Enantioselective metabolomics by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

Advances in Chiral Metabolomic Profiling and Biomarker Discovery

Chiral metabolomics entails the enantioselective measurement of the metabolome present in a biological system. Over recent years, it has garnered significant interest for its potential in discovering disease biomarkers and aiding clinical diagnostics. D-Amino acids and D-hydroxy acids, traditionally overlooked as unnatural, are now emerging as novel signaling molecules and potential biomarkers for a range of metabolic disorders, brain diseases, kidney disease, diabetes, and cancer. Despite their significance, simultaneous measurements of multiple classes of chiral metabolites in a biological system remain challenging. Hence, limited information is available regarding the metabolic pathways responsible for synthesizing D-amino/hydroxy acid and their associated pathophysiological mechanisms in various diseases. Capitalizing on recent advancements in sensitive analytical techniques, researchers have developed various targeted chiral metabolomic methods for the analysis of chiral biomarkers. Here, we highlight the pivotal role of chiral metabolic profiling studies in disease diagnosis, prognosis, and therapeutic interventions. Furthermore, we describe cutting-edge chromatographic and mass spectrometry methods that enable enantioselective analysis of chiral metabolites. These advanced techniques are instrumental in unraveling the complexities of disease biomarkers, contributing to the ongoing efforts in disease biomarker discovery.

Targeted Chiral Metabolomics of D-Amino Acids: Their Emerging Role as Potential Biomarkers in Neurological Diseases with a Focus on Their Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Analysis upon Chiral Derivatization

In neuroscience research, chiral metabolomics is an emerging field, in which D-amino acids play an important role as potential biomarkers for neurological diseases. The targeted chiral analysis of the brain metabolome, employing liquid chromatography (LC) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS), is a pivotal approach for the identification of biomarkers for neurological diseases. This review provides an overview of D-amino acids in neurological diseases and of the state-of-the-art strategies for the enantioselective analysis of chiral amino acids (AAs) in biological samples to investigate their putative role as biomarkers for neurological diseases. Fluctuations in D-amino acids (D-AAs) levels can be related to the pathology of neurological diseases, for example, through their role in the modulation of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors and neurotransmission. Because of the trace presence of these biomolecules in mammals and the complex nature of biological matrices, highly sensitive and selective analytical methods are essential. Derivatization strategies with chiral reagents are highlighted as critical tools for enhancing detection capabilities. The latest advances in chiral derivatization reactions, coupled to LC-MS/MS analysis, have improved the enantioselective quantification of these AAs and allow the separation of several chiral metabolites in a single analytical run. The enhanced performances of these methods can provide an accurate correlation between specific D-AA profiles and disease states, allowing for a better understanding of neurological diseases and drug effects on the brain.

Simultaneous Quantification of Carboxylate Enantiomers in Multiple Human Matrices with the Hydrazide-Assisted Ultrahigh-Performance Liquid Chromatography Coupled with Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Many chiral carboxylic acids with α-amino, α-hydroxyl, and α-methyl groups are concurrently present in mammals establishing unique molecular phenotypes and multiple biological functions, especially host-microbiota symbiotic interactions. Their chirality-resolved simultaneous quantification is essential to reveal the biochemical details of physiology and pathophysiology, though challenging with their low abundances in some biological matrices and difficulty in enantiomer resolution. Here, we developed a method of the chirality-resolved metabolomics with sensitivity-enhanced quantitation via probe-promotion (Met-SeqPro) for analyzing these chiral carboxylic acids. We designed and synthesized a hydrazide-based novel chiral probe, (S)-benzoyl-proline-hydrazide (SBPH), to convert carboxylic acids into amide diastereomers to enhance their retention and chiral resolution on common C18 columns. Using the d5-SBPH-labeled enantiomers as internal standards, we then developed an optimized ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography with tandem mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS/MS) method for simultaneous quantification of 60 enantiomers of 30 chiral carboxylic acids in one run. This enantiomer-resolved method showed excellent sensitivity (LOD < 4 fmol-on-column), linearity (R2 > 0.992), precision (CV < 15%), accuracy (|RE| < 20%), and recovery (80-120%) in multiple biological matrices. With the method, we then quantified 60 chiral carboxylic acids in human urine, plasma, feces, and A549 cells to define their metabolomic phenotypes. This provides basic data for human phenomics and a promising tool for investigating the mammal-microbiome symbiotic interactions.

Evaluation of Individual Variation of d-Amino Acids in Human Plasma by a Two-Dimensional LC-MS/MS System and Application to the Early Diagnosis of Chronic Kidney Disease

For the discovery of sensitive biomarkers of kidney function focusing on chiral amino acids, a multiple heart-cutting two-dimensional (2D) liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS)/MS system has been designed/developed. As the target analytes, alanine (Ala), aspartic acid, glutamic acid (Glu), leucine (Leu), lysine, methionine, phenylalanine (Phe), proline (Pro), serine (Ser), and valine were selected considering the presence of their d-forms in mammals. The 2D LC-MS/MS system consisted of the nonenantioselective reversed-phase separation of the target amino acids, the separations of the d- and l-enantiomers, and detection using MS/MS. Using the method, the plasma chiral amino acids, precolumn derivatized with 4-fluoro-7-nitro-2,1,3-benzoxadiazole, were isolated from other intrinsic substances, then determined without losing sensitivity by the fully automated whole-peak volume transfer operation from first to second dimension. In all of the tested plasma samples obtained from five healthy individuals and 15 patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD), the target chiral amino acids were determined without interference. In healthy individuals, the levels of all the tested d-amino acids were regulated in the low ranges. In contrast, the % d values of Glu, Leu, and Phe significantly increased with the progress of kidney dysfunction, besides the previously reported values of d-Ala, Pro, and Ser. Concerning Phe, the significant increase of the % d values (p < 0.05) was reported for the first time even in the mild CKD group compared to those of the healthy group; d-Phe might be a more sensitive marker than the previously reported d-forms. These results demonstrated the potential of these d-forms as the sensitive biomarkers of kidney function for the early diagnosis of CKD.

Enantioselective Reduction of Noncovalent Complexes of Amino Acids with CuII via Resonant Collision-Induced Dissociation: Collision Energy, Activation Duration Effects, and RRKM Modeling

Formation of noncovalent complexes is one of the approaches to perform chiral analysis with mass spectrometry. Enantiomeric distinction of amino acids (AAs) based on the relative rate constants of competitive fragmentations of quaternary copper complexes is an efficient method for chiral differentiation. Here, we studied the complex [CuII,(Phe,PhG,Pro-H)]+ (m/z 493) under resonant collision-induced dissociation conditions while varying the activation time. The precursor ion can yield two main fragments through the loss of the non-natural AA phenylglycine (PhG): the expected product ion [CuII,(Phe,Pro-H)]+ (m/z 342) and the reduced product ion [CuI,(Phe,Pro)]+ (m/z 343). Enantioselective reduction describes the difference in relative abundance of these ions, which depends on the chirality of the precursor ion: the formation of the reduced ion m/z 343 is favored in homochiral complexes (DDD) compared to heterochiral complexes (such as LDD). Energy-resolved mass spectrometry data show that reduction, which arises from rearrangement, is favored at a low collision energy (CE) and long activation time (ActT), whereas direct cleavage preferentially occurs at a high CE and short ActT. These results were confirmed with kinetic modeling based on RRKM theory. For this modeling, it was necessary to set a pre-exponential factor as a reference, so that the E0 values obtained are relative values. Interestingly, these simulations showed that the critical energy E0 required to form the reduced ion is comparable in both homochiral and heterochiral complexes. However, the formation of product ion m/z 342 through direct cleavage is associated with a lower E0 in heterochiral complexes. Consequently, enantioselectivity would not be caused by enhanced reduction in homochiral complexes but rather by direct cleavage being favored in heterochiral complexes.

Three-Minute Enantioselective Amino Acid Analysis by Ultra-High-Performance Liquid Chromatography Drift Tube Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry Using a Chiral Core-Shell Tandem Column Approach

Fast liquid chromatography (LC) amino acid enantiomer separation of 6-aminoquinolyl-N-hydroxysuccinimidyl carbamate (AQC) derivatives using a chiral core-shell particle tandem column with weak anion exchange and zwitterionic-type quinine carbamate selectors in less than 3 min was achieved. Enantiomers of all AQC-derivatized proteinogenic amino acids and some isomeric ones (24 in total plus achiral glycine) were baseline separated (Rs > 1.5 except for glutamic acid with Rs = 1.3), while peaks of distinct amino acids and structural isomers (constitutional isomers and diastereomers of leucine and threonine) of the same configuration overlapped to various degrees. For this reason, drift tube ion mobility-mass spectrometry was added (i.e., LC-IM-MS) as an additional selectivity filter without extending run time. The IM separation dimension in combination with high-resolution demultiplexing enabled confirmation of threonine isomers (threonine, allo-threonine, homoserine), while leucine, isoleucine, and allo-isoleucine have almost identical collisional cross-section (DTCCSN2) values and added no selectivity to the partial LC separation. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations show that IM separation of threonine isomers was possible due to conformational stabilization by hydrogen bond formation between the hydroxyl side chain and the urea group. Generally, the CCSN2 of protonated ions increased uniformly with addition of the AQC label, while outliers could be explained by consideration of intramolecular interactions and additional structural analysis. Preliminary validation of the enantioselective LC-IM-MS method for quantitative analysis showed compliance of accuracy and precision with common limits in bioanalytical methods, and applicability to a natural lipopeptide and a therapeutic synthetic peptide could be demonstrated.

Unravelling the brain metabolome: A review of liquid chromatography - mass spectrometry strategies for extracellular brain metabolomics

The analysis of the brain extracellular metabolome is of interest for numerous subdomains within neuroscience. Not only does it provide information about normal physiological functions, it is even more of interest for biomarker discovery and target discovery in disease. The extracellular analysis of the brain is particularly interesting as it provides information about the release of mediators in the brain extracellular fluid to look at cellular signaling and metabolic pathways through the release, diffusion and re-uptake of neurochemicals. In vivo samples are obtained through microdialysis, cerebral open-flow microperfusion or solid-phase microextraction. The analytes of potential interest are typically low in concentration and can have a wide range of physicochemical properties. Liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry has proven its usefulness in brain metabolomics. It allows sensitive and specific analysis of low sample volumes, obtained through different approaches. Several strategies for the analysis of the extracellular fluid have been proposed. The most widely used approaches apply sample derivatization, specific stationary phases and/or hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography. Miniaturization of these methods allows an even higher sensitivity. The development of chiral metabolomics is indispensable, as it allows to compare the enantiomeric ratio of compounds and provides even more challenges. Some limitations continue to exist for the previously developed methods and the development of new, more sensitive methods remains needed. This review provides an overview of the methods developed for sampling and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis of the extracellular metabolome.

Insight into the differences of meat quality between Qinghai white Tibetan sheep and black Tibetan sheep from the perspective of metabolomics and rumen microbiota

The purpose of this study was to investigate the differences in meat quality between two local breeds of Tibetan sheep, the White Tibetan sheep and the Black Tibetan sheep in Qinghai, and to search for metabolic mechanisms that produce meat quality differences by analyzing differential metabolites and key rumen microorganisms. The meat quality results showed that one breed, SG73, was superior to the other (WG). Further investigation identified differences in the composition of muscle metabolites and rumen microorganisms between the two Tibetan sheep breeds. It also regulates muscle tenderness, water retention, fat content and the composition and content of AA and FA through two major metabolic pathways, AA metabolism and carbohydrate metabolism. These findings could be beneficial for the development of breeding strategies for Tibetan sheep in Qinghai in the future.

Automated sample preparation with 6-Aminoquinolyl-N-hydroxysuccinimidyl carbamate and iodoacetamide derivatization reagents for enantioselective liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry amino acid analysis

Enantioselective amino acid analysis is gaining increasing importance in pharmaceutical, biomedical and food sciences. While there are many methods available for enantiomer separation of amino acids, the simultaneous analysis of all chiral proteinogenic amino acids by a single method with one column and a single condition is still challenging. Herein, we report an enantioselective high-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS) assay using Chiralpak QN-AX as chiral column. With 6-aminoquinolyl-N-hydrosysuccinimidyl carbamate (AQC) as derivatization reagent, efficient enantioselective separation of D- and L-amino acids using HPLC has become possible. Thiol-containing amino acids like Cys are alkylated prior to AQC-labelling. A protocol for automated sample preparation including both derivatization step and calibrator preparation is presented. For compensating matrix effects, u-13C15N-labelled internal standards (IS) were employed. The method was validated and applied to the enantioselective analysis of amino acids in a bacterial fermentation broth.

Simultaneous measurement of amino acid enantiomers in the serum of late-life depression patients using convenient LC–MS/MS method with Nα-(5-fluoro-2,4-dinitrophenyl)-l-leucinamide Derivatization

D-amino acids may be indicators of late-life depression but separation and quantification of enantiomers which differ only by optical rotation sign remain challenging due to their identical physical and chemical properties. A convenient LC-MS/MS method was developed for the simultaneous measurement of l- and d-amino acids based on the chiral derivatization reagent, N^α-(5-fluoro-2,4-dinitrophenyl)-L-leucinamide, and conventional octadecylsilane reversed-phase column. Methanol was used as the extraction solvent and a single-step derivatization reaction using volatile triethylamine eliminated the requirement for desalination prior to LC-MS/MS. Simultaneous separation and identification of 21 amino acids and the enantiomeric compositions of the 18 chiral proteogenic entities were achieved. Low limits of detection (0.03-4.0 nM), wide linear range (0.01-20 μM), good precision (RSDs < 10 %) and negligible matrix effects indicated the suitability of the method. Application of the method to the quantification of serum chiral amino acids in late-life depression patients (n = 40) and controls (n = 35) found a total of 17 L-amino acids, 14 D-amino acids, DL-asparagine, glycine and γ-aminobutyric acid. The statistical evaluation showed significant differences of glycine, L-threonine and D-methionine between late-life depression patients and controls, indicating that these are potential biomarkers of late-life depression.

A Facile and High-Sensitivity Method for Determining Proteinogenic Amino Acid Enantiomers by Integrating Chiral Phosphinate Derivatizing, 31P NMR and Parallel Reaction Monitoring

Here, we have documented a new protocol to determine d/l-amino acids by derivatizing amino acids via a chiral phosphinate. (R_P)-l-Menthyl phenylphosphinate was able to bond both primary and secondary amines, as well as improve the sensitivity of analytes in MS. Eighteen pairs of amino acids were successfully labeled except for Cys which has a thiol group on the side chain, and the chirality of amino acids can be discriminated by ³¹P NMR. Seventeen pairs of amino acids were separated by a C18 column within 45 min of elution, and resolution values ranged from 2.01 to 10.76. The lowest limit of detection was 10 pM acquired at parallel reaction monitoring, in which two factors collectively contributed that the ability of protonation of phosphine oxide and the sensitivity of parallel reaction monitoring. Chiral phosphine oxides might be a promising tool in future chiral metabolomics.

Comprehensive Online Reversed-Phase × Chiral Two-Dimensional Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry with Data-Independent Sequential Window Acquisition of All Theoretical Fragment-Ion Spectra-Acquisition for Untargeted Enantioselective Amino Acid Analysis

This work presents an advanced analytical platform for untargeted enantioselective amino acid analysis (eAAA) by comprehensive achiral × chiral 2D-LC hyphenated to ESI-QTOF-MS/MS utilizing data-independent SWATH (sequential window acquisition of all theoretical fragment-ion spectra) technology. The methodology involves N-terminal pre-column derivatization with 6-aminoquinolyl-N-hydroxysuccinimidyl carbamate (AQC; AccQ) as retention, selectivity, and MS tag, supporting retention and UV detection in RPLC (¹D), chiral recognition, and thus enantioselectivity by the core-shell tandem column composed of a quinine carbamate weak anion exchanger (QN-AX) and a zwitterionic chiral ion-exchanger (ZWIX(+)) (²D) as well as the ionization efficiency during positive electrospray ionization due to a high proton affinity of the AQC label. Furthermore, the urea-type MS tag gives rise to the generation of AQC-tag characteristic signature fragments in MS². The latter allows the chemoselective mass spectrometric filtering of targeted and untargeted N-derivatized amino acids or related labeled species. The chiral core-shell tandem column provides a complete enantioselective amino acid profile of all proteinogenic amino acids within 1 min, with full baseline separation of all enantiomers, but without resolution of isomeric Ile/allo-Ile (aIle)/Leu, which can be resolved by RPLC. The entire LC × LC separation occurs within a total run time of 60 min (¹D), with the chiral ²D operated in gradient elution mode and a cycle time of 60 s. A strategy to mine the 2D-LC-SWATH data is presented and demonstrated for the qualitative eAAA of two peptide hydrolysate samples of therapeutic peptides containing common and uncommon as well as primary and secondary amino acids. Absolute configuration assignment of amino acids using template matching for all proteinogenic amino acids was made feasible due to method robustness and the inclusion of an isotopically labeled L-[U-¹³C¹⁵N]-AA standard. The quantification performance of this LC × LC-MS/MS assay was also evaluated. Accuracies were acceptable for the majority of AAs enabling AA composition determination in peptide hydrolysates simultaneously with configuration assignment, as exemplified by oxytocin. This methodology represents a step toward truly untargeted 2D enantioselective amino acid analysis and metabolomics.

Indirect Enantioseparations: Recent Advances in Chiral Metabolomics for Biomedical Research

Chiral metabolomics is starting to become a well-defined research field, powered by the recent advances in separation techniques. This review aimed to cover the most relevant advances in indirect enantioseparations of endogenous metabolites that were published over the last 10 years, including improvements and development of new chiral derivatizing agents, along with advances in separation methodologies. Moreover, special emphasis is put on exciting advances in separation techniques combined with mass spectrometry, such as chiral discrimination by ion-mobility mass spectrometry together with untargeted strategies for profiling of chiral metabolites in complex matrices. These advances signify a leap in chiral metabolomics technologies that will surely offer a solid base to better understand the specific roles of enantiomeric metabolites in systems biology.