Microbiome affecting reproductive outcome in ARTs

The Role of the Vaginal and Endometrial Microbiomes in Infertility and Their Impact on Pregnancy Outcomes in Light of Recent Literature

The Human Microbiome Project (HMP), initiated in 2007, aimed to gather comprehensive knowledge to create a genetic and metabolic map of human-associated microorganisms and their contribution to physiological states and predisposition to certain diseases. Research has revealed that the human microbiome is highly diverse and exhibits significant interpersonal variability; consequently, its exact impact on health remains unclear. With the development of next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies, the broad spectrum of microbial communities has been better characterized. The lower female genital tract, particularly the vagina, is colonized by various bacterial species, with Lactobacillus spp. predominating. The upper female genital tract, especially the uterus, was long considered sterile. However, recent studies have identified a distinct endometrial microbiome. A Lactobacillus-dominated microbiome of the female genital tract is associated with favorable reproductive outcomes, including higher success rates in natural conception and assisted reproductive technologies (ART). Conversely, microbial imbalances, or dysbiosis, marked by reduced Lactobacilli as well as an increased diversity and abundance of pathogenic species (e.g., Gardnerella vaginalis or Prevotella spp.), are linked to infertility, implantation failure, and pregnancy complications such as miscarriage and preterm birth. Dysbiosis can impair the vaginal or endometrial mucosal barrier and also trigger pro-inflammatory responses, disrupting essential reproductive processes like implantation. Despite growing evidence supporting the associations between the microbiome of the female genital tract and certain gynecological and obstetric conditions, clear microbial biomarkers have yet to be identified, and there is no consensus on the precise composition of a normal or healthy microbiome. The lack of standardized protocols and biomarkers limits the routine use of microbiome screening tests. Therefore, larger patient cohorts are needed to facilitate comparative studies and improve our understanding of the physiological microbiome profiles of the uterus and vagina, as well as how dysbiosis may influence clinical outcomes. Further research is required to refine diagnostic tools and develop personalized therapeutic strategies to improve fertility and pregnancy outcomes.

Effect of Waiting Period on Initial Adverse Vaginal Microbiome Composition in IVF-ICSI Patients

Background/Objectives: In this observational prospective cohort study, conducted at the Fertility Centre of the University Hospital, Duesseldorf Germany, the spontaneous reversal capacity and the effect of waiting time on an adverse vaginal microbiome profile in subfertile patients were investigated. Methods: Vaginal swabs of 76 patients were obtained before starting a fertility treatment using a commercially available test to perform a microbiome analysis. Patients with a favorable microbiome profile ("medium" or "high profile") according to the manufacturer's algorithm proceeded with the fertility treatment. Patients with an unfavorable microbiome profile ("low profile") postponed their fertility treatment and were sampled up to four times in each successive cycle or until a shift to a more favorable profile was detected. Results: Initially, 54/76 subjects had a high or medium profile and 23/76 had a low profile. Within 3 months, 75% of patients with an initial low profile shifted to a more favorable profile (7/23 dropouts). The presence of Lactobacillus crispatus in the initial sample was associated with a higher likelihood of a spontaneous shift to a more favorable profile. Conclusions: The vaginal microbiome is subject to strong fluctuations. Even an unfavorable microbiome profile can develop into a favorable microbiome profile within a few months without treatment.

Endometriosis, Pain, and Related Psychological Disorders: Unveiling the Interplay among the Microbiome, Inflammation, and Oxidative Stress as a Common Thread

Endometriosis (EM), a chronic condition in endometrial tissue outside the uterus, affects around 10% of reproductive-age women, significantly affecting fertility. Its prevalence remains elusive due to the surgical confirmation needed for diagnosis. Manifesting with a range of symptoms, including dysmenorrhea, dyschezia, dysuria, dyspareunia, fatigue, and gastrointestinal discomfort, EM significantly impairs quality of life due to severe chronic pelvic pain (CPP). Psychological manifestations, notably depression and anxiety, frequently accompany the physical symptoms, with CPP serving as a key mediator. Pain stems from endometrial lesions, involving oxidative stress, neuroinflammation, angiogenesis, and sensitization processes. Microbial dysbiosis appears to be crucial in the inflammatory mechanisms underlying EM and associated CPP, as well as psychological symptoms. In this scenario, dietary interventions and nutritional supplements could help manage EM symptoms by targeting inflammation, oxidative stress, and the microbiome. Our manuscript starts by delving into the complex relationship between EM pain and psychological comorbidities. It subsequently addresses the emerging roles of the microbiome, inflammation, and oxidative stress as common links among these abovementioned conditions. Furthermore, the review explores how dietary and nutritional interventions may influence the composition and function of the microbiome, reduce inflammation and oxidative stress, alleviate pain, and potentially affect EM-associated psychological disorders.

Correlation between hysteroscopic features and specific microbial species in women with chronic endometritis

Objective and rationale

Chronic endometritis (CE) has recently been associated with unexplained infertility and recurrent miscarriages. The current gold standard for CE detection is histopathological examination. However, office hysteroscopy and endometrial cultures are also significant, due to the possible link between CE and various microorganisms. Bacterial colonization of the endometrium has been associated with reduced success rates of in vitro fertilisation embryo transfer. Few studies have tried to correlate CE hysteroscopy findings with pathogenic microorganisms. This prospective cohort study sought to establish whether hysteroscopic diagnostic lesions correlate with specific microbial species.

Methods

The study encompassed women undergoing diagnostic tests for a range of subfertility health issues. 189 women completed the standard office diagnostic hysteroscopy (DH). 181 had also endometrial samples taken for microbial culture investigation. Correlation analysis (χ2 and Fisher's exact test) between hysteroscopic findings suggestive of CE and endometrial cultures was carried out. Logistic regression models were also fitted to measure whether a positive endometrial culture could affect CE conditions.

Results

A significant association of E. coli was observed between the hysteroscopically characterized CE + group with focal hyperplasia, when compared to the non-CE group. Logistic regression analysis revealed that women positive for E. coli were 4.423 times more likely to have focal endometrial hyperplasia. No other significant correlations were identified between DH and positive endometrial cultures.

Conclusions

The presence of E. coli in the endometrium was significantly correlated with focal hyperplasia findings from hysteroscopy, emphasizing the importance of microbial cultures in the diagnosis and targeted treatment of CE in women with subfertility.

Microbiome in Female Reproductive Health: Implications for Fertility and Assisted Reproductive Technologies

The microbiome plays a critical role in the process of conception and the outcomes of pregnancy. Disruptions in microbiome homeostasis in women of reproductive age can lead to various pregnancy complications, which significantly impact maternal and fetal health. Recent studies have associated the microbiome in the female reproductive tract (FRT) with assisted reproductive technology (ART) outcomes, and restoring microbiome balance has been shown to improve fertility in infertile couples. This review provides an overview of the role of the microbiome in female reproductive health, including its implications for pregnancy outcomes and ARTs. Additionally, recent advances in the use of microbial biomarkers as indicators of pregnancy disorders are summarized. A comprehensive understanding of the characteristics of the microbiome before and during pregnancy and its impact on reproductive health will greatly promote maternal and fetal health. Such knowledge can also contribute to the development of ARTs and microbiome-based interventions.

Culturomics in Unraveling the Upper Female Reproductive Tract Microbiota

In recent years, the study of the human microbiome has surged, shedding light on potential connections between microbiome composition and various diseases. One specific area of intense interest within this research is the female reproductive tract, as it holds the potential to influence the process of embryo implantation. Advanced sequencing technologies have delivered unprecedented insights into the microbial communities, also known as microbiota, residing in the female reproductive tract. However, their efficacy encounters significant challenges when analyzing low-biomass microbiota, such as those present in the endometrium. These molecular techniques are susceptible to contamination from laboratory reagents and extraction kits, leading to sequencing bias that can significantly alter the perceived taxonomy of a sample. Consequently, investigating the microbiota of the upper female reproductive tract necessitates the exploration of alternative methods. In this context, the current review delves into the application of culturomics in unraveling the upper female reproductive tract microbiota. While culturomics holds value in research, its transition to routine clinical practice appears remote, at least in the foreseeable future.

A Narrative Review Discussing the Obstetric Repercussions Due to Alterations of Personalized Bacterial Sites Developed within the Vagina, Cervix, and Endometrium

BACKGROUND

The reproductive tract microbiota that evolved as an integrative component has been studied intensively in the last decade. As a result, novel research, clinical opportunities, and perspectives have been derived following the close investigation of this microecological environment. This has paved the way for an update to and improvement of the management strategies and therapeutic approaches. However, obscurities, contradictions, and controversies arise regarding the ascension route from the vagina to the endometrium via the cervix, with finality in adverse obstetric outcomes.

METHODS

Starting from these considerations, we aimed to gather all existing data and information from four major academic databases (PubMed, ISI Web of Knowledge, Scopus, and ScienceDirect) published in the last 13 years (2010-2023) using a controlled vocabulary and dedicated terminology to enhance the coverage, identification, and sorting of potentially eligible studies.

RESULTS

Despite the high number of returned entries (n = 804), only a slight percentage (2.73%) of all manuscripts were deemed eligible following two rounds of evaluation. Cumulatively, a low level of Lactobacillus spp. and of other core microbiota members is mandatory, with a possible eubiosis-to-dysbiosis transition leading to an impairment of metabolic and endocrine network homeostasis. This transposes into a change in the pro-inflammatory landscape and activation of signaling pathways due to activity exerted by the bacterial lipopolysaccharides (LPSs)/endotoxins that further reflect a high risk of miscarriage in various stages. While the presence of some pathogenic entities may be suggestive of an adverse obstetric predisposition, there are still pros and cons of the role of specific strains, as only the vagina and cervix have been targeted as opposed to the endometrium, which recently started to be viewed as the key player in the vagina-cervix-endometrium route. Consequently, based on an individual's profile, diet, and regime, antibiotics and probiotics might be practical or not.

CONCLUSIONS

Resident bacteria have a dual facet and are beneficial for women's health, but, at the same time, relaying on the abundance, richness, and evenness that are definitory indexes standing as intermediaries of a miscarriage.

An Overview of the Microbiota of the Human Urinary Tract in Health and Disease: Current Issues and Perspectives

This article is intended to deepen our knowledge to date regarding the functions of the resident microbiota/microbiome in the urinary system for human health and disease. First, we sought to report the general characteristics (composition and stability) of the normal urinary system microbiota in the different anatomical sites in relation to some factors such as the effect of age, gender and diet, analyzing in detail the functions and the composition of the microbiota in the light of current knowledge. Several pieces of evidence suggest the importance of preserving the micro-ecosystem of the urinary system, and in some cases their relationship with diseases is important for maintaining human health is well understood. The female and male reproductive microbiota have mainly been studied over the past decade. In the past, the arrest was thought to have taken place in a sterile environment. Microorganisms of the microbiota form biofilms, three-dimensional structures, that differ in the reproductive organs and interact with both gametes and the embryo as well as with maternal tissues. These biofilms from the reproductive system also interact with others, such as that of the gastrointestinal tract. Reduction in its diversity intestinal microbiota can disrupt estrogen metabolism and affect the reproductive microbiota. It is therefore understood that its quantitative and qualitative identification is important for microbiota, but also the study of the structures formed by the microorganisms. A dysbiosis with local or systemic causes can lead to serious diseases. The role of probiotics in maintaining microbial population harmony (eubiosis) and preventing certain pathologies of the urinary and reproductive system was also investigated. A negative variation in the qualitative and quantitative composition of certain strains of microorganisms (dysbiosis) due to local or systemic causes can even lead to serious diseases. The role of probiotics in maintaining the healthy balance of microorganism populations (eubiosis), and thus in the prevention of certain pathologies of the urinary and reproductive system, has also been studied.

Vaginal microbes confounders and implications on women's health

The vagina has diverse vaginal microbes (Vm). A disturbance in the delicate balance maintained in Vm is linked to women's obstetrical and reproductive tract problems. Vaginal microbes play an essential role in protecting the health of the female reproductive tract by alleviating gynecological infection. However, Vm profiling has many confounders that need to be addressed during sampling, including age, race, pregnancy, medical illness, and smoking. Vm profiling improves reproduction odds, may serve as a marker for genital malignancies and have a therapeutic application in menopausal women and women with cervical cancers.

Characterization of the Ovine Vaginal Microbiome and Inflammation Patterns as an Improved Testing Model of Human Vaginal Irritation

The development of therapies targeted to improve the health of women has utilized direct vaginal delivery as a more effective and less toxic method of protection from HIV and other pathogens. Vaginal applicants and delivery devices that provide sustained effects have been met with increasing acceptability, but the efficacy and toxicity outcomes have not been successfully predicted by preclinical in vitro studies and animal modeling. We have explored the utilization of sheep as a model for testing the safety of vaginal applicants and devices based on spatial and structural similarities to the human vagina. As recently noted by the FDA, an additional safety measure is an impact on the vaginal microbiome (VMB) that is known to contribute to vaginal health and influence pathogen susceptibility and drug metabolism. To advance the utility of the sheep vaginal model, we completed a thorough molecular characterization of the ovine VMB utilizing both next-generation sequencing (NGS) and PCR methods. The process also created a custom PCR array to quantify ovine VMB community profiles in an affordable, higher throughput fashion. The results from vaginal swabs (>475 samples) collected from non-pregnant crossbred Dorset and Merino ewes treated with selected vaginal applicants or collected as sham samples established 16 VMB community types (VMB CTs). To associate VMB CTs with eubiosis or dysbiosis, we also completed custom ELISAs for six cytokines identifying IL1B, IL8, TNFa, and CXCL10 as useful markers to support the characterization of ovine vaginal inflammation. The results indicated that Pasteurella, Actinobacillus, Pseudomonas, Bacteroides, Leptotrichia, and E. coli were common markers of eubiosis (low inflammatory marker expression), and that Haemophilus, Ureaplasma, and Corynebacterium were associated with dysbiosis (high cytokine levels). Utilizing the optimized workflow, we also confirmed the utility of three commonly used vaginal applicants for impact on the VMB and inflammatory state, producing a dataset that supports the recommendation for the use of sheep for testing of vaginal applicants and devices as part of preclinical pipelines.

The role of gut and genital microbiota and the estrobolome in endometriosis, infertility and chronic pelvic pain

BACKGROUND

Endometriosis is a chronic, burdensome condition that is historically understudied. Consequently, there is a lack of understanding of the etiology of the disease and its associated symptoms, including infertility and chronic pelvic pain (CPP). Endometriosis development is influenced by estrogen metabolism and inflammation, which are modulated by several factors including the microbiome and the estrobolome (the collection of genes encoding estrogen-metabolizing enzymes in the gut microbiome). Therefore, there is increasing interest in understanding the role of microbiota in endometriosis etiology.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

To date, there is no cure for endometriosis and treatment options often are ineffective. This manuscript will review the potential relationship between the microbiome and endometriosis, infertility and CPP and highlight the available data on the microbiome in relation to endometriosis and its related symptoms. The overarching goal of this manuscript is to inform future microbiome research that will lead to a deeper understanding of the etiology of the disease and possible diagnostic modalities and treatments. The potential impact of the microbiome on estrogen regulation modulated by the estrobolome, as well as inflammation and other endometriosis-promoting mechanisms within the genital tract, will be reviewed. The methodological limitations of microbiome-related studies will be critically assessed to provide improved guidelines for future microbiome and clinical studies.

SEARCH METHODS

PubMed databases were searched using the following keywords: endometriosis AND microbiome, infertility AND microbiome, pelvic pain AND microbiome, IVF (in-vitro fertilization) AND microbiome, endometriosis AND infertility. Clinical and preclinical animal trials that were eligible for review, and related to microbiome and endometriosis, infertility or CPP were included. All available manuscripts were published in 2002-2021.

OUTCOMES

In total, 28 clinical and 6 animal studies were included in the review. In both human and animal studies, bacteria were enriched in endometriosis groups, although there was no clear consensus on specific microbiota compositions that were associated with endometriosis, and no studies included infertility or CPP with endometriosis. However, bacterial vaginosis-associated bacteria and Lactobacillus depletion in the cervicovaginal microbiome were associated with endometriosis and infertility in the majority (23/28) of studies. Interpretation of endometrial studies is limited owing to a variety of methodological factors, discussed in this review. In addition, metadata outlining antibiotic usage, age, race/ethnicity, menopausal status and timing of sample collection in relation to diagnosis of endometriosis was not consistently reported. Animal studies (6/6) support a bidirectional relationship between the gut microbiota and endometriosis onset and progression.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

There is evidence that a dysbiotic gut or genital microbiota is associated with multiple gynecologic conditions, with mounting data supporting an association between the microbiome and endometriosis and infertility. These microbiomes likely play a role in the gut-brain axis, which further supports a putative association with the spectrum of symptoms associated with endometriosis, including infertility and CPP. Collectively, this review highlights the demand for more rigorous and transparent methodology and controls, consistency across the field, and inclusion of key demographic and clinical characteristics of disease and comparison participants. Rigorous study designs will allow for a better understanding of the potential role of the microbiome in endometriosis etiology and the relationship to other disorders of the female reproductive tract.