An Investigation of the Heat Induced during Ultrasonic Post Removal

Temperature rise during removal of fractured components out of the implant body: an in vitro study comparing two ultrasonic devices and five implant types

BACKGROUND

Ultrasonic instrumentation under magnification may facilitate mobilization of screw remnants but may induce heat trauma to surrounding bone. An increase of 5°C is considered detrimental to osseointegration. The objective of this investigation was to examine the rise in temperature of the outer implant body after 30 s of ultrasonic instrumentation to the inner part, in relation to implant type, type of ultrasonic equipment, and the use of coolants in vitro.

METHODS

Two ultrasonic devices (Satelec Suprasson T Max and Electro Medical Systems (EMS) miniMaster) were used on five different implant types that were provided with a thermo couple (Astra 3.5 mm, bone level Regular CrossFit (RC) 4.1 mm, bone level Narrow CrossFit (NC) 3.3 mm, Straumann tissue level regular body regular neck 3.3 mm, and Straumann tissue level wide body regular neck 4.8 mm), either with or without cooling during 30 s. Temperature rise at this point in time is the primary outcome measure. In addition, the mean maximum rise in temperature (all implants combined) was assessed and statistically compared among devices, implant systems, and cooling mode (independent t-tests, ANOVA, and post hoc analysis).

RESULTS

The Satelec device without cooling induces the highest temperature change of up to 13°C, particularly in both bone level implants (p < 0.05) but appears safe for approximately 10 s of continuous instrumentation, after which a cooling down period is rational. Cooling is effective for both devices. However, when the Satelec device is used with coolant for a longer period of time, a rise in temperature must be anticipated after cessation of instrumentation, and post-operational cooling is advised.

CONCLUSIONS

The in vitro setup used in this experiment implies that care should be taken when translating the observations to clinical recommendations, but it is carefully suggested that the EMS device causes limited rise in temperature, even without coolant.

Evaluation of a new protocol for removing metal retainers from multirooted teeth

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to evaluate in vitro a new protocol for removing intraradicular retainers from multirooted teeth applying ultrasonic vibration.

METHODS

Forty mandibular molars were endodontically treated to receive cast intraradicular retainers, which were distributed into the following 4 groups: group 1: control without a slot and without ultrasound, group 2: control with a slot and without ultrasound, group 3: ultrasonic vibration in the core without a slot, and group 4: ultrasonic vibration in the core with a slot. After the intraradicular retainers were cemented with zinc phosphate, ultrasonic vibration was applied for 1 minute. The test specimens were then submitted to the traction test in the universal testing machine at a speed of 1 mm/min. The maximum traction force required to remove the intraradicular retainer was recorded in newtons, and the data were statistically analyzed using analysis of variance and the Tukey-Kramer test (P < .05).

RESULTS

The results showed statistically significant differences among the groups tested (group 1 = 234.34 N, group 2 = 201.67 N, group 3 = 139.57 N, and group 4 = 83.23 N). The lowest mean value of traction force recorded was when ultrasonic vibration was applied on the core with a slot.

CONCLUSIONS

Creating a slot in the core and the ultrasound application on all surfaces and inside the slot reduced the force required for removing intraradicular metal retainers from multirooted teeth cemented with zinc phosphate.

Effect of ultrasonic tip designs on intraradicular post removal

Objectives

To evaluate the effect of different ultrasonic tip designs on intraradicular post removal.

Materials and Methods

The crowns of forty human canine teeth were removed, and after biomechanical preparation and filling, the roots were embedded in acrylic resin blocks. The post spaces were made, and root canal molding was performed with self-cured acrylic resin. After casting (Cu-Al), the posts were cemented with zinc phosphate cement. The specimens were randomly separated into 4 groups (n = 10), as follows: G1 - no ultrasonic vibration (control); G2 - ultrasonic vibration using an elongated cylindrical-shaped and active rounded tip; G3 - ultrasonic vibration with a flattened convex and linear active tip; G4 - ultrasonic vibration with active semicircular tapered tip. Ultrasonic vibration was applied for 15 seconds on each post surface and tensile test was performed in a Universal Testing Machine (Instron 4444 - 1 mm/min).

Results

G4 presented the highest mean values, however, with no statistically significant difference in comparison to G3 (P > 0.05). G2 presented the lowest mean values with statistically significant difference to G3 and G4 (P < 0.05).

Conclusions

Ultrasonic vibration with elongated cylindrical-shaped and active rounded tip was most effective in reducing force required for intraradicular post removal.

Thermal effects from modified endodontic laser tips used in the apical third of root canals with erbium-doped yttrium aluminium garnet and erbium, chromium-doped yttrium scandium gallium garnet lasers

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the temperature changes occurring on the apical third of root surfaces when erbium-doped yttrium aluminium garnet (Er:YAG) and erbium, chromium-doped yttrium scandium gallium garnet (Er,Cr:YSGG) laser energy was delivered with a tube etched, laterally emitting conical tip and a conventional bare design optical fiber tip.

BACKGROUND DATA

Thermal effects of root canal laser treatments on periodontal ligament cells and alveolar bone are of concern in terms of safety.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 64 single-rooted extracted teeth were prepared 1 mm short of the working length using rotary nickel-titanium Pro-Taper files to an apical size corresponding to a F5 Pro-Taper instrument. A thermocouple located 2 mm from the apex was used to record temperature changes arising from delivery of laser energy through laterally emitting conical tips or plain tips, using an Er:YAG or Er,Cr:YSGG laser.

RESULTS

For the Er:YAG and Er,Cr:YSGG systems, conical fibers showed greater lateral emissions (452 + 69% and 443 + 64%) and corresponding lower forward emissions (48 + 5% and 49 + 5%) than conventional plain-fiber tips. All four combinations of laser system and fiber design elicited temperature increases less than 2.5 degrees C during lasing. The use of water irrigation attenuated completely the thermal effects of individual lasing cycles.

CONCLUSIONS

Laterally emitting conical fiber tips can be used safely under defined conditions for intracanal irradiation without harmful thermal effects on the periodontal apparatus.

Effect of different water flows on root surface temperature during ultrasonic removal of posts

OBJECTIVE

This in vitro study evaluated rises in temperature on the outer root surface of human incisors during ultrasonic post removal with different water flows.

STUDY DESIGN

Thirty-six extracted teeth (12 maxillary central incisors, 12 maxillary lateral incisors, and 12 mandibular incisors) were used. After root canal preparation, the teeth were obturated, and prefabricated posts were cemented into the prepared spaces. Posts were ultrasonically instrumented dry and with irrigation at 20 mL/min and 40 mL/min. Temperature changes on the entire mesial outer surfaces of the roots were measured at 10-second intervals using an infrared thermal imaging camera.

RESULTS

Increases in root surface temperature were significantly lower when posts were instrumented with 40 mL/min water irrigation compared with dry vibration and 20 mL/min irrigation, which also significantly differed from each other. Statistical analysis among tooth groups showed differences in the mean temperature rise of maxillary central incisors and maxillary lateral incisors compared with mandibular incisors when posts were instrumented dry or with 20 mL/min irrigation. There were no significant differences in mean temperature rises between the studied groups when 40 mL/min irrigation was used.

CONCLUSIONS

Water cooling during ultrasonic post instrumentation significantly reduced temperature increases on the outer root surface; however, the intensity of the cooling was also important. Our results suggest that copious water irrigation during post removal is an effective method to protect the root's surrounding tissue.