Can cardiologists distinguish innocent from pathologic murmurs in neonates?

Major congenital heart defects are rarely diagnosed after newborns' hospital discharge with modern screening

AIM

Our aim was to assess undiagnosed congenital heart defects (CHD) after newborns' hospital discharge in patients with a murmur or CHD suspicion, to find out the signs that predict CHDs and to estimate the costs of the examinations.

METHODS

We reviewed retrospective medical records of patients (n = 490) referred for the evaluation of CHD suspicion during 2017-2018.

RESULTS

The median age of the patients was 2.5 (IQR 0.5-7.4) years. Sixty-three (13%) patients had an abnormal echocardiography. Neither ductal-dependent nor cyanotic CHDs were found. Cardiac interventions were performed for 14 out of 63 (22%) patients. Clinical signs indicating CHDs were murmur grade ≥3 (10/11 [91%] vs. 53/479 [11%], p < 0.001) and harsh murmur (15/44 [34%] vs. 48/446 [11%], p < 0.001). Abnormal electrocardiography did not indicate CHD (8/40 [20%] vs. 55/447 [12%], p = 0.165). The total cost of the examinations was 259 700€. The share of the cost of studies assessed as benign was 59%.

CONCLUSION

Only a few CHDs were found after newborn hospital discharge among patients who received foetal and newborn screening and were examined due to CHD suspicion. The high number of benign murmurs in children leads to many referrals, resulting in unnecessary healthcare costs.

Anxiety levels in parents of asymptomatic neonates and young infants referred for echocardiography

INTRODUCTION

Previous studies in children with innocent murmurs have shown that parental concern is common.

METHODS

We assessed the anxiety levels among parents of asymptomatic neonates or infants up-to 6 weeks referred for cardiologic consultation because of a heart murmur. A six-item short-form of the state scale of the Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) was completed by the parents before and after consultation.

RESULTS

The average STAI score decreased from 14.42 ± 4.54 on arrival to 9.69 ± 4.26 after the consultation (p < 0.001). Overall, the parents felt more calm, less tense, less upset, more relaxed, more content and less worried after the consultation (p < 0.001). Multivariable linear regression analysis showed that the STAI score prior to consultation was related to infants age (coefficient β = - 0.172; P = 0.046) and STAI score post consultation was related to the final diagnosis (β = 0.312; P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, parents of asymptomatic neonates and young infants with a murmur exhibit moderate levels of anxiety which can be ameliorated after consultation. Parental education in the field is of paramount importance and the role of both paediatric cardiologists as well as primary care physicians is crucial and decisive.

Precordial ECG Amplitudes in the Days After Birth: Electrocardiographic Changes During Transition from Fetal to Neonatal Circulation

During the first month of life, the relation between right and left ventricular function is markedly altered. We aimed at describing the electrocardiographic transition from fetal to neonatal circulation by investigating changes in R- and S-wave amplitudes in V1 and V6 during the first 4 weeks of life. This study is part of the prospective, population-based Copenhagen Baby Heart Study offering cardiac evaluation to newborns within 28 days from birth. ECGs were obtained and analyzed using a computerized algorithm. A total of 14,577 newborns (52% boys), median age of 11.0 days, were included. All had normal echocardiograms. Within 28 days from birth, the amplitudes in V1 decreased: R-V1 (1262 µV day0; 947 µV day28, p < 0.001) and S-V1 (1240 µV day0; 473 µV day28, p < 0.001). An increase was observed for R-V6 (825 µV day0; 1196 µV day28, p = 0.002), while S-V6 decreased (830 µV day0; 634 µV day28, p = 0.003). For all amplitudes, interindividual variation was large (up to 20 times). The amplitudes were not affected by sex (p > 0.05), but R-V1, R-V6, and S-V6 positively correlated with newborn weight (p < 0.01). R-V1 and S-V6 showed positive correlation with gestational age (p < 0.05). In conclusion, systematic analyses of ECGs from healthy newborns showed significant decreases in R-V1, S-V1, and S-V6 amplitudes, while R-V6 increased. Interindividual variation was large, making ECGs unlikely as a sensitive tool for diagnosing congenital heart diseases. Our data may serve as updated, digitalized reference values in newborns.

Congenital heart disease diagnosed with echocardiogram in newborns with asymptomatic cardiac murmurs: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

More than 50% of newborns with congenital heart disease (CHD) are unrecognized at birth; however, the use of echocardiogram (Echo) for diagnosing CHD in newborns with asymptomatic, non-syndromic cardiac murmurs (ANCM), has not been systematically reviewed yet. We aimed to identify the incidence of CHD diagnosed with Echo and systematically review whether Echo should be recommended in this patient group.

METHODS

The methodology utilized in this systematic review adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses framework. Using the MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library databases, we performed a systematic review of publications reporting CHD diagnosed with Echo in newborns with cardiac murmurs. The quality of the included studies was evaluated using the Study Quality Assessment Tools developed by the National Institutes of Health.

RESULTS

Of the 630 studies screened, six cohort studies, four cross-sectional studies, and two case reports were included in this review. The incidence of cardiac murmurs ranged from 0.6-8.6%. Among the 1928 newborns with ANCM, 719 (37.3%) were diagnosed with Echo as having CHD, and ventricular septal defect was the most common congenital malformation. More than 50% of the newborns showed moderate CHD necessitating outpatient cardiology follow-up, and 2.5% had severe CHD requiring immediate interventions, such as cardiac catheterization and heart surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

In this systematic review, a high incidence of CHD in newborns with ANCM was detected using Echo. This indicates that the use of Echo for diagnosing CHD in healthy newborns with cardiac murmurs could be helpful in earlier detection of CHD, thereby improving clinical outcomes for newborns with severe CHD.

Accuracy of cardiac auscultation in detection of neonatal congenital heart disease by general paediatricians

BACKGROUND

Challenges remain in the judgement of pathological murmurs in newborns at maternity hospitals, and there are still many simple major CHD patients in developing countries who are not diagnosed in a timely fashion. This study aimed to evaluate the accuracy of cardiac auscultation on neonatal CHD by general paediatricians.

METHODS

We conducted a prospective study at three hospitals. All asymptomatic newborns underwent auscultation, pulse oximetry monitoring, and echocardiography. Major CHD was classified and confirmed through follow-up. We evaluated the accuracy of various degrees of murmurs for detecting major CHD to determine the most appropriate standards and time of auscultation.

RESULTS

A total of 6750 newborns were included. The median age of auscultation was 43 hours. Cardiac murmurs were identified in 6.6% of newborns. For all CHD, 44.4% had varying degrees of murmurs. A murmur of grade ≥2 used as a reference standard for major CHD had a sensitivity of 89.58%. The false positive rate of murmurs of grade ≥2 for detecting major CHD was significantly negatively related to auscultation time, with 84.4% of false positives requiring follow-up for non-major CHD cardiac issues. Auscultation after 27 hours of life could reduce the false positive rate of major CHD from 2.7 to 0.9%.

CONCLUSIONS

With appropriate training, maternity hospital's paediatricians can detect major CHD with high detection rates with an acceptable false positive rate.

Does Echocardiography Have a Role in the Cardiologist's Diagnosis of Innocent Murmurs in Childhood?

BACKGROUND

Innocent murmurs are common in childhood. Echocardiography may diagnose almost all congenital cardiac abnormalities. Earlier studies have suggested that it may be unnecessary when a clinical diagnosis of an innocent murmur is made by an experienced cardiologist. Yet, echocardiography is commonly performed despite such a diagnosis. Is that justifiable?

METHODS

Patients referred to a paediatric cardiologist for evaluation of a murmur were assessed. If an innocent murmur was clinically diagnosed, an echocardiogram and an electrocardiogram were ordered when requested. The cardiologist completed a questionnaire documenting the reasons for the investigations and his degree of confidence in the clinical diagnosis. The parents and patients were informed of the diagnosis and the results of the investigations.

RESULTS

In almost all 62 cases whose murmurs were clinically considered to be innocent, the referring doctor expected an echocardiogram to be performed. Following echocardiography, one patient was found to have a small muscular ventricular septal defect. On review, the murmur was consistent with that diagnosis. Three (3) others had abnormal echocardiograms namely congenitally corrected transposition of great arteries, partial anomalous right upper lobe pulmonary vein, and left ventricular non-compaction. All on review were still considered clinically to have innocent murmurs.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the competency of the cardiologist, echocardiography diagnosed important but relatively uncommon cardiac abnormalities with prognostic implications that would have been missed if only the clinical examination was performed. Over and above the referring doctor's expectations for an echocardiogram to be performed is the need for the cardiologist to provide a complete and definitive diagnosis.

Cardiac Murmurs in Children: A Challenge For The Primary Care Physician

Congenital heart disease is present in almost 1% of live births and despite current progress in prenatal screening a significant percentage has delayed diagnosis or remain undiagnosed. A cardiac murmur may be the first or unique clinical sign of congenital heart disease in childhood, however, less than 1% of auscultated murmurs are of an organic cause. Distinguishing between an innocent and a pathologic murmur can be challenging and the experience of the examiner is crucial for identifying the distinctive properties of an innocent murmur. Timely diagnosis of underlying cardiovascular pathology is of great significance so that prompt management is provided and morbidity or mortality are restricted. Of similar importance is the avoidance of unnecessary anxiety for the parents and unreasonable referrals to Paediatric Cardiologists. Indications for referral include a medical history suggestive of a cardiac abnormality, such as the presence of relevant symptoms, the identification of abnormal findings on clinical examination, auscultatory findings suggestive of an organic murmur, and very young patient age. ECG and a chest X-ray are not usually part of the diagnostic approach of a child with a cardiac murmur, as they do not increase the success rate of diagnosing heart disease, as compared to a detailed medical history accompanied by a thorough physical examination. In conclusion, the recognition of suspicious distinctive features of cardiac murmurs is crucial and requires skills based on sufficient training and experience.

Heart murmurs and echocardiography findings in the normal newborn nursery

OBJECTIVE

To determine the clinical findings and management implications of echocardiograms performed on infants with murmurs in the nursery.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study conducted from January 2008 through December 2015. Patients in the study were followed by chart review for up to 5 years. In addition, a survey of nursery providers was conducted in February 2016.

SETTING

A single community hospital associated with a university.

PATIENTS

All 26 573 infants who received care in the normal newborn nursery were eligible for inclusion in the study. Infants with echocardiograms were analyzed. The survey was sent by e-mail to all 135 physicians who work in the nursery.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcomes include the specific findings on echocardiogram and whether the findings required an acute change in management, outpatient follow up, or were incidental findings. The primary survey question was how physicians would manage an otherwise asymptomatic newborn with a heart murmur.

RESULTS

Four hundred ninety-nine infants had echocardiograms, and over the study period the utilization of echocardiography increased from 1.02% to 2.56% (P < .001) of all infants. Three hundred fifty-four babies had echocardiography performed because of a heart murmur. One hundred sixty-three (46.0%) of these echocardiograms were normal and 160 (45.2%) had findings that did not require additional care. Twenty-three neonates (6.5%) had echocardiographic findings that necessitated outpatient follow-up and 8 neonates (2.3%) required neonatal intensive care due to the findings on their echocardiogram. In total, 14 infants (4%) would go on to require heart surgery or interventional cardiac catheterization. 63/135 (47%) physicians completed the survey, with wide variations in the management of newborns with heart murmurs.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of echocardiography in the normal newborn nursery has increased with time despite improved prenatal detection of heart disease and the use of pulse oximetry screening, and identifies significant heart disease in a small but important number of infants.

Managing a "New" Murmur in Healthy Children and Teens

An asymptomatic child with a murmur can be challenging practice management conundrum. Some providers refer all patients with a "new" murmur to a cardiologist, likely resulting in excessive resource utilization and parental anxiety. This study examines whether the prevalence of significant cardiac pathology differs in asymptomatic patients aged 2 to 18 years who were referred for a murmur that was "new" versus those referred for a murmur that was known to exist and followed conservatively during the previous 2 years. Of 473 patients meeting inclusion criteria, 33/473 (7.0%) were diagnosed with cardiac pathology, with 21/357 (5.9%) occurring among "new" murmur referrals and 12/116 (10.3%) occurring among "known" murmur referrals. Notably, 34/357 (9.5%) patients referred for a "new" murmur had no murmur present when assessed by the cardiologist. This study suggests that asymptomatic children with a "new" murmur may be conservatively managed. This may lessen health care resource utilization rates and overall parental anxiety.

Outpatient echocardiography in the evaluation of innocent murmurs in children: utilisation benchmarking

OBJECTIVES

We sought to benchmark the utilisation of echocardiography in the outpatient evaluation of heart murmurs by evaluating two large paediatric cardiology centres.

BACKGROUND

Although criteria exist for appropriate use of echocardiography, there are no benchmarking data demonstrating its utilisation.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective cohort study of outpatients aged between 0 and 18 years at the Sibley Heart Center Cardiology and the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Division of Cardiology, given a sole diagnosis of "innocent murmur" from 1 July, 2007 to 31 October, 2010. Using internal claims data, we compared the utilisation of echocardiography according to centre, patient age, and physician years of service.

RESULTS

Of 23,114 eligible patients (Sibley Heart Center Cardiology: 12,815, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Division of Cardiology: 10,299), 43.1% (Sibley Heart Center Cardiology: 45.2%, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Division of Cardiology: 40.4%; p1-5 years had the lowest utilisation (32.7%).

CONCLUSIONS

In two large paediatric cardiology practices, the overall utilisation of echocardiography by physicians with a sole diagnosis of innocent murmur was similar. There was significant and similar variability in utilisation by provider at both centres. Although these data serve as initial benchmarking, the variability in utilisation highlights the importance of appropriate use criteria.

The Critically Ill Infant with Congenital Heart Disease

This article presents an approach for identification of infants with congenital heart disorders. These disorders are difficult to diagnose because of the complexity and variety of cardiac malformations; additionally presentation can be complicated by age-dependent physiology. By compiling data from the history and the physical examination, the emergency physician can identify lesion category and initiate stabilization procedures. Critical congenital cardiac lesions can be classified as left-sided obstructive ductal dependent, right-sided obstructive ductal dependent, and shunting or mixing. The simplified approach categorizes infants with these lesions respectively as "pink," "blue," or "gray." The emergency provider can provide life-saving stabilization until specialized care can be obtained.

Innocent Cardiac Murmur in Puppies: Prevalence, Correlation with Hematocrit, and Auscultation Characteristics

BACKGROUND

The aims of this study were to establish the prevalence of innocent cardiac murmurs in clinically healthy puppies, to investigate a possible correlation between the presence of an innocent murmur and hematocrit, and to describe the auscultation characteristics of innocent murmurs.

HYPOTHESIS

Lower hematocrit contributes to the genesis of innocent murmurs.

ANIMALS

Five hundred and eighty-four client-owned clinically healthy puppies, between 20 and 108 days old.

METHODS

Two cross-sectional surveys with a 1-year (n = 389 pups) pilot and a half-year (n = 195 pups) principal study periods. Cardiac auscultation was performed by a single, board-certified cardiologist. Hematocrit was measured with an automatized hematology analyzer. Echocardiography was performed only on puppies with a cardiac murmur in the principal study.

RESULTS

In the pilot study, 15% of the dogs had a murmur. Innocent murmur was diagnosed in 28% of the 195 dogs in the principal study. Innocent murmurs were systolic, mostly with a musical character and with a maximal intensity of 2 of 6, and mostly with the point of maximal intensity in the left cardiac base. The hematocrit was significantly lower in the group with a murmur compared to the group without (P = .023).

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL IMPORTANCE

Innocent murmur was a common finding in puppies at the age when the first veterinary controls usually take place. Physiologic anemia contributes to the genesis of innocent murmurs in puppies. Rising hematocrit in growing puppies can explain the spontaneous disappearance of innocent murmurs with aging. Hematocrit did not differentiate innocent murmurs from abnormal murmurs.

Teenage heart murmurs

The first-time appearance of a murmur in an adolescent can create a substantial amount of anxiety in the parents and the teenager. The appropriate evaluation and diagnosis is very important in decision-making regarding sports participation in this population. Accurate identification of the innocent murmurs can obviate the need for echocardiography. Identification of a pathologic murmur may reduce morbidity and, possibly, mortality in critical lesions such as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy. This article discusses the physiology and characteristics of different murmurs, and outlines an approach to cardiac murmurs in adolescents.

Evaluation of children with heart murmurs

Cardiac murmurs can be a source of anxiety for both physicians and parents until serious cardiac disorders are excluded. The innocent cardiac murmur is still the most common finding in healthy children and can usually be diagnosed through obtaining a complete history and performing a complete physical examination. However, a cardiac murmur may be the first sign of a structural cardiac disease and should not be ignored. Referral to a pediatric cardiologist for further evaluation is required when murmur assessment is not clear and diagnostic uncertainty is present. Educating and reassuring parents remains an important aspect of this evaluation. This article discusses features of innocent and pathological murmurs and provides an approach to cardiac murmurs in children.

An audit of the management of heart murmurs on the postnatal wards

Background

Investigation and management of neonatal heart murmurs varies widely and is dependent on local resources. In order to standardise the management of heart murmurs in our hospital a guideline (based on clinical examination with selective cardiology review) was introduced.

Aims

To establish adherence to and safety of the guideline; to review workload implications and to define the causes of neonatal heart murmurs in our population.

Methods

Patients were prospectively identified over a 2-year period (August 2006 to July 2008). Case notes were reviewed and examination findings, investigations, follow up and diagnosis recorded.

Results

89 babies were identified. The guideline was generally well adhered to. In total 51 (57%) of babies were referred for cardiology assessment. In 40 babies this assessment included an echocardiogram. 30 babies (34%) had an underlying cardiac malformation: 25 were identified before discharge home. 15/30 (50%) of the babies with a cardiac malformation remain under cardiology follow up at the age of 1 year. No baby discharged from follow up without cardiology review subsequently presented with a cardiac problem.

Conclusion

A significant minority of babies with a heart murmur have an underlying cardiac malformation. Our guideline appears to ensure the timely identification of these babies and rationalises our use of specialist services.

Benefits of predischarge echocardiography service for postnatal heart murmurs

AIM

To review the findings and outcomes of predischarge echocardiography service for postnatal heart murmurs provided by neonatologists.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed all predischarge echocardiograms performed on babies from the postnatal wards (PNW) over the last 3 years. We evaluated the indications, median age, findings and outcome.

RESULTS

A total of 408 echocardiograms were performed on 350 babies on the PNW. The most common indication was presence of a murmur (58%). In babies with a heart murmur, 26% had a normal echocardiogram, 2% had major structural heart defects, 38% had minor structural heart defects and 34% had transient circulatory changes. 32% were discharged with no follow-up, 28% were followed up in the local cardiac clinic and 40% were referred to the cardiologist.

CONCLUSION

Predischarge echocardiography service for postnatal heart murmurs provided by neonatologists has the benefit of providing an early diagnosis, counselling of the parents and arranging appropriate follow-up. It helps to triage the referrals to the cardiologist. We felt that we were able to alleviate parental anxieties by providing a definitive diagnosis and written information prior to discharge from hospital. We strongly believe that this service should only be provided by those appropriately trained and skilled in echocardiography.

Accuracy of cardiac auscultation in asymptomatic neonates with heart murmurs: comparison between pediatric trainees and neonatologists

The aim of this study was to assess whether cardiac auscultation performed by pediatric trainees and neonatologists can reliably distinguish innocent from pathologic heart murmurs in asymptomatic neonates. From January 2008 to April 2009 the pediatric trainees of our institution were requested to refer all asymptomatic neonates with a murmur and classify the murmurs as "innocent," "pathologic," or "possibly pathologic." Prior to echocardiography, each neonate was evaluated by two experienced neonatologists. The echocardiographic studies of 169 neonates were analyzed. Abnormal cardiac anatomy was found in 55 neonates (32.6%). The overall ability of pediatric trainees in identifying congenital heart disease (CHD) was moderate [area under the curve (AUC) = 0.855] and significantly lower compared to neonatologists (AUC = 0.919, p = 0.007). However, at "lower" levels of clinical confidence (i.e., clinical diagnosis of possibly pathologic murmurs), pediatric trainees had good ability in excluding CHD (sensitivity 94.6%; negative likelihood ratio = 0.09). The ability of cardiac auscultation for diagnosing CHD in asymptomatic neonates is limited and dependent on the physician's experience and level of clinical confidence. Echocardiography should remain an option for all neonates with a possibly pathologic murmur.

What's new in outpatient cardiology

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Nearing the end of the first decade of this new century, the challenges and changes in the field of outpatient pediatric cardiology continue to accelerate.

RECENT FINDINGS

To help the general pediatrician and family practice physician become aware of several new care guidelines and practice trends as well as the controversies surrounding them this article reviews recent publications and places them in a larger context. Current guidelines and policy statements for cardiovascular monitoring for children with attention deficit disorder, subacute bacterial endocarditis prophylaxis and follow-up of adults with congenital heart disease are discussed. Trends regarding use of echocardiograms, changing drug therapy for Marfan syndrome, follow-up of infant with complex coronary heart disease, and treatment of obesity are reviewed.

SUMMARY

It is important for the practicing pediatrician to be aware of these developments, so they can be incorporated into current patient care and increase the physician's ability to answer patient and family questions about these guidelines.