Differential patterns of pathology in and interaction between joint tissues in long-term osteoarthritis with different initiating causes: phenotype matters

Temporal progression of subchondral bone alterations in OA models involving induction of compromised meniscus integrity in mice and rats: A scoping review

OBJECTIVE

To categorize the temporal progression of subchondral bone alterations induced by compromising meniscus integrity in mouse and rat models of knee osteoarthritis (OA).

METHOD

Scoping review of investigations reporting subchondral bone changes with appropriate negative controls in the different mouse and rat models of OA induced by compromising meniscus integrity.

RESULTS

The available literature provides appropriate temporal detail on subchondral changes in these models, covering the entire spectrum of OA with an emphasis on early and mid-term time points. Microstructural changes of the subarticular spongiosa are comprehensively described; those of the subchondral bone plate are not. In mouse models, global subchondral bone alterations are unidirectional, involving an advancing sclerosis of the trabecular structure over time. In rats, biphasic subchondral bone alterations begin with an osteopenic degeneration and loss of subchondral trabeculae, progressing to a late sclerosis of the entire subchondral bone. Rat models, independently from the applied technique, relatively faithfully mirror the early bone loss detected in larger animals, and the late subchondral bone sclerosis observed in human advanced OA.

CONCLUSION

Mice and rats allow us to study the microstructural consequences of compromising meniscus integrity at high temporal detail. Thickening of the subchondral bone plate, an early loss of thinner subarticular trabecular elements, followed by a subsequent sclerosis of the entire subchondral bone are all important and reliable hallmarks that occur in parallel with the advancing articular cartilage degeneration. Thoughtful decisions on the study design, laterality, selection of controls and volumes of interest are crucial to obtain meaningful data.

The common marmoset as a translational model of age-related osteoarthritis

Age-related osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative joint disease characterized by pathological changes in nearly every intra- and peri-articular tissue that contributes to disability in older adults. Studying the etiology of age-related OA in humans is difficult due to an unpredictable onset and insidious nature. A barrier in developing OA modifying therapies is the lack of translational models that replicate human joint anatomy and age-related OA progression. The purpose of this study was to determine whether the common marmoset is a faithful model of human age-related knee OA. Semi-quantitative microCT scoring revealed greater radiographic OA in geriatric versus adult marmosets, and the age-related increase in OA prevalence was similar between marmosets and humans. Quantitative assessments indicate greater medial tibial cortical and trabecular bone thickness and heterogeneity in geriatric versus adult marmosets which is consistent with an age-related increase in focal subchondral bone sclerosis. Additionally, marmosets displayed an age-associated increase in synovitis and calcification of the meniscus and patella. Histological OA pathology in the medial tibial plateau was greater in geriatric versus adult marmosets driven by articular cartilage damage, proteoglycan loss, and altered chondrocyte cellularity. The age-associated increase in medial tibial cartilage OA pathology and meniscal calcification was greater in female versus male geriatric marmosets. Overall, marmosets largely replicate human OA as evident by similar 1) cartilage and skeletal morphology, 2) age-related progression in OA pathology, and 3) sex differences in OA pathology with increasing age. Collectively, these data suggest that the common marmoset is a highly translatable model of the naturally occurring, age-related OA seen in humans.

A standardized approach to evaluation and reporting of synovial histopathology in two surgically induced murine models of osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

Synovial pathology has been linked to osteoarthritis (OA) pain in patients. Microscopic grading systems for synovial changes in human OA have been described, but a standardized approach for murine models of OA is needed. We sought to develop a reproducible approach and set of minimum recommendations for reporting of synovial histopathology in mouse models of OA.

METHODS

Coronal and sagittal sections from male mouse knee joints subjected to destabilization of medial meniscus (DMM) or partial meniscectomy (PMX) were collected as part of other studies. Stains included Hematoxylin and Eosin (H&E), Toluidine Blue (T-Blue), and Safranin O/Fast Green (Saf-O). Four blinded readers graded pathological features (hyperplasia, cellularity, and fibrosis) at specific anatomic locations. Inter-reader agreement of each feature score was determined.

RESULTS

There was acceptable to very good agreement when using 3-4 individual readers. After DMM and PMX, expected medial predominant changes in hyperplasia and cellularity were observed, with fibrosis noted at 12 weeks post-PMX. Synovial changes were consistent from section to section in the mid-joint area. When comparing stains, H&E and T-blue resulted in better agreement compared to Saf-O stain.

CONCLUSIONS

To account for the pathologic and anatomic variability in synovial pathology and allow for a more standardized evaluation that can be compared across studies, we recommend evaluating a minimum set of 3 pathological features at standardized anatomic areas. Further, we suggest reporting individual feature scores separately before relying on a single summed "synovitis" score. H&E or T-blue are preferred, inter-reader agreement for each feature should be considered.

Streamlining quantitative joint-wide medial femoro-tibial histopathological scoring of mouse post-traumatic knee osteoarthritis models

OBJECTIVES

Histological scoring remains the gold-standard for quantifying post-traumatic osteoarthritis (ptOA) in animal models, allowing concurrent evaluation of numerous joint tissues. Available systems require scoring multiple sections/joint making analysis laborious and expensive. We investigated if a single section allowed equivalent quantitation of pathology in different joint tissues and disease stages, in three ptOA models.

METHOD

Male 10-12-week-old C57BL/6 mice underwent surgical medial-meniscal-destabilization, anterior-cruciate-ligament (ACL) transection, non-invasive-ACL-rupture, or served as sham-surgical, non-invasive-ACL-strain, or naïve/non-operated controls. Mice (n = 12/group) were harvested 1-, 4-, 8-, and 16-week post-intervention. Serial sagittal toluidine-blue/fast-green stained sections of the medial-femoro-tibial joint (n = 7/joint, 84 µm apart) underwent blinded scoring of 40 histology-outcomes. We evaluated agreement between single-slide versus entire slide-set maximum or median scores (weighted-kappa), and sensitivity/specificity of single-slide versus median/maximum to detect OA pathology.

RESULTS

A single optimal mid-sagittal section showed excellent agreement with median (weighted-kappa 0.960) and maximum (weighted-kappa 0.926) scores. Agreement for individual histology-outcomes was high with only 19/240 median and 15/240 maximum scores having a weighted-kappa ≤0.4, the majority of these (16/19 and 11/15) in control groups. Statistically-significant histology-outcome differences between ptOA models and their controls detected with the entire slide-set were reliably reproduced using a single slide (sensitivity >93.15%, specificity >93.10%). The majority of false-negatives with single-slide scoring were meniscal and subchondral bone histology-outcomes (89%) and occurred in weeks 1-4 post-injury (84%).

CONCLUSION

A single mid-sagittal slide reduced the time needed to score diverse histopathological changes by 87% without compromising the sensitivity or specificity of the analysis, across a variety of ptOA models and time-points.

Loss of Grem1-lineage chondrogenic progenitor cells causes osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis (OA) is characterised by an irreversible degeneration of articular cartilage. Here we show that the BMP-antagonist Gremlin 1 (Grem1) marks a bipotent chondrogenic and osteogenic progenitor cell population within the articular surface. Notably, these progenitors are depleted by injury-induced OA and increasing age. OA is also caused by ablation of Grem1 cells in mice. Transcriptomic and functional analysis in mice found that articular surface Grem1-lineage cells are dependent on Foxo1 and ablation of Foxo1 in Grem1-lineage cells caused OA. FGFR3 signalling was confirmed as a promising therapeutic pathway by administration of pathway activator, FGF18, resulting in Grem1-lineage chondrocyte progenitor cell proliferation, increased cartilage thickness and reduced OA. These findings suggest that OA, in part, is caused by mechanical, developmental or age-related attrition of Grem1 expressing articular cartilage progenitor cells. These cells, and the FGFR3 signalling pathway that sustains them, may be effective future targets for biological management of OA.

Recommendations For a Standardized Approach to Histopathologic Evaluation of Synovial Membrane in Murine Models of Experimental Osteoarthritis

Background

Synovial pathology has been linked to osteoarthritis (OA) pain in patients. Microscopic grading systems for synovial changes in human OA have been described, but a standardized approach for murine models of OA is needed. We sought to develop a reproducible approach and set of minimum recommendations for synovial histopathology in mouse models of OA.

Methods

Coronal and sagittal sections from male mouse knee joints subjected to destabilization of medial meniscus (DMM) or partial meniscectomy (PMX) were collected as part of other studies. Stains included Hematoxylin and Eosin (H&E), Toluidine Blue (T-Blue) and Safranin O/Fast Green (Saf-O). Four blinded readers graded pathological features (hyperplasia, cellularity, and fibrosis) at specific anatomic locations in the medial and lateral compartments. Inter-reader reliability of each feature was determined.

Results

There was acceptable to very good agreement between raters. After DMM, increased hyperplasia and cellularity and a trend towards increased fibrosis were observed 6 weeks after DMM in the medial locations, and persisted up to 16 weeks. In the PMX model, cellularity and hyperplasia were evident in both medial and lateral compartments while fibrotic changes were largely seen on the medial side. Synovial changes were consistent from section to section in the mid-joint area mice. H&E, T-blue, and Saf-O stains resulted in comparable reliability.

Conclusions

To allow for a standard evaluation that can be implemented and compared across labs and studies, we recommend using 3 readers to evaluate a minimum set of 3 pathological features at standardized anatomic areas. Pre-defining areas to be scored, and reliability for each pathologic feature should be considered.

The GM-CSF/CCL17 pathway in obesity-associated osteoarthritic pain and disease in mice

OBJECTIVES

We have previously identified a granulocyte macrophage-colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF)/C-C motif ligand 17 (CCL17) pathway in monocytes/macrophages, in which GM-CSF regulates the formation of CCL17, and it is important for an experimental osteoarthritis (OA) model. We explore here additional OA models, including in the presence of obesity, such as a requirement for this pathway.

DESIGN

The roles of GM-CSF, CCL17, CCR4, and CCL22 in various experimental OA models, including those incorporating obesity (eight-week high-fat diet), were investigated using gene-deficient male mice. Pain-like behavior and arthritis were assessed by relative static weight distribution and histology, respectively. Cell populations (flow cytometry) and cytokine messenger RNA (mRNA) expression (qPCR) in knee infrapatellar fat pad were analyzed. Human OA sera were collected for circulating CCL17 levels (ELISA) and OA knee synovial tissue for gene expression (qPCR).

RESULTS

We present evidence that: i) GM-CSF, CCL17, and CCR4, but not CCL22, are required for the development of pain-like behavior and optimal disease in three experimental OA models, as well as for exacerbated OA development due to obesity, ii) obesity alone leads to spontaneous knee joint damage in a GM-CSF- and CCL17-dependent manner, and iii) in knee OA patients, early indications are that BMI correlates with a lower Oxford Knee Score (r = -0.458 and p = 0.0096), with elevated circulating CCL17 levels (r = 0.2108 and p = 0.0153) and with elevated GM-CSF and CCL17 gene expression in OA synovial tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

The above findings indicate that GM-CSF, CCL17, and CCR4 are involved in obesity-associated OA development, broadening their potential as targets for possible treatments for OA.

Disease-modifying interactions between chronic kidney disease and osteoarthritis: a new comorbid mouse model

OBJECTIVE

The prevalence of comorbid chronic kidney disease (CKD) and osteoarthritis (OA) is increasing globally. While sharing common risk factors, the mechanism and consequences of concurrent CKD-OA are unclear. The aims of the study were to develop a preclinical comorbid model, and to investigate the disease-modifying interactions.

METHODS

Seventy (70) male 8-10 week-old C57BL/6 mice were subjected to 5/6 nephrectomy (5/6Nx)±destabilisation of medial meniscus (DMM) or sham surgery. OA pathology and CKD were assessed 12 weeks postinduction by blinded histology scoring, micro-CT, immunohistochemistry for osteoclast and matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-13 activity, and serum analysis of bone metabolic markers.

RESULTS

The 5/6Nx model recapitulated characteristic features of CKD, with renal fibrosis and deranged serum alkaline phosphatase, calcium and phosphate. There was no histological evidence of cartilage pathology induced by 5/6Nx alone, however, synovial MMP-13 expression and subchondral bone osteoclastic activity were increased (p<0.05), with accompanying reductions (p<0.05) in subchondral trabecular bone, bone volume and mineral density. DMM significantly (p<0.05) increased tibiofemoral cartilage damage, subchondral bone sclerosis, marginal osteophytes and synovitis, in association with increased cartilage and synovial MMP-13. DMM alone induced (p<0.05) renal fibrosis, proteinuria and increased (p<0.05) 5/6Nx-induced serum urea. However, DMM in 5/6Nx-mice resulted in significantly reduced (p<0.05) cartilage pathology and marginal osteophyte development, in association with reduced subchondral bone volume and density, and inhibition of 5/6Nx-induced subchondral bone osteoclast activation.

CONCLUSION

This study assessed a world-first preclinical comorbid CKD-OA model. Our findings demonstrate significant bidirectional disease-modifying interaction between CKD and OA.

System pharmacology analysis to decipher the effect and mechanism of active ingredients combination from Duhuo Jisheng decoction on osteoarthritis in rats

ETHNOPHARMACOLOGY RELEVANCE

Duhuo Jisheng decoction is a traditional Chinese formula that has been widely used in clinical practice to treat osteoarthritis, which has the effects of removing invaded cold and dampness, relieving joint pain. However, it is difficult to determine the effective substances and mechanisms due to assorted herbs and components, and further research is needed.

AIM OF THE STUDY

This study was designed to explore and verify the mechanism and targets of DHJSD in the treatment of OA via network analysis and experiments.

METHOD

In this study, the active ingredients of DHJSD were qualitatively analyzed by UPLC-QDA. Network analysis was used to identify common targets and pathways. Next, we explored the therapeutic mechanism of DHJSD through a rat model of knee osteoarthritis. HE staining was used to judge the establishment of the animal model. ELISA and Western blotting were used to verify the expression of key pathway proteins.

CONCLUSION

In this study, seventeen chemical constituents in DHJSD were identified. According to the network analysis, we obtained the potential associated pathways of action. Then, molecular docking and SPR experiments showed that the sixteen identified components had high binding energies to IL-6. HE staining showed that the high-dose group of DHJSD had an obvious therapeutic effect on model rats. Compared with the model group, the levels of IL-1β, TNF-α, IL-6, MMP3, MMP13, ADAMTS4 and ADAMTS5 in serum and the expression of STAT3 and p-STAT3 protein in administration groups were significantly decreased. This result indicated that the IL-6/STAT3 signaling pathway was one of the important pathways regulated by DHJSD to improve OA.

Animal models of osteoarthritis

Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2022;11(8):514–517.

OA foundations - experimental models of osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis (OA) is increasingly recognised as a disease of diverse phenotypes with variable clinical presentation, progression, and response to therapeutic intervention. This same diversity is readily apparent in the many animal models of OA. However, model selection, study design, and interpretation of resultant findings, are not routinely done in the context of the target human (or veterinary) patient OA sub-population or phenotype. This review discusses the selection and use of animal models of OA in discovery and therapeutic-development research. Beyond evaluation of the different animal models on offer, this review suggests focussing the approach to OA-animal model selection on study objective(s), alignment of available models with OA-patient sub-types, and the resources available to achieve valid and translatable results. How this approach impacts model selection is discussed and an experimental design checklist for selecting the optimal model(s) is proposed. This approach should act as a guide to new researchers and a reminder to those already in the field, as to issues that need to be considered before embarking on in vivo pre-clinical research. The ultimate purpose of using an OA animal model is to provide the best possible evidence if, how, when and where a molecule, pathway, cell or process is important in clinical disease. By definition this requires both model and study outcomes to align with and be predictive of outcomes in patients. Keeping this at the forefront of research using pre-clinical OA models, will go a long way to improving the quality of evidence and its translational value.

Animal Models of Bone Marrow Lesions in Osteoarthritis

Bone marrow lesions are abnormalities in magnetic resonance images that have been associated with joint pain and osteoarthritis in clinical studies. Increases in the volume of bone marrow lesions have been associated with progression of joint degeneration, leading to the suggestion that bone marrow lesions may be an early indicator of—or even a contributor to—cartilage loss preceding irreversible damage to the joint. Despite evidence that bone marrow lesions play a role in osteoarthritis pathology, very little is known about the natural history of bone marrow lesions and their contribution to joint degeneration. As a result, there are limited data regarding the cell activity within a bone marrow lesion and any associated bone‐cartilage cross‐talk. Animal models provide the best approach for understanding bone marrow lesions at their early, reversible stages. Here, we review the few animal studies of bone marrow lesions. An ideal animal model of a bone marrow lesion occurs in joints large enough to accurately measure bone marrow lesion volume. Additionally, the ideal animal model would facilitate the study of bone‐cartilage cross‐talk by generating the bone marrow lesion immediately adjacent to subchondral bone and would do so without causing direct damage to neighboring soft tissues to isolate the effects of the bone marrow lesion on cartilage loss. Early reports demonstrate the feasibility of such an animal model. Given the irreversible nature of osteoarthritic changes in the joint, factors such as bone marrow lesions that are present early in disease pathogenesis remain an enticing target for new therapeutic approaches. © 2022 The Authors. JBMR Plus published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of American Society for Bone and Mineral Research.

Monocytes, Macrophages, and Their Potential Niches in Synovial Joints - Therapeutic Targets in Post-Traumatic Osteoarthritis?

Synovial joints are complex structures that enable normal locomotion. Following injury, they undergo a series of changes, including a prevalent inflammatory response. This increases the risk for development of osteoarthritis (OA), the most common joint disorder. In healthy joints, macrophages are the predominant immune cells. They regulate bone turnover, constantly scavenge debris from the joint cavity and, together with synovial fibroblasts, form a protective barrier. Macrophages thus work in concert with the non-hematopoietic stroma. In turn, the stroma provides a scaffold as well as molecular signals for macrophage survival and functional imprinting: “a macrophage niche”. These intricate cellular interactions are susceptible to perturbations like those induced by joint injury. With this review, we explore how the concepts of local tissue niches apply to synovial joints. We introduce the joint micro-anatomy and cellular players, and discuss their potential interactions in healthy joints, with an emphasis on molecular cues underlying their crosstalk and relevance to joint functionality. We then consider how these interactions are perturbed by joint injury and how they may contribute to OA pathogenesis. We conclude by discussing how understanding these changes might help identify novel therapeutic avenues with the potential of restoring joint function and reducing post-traumatic OA risk.

Pathology-pain relationships in different osteoarthritis animal model phenotypes: it matters what you measure, when you measure, and how you got there

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether osteoarthritis (OA) pain characteristics and mechanistic pathways in pre-clinical models are phenotype-specific.

DESIGN

Male 11-week-old C57BL6 mice had unilateral medial-meniscal-destabilization (DMM) or antigen-induced-arthritis (AIA), vs sham-surgery/immunised-controls (Sham/Im-CT). Pain behaviour (allodynia, mechanical- and thermal-hyperalgesia, hindlimb static weight-bearing, stride-length) and lumbar dorsal root ganglia (DRG) gene-expression were measured at baseline, day-3, week-1/-2/-4/-8/-16, and pain-behaviour:gene-expression:joint-pathology associations investigated.

RESULTS

DMM and AIA induced structural OA defined by progressively increasing cartilage erosion, subchondral bone sclerosis and osteophyte size and maturation. All pain-behaviours were modified, with model-specific differences in severity and temporal pattern. Tactile allodynia developed acutely in both models and persisted to week-16. During early-OA (wk4-8) there was; reduced right hindlimb weight-bearing in AIA; thermal-hyperalgesia and reduced stride-length in DMM. During chronic-OA (wk12-16); mechanical-hyperalgesia and reduced right hindlimb weight-bearing were observed in DMM only. There were no associations in either model between different pain-behaviour outcomes. A coordinated DRG-expression profile was observed in sham and Im-CT for all 11 genes tested, but not in AIA and DMM. At wk-16 despite equivalent joint pathology, changes in DRG-expression (Calca, Trpa1, Trpv1, Trpv4) were observed only in DMM. In AIA mechanical-hyperalgesia was associated with Trpv1 (r = -0.79) and Il1b (r = 0.53). In DMM stride-length was associated with Calca, Tac1, Trpv1, Trpv2, Trpv4 and Adamts5 (r = 0.4-0.57). DRG gene-expression change was correlated with subchondral-bone sclerosis in DMM, and cartilage damage in AIA. Positive pain-behaviour:joint-pathology associations were only present in AIA - for synovitis, subchondral-bone resorption, chondrocyte-hypertrophy and cartilage damage.

CONCLUSION

Pain and peripheral sensory neuronal responses are OA-phenotype-specific with distinct pathology:pain-outcome:molecular-mechanism relationships.

Clinical Manifestations, Histopathological Changes And Quality Of Life In Patients With Advanced Knee Osteoarthritis Caused By Age, Trauma, Obesity And Their Combination

Objective — to reveal and analyze clinical characteristics, knee joint histopathology, and quality of life in patients at late stages of knee osteoarthritis (OA) triggered by age, trauma, metabolic syndrome, or their combination. Material and methods — We studied 120 subjects with knee OA (sensu Altman R.D., 1991) of Kellgren-Lawrence Grades 3-4. They were distributed among 4 groups (30 participants in each) based on the presence of age-related, post-traumatic, metabolic, or combined phenotypes. Clinical examination of patients with pain and their functional status evaluation (via Visual Analogue Scale, WOMAC, Lequesne index), quality of life assessment (MOS SF-36 questionnaire), along with histopathological study of medial tibial plateau cartilage and synovial membrane, were caried out, followed by statistical data processing. Results — Age-related OA phenotype was characterized by the latest clinical onset [59.5 (54-68) years of age] with the largest average patient age [72.5 (63-77) years], moderate to severe pain and knee dysfunction [total WOMAC score of 160 (127-190) points and Lequesne index of 20 (8-21) points], severe degenerative cartilage lesions [8.5 (6-10) points sensu Mankin] with high-grade synovitis [5 (3-8) points sensu Krenn]. Post-traumatic OA phenotype was distinguished by the lowest pain, stiffness and knee functional limitations [total WOMAC score of 129 (100-166), Lequesne index of 15 (14-19)], the highest quality of life in patients [physical component summary of 34.1 (30.5-36.1) points, mental component summary of 40.4 (32.9-43.8) points] against the background of local severe cartilage lesions [8 (6-8) sensu Mankin] with reparative pattern and synovial fibrosis. For metabolic OA phenotype, the typical traits included female-biased sex ratio (87%), high prevalence of clinical synovitis (77%), severe pain and functional knee disorders [total WOMAC score of 188 (162-207) points, Lequesne index of 20 (19-23) points], the worst quality of life [physical component summary of 28.0 (24.3-31.9) points, mental component summary of 30.9 (26.9-35.9) points], vascular invasion of cartilage, and high-grade synovitis [4 (3-5) points sensu Krenn]. Combined OA phenotype was characterized by variable clinical and histopathological features. Conclusion — Comprehensive comparative clinical and morphological analysis of late-stage knee OA of various origin was completed, and age-related, post-traumatic, metabolic and combined OA phenotypes were studied. The methodological basis for differential approach to treating different categories of OA patients was developed.