Delayed repair of the peripheral nerve: A novel model in the rat sciatic nerve

Effects of regenerative peripheral nerve interface on dorsal root ganglia neurons following peripheral axotomy

Background

Long-term delayed reconstruction of injured peripheral nerves always results in poor recovery. One important reason is retrograde cell death among injured sensory neurons of dorsal root ganglia (DRG). A regenerative peripheral nerve interface (RPNI) was capable of generating new synaptogenesis between the proximal nerve stump and free muscle graft. Meanwhile, sensory receptors within the skeletal muscle can also be readily reinnervated by donor sensory axons, which allows the target muscles to become sources of sensory information for function reconstruction. To date, the effect of RPNI on injured sensory neurons is still unclear. Here, we aim to investigate the potential neuroprotective role of RPNI on sensory DRG neurons after sciatic axotomy in adult rats.

Materials and methods

The sciatic nerves of sixty rats were transected. The rats were randomly divided into three groups following this nerve injury: no treatment (control group, n = 20), nerve stump implantation inside a fully innervated muscle (NSM group, n = 20), or nerve stump implantation inside a free muscle graft (RPNI group, n = 20). At 8 weeks post-axotomy, ipsilateral L4 and L5 DRGs were harvested in each group. Toluidine blue staining was employed to quantify the neuronal densities in DRGs. The neuronal apoptosis index was quantified with TUNEL assay. Western blotting was applied to measure the expressions of Bax, Bcl-2, and neurotrophins (NTs) in ipsilateral DRGs.

Results

There were significantly higher densities of neurons in ipsilateral DRGs of RPNI group than NSM and control groups at 8 weeks post-axotomy (p < 0.01). Meanwhile, neuronal apoptosis index and the expressions of pro-apoptotic Bax within the ipsilateral DRGs were significantly lower in the RPNI group than those in the control and NSM groups (p < 0.05), while the opposite result was observed in the expression of pro-survival Bcl-2. Furthermore, the expressions of NGF, NT-3, BDNF, and GDNF were also upregulated in the ipsilateral DRGs in the RPNI group (p < 0.01).

Conclusion

The present results demonstrate that RPNI could prevent neuronal loss after peripheral axotomy. And the neuroprotection effect has a relationship with the upregulation of NTs in DRGs, such as NGF, NT-3, BDNF, and GDNF. These findings provide an effective therapy for neuroprotection in the delayed repair of the peripheral nerve injury.

The proteome of distal nerves: implication in delayed repair and poor functional recovery

Chronic denervation is one of the key factors that affect nerve regeneration. Chronic axotomy deteriorates the distal nerve stump, causes protein changes, and renders the microenvironment less permissive for regeneration. Some of these factors/proteins have been individually studied. To better delineate the comprehensive protein expression profiles and identify proteins that contribute to or are associated with this detrimental effect, we carried out a proteomic analysis of the distal nerve using an established delayed rat sciatic nerve repair model. Four rats that received immediate repair after sciatic nerve transection served as control, whereas four rats in the experimental group (chronic denervation) had their sciatic nerve repaired after a 12-week delay. All the rats were sacrificed after 16 weeks to harvest the distal nerves for extracting proteins. Twenty-five micrograms of protein from each sample were fractionated in SDS-PAGE gels. NanoLC-MS/MS analysis was applied to the gels. Protein expression levels of nerves on the surgery side were compared to those on the contralateral side. Any protein with a P value of less than 0.05 and a fold change of 4 or higher was deemed differentially expressed. All the differentially expressed proteins in both groups were further stratified according to the biological processes. A PubMed search was also conducted to identify the differentially expressed proteins that have been reported to be either beneficial or detrimental to nerve regeneration. Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) software was used for pathway analysis. The results showed that 709 differentially expressed proteins were identified in the delayed repair group, with a bigger proportion of immune and inflammatory process-related proteins and a smaller proportion of proteins related to axon regeneration and lipid metabolism in comparison to the control group where 478 differentially expressed proteins were identified. The experimental group also had more beneficial proteins that were downregulated and more detrimental proteins that were upregulated. IPA revealed that protective pathways such as LXR/RXR, acute phase response, RAC, ERK/MAPK, CNTF, IL-6, and FGF signaling were inhibited in the delayed repair group, whereas three detrimental pathways, including the complement system, PTEN, and apoptosis signaling, were activated. An available database of the adult rodent sciatic nerve was used to assign protein changes to specific cell types. The poor regeneration seen in the delayed repair group could be associated with the down-regulation of beneficial proteins and up-regulation of detrimental proteins. The proteins and pathways identified in this study may offer clues for future studies to identify therapeutic targets.

Effects of delayed repair of peripheral nerve injury on the spatial distribution of motor endplates in target muscle

Motor endplates (MEPs) are important sites of information exchange between motor neurons and skeletal muscle, and are distributed in an organized pattern of lamellae in the muscle. Delayed repair of peripheral nerve injury typically results in unsatisfactory functional recovery because of MEP degeneration. In this study, the mouse tibial nerve was transected and repaired with a biodegradable chitin conduit, immediately following or 1 or 3 months after the injury. Fluorescent α-bungarotoxin was injected to label MEPs. Tissue optical clearing combined with light-sheet microscopy revealed that MEPs were distributed in an organized pattern of lamellae in skeletal muscle after delayed repair for 1 and 3 months. However, the total number of MEPs, the number of MEPs per lamellar cluster, and the maturation of single MEPs in gastrocnemius muscle gradually decreased with increasing denervation time. These findings suggest that delayed repair can restore the spatial distribution of MEPs, but it has an adverse effect on the homogeneity of MEPs in the lamellar clusters and the total number of MEPs in the target muscle. The study procedures were approved by the Animal Ethics Committee of the Peking University People's Hospital (approval No. 2019PHC015) on April 8, 2019.

Repair of peripheral nerve injuries using a prevascularized cell-based tissue-engineered nerve conduit

One of the major challenges in the development of a larger and longer nerve conduit for peripheral nerve repair is the limitation in oxygen and nutrient diffusion within the tissue after transplantation preventing Schwann cell and axonal migration. This restriction is due to the slow neovascularization process of the graft starting from both nerve endings. To overcome this limitation, we propose the design of a living tissue-engineered nerve conduit made of an internal tube with a three-dimensional structure supporting axonal migration, which is inserted inside a hollow external tube that plays the role of an epineurium and is strong enough to be stitched to the severed nerve stumps. The internal tube is made of a rolled living fibroblast sheet and can be seeded with endothelial cells to promote the formation of a network containing capillary-like structures which allow rapid inosculation with the host nerve microvasculature after grafting. Human nerve conduits were grafted in immunodeficient rats to bridge a 15 mm sciatic nerve gap. Human capillaries within the pre-vascularized nerve conduit successfully connected to the host circulation 2 weeks after grafting. Twenty-two weeks after surgery, rats transplanted with the nerve conduits had a similar motor function recovery compared to the autograft group. By promoting rapid vascularization of the internal nerve tube from both ends of the nerve stumps, this endothelialized nerve conduit model displays a favorable environment to enhance axonal migration in both larger caliber and longer nerve grafts.

Animal models used to study direct peripheral nerve repair: a systematic review

Objective:

Peripheral nerve repair is required after traumatic injury. This common condition represents a major public health problem worldwide. Recovery after nerve repair depends on several factors, including the severity of the injury, the nerve involved, and the surgeon’s technical skills. Despite the precise microsurgical repair of nerve lesions, adequate functional recovery is not always achieved and, therefore, the regeneration process and surgical techniques are still being studied. Pre-clinical animal models are essential for this research and, for this reason, the focus of the present systematic review (according to the PRISMA statement) was to analyze the different animal models used in pre-clinical peripheral nerve repair studies.

Data sources:

Original articles, published in English from 2000 to 2018, were collected using the Web of Science, Scopus, and PubMed databases.

Data selection:

Only preclinical trials on direct nerve repair were included in this review. The articles were evaluated by the first two authors, in accordance with predefined data fields.

Outcome measures:

The primary outcomes included functional motor abilities, daily activity and regeneration rate. Secondary outcomes included coaptation technique and animal model.

Results:

This review yielded 267 articles, of which, after completion of the screening, 49 studies were analyzed. There were 1425 animals in those 49 studies, being rats, mice, guinea pigs, rabbits, cats and dogs the different pre-clinical models. The nerves used were classified into three groups: head and neck (11), forelimb (8) and hindlimb (30). The techniques used to perform the coaptation were: microsuture (46), glue (12), laser (8) and mechanical (2). The follow-up examinations were histology (43), electrophysiological analysis (24) and behavioral observation (22).

Conclusion:

The most widely used animal model in the study of peripheral nerve repair is the rat. Other animal models are also used but the cost-benefit of the rat model provides several strengths over the others. Suture techniques are currently the first option for nerve repair, but the use of glues, lasers and bioengineering materials is increasing. Hence, further research in this field is required to improve clinical practice.

Approaches to Peripheral Nerve Repair: Generations of Biomaterial Conduits Yielding to Replacing Autologous Nerve Grafts in Craniomaxillofacial Surgery

Peripheral nerve injury is a common clinical entity, which may arise due to traumatic, tumorous, or even iatrogenic injury in craniomaxillofacial surgery. Despite advances in biomaterials and techniques over the past several decades, reconstruction of nerve gaps remains a challenge. Autografts are the gold standard for nerve reconstruction. Using autografts, there is donor site morbidity, subsequent sensory deficit, and potential for neuroma development and infection. Moreover, the need for a second surgical site and limited availability of donor nerves remain a challenge. Thus, increasing efforts have been directed to develop artificial nerve guidance conduits (ANCs) as new methods to replace autografts in the future. Various synthetic conduit materials have been tested in vitro and in vivo, and several first- and second-generation conduits are FDA approved and available for purchase, while third-generation conduits still remain in experimental stages. This paper reviews the current treatment options, summarizes the published literature, and assesses future prospects for the repair of peripheral nerve injury in craniomaxillofacial surgery with a particular focus on facial nerve regeneration.

Key changes in denervated muscles and their impact on regeneration and reinnervation

The neuromuscular junction becomes progressively less receptive to regenerating axons if nerve repair is delayed for a long period of time. It is difficult to ascertain the denervated muscle's residual receptivity by time alone. Other sensitive markers that closely correlate with the extent of denervation should be found. After a denervated muscle develops a fibrillation potential, muscle fiber conduction velocity, muscle fiber diameter, muscle wet weight, and maximal isometric force all decrease; remodeling increases neuromuscular junction fragmentation and plantar area, and expression of myogenesis-related genes is initially up-regulated and then down-regulated. All these changes correlate with both the time course and degree of denervation. The nature and time course of these denervation changes in muscle are reviewed from the literature to explore their roles in assessing both the degree of detrimental changes and the potential success of a nerve repair. Fibrillation potential amplitude, muscle fiber conduction velocity, muscle fiber diameter, mRNA expression levels of myogenic regulatory factors and nicotinic acetylcholine receptor could all reflect the severity and length of denervation and the receptiveness of denervated muscle to regenerating axons, which could possibly offer an important clue for surgical choices and predict the outcomes of delayed nerve repair.

A review of bioactive release from nerve conduits as a neurotherapeutic strategy for neuronal growth in peripheral nerve injury

Peripheral nerve regeneration strategies employ the use of polymeric engineered nerve conduits encompassed with components of a delivery system. This allows for the controlled and sustained release of neurotrophic growth factors for the enhancement of the innate regenerative capacity of the injured nerves. This review article focuses on the delivery of neurotrophic factors (NTFs) and the importance of the parameters that control release kinetics in the delivery of optimal quantities of NTFs for improved therapeutic effect and prevention of dose dumping. Studies utilizing various controlled-release strategies, in attempt to obtain ideal release kinetics, have been reviewed in this paper. Release strategies discussed include affinity-based models, crosslinking techniques, and layer-by-layer technologies. Currently available synthetic hollow nerve conduits, an alternative to the nerve autografts, have proven to be successful in the bridging and regeneration of primarily the short transected nerve gaps in several patient cases. However, current research emphasizes on the development of more advanced nerve conduits able to simulate the effectiveness of the autograft which includes, in particular, the ability to deliver growth factors.

Follow-up evaluation with ultrasonography of peripheral nerve injuries after an earthquake

Published data on earthquake-associated peripheral nerve injury is very limited. Ultrasonography has been proven to be efficient in the clinic to diagnose peripheral nerve injury. The aim of this study was to assess the role of ultrasound in the evaluation of persistent peripheral nerve injuries 1 year after the Wenchuan earthquake. Thirty-four patients with persistent clinical symptoms and neurologic signs of impaired nerve function were evaluated with sonography prior to surgical repair. Among 34 patients, ultrasonography showed that 48 peripheral nerves were entrapped, and 11 peripheral nerves were disrupted. There was one case of misdiagnosis on ultrasonography. The concordance rate of ultrasonographic findings with those of surgical findings was 98%. A total of 48 involved nerves underwent neurolysis and the symptoms resolved. Only five nerves had scar tissue entrapment. Preoperative and postoperative clinical and ultrasonographic results were concordant, which verified that ultrasonography is useful for preoperative diagnosis and postoperative evaluation of injured peripheral nerves.

Skin derived precursor Schwann cells improve behavioral recovery for acute and delayed nerve repair

Previous work has shown that infusion of skin-derived precursors pre-differentiated into Schwann cells (SKP-SCs) can remyelinate injured and regenerating axons, and improve indices of axonal regeneration and electrophysiological parameters in rodents. We hypothesized that SKP-SC therapy would improve behavioral outcomes following nerve injury repair and tested this in a pre-clinical trial in 90 rats. A model of sciatic nerve injury and acellular graft repair was used to compare injected SKP-SCs to nerve-derived Schwann cells or media, and each was compared to the gold standard nerve isograft repair. In a second experiment, rats underwent right tibial nerve transection and received either acute or delayed direct nerve repair, with injections of either 1) SKP-SCs distal to the repair site, 2) carrier medium alone, or 3) dead SKP-SCs, and were followed for 4, 8 or 17weeks. For delayed repairs, both transected nerve ends were capped and repaired 11weeks later, along with injections of cells or media as above, and followed for 9 additional weeks (total of 20weeks). Rats were serially tested for skilled locomotion and a slip ratio was calculated for the horizontal ladder-rung and tapered beam tasks. Immediately after nerve injury and with chronic denervation, slip ratios were dramatically elevated. In the GRAFT repair study, the SKP-SC treated rats showed statistically significant improvement in ladder rung as compared to all other groups, and exhibited the greatest similarity to the sham controls on the tapered beam by study termination. In the ACUTE repair arm, the SKP-SC group showed marked improvement in ladder rung slip ratio as early as 5weeks after surgery, which was sustained for the duration of the experiment. Groups that received media and dead SKP-SCs improved with significantly slower progression. In the DELAYED repair arm, the SKP-SC group became significantly better than other groups 7weeks after the repair, while the media and the dead SKP-SCs showed no significant improvement in slip ratios. On histomorphometrical analysis, SKP-SC group showed significantly increased mean axon counts while the percent myelin debris was significantly lower at both 4 and 8weeks, suggesting that a less inhibitory micro-environment may have contributed to accelerated axonal regeneration. For delayed repair, mean axon counts were significantly higher in the SKP-SC group. Compound action potential amplitudes and muscle weights were also improved by cell therapy. In conclusion, SKP-SC therapy improves behavioral recovery after acute, chronic and nerve graft repair beyond the current standard of microsurgical nerve repair.

Immediate versus delayed primary nerve repair in the rabbit sciatic nerve

It is well known that peripheral nerve injury should be treated immediately in the clinic, but in some instances, repair can be delayed. This study investigated the effects of immediate versus delayed (3 days after injury) neurorrhaphy on repair of transected sciatic nerve in New Zealand rabbits using stereological, histomorphological and biomechanical methods. At 8 weeks after immediate and delayed neurorrhaphy, axon number and area in the sciatic nerve, myelin sheath and epineurium thickness, Schwann cell morphology, and the mechanical property of nerve fibers did not differ obviously. These results indicate that delayed neurorrhaphy do not produce any deleterious effect on sciatic nerve repair.