Quality control methods for optimal BCR-ABL1 clinical testing in human whole blood samples

Setting up a network of comprehensive care for patients with chronic myeloid leukemia: Lessons learned from Tanzania

Over the last 2 decades, the introduction of targeted therapies and the advances in the detection of BCR::ABL1 oncogene have dramatically improved comprehensive care for patients with Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). The once deadly malignancy has now transformed into a chronic disease with an overall patient survival approaching that of the age-matched general population. While excellent prognoses have been reported among CML patients in high-income countries, it is unfortunately not the same for those living in low and middle-income (LMIC) countries such as Tanzania. This disparity is largely contributed by barriers associated with the provision of comprehensive care including early diagnosis, access to treatment, and regular monitoring of the disease. In this review, we will share our experiences and lessons learned in setting up a network of comprehensive care for patients with CML in Tanzania.

Reverse Transcription Can Critically Impact the Diagnostic Outcome of BCR::ABL1 Quantitative Real-Time RT-PCR

Reverse transcriptases (RT) are essential tools in BCR::ABL1 fusion transcript monitoring in chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). The RT type and cDNA priming method may impair the stoichiometry of cDNA synthesis, thereby potentially introducing a bias in BCR::ABL1 qRT-PCR data. Using the Acrometrix™ BCR::ABL1 reference panel and 37 clinical specimens, we have comparatively investigated the performance of the RTs MLV and SuperScript IV with random hexamer vs. target-specific priming. Quantitative RT-PCR results identified the priming type and RT type as major factors for diagnostic data variation, mainly due to the different efficacies of processing BCR::ABL1 low-copy-numbers (<50) compared to GUSB or ABL1 high-copy targets. The impairment of SuperScript IV in processing low- and high-copy-number RNA targets equally was not reflected by the diagnostically relevant Log (BCR::ABL1/GUSB%) values. Therefore, the correct representation of housekeeping and BCR::ABL1 target genes should have priority when aiming at as high a number of housekeeping gene copies as possible. Our data suggest that for improving BCR::ABL1 assay sensitivity, increased RNA/cDNA amounts and the use of distinct RT/priming combinations are advantageous. However, for inter-laboratory harmonization, the proper conversion factor according to the CML international standard (IS) has to be reevaluated each time the grade of RT is changed.

[The establishment and multicenter application of internal quality control system for real-time quantitative PCR detection of BCR-ABL (P210) transcript level]

Objective: The study aims to establish a perfect BCR-ABL (P210) internal quality control system and ensure the long-term stability and comparability of the detection results between laboratories and to popularize and apply it in the three hospitals. Methods: The Qilu Hospital of Shandong University (H1) prepared a set of the BCR-ABL (P210) quality control substances to establish and improve internal quality control system. We went to other three participating hospitals (H2, H3, and H4) to inspect quality control before the measurement. In addition, we mailed 25 sets of quality control substances to each of the hospital for detection. The slope and intercept of the standard curve of each hospital and the detection results were analyzed and statistically judged using the Levey-Jennings quality control chart combined with the Westgard multirule theory. Then, we made a quality control evaluation. Results: ①An internal quality control system for the BCR-ABL (P210) transcript levels monitoring was successfully established for the quality inspection before the measurement, statistical judgment during the measurement, and evaluation after the measurement. ② Both the slope and intercept of the standard curve of the four hospitals was under control. ③The multicenter quality control substance judgment results were as follows: for H1 hospital, two times of "1(2s)" warning were found in the middle-level quality control substance, which was judged as being under control; for H2 hospital, one time of "1(2s)" warning was found for each quality control substance, which was judged as being "2(2s)" out of control; for H3 hospital, its high-level quality control substance violated the "1(3s)" rule, and low-level quality control substance appeared "1(2s)" warning, which was judged as "1(3s)" out of control; and all quality control substances were under control in H4 hospital. ④The quality control evaluation and correction were as follows: two hospitals were under control, and the other two hospitals had an "out of control." We found out the reason for the out of control and corrected them. ⑤The comparisons of the original values of the multicenter quality control substance were as follows: there were statistical differences in the results of high-level quality control substance among the four hospitals, and no significant difference was found in the results of the medium-level and low-level quality control substance. ⑥The comparisons of the IS values of the multicenter quality control substance were as follows: the IS values of the three quality control substance in H2 and H3 hospitals were significantly higher than those of H1 hospital, and H2 hospital was significantly higher than H3 hospital. Conclusion: A perfect and stable internal quality control system for the BCR-ABL (P210) transcripts has been established, which can effectively ensure the accuracy and stability of the clinical detection results. This internal quality control system has been successfully popularized and applied in other hospitals.

BCR-ABL1 (p210) Transcript Kinetics

Context.—

Delta checks are a powerful technique for monitoring clinical assays in many disciplines but have not been routinely used in molecular testing.

Objective.—

To determine if the biologically determined kinetics of BCR-ABL1's rise and fall could allow the development of a delta check in BCR-ABL1 testing.

Design.—

Nine years of BCR-ABL1 p210 results were evaluated and patients with 3 or more results were selected for inclusion. The kinetics of these percentages of international standard values were plotted against time along with the median and the 90th and 95th percentile lines. A Monte Carlo simulation of a batch mix-up was performed for 6 months of data to determine the efficacy of the proposed cutoff.

Results.—

The median kinetics showed a 1-log drop of the percentage of international standard in 90 days, with less than 5% of cases showing faster than a 2-log drop in 90 days, and less than 2.5% showing a faster than 3-log drop in 90 days (extrapolated to 1 log in 30 days). The Monte Carlo simulation of a batch mix-up showed that an average batch mix-up of 23 samples could routinely be flagged by this cutoff, albeit with wide variance.

Conclusions.—

These results suggest that using a drop in the percentage of international standard of greater than 1 log in 30 days can be a useful trigger in implementing a delta-check system for this molecular test.

Microbiota Introduced to Germ-Free Rats Restores Vascular Contractility and Blood Pressure

Commensal gut microbiota are strongly correlated with host hemodynamic homeostasis but only broadly associated with cardiovascular health. This includes a general correspondence of quantitative and qualitative shifts in intestinal microbial communities found in hypertensive rat models and human patients. However, the mechanisms by which gut microbes contribute to the function of organs important for blood pressure (BP) control remain unanswered. To examine the direct effects of microbiota on BP, we conventionalized germ-free (GF) rats with specific pathogen-free rats for a short-term period of 10 days, which served as a model system to observe the dynamic responses when reconstituting the holobiome. The absence of microbiota in GF rats resulted with relative hypotension compared with their conventionalized counterparts, suggesting an obligatory role of microbiota in BP homeostasis. Hypotension observed in GF rats was accompanied by a marked reduction in vascular contractility. Both BP and vascular contractility were restored by the introduction of microbiota to GF rats, indicating that microbiota could impact BP through a vascular-dependent mechanism. This is further supported by the decrease in actin polymerization in arteries from GF rats. Improved vascular contractility in conventionalized GF rats, as indicated through stabilized actin filaments, was associated with an increase in cofilin phosphorylation. These data indicate that the vascular system senses the presence (or lack of) microbiota to maintain vascular tone via actin polymerization. Overall, these results constitute a fundamental discovery of the essential nature of microbiota in BP regulation.

New Tool for Monitoring Molecular Response in Patients With Chronic Myeloid Leukemia

OBJECTIVE

Chronic myeloid leukemia treatment monitoring using polymerase chain reaction-based peripheral blood testing of t9;22 BCR-ABL1 provides improved test sensitivity over cytology but suffers from inadequate standardization in most laboratories due to variations inherent in the existing polymerase chain reaction methodologies. We performed the initial analytic performance evaluation of a novel competitive template-based peripheral blood b2a2/b3a2 transcript abundance method, called standardized nucleic acid quantification (SNAQ) test, with hypothesis that this will produced more consistent results with less frequent interlaboratory variations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-six chronic myeloid leukemia patients treated at our institution were enrolled. We compared SNAQ test with 2 laboratory developed test at the MD Anderson molecular diagnostic laboratory and Cancer Genetics Institute for analyzing BCR-ABL1 from peripheral blood samples. Each test result (n=36) was ranked against all the other samples tested by the same method.

RESULTS

The Pearson correlation between SNAQ and laboratory developed test done at 2 labs was met by correlations of 0.97, 0.96, 0.96, and 0.94. Analysis of variance of log %BCR-ABL1 interlaboratory results indicated no significant difference (P=0.98). Post hoc analysis of method agreement showed the SNAQ method had a 95% limit of agreement of ±3-fold between laboratories.

CONCLUSIONS

In this pilot study, SNAQ methodology performed consistent with half-log accuracy. Additional studies from a larger sample size and correlation with clinical outcomes are required to confirm this observation.

[The establishment and application of internal quality control system for real-time quantitative PCR detection of BCR-ABL (P210) transcript levels]

Objective: To set internal quality control system of BCR-ABL (P210) transcript levels for real-time quantitative PCR (RQ-PCR). Methods: Using K562 cells and HL-60 cells, we prepared high- and low-level BCR-ABL internal quality control substance. The BCR-ABL (P210) transcript levels of internal quality control substance have been determined for 184 times together with clinical samples from August 2013 to October 2015. The slope rate, intercept and correlation coefficient of standard curve were calculated according to different reagent lots (lots number 20130303, 20131212, 20140411 and 20150327 are called R1、R2、R3 and R4 for short respectively), and the detection results of quality control substance were calculated according to different reagent lots and quality control substance lots (lots number 20130725, 20140611 are called Q1、Q2 for short respectively). Then the results were analyzed by Levey-Jennings quality control chart combined with Westgard multi-rules theory. Results: ①We analyzed the slope rate and intercept of standard curve. Fifty-three times of the R1 reagent detection, 80 times of the R3 reagent detection and 14 times of the R4 reagent detection were all under control. For 37 times detection of R2 reagent, the slope rate was out of control for 6 times. It was lower than x-s for the 2-8 tests and upper the average for the 12-37 tests. The intercept was out of control for 9 times, upper the x+s for the 1-8 tests and lower the average for the 12-37 tests. ② According to the detection results of quality control substance, for Q1 quality control substance, 49 tests by R1 reagent were under control, and 1 out of 23 tests by R2 reagent was out of control. For Q2 quality control substance, 14 tests by R2 reagent detection, 72 tests by R3 reagent detection and 14 tests by R4 reagent were all under control. Conclusion: The preparation of high- and low-level quality control substance using K562 and HL-60 cells was convenient and the detection results were reliable and stable. The application of quality control substance combined with slope rate and intercept in the internal quality control may contribute to quality assurance for quantitative detection of BCR-ABL (P210) transcript levels.

A DNA real-time quantitative PCR method suitable for routine monitoring of low levels of minimal residual disease in chronic myeloid leukemia

The BCR-ABL1 sequence has advantages over the BCR-ABL1 transcript as a molecular marker in chronic myeloid leukemia and has been used in research studies. We developed a DNA real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) method for quantification of BCR-ABL1 sequences, which is also potentially suitable for routine use. The BCR-ABL1 breakpoint was sequenced after isolation by nested short-range PCR of DNA from blood, marrow, and cells on slides, obtained either at diagnosis or during treatment, or from artificial mixtures. PCR primers were chosen from a library of presynthesized and pretested BCR (n = 19) and ABL1 (n = 568) primers. BCR-ABL1 sequences were quantified relative to BCR sequences in 521 assays on 266 samples from 92 patients. For minimal residual disease detectable by DNA qPCR and RT-qPCR, DNA qPCR gave similar minimal residual disease results as RT-qPCR but had better precision at low minimal residual disease levels. The limit of detection of DNA qPCR depended on the amount of DNA assayed, being 10(-5.8) when 5 μg was assayed and 10(-7.0) when 80 μg was assayed. DNA qPCR may be useful and practical for monitoring the increasing number of patients with minimal residual disease around or below the limit of detection of RT-qPCR as the assay itself is simple and the up-front costs will be amortized if sequential assays are performed.

A multiplex two-color real-time PCR method for quality-controlled molecular diagnostic testing of FFPE samples

Background

Reverse transcription quantitative real-time PCR (RT-qPCR) tests support personalized cancer treatment through more clinically meaningful diagnosis. However, samples obtained through standard clinical pathology procedures are formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) and yield small samples with low integrity RNA containing PCR interfering substances. RT-qPCR tests able to assess FFPE samples with quality control and inter-laboratory reproducibility are needed.

Methods

We developed an RT-qPCR method by which 1) each gene was measured relative to a known number of its respective competitive internal standard molecules to control for interfering substances, 2) two-color fluorometric hydrolysis probes enabled analysis on a real-time platform, 3) external standards controlled for variation in probe fluorescence intensity, and 4) pre-amplification maximized signal from FFPE RNA samples. Reagents were developed for four genes comprised by a previously reported lung cancer diagnostic test (LCDT) then subjected to analytical validation using synthetic native templates as test articles to assess linearity, signal-to-analyte response, lower detection threshold, imprecision and accuracy. Fitness of this method and these reagents for clinical testing was assessed in FFPE normal (N = 10) and malignant (N = 10) lung samples.

Results

Reagents for each of four genes, MYC, E2F1, CDKN1A and ACTB comprised by the LCDT had acceptable linearity (R²>0.99), signal-to-analyte response (slope 1.0±0.05), lower detection threshold (<10 molecules) and imprecision (CV <20%). Poisson analysis confirmed accuracy of internal standard concentrations. Internal standards controlled for experimentally introduced interference, prevented false-negatives and enabled pre-amplification to increase signal without altering measured values. In the fitness for purpose testing of this two-color fluorometric LCDT using surgical FFPE samples, the diagnostic accuracy was 93% which was similar to that previously reported for analysis of fresh samples.

Conclusions

This quality-controlled two-color fluorometric RT-qPCR approach will facilitate the development of reliable, robust RT-qPCR-based molecular diagnostic tests in FFPE clinical samples.