plaques. The adjusted coefficient of determination indicated a good correlation between contact pressures for calcified and hypocellular plaque models. Regarding the directionality of wall properties, contact pressure and force observations were not significantly different between isotropic and anisotropic arteries. Moreover, variations in friction coefficients did not substantially affect the interfacial contact pressures.

Mechanical behaviors of a new elliptical valve stent in bicuspid aortic valve

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The conventional valve stents that are cylindrical in shape will become elliptical when implanted in bicuspid aortic valve, thereby reducing the durability of the artificial valve. In this study, a new design of valve stent is presented where valve stents have elliptical cross-section at the annulus and it is expected to have better expandability and circle shape during the interaction between the stent and bicuspid aortic valve, thereby extending the durability of artificial valve.

METHODS

Finite element method (FEM) is used to study the mechanical behavior of the novel valve stent in the bicuspid aortic valve. The effects of three matching relationship between the ellipticity of the stents and the ellipticity of the annulus (i.e., the ellipticity of the stent is greater than, equal to and less than the annulus ellipticity, respectively) on the mechanical behavior of stent expansion are studied. In addition, the expansion mechanical behavior of the novel valve stent at different implantation depths is also compared.

RESULTS

Results indicate that novel valve stent implantation with elliptical features is superior to conventional circular valve stent. When the novel valve stent ellipticity is less than the annulus ellipticity, the ellipticity of the novel valve stent after implantation is smaller than that of the conventional circular valve stent. This indicated that the novel valve stent has better expandability and post-expansion shape, making artificial valve to have better durability. The risk of paravalvular leak after implantation is lowest when the novel valve stent ellipticity is less than annulus ellipticity. When the novel valve stent ellipticity coincides with annulus ellipticity, the aortic wall is subjected to greatest stress. With the increase of implantation depth, the stress on the novel valve stent decrease.

CONCLUSIONS

This study might provide insights for improving stent design for bicuspid aortic valve.

Angulation and curvature of aortic landing zone affect implantation depth in transcatheter aortic valve implantation

In transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI), final device position may be affected by device interaction with the whole aortic landing zone (LZ) extending to ascending aorta. We investigated the impact of aortic LZ curvature and angulation on TAVI implantation depth, comparing short-frame balloon-expanding (BE) and long-frame self-expanding (SE) devices. Patients (n = 202) treated with BE or SE devices were matched based on one-to-one propensity score. Primary endpoint was the mismatch between the intended (HPre) and the final (HPost) implantation depth. LZ curvature and angulation were calculated based on the aortic centerline trajectory available from pre-TAVI computed tomography. Total LZ curvature ( k L Z , t o t ) and LZ angulation distal to aortic annulus ( α L Z , D i s t a l ) were greater in the SE compared to the BE group (P < 0.001 for both). In the BE group, HPost was significantly higher than HPre at both cusps (P < 0.001). In the SE group, HPost was significantly deeper than HPre only at the left coronary cusp (P = 0.013). At multivariate analysis, α L Z , D i s t a l was the only independent predictor (OR = 1.11, P = 0.002) of deeper final implantation depth with a cut-off value of 17.8°. Aortic LZ curvature and angulation significantly affected final TAVI implantation depth, especially in high stent-frame SE devices reporting, upon complete release, deeper implantation depth with respect to the intended one.

On the necessity to include arterial pre-stress in patient-specific simulations of minimally invasive procedures

Transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) and thoracic endovascular aortic repair (TEVAR) are minimally invasive procedures for treating aortic valves and diseases. Finite element simulations have proven to be valuable tools in predicting device-related complications. In the literature, the inclusion of aortic pre-stress has not been widely investigated. It plays a crucial role in determining the biomechanical response of the vessel and the device-tissue interaction. This study aims at demonstrating how and when to include the aortic pre-stress in patient-specific TAVI and TEVAR simulations. A percutaneous aortic valve and a stent-graft were implanted in aortic models reconstructed from patient-specific CT scans. Two scenarios for each patient were compared, i.e., including and neglecting the wall pre-stress. The neglection of pre-stress underestimates the contact pressure of 48% and 55%, the aorta stresses of 162% and 157%, the aorta strains of 77% and 21% for TAVI and TEVAR models, respectively. The stent stresses are higher than 48% with the pre-stressed aorta in TAVI simulations; while, similar results are obtained in TEVAR cases. The distance between the device and the aorta is similar with and without pre-stress. The inclusion of the aortic wall pre-stress has the capability to give a better representation of the biomechanical behavior of the arterial tissues and the implanted device. It is suggested to include this effect in patient-specific simulations replicating the procedures.

Recommendations for finite element modelling of nickel-titanium stents-Verification and validation activities

The objective of this study is to present a credibility assessment of finite element modelling of self-expanding nickel-titanium (Ni-Ti) stents through verification and validation (VV) activities, as set out in the ASME VV-40 standard. As part of the study, the role of calculation verification, model input sensitivity, and model validation is examined across three different application contexts (radial compression, stent deployment in a vessel, fatigue estimation). A commercially available self-expanding Ni-Ti stent was modelled, and calculation verification activities addressed the effects of mesh density, element integration and stable time increment on different quantities of interests, for each context of use considered. Sensitivity analysis of the geometrical and material input parameters and validation of deployment configuration with in vitro comparators were investigated. Results showed similar trends for global and local outputs across the contexts of use in response to the selection of discretization parameters, although with varying sensitivities. Mesh discretisation showed substantial variability for less than 4 × 4 element density across the strut cross-section in radial compression and deployment cases, while a finer grid was deemed necessary in fatigue estimation for reliable predictions of strain/stress. Element formulation also led to substantial variation depending on the chosen integration options. Furthermore, for explicit analyses, model results were highly sensitive to the chosen target time increment (e.g., mass scaling parameters), irrespective of whether quasistatic conditions were ensured (ratios of kinetic and internal energies below 5%). The higher variability was found for fatigue life simulation, with the estimation of fatigue safety factor varying up to an order of magnitude depending on the selection of discretization parameters. Model input sensitivity analysis highlighted that the predictions of outputs such as radial force and stresses showed relatively low sensitivity to Ni-Ti material parameters, which suggests that the calibration approaches used in the literature to date appear reasonable, but a higher sensitivity to stent geometry, namely strut thickness and width, was found. In contrast, the prediction of vessel diameter following deployment was least sensitive to numerical parameters, and its validation with in vitro comparators offered a simple and accurate (error ~ 1-2%) method when predicting diameter gain, and lumen area, provided that the material of the vessel is appropriately characterized and modelled.

A review of numerical simulation in transcatheter aortic valve replacement decision optimization

BACKGROUND

Recent trials indicated a further expansion of clinical indication of transcatheter aortic valve replacement to younger and low-risk patients. Factors related to longer-term complications are becoming more important for use in these patients. Accumulating evidence indicates that numerical simulation plays a significant role in improving the outcome of transcatheter aortic valve replacement. Understanding mechanical features' magnitude, pattern, and duration is a topic of ongoing relevance.

METHODS

We searched the PubMed database using keywords such as "transcatheter aortic valve replacement" and "numerical simulation" and reviewed and summarized relevant literature.

FINDINGS

This review integrated recently published evidence into three subtopics: 1) prediction of transcatheter aortic valve replacement outcomes through numerical simulation, 2) implications for surgeons, and 3) trends in transcatheter aortic valve replacement numerical simulation.

INTERPRETATIONS

Our study offers a comprehensive overview of the utilization of numerical simulation in the context of transcatheter aortic valve replacement, and highlights the advantages, potential challenges from a clinical standpoint. The convergence of medicine and engineering plays a pivotal role in enhancing the outcomes of transcatheter aortic valve replacement. Numerical simulation has provided evidence of potential utility for tailored treatments.

Impact of nickel-titanium super-elastic material properties on the mechanical performance of self-expandable transcatheter aortic valves

Self-expandable transcatheter aortic valves (TAVs) elastically resume their initial shape when implanted without the need for balloon inflation by virtue of the nickel-titanium (NiTi) frame super-elastic properties. Experimental findings suggest that NiTi mechanical properties can vary markedly because of a strong dependence on the chemical composition and processing operations. In this context, this study presents a computational framework to investigate the impact of the NiTi super-elastic material properties on the TAV mechanical performance. Finite element (FE) analyses of TAV implantation were performed considering two different TAV frames and three idealized aortic root anatomies, evaluating the device mechanical response in terms of pullout force magnitude exerted by the TAV frame and peak maximum principal stress within the aortic root. The widely adopted NiTi constitute model by Auricchio and Taylor (1997) was used. A multi-parametric sensitivity analysis and a multi-objective optimization of the TAV mechanical performance were conducted in relation to the parameters of the NiTi constitutive model. The results highlighted that: five NiTi material model parameters (E_A, σ_tL^S, σ_tU^S, σ_tU^E and σ_cL^S) are significantly correlated with the FE outputs; the TAV frame geometry and aortic root anatomy have a marginal effect on the level of influence of each NiTi material parameter; NiTi alloy candidates with pareto-optimal characteristics in terms of TAV mechanical performance can be successfully identified. In conclusion, the proposed computational framework supports the TAV design phase, providing information on the relationship between the super-elastic behavior of the supplied NiTi alloys and the device mechanical response.

Biomechanical characteristics of self-expanding sinus stents during crimping and deployment_A comparison between different biomaterials

Self-expanding sinus stents are often used in functional endoscopic sinus surgery to treat inflamed sinuses. The PROPEL self-expanding sinus stent offers mechanical support to the sinus cavity to prevent restenosis. The stent is made of a bioabsorbable material (PLGA) that disappears after wound healing. However, complications such as foreign body sensation and severe stent migration/expulsion have been reported after implantation. Little is known about the contact characteristics of self-expanding sinus stents from when the stent is crimped into the insertion device through to deployment into the sinus cavity. This current study developed a test platform to analyze the biomechanical behavior of the stent during this process. Three common bioabsorbable materials, PLGA, PCL and Mg alloy, were evaluated to understand how the choice of material affects the biomechanical characteristics of self-expanding sinus stents. The results showed that the material can have a considerable influence on the contact characteristics during crimping and deployment. When crimped, the PLGA and Mg alloy stents showed much higher plastic strain and contact stress than the PCL stent. When deployed, the PCL stent had the largest contact area (4.3 mm²) and the lowest contact pressure (0.1 MPa) on the inner surface of the sinus canal. The results indicate that PCL could be a suitable choice for self-expanding sinus stents. This current study provides a method for observing the biomechanical characteristics of sinus stents during stent crimping and deployment.

Accelerating Digitalization in Healthcare with the InSilicoTrials Cloud-Based Platform: Four Use Cases

The use of in silico trials is expected to play an increasingly important role in the development and regulatory evaluation of new medical products. Among the advantages that in silico approaches offer, is that they permit testing of drug candidates and new medical devices using virtual patients or computational emulations of preclinical experiments, allowing to refine, reduce or even replace time-consuming and costly benchtop/in vitro/ex vivo experiments as well as the involvement of animals and humans in in vivo studies. To facilitate and widen the adoption of in silico trials, InSilicoTrials Technologies has developed a cloud-based platform, hosting healthcare simulation tools for different bench, preclinical and clinical evaluations, and for diverse disease areas. This paper discusses four use cases of in silico trials performed using the InSilicoTrials.com platform. The first application illustrates how in silico approaches can improve the early preclinical assessment of drug-induced cardiotoxicity risks. The second use case is a virtual reproduction of a bench test for the safety assessment of transcatheter heart valve substitutes. The third and fourth use cases are examples of virtual patients generation to evaluate treatment effects in multiple sclerosis and prostate cancer patients, respectively.

Virtual reality in cardiac interventions-New tools or new toys?

Improvementsin medical imaging and a steady increase in computing power are leading to new possibilities in the field of cardiovascular interventions. Interventions can be planned in advance in greater detail, even to the point of simulating procedures. Nevertheless, all techniques are at an early stage of development. It is of utmost importance that tools, especially if they can be used as decision support are intensively validated and their accuracy is demonstrated. In our commentary, we summarize current techniques for impprovements in planning and guiding of procedures, but also critically discuss the downsides of these techniques. Following the work of Kenichi and colleagues, we also discuss necessary steps in advancing new tools and techniques, particularly as they are used in routine clinical practice. We also discuss the role of artificial intelligence, which could play a crucial role in this context in the future.

On the Modeling of Transcatheter Therapies for the Aortic and Mitral Valves: A Review

Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) has become a milestone for the management of aortic stenosis in a growing number of patients who are unfavorable candidates for surgery. With the new generation of transcatheter heart valves (THV), the feasibility of transcatheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR) for degenerated mitral bioprostheses and failed annuloplasty rings has been demonstrated. In this setting, computational simulations are modernizing the preoperative planning of transcatheter heart valve interventions by predicting the outcome of the bioprosthesis interaction with the human host in a patient-specific fashion. However, computational modeling needs to carry out increasingly challenging levels including the verification and validation to obtain accurate and realistic predictions. This review aims to provide an overall assessment of the recent advances in computational modeling for TAVR and TMVR as well as gaps in the knowledge limiting model credibility and reliability.

A computational optimization study of a self-expandable transcatheter aortic valve

Developing an efficient stent frame for transcatheter aortic valves (TAV) needs thorough investigation in different design and functional aspects. In recent years, most TAV studies have focused on their clinical performance, leaflet design, and durability. Although several optimization studies on peripheral stents exist, the TAV stents have different functional requirements and need to be explicitly studied. The aim of this study is to develop a cost-effective optimization framework to find the optimal TAV stent design made of Ni-Ti alloy. The proposed framework focuses on minimizing the maximum strain occurring in the stent during crimping, making use of a simplified model of the stent to reduce computational cost. The effect of the strut cross-section of the stent, i.e., width and thickness, and the number and geometry of the repeating units of the stent (both influencing the cell size) on the maximum strain is investigated. Three-dimensional simulations of the crimping process are used to verify the validity of the simplified representation of the stent, and the radial force has been calculated for further evaluation. The results suggest the key role of the number of cells (repeating units) and strut width on the maximum strain and, consequently, on the stent design. The difference in terms of the maximum strain between the simplified and the 3D model was less than 5%, confirming the validity of the adopted modeling strategy and the robustness of the framework to improve the TAV stent designs through a simple, cost-effective, and reliable procedure.