Management of ranula: 9 years' clinical experience in pediatric and adult patients

Diagnostic Difficulties of Plunging Ranula: A Review of 18 Cases

OBJECTIVE(S)

Despite advancements in imaging techniques and cytological analysis, plunging ranula remains a challenging surgical, radiologic, and pathologic phenomenon. Of the 18 patients we evaluated at our institution, we highlight three cases that illustrate the high rate of misleading imaging and cytological results when assessing plunging ranula.

METHODS

Imaging results, biopsy findings, operative techniques, and pathological reports were reviewed from patients who had either a preoperative or postoperative diagnosis of ranula and underwent surgery by a single head and neck surgeon at a tertiary care center.

RESULTS

Of the 18 identified patients, computed tomography was correct on preoperative imaging 73% of the time and magnetic resonance imaging was correct on preoperative imaging 71% of the time. Two patients underwent preoperative ultrasound and their ultrasound reports did not accurately diagnose the presence of a ranula. Two patients underwent preoperative fine needle aspiration biopsy due to inconclusive preoperative imaging, in which results suggested either a ranula or epidermal cyst. Both ultimately did not match the final pathology. Three of eighteen patients (17%) underwent an inappropriate initial surgery due to incorrect imaging diagnoses and/or biopsy findings.

CONCLUSION

Despite use of preoperative modalities to distinguish plunging ranula from other cystic floor of mouth lesions, surgeons must be aware that no workup modality is fully precise. The potential for revision surgery must be included in all preoperative discussions for presumed plunging ranula.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 134:2689-2696, 2024.

Surgical Management of Huge Ranula Resembling Double Tongue in Pediatric Patients: A Successful Treatment of Two Cases

Ranula is a fluid collection in a pseudo cystic wall secondary to the damage of the sublingual salivary gland causing blockage of salivary flow, leading to the extravasation phenomena. The growth rate of ranula varies depending on its severity. Due to its tendency to recur, the gold standard management of ranula has yet to be decided. The authors described two cases of young girls with huge ranulas on the floor of the mouth (FOM) resembling double tongue, which caused pain and discomfort during mastication. Following surgical excision of the ranulas along with the affected sublingual glands, both cases demonstrated successful treatment outcomes with no recurrence observed during post-operative follow-up. These cases highlight the importance of surgical excision of ranulas and removal of affected sublingual glands to prevent recurrence.

New Conservative Approach for the Management of Recurrent Sublingual Ranula-A Case Report

Ranula is a rare and benign extravasation mucocele that is clinically characterized by asymptomatic sublingual or submandibular masses. Surgical excision is considered the most effective treatment approach, but it has been associated with high invasiveness and several complications (hemorrhage, damage to Wharton's duct, and lingual nerve injury). Over the past decade, more conservative therapies have been rapidly disseminated into clinical practice to seek a more effective and less traumatic approach for young patients. In this report, an 8-year-old female with an asymptomatic, recurrent sublingual ranula was treated using a conservative approach with marsupialization and an intracystic injection of a plaque remover (Hybenx^® gel). After incision of the cystic dome, Hybenx^® gel was applied into the cystic lumen for 20 seconds and then aspirated; next, the area was rinsed thoroughly with sterile saline solution before suturing. Ultrasound re-evaluation at 10 months and intraoral clinical examination at 24 months confirmed the absence of relapse. Our results support the hypothesis that marsupialization combined with intracystic injection of Hybenx^® gel could be an encouraging conservative treatment alternative for recurrent sublingual ranula in children. Further randomized controlled trials are needed to test this hypothesis.

The importance of sublingual gland removal in treatment of ranulas: A large retrospective study

PURPOSE

Investigate the efficacy of sublingual gland removal for the treatment of simple and plunging ranulas.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

After IRB approval, a retrospective review was performed on patients treated for a ranula from February 2013 to May 2018 at Texas Children's Hospital in Houston, TX. Clinical data was collected from medical records and patients were contacted in November 2018 to obtain additional information about recurrences or complications.

RESULTS

This study included 52 patients with ranulas (10 plunging, 42 simple; M:F 21:31) with a mean age of 9.68 years. Eighteen patients provided information in the extended follow-up period. Simple ranulas were treated with intraoral excision of the cyst and the sublingual gland (27 cases), marsupialization (7 cases), intraoral excision of the cyst alone (7 cases), and intraoral excision of the cystic component and subsequent marsupialization after recurrence (1 case); intraoral excision of the sublingual gland was not associated with any recurrence. Plunging ranulas were treated with intraoral excision of the cyst and/or sublingual gland (7 cases) or with a transcervical approach (3 cases). One patient was initially treated with sclerotherapy before undergoing intraoral excision of the sublingual gland. Two patients treated with transcervical excision of the cyst experienced recurrence compared to no recurrence with intraoral excision of the sublingual gland.

CONCLUSION

Intraoral removal of the sublingual gland is the most effective treatment for both simple and plunging ranulas. Plunging ranulas must be considered in patients presenting with a submandibular and submental cystic mass given intraoral extension may not be apparent.

The anatomical basis and rational for the transoral approach during the surgical excision of the sublingual salivary gland for the management of plunging ranula

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to illustrate and confirm that the complete intraoral excision of the sublingual gland alone, is anatomically the most rational approach, for the management of plunging ranula.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed clinical charts of diagnosed HIV-infected patients presenting with plunging ranula. The intraoral approach was used for the complete excision of the sublingual gland with evacuation of the pseudocystic content only. Neither extra oral approach, nor ranula dissection / drainage was performed. The surgical procedure was performed using local anesthesia. Pre- and postoperative MRI-scan investigations were recorded. Histological reports were documented to confirm the diagnosis of oral mucocele. Patients were clinically monitored.

RESULTS

We identified 90 adults presenting with oral mucocele, type ranula. Seventy (77%) of them were diagnosed with HIV infection. Plunging ranula was recorded in 35 (50%) patients from the latter group. The study enrolled 11 operated patients whose files contained useable data, including an acceptable follow-up period. The postoperative follow-up period ranged from three to 15 months. The clinical and postoperative MRI-scans of operated patients demonstrated satisfactory results. There were neither postoperative complications nor recurrence of ranula reported.

CONCLUSION

The location of the sublingual gland in the floor of the mouth coupled with the physio-pathogenesis of the plunging ranula, makes the transoral complete excision of the offending gland, with the intraoral evacuation of the pseudocyst, anatomically the most rational approach for plunging ranula management. There is no need for cervical approach, ranula dissection and/or postoperative placement of drainage.

Modified Micromarsupialization as Treatment of Ranula in a Pediatric Patient

Ranulas are mucoceles located on the floor of the mouth. The main form of treatment for these lesions is surgical excision, but this can lead to complications such as hemorrhage, recurrence of the lesion, and damage to the lingual nerve. Thus, other therapeutic modalities are indicated, such as modified micromarsupialization, which is a simple technique and not associated with recurrences, and without the need of a new intervention in the postoperative period. An 11-year-old female child, nonwhite, presented with bubble-shaped lesion located on floor of the mouth, on the left side, with exophytic growth, sessile base, bluish coloration, measuring about 4.0 cm in diameter, showing well-defined limits, well-delimited contours and borders, smooth surface, and softened consistency. Under the diagnostic hypothesis of the ranula, a modified micromarsupialization was performed. After 90 days of observation, complete regression and repair of the lesion were observed, without recurrence. Modified micromarsupialization is a simple therapeutic modality, low cost, and well-tolerated by the patient, mainly the pediatric one, being considered very effective in the treatment of lesions of difficult clinical management, as the ranula.

Percutaneous treatment of ranulas: ultrasound-guided drainage with salivary gland chemical ablation

BACKGROUND

Ranulas are salivary pseudocysts in the floor of the mouth adjacent to damaged salivary glands. Current surgical management is drainage of the ranula with removal of the offending gland. An analogous percutaneous procedure could potentially offer similar treatment efficacy in a more minimally invasive way.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the outcomes of a cohort of patients with ranulas treated with percutaneous ranula aspiration and chemical ablation of the source salivary gland to see whether this technique could be proposed as a minimally invasive treatment alternative.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This retrospective single-center study evaluated 24 patients treated percutaneously for ranulas between January 2004 and December 2014. All patients were treated with percutaneous ranula aspiration and chemical ablation of the offending salivary gland. Treatment success and any complications were recorded.

RESULTS

Complete ranula eradication was successfully accomplished in 87.5% of the patients with no complications.

CONCLUSION

Initial results suggest that our technique of percutaneous aspiration of ranulas and chemical ablation of the source salivary gland is safe and effective.

Sublingual gland excision for the surgical management of plunging ranula

OBJECTIVE

A plunging ranula is a pseudocystic collection of mucin extravasated from the sublingual gland into the floor of mouth and through the mylohyoid muscle into the neck. While the lining of a ranula is non-secreting and resection of the sublingual gland is adequate for simple sublingual mucoceles, many surgeons attempt to address plunging ranulas with extensive transoral and transcervical dissections. We review our experience managing plunging ranulas with intraoral sublingual gland excision and ranula drainage alone.

METHODS

This is a case series of patients with plunging ranulas who underwent transoral sublingual gland excision and ranula drainage in the past 10 years at the Massachusetts Eye and Ear. All ranulas were confirmed by radiographic imaging. Data were gathered from the medical record and telephone surveys.

RESULTS

Twenty-one patients with 22 distinct ranulas underwent this surgical approach. Average ranula size on imaging was 4.3 cm (SD = 1.3). Thirteen patients with 14 ranulas were followed up for greater than 6 months while the remaining 7 patients were lost to follow-up. Median follow-up for the 13 patients was 30 months (range 6 to 80). One ranula recurred requiring excision of residual sublingual gland (7%). One patient developed a local infection that was treated with antibiotics (7%). No long term complications were reported.

CONCLUSION

Simple transoral excision of the sublingual gland with ranula drainage is sufficient for treatment of plunging ranulas. It is essential to obtain a full resection of the gland to prevent relapse. This limited approach has low rates of complications and ranula recurrence.

Modern management of paediatric obstructive salivary disorders: long-term clinical experience

Recent technological improvements in head and neck field have changed diagnostic and therapeutic strategies for salivary disorders. Diagnosis is now based on colour Doppler ultrasonography (US), magnetic resonance (MR) sialography and cone beam 3D computed tomography (CT), and extra- and intracorporeal lithotripsy, interventional sialendscopy and sialendoscopy-assisted surgery are used as minimally invasive, conservative procedures for functional preservation of the affected gland. We evaluated the results of our long-term experience in the management of paediatric obstructive salivary disorders. The study involved a consecutive series of 66 children (38 females) whose obstructive salivary symptoms caused by juvenile recurrent parotitis (JRP) (n = 32), stones (n = 20), ranula (n = 9) and ductal stenosis (n = 5). 45 patients underwent interventional sialendoscopy for JRP, stones and stenoses, 12 a cycle of extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy (ESWL), three sialendoscopy-assisted transoral surgery, one drainage, six marsupialisation, and two suturing of a ranula. Three children underwent combined ESWL and interventional sialendoscopy, and seven a secondary procedure. An overall successful result was obtained in 90.9% of cases. None of the patients underwent traditional invasive sialadenectomy notwithstanding persistence of mild obstructive symptoms in six patients. No major complications were observed. Using a diagnostic work-up based on colour Doppler US, MR sialography and cone beam 3D TC, children with obstructive salivary disorders can be effectively treated in a modern minimally-invasive manner by extracorporeal and intracorporeal lithotripsy, interventional sialendoscopy and sialendoscopy-assisted transoral surgery; this approach guarantees a successful result in most patients, thus avoiding the need for invasive sialadenectomy while functionally preserving the gland.

Plunging Ranula: A Case Report

A plunging or diving ranula is a rare mucous fluid collection in the submandibular or parapharyngeal space resulting from damage or rupture of one or more ducts of the sublingual gland. The most common clinical presentation is a painless, slow-growing, pliable mass in the floor of the mouth, sometimes extending below the mandible through a defect in the mylohyoid muscle. This case report presents a young female patient who was suspected of having a plunging ranula. This case also highlights the role that sonography and other diagnostic tools play in the evaluation of this phenomenon.

A 17-year surgical experience of the intraoral approach for ranulas

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to analyze the clinical features and treatment outcomes in order to determine the optimal management of ranulas in our Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery department with long-term results.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A retrospective study was performed to evaluate patients with a final diagnosis of a simple or plunging ranula at Lille Teaching Hospital from May 2000 to January 2017. Clinical data on ranulas that were reviewed included gender, age, symptoms, location of the lesion, surgical procedures, complications, recurrence and follow-up.

RESULTS

The 26 patients included in the study comprised 18 males and 8 females, ranging from 3-months to 38 years of age. A total of 27 ranulas were managed: 25 oral ranula and 2 plunging ranulas. Twelve patients had undergone marsupialization (44.4%), 7 patients had complete excisions of the ranula (25.9%) or partial excisions combined with marsupialization (14.8%) and 4 patients (14.8%) had undergone excision of the sublingual gland (SLG). Seven ranulas recurred (25.9%). Not a single case recurred following the excision of the SLG. Treatments that included marsupialization were associated with the lowest recurrence rate (16.7%) after SLG excision, followed by combined marsupialization and ranula excision (25%) and by ranula excision alone (57%). There were no major complications.

DISCUSSION

Long-term outcomes confirm the different surgical procedures available in the outpatient clinic for the management of ranulas based on our surgical experience. Transoral resection of the SLG should be the optimal treatment, producing the lowest recurrence rate.

Ranula: Current Concept of Pathophysiologic Basis and Surgical Management Options

Background

There is no consensus opinion on a definitive surgical management option for ranulas to curtail recurrence, largely from the existing gap in knowledge on the pathophysiologic basis.

Aim

To highlight the current scientific basis of ranula development that informed the preferred surgical approach.

Design

Retrospective cohort study.

Setting

Public Tertiary Academic Health Institution.

Method

A 7-year 7-month study of ranulas surgically managed at our tertiary health institution was undertaken—June 1, 2008–December 31, 2015—from case files retrieved utilising the ICD-10 version 10 standard codes.

Results

Twelve cases, representing 0.4 and 1.2% of all institutional and ENT operations, respectively, were managed for ranulas with a M:F = 1:1. The ages ranged from 5/12 to 39 years, mean = 18.5 years, and the disease was prevalent in the third decade of life. Main presentation in the under-fives was related to airway and feeding compromise, while in adults, cosmetic facial appearance. Ranulas in adults were plunging (n = 8, 58.3%), left-sided save one with M:F = 2:1. All were unilateral with R:L = 1:2. Treatment included aspiration (n = 2, 16.7%) with 100% recurrence, intra-/extraoral excision of ranula only (n = 4, 33.3%) with recurrence rate of 50% (n = 2, 16.7%), while marsupialisation in children (n = 1, 8.3%) had no recurrence. Similarly, transcervical approach (n = 5, 41.7%) with excision of both the ranula/sublingual salivary gland recorded zero recurrence. Recurrence was the main complication (n = 4, 33.3%).

Conclusion

With the current knowledge on the pathophysiologic basis, extirpation of both the sublingual salivary gland and the ranula by a specialist surgeon is key for a successful outcome.

Plunging ranula - patient characteristics, treatment, and comparison between different populations

OBJECTIVES

To review our clinical experience and characteristics of Finnish patients with plunging ranula and compare our results with reports from other populations.

DESIGN

A retrospective study from the electronic hospital records between 2005 and 2016.

SETTING

The Department of Otorhinolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery of Helsinki University Hospital, Finland.

RESULTS

We describe the characteristics and treatment of 41 patients with MRI-confirmed plunging ranula. Most of our patients were young adults and 88% of them were male. Surgery and sclerotherapy were used for treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

The vast majority of Finnish plunging ranula patients in our cohort were male, suggesting significant population-related differences in plunging ranula gender distribution. Transoral surgery seemed to result in lowest recurrence rate and was the most common treatment in our clinic.

Plunging Ranula in Children: Case Report and Literature Review

Few cases of plunging ranulas (PRs) occur during childhood and the lesions are frequently misdiagnosed. Here, a PR in a child is reported along with a literature review. A seven-year-old female complaining of swelling in the midline neck, left-submandibular region, was evaluated. No oral cavity or major salivary glands abnormalities were detected. On palpation, a soft, painless, and fluid-containing mass was observed. The suspicion PR was performed by ultrasound. The diagnosis was confirmed with a histopathological examination. The lesion was removed with a cervical approach, without recurrence. PR is an uncommon condition in children under 10 years of age. Differential diagnosis depends on clinical examination and ultrasonography. A computed tomography-scan and magnetic resonance imaging can be performed if the diagnosis remains uncertain. In pediatrics, the key to success of the treatment may rely on the radical excision of the cyst and sublingual gland, via an intraoral or submandibular approach.

Are the patients with anatomic variation of the sublingual/Wharton's duct system predisposed to ranula formation?

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate ranula development according to anatomic variation of the ductal system of sublingual gland (SLG), especially the presence of Bartholin's duct.

METHODS

The anatomic variation of SLG duct was prospectively investigated and compared between 55 consecutive patients with ranulas treated by SLG excision (group 1) and another 15 consecutive patients undergoing similar surgeries for other conditions (group 2). The ductal structures of SLGs and submandibular glands (SMG) were also compared between the pediatric patients and adult patients with ranulas.

RESULTS

In 32 of 55 patients with ranulas (58.2%) and 1 of 15 patients without ranulas (6.7%), the SLG showed an anatomic variation of the main duct called Bartholin's duct structure (P<0.01). Seventeen of 22 (77.3%) pediatric patients with ranulas had Bartholin's ducts and 15 of 33 (45.5%) adult patients with ranulas had Bartholin's ducts (0.01<P<0.05), but Bartholin's duct which opens near to the orifice of Wharton's duct was not found in this study population. Plunging ranulas that extravasate deep to the mylohyoid were observed in the 6 patients (4 children and 2 adults). There was no recurrence in all cases with ranulas.

CONCLUSIONS

Congenital anatomic variation of the ductal system of the SLG might be a possible cause of ranulas in the patients with simple ranulas, especially in pediatric patients. Surgical resection of the SLG is a better treatment choice for ranulas than other conservative treatments.

What is new in management of pediatric ranula?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Ranula is extravasation mucocele arising from the sublingual gland, influencing the swallowing or eating; this review focuses on the most recent literature pertaining to pediatric ranulas and aims to comprehensively describe the methods of diagnosis and management approaches.

RECENT FINDINGS

Ranulas consist of intraoral ranula and plunging ranula, which are frequently misdiagnosed, so it is vital for the differential diagnosis of pediatric ranulas to depend on the clinical examination, imaging and fine-needle aspiration cytology. Pediatric patients should first be observed for 6 months before other treatments. OK-432 could activate inflammatory reaction to induce shrinkage of pediatric ranulas. Marsupialization, incision with drainage and ranula excision alone, are associated with a high rate of recurrence, even marsupialization with packing and modified micromarsupialization should be prudently applied for primary treatment of intraoral ranula. Laser excision is considered an alternative treatment for intraoral ranula of pediatric patients because of low recurrence rates and surgical complications. Recently, sublingual gland with or without ranula excision is a reasonable and suitable choice for radical treatment in pediatric patients.

SUMMARY

The principal goal of pediatric ranula management is radical sublingual gland excision, sealing the mucus extravasates and lowest complications.

Minimally invasive treatment of oral ranulae: adaption to an old technique

Oral ranulas are cysts in the floor of the mouth that result from the extravasation of mucous. Historically there has been little consensus on the ideal first-line treatment, but currently, definitive treatment involves excision of the sublingual gland, which can injure the lingual nerve and submandibular duct. Minimally invasive surgical alternatives such as marsupialisation have been proposed, but so far have been associated with a high rate of recurrence. The aim of this pilot study was to evaluate the success of a simple, modified suture technique for the treatment of oral ranulas that can be done in the outpatient department. We retrospectively analysed outcomes after the technique was used as a first-line treatment in 15 consecutive patients between 2011 and 2013. Although 2 attempts were needed in 4 patients, complete resolution of the ranula was seen in 13. Other than the need for a second attempt, and recurrent failure in 2 cases, there were no complications. This minimally invasive and quick procedure is a suitable first-line alternative to other less successful or higher risk options.

Symptomatic Floor-of-Mouth Swelling with Neck Extension in a 14-Year-Old Girl

A plunging ranula is a soft-tissue mass stemming from a mucous extravasation cyst of the sublingual gland which can herniate through the mylohyoid muscle. We describe a case in which a 14-year-old girl presented with a rapidly expanding mass on the floor of her mouth affecting her ability to swallow and speak and causing tracheal compression. The patient was initially managed conservatively with antibiotics and steroids; however, the mass continued to expand necessitating emergent bedside incision and drainage and subsequent surgical intervention. The pathophysiology and management options for ranulas are also discussed herein.

Salivary gland diseases in children

Salivary gland diseases in children are rare, apart from viral-induced diseases. Nevertheless, it is essential for the otolaryngologist to recognize these uncommon findings in children and adolescents and to diagnose and initiate the proper treatment.

The present work provides an overview of the entire spectrum of congenital and acquired diseases of the salivary glands in childhood and adolescence. The current literature was reviewed and the results discussed and summarized.

Besides congenital diseases of the salivary glands in children, the main etiologies of viral and bacterial infections, autoimmune diseases and tumors of the salivary glands were considered. In addition to the known facts, new developments in diagnostics, imaging and therapy, including sialendoscopy in obstructive diseases and chronic recurrent juvenile sialadenitis were taken into account. In addition, systemic causes of salivary gland swelling and the treatment of sialorrhoea were discussed. Although salivary gland diseases in children are usually included in the pathology of the adult, they differ in their incidence and some­times in their symptoms. Clinical diagnostics and especially the surgical treatment are influenced by a stringent indications and a less invasive strategy. Due to the rarity of tumors of the salivary glands in children, it is recommended to treat them in a specialized center with greater surgical experience.

Altogether the knowledge of the differential diagnoses in salivary gland diseases in children is important for otolaryngologists, to indicate the proper therapeutic approach.

Submental epidermoid cysts in children

Epidermoid cysts are lesions, which form as a result of implantation of the epidermis in the layers of the dermis or the mucous membrane. The lesions are rare in adults with 7% occurring in the head and neck area and most often located in the submental region. In children population submental epidermoid cysts are extremely rare. The differential diagnosis of the lesions is necessary as it affects the choice of treatment methods. Among the pathological conditions occurring in that region, salivary retention cyst (ranula), thyroglossal duct cyst, vascular lymphatic malformation (cystic hygroma), median neck cyst, lymphadenopathy, thyroid gland tumor, laryngeal cyst, epidermoid and dermoid cysts, submental abscess, sialolithiasis and salivary gland inflammation should be considered. The authors of the present report demonstrate two cases of submental epidermoid cysts in children. Differential diagnosis in case of suspected submental epidermoid cyst in a child with proposed clinical practice and literature review is provided.

Pediatric soft tissue oral lesions

This article provides an overview of common color changes and soft tissue oral nodular abnormalities in children and adolescents. The clinical presentation and treatment options to address these conditions are presented in a concise approach, highlighting key features relevant to the oral health care professional.